Added: 3 years ago
From: ManiaTVdotcom
Views: 31,556
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (195)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • they r brilliant live saw them glasgow few yr ago

  • No offense but his breathing and his barking isn't doing him or the band justice. I've seen other videos where he sings better than this so why he would sing bad live makes no sense if he is capable of singing better. I do agree though that he has a horrible technique and needs to improve since he runs out of air too much and struggles.

  • whats with the pansy red booties O_o

  • @daveed - You are right actually. I wouldn't be. I'm being snarky because I think the band sucks (sincerely) but I won't turn my out of turn statement into a pissing match.

    I am indeed a seasoned musician, and have played with a lot of well known people in the metal genre, and I do know my shit. I also think these guys are putting their look before their music. I'm sorry that is just the way it is. Then again, the Kill Hannah stuff is so generic and rote I am remiss to call it music in a sense.

  • @Daveed - Yeah. Poser. That's me. LOL. If you only knew man, if you only knew. Kill Hannah is still sub par music that is more concerned with its look than doing anything original, or even exemplifying an already existing genre. My collection includes John Zorn, Nina Simone, YOB, Enslaved, Serge Gainsbourg, Exodus, Ennio Moriconne, Redd Kross (glam inspired hard stuff with a look AND talent, KillHannah should take note) etc.

  • @shootitinthehead Regardless, if you even think you're any type of knowledgable musician you wouldn't even be that arrogant to anybody who plays music.

  • @pr3ttyr4v3g1rl13 he had to be and he still put on a good show.

  • may i say that jonny is the hotest even hoter than bill kaolitz i know that alot of peapel disagerea but if you do fuck you

  • kill hannah 4 eva

    but mat dont sing as good live in this video :(

    its actually kinda annoying coz he dont sonud very good this time

  • kill hannah 4 eva

    but mat dont sing as good live in this video :(

  • His sounds way better in other videos, he's probably sick in this one:(

  • omg.

    i love me some kill hannah,

    but matt sounds awful!

  • Fake music for fake people. Have fun at Hot Topic all you poser mallrats.

  • @shootitinthehead I see how you can make that comparison... but I've played gigs with these guys back to like 2001. They got their shit together and paid their dues.

    Haven't you heard? Playing pop music is a viable form of income now. That's why they pay us the big bucks.

  • @shootitinthehead Who are you to even say that? You honestly must be the most ignorant person i've ever encountered. Anybody who is in a band or who ACTUALLY knows music would say that you can dislike a certain type of music and still 100% appreciate and respect a band who clearly has it together and can play well with eachother. It's people like you who are posers. Enjoy living life thinking you know music when in reality you're a fool for even commenting on this video.

  • awesome!

  • Aaaaaah, Seeing them sooon. Caant wait. :D

  • sorry...but i got admit...at first sight i thought the singer was a girl...hahaa...early mornings sure dun do good for my eyes...

  • @MetallicBlack86 Me too.

  • i can't find teh right tab for this. does anybody know the chords they're playing?!?!

  • Just listen to Adam Ant!

  • I really like Kill Hannah but oh gosh! Burn those red boots please!

  • i think he is sick of something

  • Seeing them live in May, so looking forward to it : D

  • Ok ..this is the truth..i love Kill hannah. But he cannot sing. but thats okay because people have fell in love with the style of his voice. But don't defend him saying he can sing when he cant..it makes you look like a preteen who doesnt know anything.

  • And btw what was hanging off of Mat's side? it looks like a wallet attached to a chain but idk lol

  • At like 2:18 Jon (I think that's his name) does the chicken thing! Ha ha ughhh I really need to stop watching these things when I'm tired -_-

  • awesome!

  • @Wheelio You suck, loads of dick

  • i love the beat.

  • he sings way of the notes !

  • no no one is

  • Okay, seriously p[people who say hes a bad singer live, do you see how much he jumps around and shit?

  • @BluejoeyProductions jumping around = being a good singer?

  • I'm saying if you expect him to nail notes perfectly while dancing and jumping around then you're dumb.

  • Not really. Plenty of vocalists are just as energetic on stage and can still sing fine. In either case, Mr. Devine is pretty motionless during the parts when he sings. He just has really terrible singing technique; all of it's coming from his throat.

  • I have to disagree, at all the shows I go to he sings better than this, and jumps around and dances and w/e a lot.

  • @BluejoeyProductions Disagree with which part? When I said that he was motionless when he sang, I was referring specifically to this video. As for his technique, it's pretty bad in all of the live videos on Youtube, but I must admit I've never seen them live myself; I missed an opportunity to do so earlier this year.

  • Overall bad technique. And I've seen them recently it was awesome :)

  • @ToyBoxMonster I've seen em three times and he's sang fine all those time (seeing em again in less than a month :D :D :D) but they never play my favourite songs :(

  • @LiamBamBam im seeing them in 2 weeks XD

  • @Rawrrgirl23 where to?

  • @LiamBamBam London :) with my passion:)

  • @ToyBoxMonster Yeah you should probably see them live before you say he has bad techniques. I've seen him live and this video is nothing compared to his vocal techniques and stage presence. And stage presence is an easy 50% of why shows go sold out

  • @daveevad1671 Do you understand what vocal technique is? I have difficulty believing that you can evaluate a singer's vocal technique (his breathing, resonation, etc) over the loud noise of a rock concert. In any case, I certainly didn't make any comment about the role of vocal technique in attracting audiences and selling out shows.

  • @ToyBoxMonster Im sure you do have difficulty believing that but after 11 years of being involved in music and being around good vocal techniques and bad techniques i can easily pick out each just by watching the singer, how well they hold notes, how well they can execute all the notes in their range, etc.

  • @daveevad1671 Unfortunately, your claim that you've worked in music for so long and that you can "pick out" vocal techniques by sight doesn't quite outweigh all of the evidence that Mr. Devine has rather awful technique. I can't find a single performance on Youtube on which he does not struggle to reach high notes and/ sing from the throat/ struggle to catch his breath. He strains his voice to such an extent that it cracks. Do you believe that he purposely does this each time he's being filmed?

  • @ToyBoxMonster You're completely right that he has miserable technique. In fact, if you read any of his blogs, every single one of his tour diaries is "my voice is shot". I caught 3 shows in 30 days. And by the 3rd one he was so torn from the tour, but he put on a good face and rocked it.  The high notes (like the one in the chorus of Lips Like Morphine) have become a lot easier for him lately. He definitely has stretched his vocal chords. But he's gonna fry them if he doesn't get lessons

  • 2:13

  • Comment removed

  • his voice live is a shit!!

  • Jonny looked awesome. too bad he quit

  • lurve kill hannah

    they wer so gd live wen i saw em

    nd ppl if u dnt like it dnt watch it or comment on it 2 start a freakin argument its just stupid

    KH FTW!

  • キルハンナ大好きです!

    (i really love KIll Hannah!)

    well,

    i gotta say,

    FUCK YOU ALL

    WHO ARE TALKING THE SHIT

    ABOUT KILL HANNAH!!!

  • xD mat sounds lyk hes got a cold <3 XD

  • That guy can't sing live. The song is better on CD.

  • For real. He sounds terrible live. The CD's fantastic though.

  • no he just sounded bad in this video. He's great live.

  • Well yeah.. I've seen them live and he was really good. Hmmm... bad night I guess.

  • @HerRevenge i hope so

    im gonna go see them

  • Comment removed

  • awtz.... it hurt..

  • for all i know, Mat was sick when they made this video......so why don't u stop insulting him

  • so THIS is what faggot emo's listen to nowadays? hmm, guess i'm not suprised. perfect level of gay. and what's extra sad is how i'm 15, and im better then them at all their all instruments. the singers balls need to drop to.

  • yes this is wat we listen to nowadays, and u r the fucking gay one here.. talking about some one else's balls just cause u have none..

  • haha you somehow know that i have balls? wow you must be a wizard to know that without even seeing a piture of me. or maybe, you're just making shitty insults?? hmm, strange. well you're probly upset now so why don't you go cut yourself now since that's the new cool fad to do in the emo scene. or just be a giant pussy about everything. whatever suits you better emo fag, whatever suits you better..

  • it doesn't take much magic to know that douche bags like u some how "have balls" and hun i aint making shitty insults.. is that the best u got "so why dont u go cut yourself" come on where have i heard that... hmm, lets c every where.. grow up, get a life and get some balls to stop hating people just cause most of us are better then u.. ass hole

  • Shut the fuck up, you ignorant little cunt. You think you're hot shit, but when you get out of high school and into the real world, someone is going to take you down a couple pegs, or put a fucking bullet in your head. Grow the fuck up.

  • i really don't think someones going to kill me for thinking emo's are stupid.

  • No, they're going to kill you because you shoot your mouth of without knowing what you're talking about. Kill Hannah are not emo, and I seriously doubt you play your instrument (skin flute doesn't count) better than any of them.

    Also, you're mom probably still drives you everywhere, so where do you get off feeling superior to anyone?

  • ok maybe killhannah isnt emo but it;s definitley gay. but you know what they say, tomato tamoto. anyways, i play guitar, know drum beats, i know bass, and anyone can sing better then that guy so i guess i win. and second of all i walk everywhere and take the bus cuz i don't have a car. this is because i'm not a spoiled shit and i actually have to work for my things. and i don't have a job at the time.

  • So what if it is gay? "Gay" shouldn't be a substitute word for stuff you think is shitty. Plus, virtually all rock music has an undercurrent of homo-eroticism, including whatever shit you listen to.

  • In fact, metal is the gayest musical genre there is, I mean metal shows are mostly made up of sweaty guys rubbing against each other in the mosh pit anyway.

  • ok let me find a more fitting word for them and emos then. shit. and of course gays are in all types of music even metal. singer of judas priest is gay. but theres also straightness. all the songs singing about sex with girls and stuff. thats pretty straight. and mosh pits aren't for "rubbing up" it's for pushing and fighting eachother to get out that energy the song puts into you. haha you think I listen to shit? look at this band dude. anyone who listens to this band, listens to shit.

  • That energy you're referring to is pent up sexual energy. Guys pushing each other and "play-fighting" is very homo-erotic, even though most guys would never admit that. Throughout history the manliest gladiators have also been the gayest.

    If you don't like this band, that's fine. Taste is objective. I might not care for the music you like, but I'm not going to call you and idiot because of it. That's immature. Also, I was just using "shit" as a general term for "stuff". Relax.

  • i'm pretty sure the energy a good song gives me doesn't make me go want to fuck a dude. it just gets me pumped, i wanna do something. nothing gay though and i know this because i know how my mind works. you cannot prove me wrong unless you have psycic powers.and how would you know the manliest gladiators were gay? seriously that is complete bullshit, i'm sure there were a few gay gladiators but you just made that up. and it's not even the music i hate, (i still don't like it) i just hate the

  • fact that the band is made of a couple of kids who have no talent. i am better than them at their "skills"! and people go down on their knees for them seeing them as gods. they're just a few douche bags selling out and have no talent.

  • Comment removed

  • Pegasuslover97 go fuck Pegasus!!

  • would you just give it up! just face it! you havent got a clue what your talking about! Kill Hannah are amazing! and theyre not emo either! so just stop trying to make it sound like you know everything about everything because you dont!

  • i do know what the fuck i'm talking about. they aren't amazing, theyre a few talentless douche bags. and emo or not they're pretty fucking stupid and shouldn't even be considered musicians. because they aren't. just a few faggot teens thinking they're deep and hardcore, whatever. and how is knowing about one band knowing about everything? this is a single thing, in fact it's like a fraction of a thing cuz they're so bad the don't even count as one while.

  • @pegasuslover97 You're so arrogant. like honestly you have clearly shown that you have no idea what you're talking about. WOW you can play instruments better than them? can you put together an entire album that has great sound and emotion by yourself, too? You're 15. kids your age don't know shit about music and respecting it, and the ones that do i applaud because it's people like you who make us older generations laugh at how foolish you all are.

  • @daveevad1671 haha that's funny cuz you think you're like above me or something. and i can play instruments better than them AND play with more emotion sooo yeah. and no i can't make an album, i'm 15 and that's a pretty hard thing to do especially when i only have a guitar...................anywa­ys the only reason these guys have albums is they're pussy sell out emos. i know about music and i respect a good band when i hear one but these guys are a joke dude. long live real music

  • @pegasuslover97 thats fair and i agree that theyre probably only known because of all the homo emo kids who are the real posers but i have seen them live and surprisingly enough enjoyed them a lot. and i already made 3 albums by the time i was 17 and i only owned a drumset and guitar.

  • Mat sounds so bad because he was sick at the time. He isn't necessarily amazing live, but it's never this bad. There has to be something wrong with him. Sore throat maybe?

  • mat totally has a cold here. his voice sounds more nasel-y than usual.

    ps: i REALLY miss jonny.

  • ddaaannngggg poor dude is suffering on stage he must be sick like way way bad..cool vid tho

  • this is LOLLOLOLOLOLOLOL

  • there is a backing track hahahah. The only thing that is really right now is the vocals... unfortunately

  • The band is all in, the levels just suck. There is loop with samples and synth and whatnot, but the band is all there, you can tell with the bass mostly.

  • wtf??? i can sing better than this guy.

    why does he suck?

  • the sound is shitty!

  • kill hannah...montana??

  • ive seen them live twice and they were amazing

    something was wrong here.

    mat sounds sickk

  • you can tell that theres someband tension... and wtf mat =/ EHHH fucked up =[[[[[ and ive seen them 9 times live WTF!

  • kaseyyy I thought you only saw them like 5 times lol.

    and Mat looks great though =]

  • the 80's all over again.

  • lol..

    i love it.

    love josh

  • dunno, the lead guitarist, johnathan radtke is pretty good. hes got a unique style, maybe not in this song but hes good

  • yeah totally sad jonnys gone now

  • They don't sound to great live.. but they're ok i still like studio

  • TBH I think he's going for the New Romantic look it looks pre good

  • the boots doesnt really suit the clothes matt.............and the other clothing..........GOTTA GO!!!!!!!!!!!!!! wear skinnies or something if u wanna be a punk ass

  • Its MAT not Matt by the way, sorry it just annoys me........

    ~ashleigh<3333

  • really Mat not Matt?

  • well technically they are the same cuz they both come from Matthew but he spells it Mat not Matt if you look them both up you get completely different results...and it just annoys me for some reason when i see people put it as Matt idk it just does.

    ~ashleigh<3333

  • love the comment beneath mine and never thought matt sounds so different in person

  • i think the name was inspired by how many people hate hannah montana =)

  • oh wow, i never thought of it like that

  • kill hannah was around b4 hannah montana ..hannah was an ex-girlfriend of matt devine but yah..id agree with u.

  • no it's not about Hannah Montana! It was some of girls they know... But I can't rebember... just search for some vid about intrview whit kill Hannah! :)

  • uuuhhhhhhh.

    oooohhhhh

    i wanna fuck!

    gay.gay.gay!!!!

  • their effin amazing!

  • noooo...:O

  • Please post links to your bands videos so we can see how much better your do :)

  • well said

  • although i dont like your opinion, i will agree this paticular time the song was not given justice live

  • ...singer***

  • OMFG wth is up with all these bad comments?!? Kill Hannah is the best band BY FAR EVERRRR! and this live preformance isnt even bad!wth! mat is the best siner like really! liy MAT!!!

    ~ashleigh<33333

  • You would be wrong though. Don't be a fangirl. I love KH and they were great both times I have seen them but Mat sounds pretty bad here... The rest of the guys sound good, but the mix killed that pretty well...

  • :) Chris K was video taping this for KH-TV

  • I did the same thing as you dude- rude awakening that's for sure sweet Jesus

  • ... this is an amazing song live.

    I should stick up for Mat here and explain that this was after pretty much a year and a half of solid touring and his voice was f**ked!

  • I do love KH. I also know that they sound truly awful on this video. They are a live band!! However, I do have to say kudos to stvtripp for a hillarious comment! I obviously don't agree with it, but damn it's funnY!

  • true mate haha

    good call

  • Matt sounds horrible in this performance..the studio recorded version is much better

  • too bad that he was sick

    he's holding his stomach at 0:31

  • Not sick. His stage mannerisms are just him grabbing himself and his clothes randomly. Thats just how he is. I will also say he is usually better than this, but the mix is also terrible. These stage5 people can't really mix well..

  • Wow you need to go back to preschool

    Mat's (possessive?) Devines shoes are

    terribly,,,,terribly WHAT!?

    and btw his shoes are amazing one

    and two how does a pair of shoes describe sexual preference?!

    the end

  • I don't think,that he is a gay,because he has terribly shoes,oh no ! :)

    First think- he has terribly shoes.

    Second think-I love Kill Hannah,I love Mat Devine,but I watched movies (Mat loves Johny,blah,blah...) and that's it.

    Shoes and sexual preferenca are two other thing omg :)

  • ahh I see

    sorry about that

    I thought you ment he has terrible shoes so he is automaticly gay...

    i was kinda thinking wtf

    sorry i kinda protect themm way to much =]

  • Aw poor thing!! Gotta give them props for not cancelling tho

  • His voice sounds as usually.

  • wtf its a boy? i thought it was girl wth?

  • yeah, you can tell he's sick, cos he can't say his n's properly and strains his voice in the middle bit. aww. no matter, they were great when i saw them ;)

  • poor sick mat...

    they're usually good

    but you can obviously tell he isn't at his best today :,(

  • MAT is sick i can tell he is way to pail and his voice...oh poor mat

  • why is it all of the good bands and artists always sound bad live?

  • the mix is terrible here... You can tell because Dan's guitar is almost inaudible and Mats voice is way too loud and poorly EQed... I have seen these guys live and they are actually pretty good live. Not CD quality, but impressive nontheless

  • Yeah, that wasn't definitely Mat's best day. But not too bad, I still like his voice in this vid. even he does usually sounds so much better.

  • There was definitely something wrong on this given day, they are better than this live. His voice even broke in the bridge lol. Must have been sick or something.

  • Mat's voice is never perfect. He's not the best singer on the world. So, that's the reason.

  • He is a good singer, that is what drew me to the band in the first place... watch any of the other live videos but this one, he is good.

  • yeah? As I said, they are very good playing live. I know their live videos. Did you hear "I wanna be a Kennedy", live? His voice is almost inaudibly. Chester Bennington, for example, is a great singer. But, I don't wanna quarrel with you.

  • I agree that they could have done better, but a band won't ever sound like they do on the record. They probably were just having a bad day, I've seen better from them.

  • Co Mat ma na nogach?! O Jasny gwint! By the way, they are very good playing live.

  • lol at 0:00 - 4:21

  • Mat usually sounds a HELL of a lot better than this.

    So does the rest of the band for that matter.

    Must have just been a bad day for them.

    I LOVE KH<3

  • ouch sounds bad without the touchups of recored songs

  • Mat...what's up? you normally sound a hell of a lot better!

  • Love this band, but who is playing the synths...?

  • mats voice isnt at its best but thats just because hes been on tour and he cant be perfect all the time.:/

    but i love kh and mat forever and ever.<3

  • Shutt A fuck Off with Bad Comments!

    I Love this song! s

  • they dont have a girl! and yeah, they are kinda sucky live, but they are awesome with their studio tracks..

  • wth is this....

  • I bought their debut cd for my wife 2 years ago for valentines day- she still loves this song!!!Her nick name -Angel..

  • This song isn't from their major label debut. Its from their "sophmore" effort.