well LeoBen207 analyzing this song!!!!!! I am bit worried bout u :p personal I connect with this sdunno what to feel bout me !!!!!!!!!!talk about confusion :)
Listened to this 45 over and over and over until I had each and every word memorized. It was the 60's, we were stationed in Germany, I was a kid and it was the loneliest I had ever felt in my life
hi i see there are millions of YouTube comments but please Read anyway. I write original songs and sing , they are ruff but real, we are acoustic but will go electric for most songs Getting a fanbase is really difficult for artists and bands, still undiscovered by the big music labels, so it would really mean a lot to me if you could check out my channel and listen to my songs. If you could Llike' This Comment, that would be great too, so other people can see this comment thanks
@GirlFromlpanema1966 we don't want anyone to tamper with this beautiful song. Especially someone whose voice doesn't work with Simon and Garfunkal's type of music.
@GirlFromIpanema1966 YES!!! BY ALL THAT EXISTS IN THIS WORLD YES!! JUSTIN BIEBER WILL NEVER BE WORTHY OF SIMON OR GARFUNKEL AND HIS NAME IS A STAIN ON THIS PAGE!!!
keep in mind, no offense to you personally. just to justin bieber, who deserves every offense I can give him.
@GirlFromIpanema1966 I want to hear no one even try to make a cover of this song. And I want to hear Justin Bieber no more on ANY classic videos, for God's sake... Just talk about the music you just listened to and how it changed your life and stop bringing up another artist...
started school my girl of 3 yrs tells me she isnt interested in me or men in general anymore and wants a woman....If I never loved I never would have cried
I have no need for friendship, friendship causes pain.....can u dumb humans stop fucking ruining every great song with comments about Justin beiber. It's fucking lame. Thanks:)
Go read "meditation 17" after listening, this was a response to that poem. Everyone can relate to this song at a point in their life...but read the poem and you'll see there are always two sides in life.
If you are a truth seeker, search "Truth Contest" in Google and click on the 1st result, then open The Present and read what it says. Everyone needs to see this. The Present will turn this world right-side up if it reaches enough people. You will see what I mean when you read the first page.
From 1:22 TO 1:26 cHiLls... then from 1:34 to 1:44 EPIC CHILLS.... There really is no other likeness to the harmonies of Simon and Garfunkel. And God said, "Let there be melody and harmony to perfection" And BAM! There was Simon and Garfunkel.
it's a shame that the poetry of today consists of "bitches and hoes" there is no music, no melody, and no depth. So glad I am 61 and experienced all of that, I have been a poet since I was 14. Never let real music die please.
You are so, so funny! But don't question their gift in singing and songwriting. The two of them deserve all the kudos in this world. Since the 70's (?), and they are still loved by fans - where I am no. 1!
You are so, so funny! But don't question their gift in singing and songwriting. the two of them deserve all the kudos in this world. Since the 70's (?), and they are still loved by fans - where I am no. 1!
A great song of alienation, angst and plain old bummed out LOW! Simon plays a great guitar and Art doesn't mind blending his beautiful voice to Paul's vocal. Up there with the best as was said in 1968 with the Beatles and the Doors - tremendous!
1969-Freshman English class and the introduction to this pair of outstanding artists- the beginning of a love affair -remembering the paper we had to write on this and the Sounds of Silence....
love this song, because at one point i was having a breakdown, went to the beach with in my headphones with this song on and there so happens to be a mewstone rock there and i sat there and listened to this song ,thinking i was the rock , and its true its an island it touches no one and no one touches me ,and the rock feels no pain ,and the mind wonders, very theraputic,anyone understand?
Imagine Paul Simon's ego and how Artie must have been dealing with it all the time .. Don't get me wrong, I love both of these guys, went to a Paul Simon concert a few days ago and it was AMAZING, but the guy was not made to share the spotlight ..
Their best song. Great rebuttal to "It is better to have loved and lost then to have not loved at all." It is laughter and it is loving I disdain. Great great song.
Friendship causes pain
777PerfectDark 10 hours ago
This is my theme.
ModGirl1967 10 hours ago
A wonderful song that describes a situation we all go through at least once in life.
Michele640 2 days ago 2
well LeoBen207 analyzing this song!!!!!! I am bit worried bout u :p personal I connect with this sdunno what to feel bout me !!!!!!!!!!talk about confusion :)
dreammakerunlimited1 2 days ago
Schizoid personality disorder....A rock feels no pain
LeoBen207 2 weeks ago
What concert was it?
Karolingful 2 weeks ago
Not often am I struck by male voices as "beautiful," but man... these guys sing beautifully. :)
Honeydew7396 2 weeks ago
Boo, for the poor cut at the end.
PricklyPete10 3 weeks ago
A gold standard by which to compare all vocal harmonies. Timeless.
regretminimizer 3 weeks ago
This touched my soul like no others in days gone by when the cold winds blew, when life was sad and lonliness hit me hard.
ThePeterichardson 1 month ago 2
Songs like this heal a weary soul.
ThePurpleHarpoon 1 month ago 2
easily one of the best songs ever written
tbonius95 1 month ago 6
different class,nuff said!!
mickmartin777 1 month ago
This thes song has been relevent to EVERYONE at some point in their lives. If you say no, then you are a liar,
cardman330 1 month ago 4
Listened to this 45 over and over and over until I had each and every word memorized. It was the 60's, we were stationed in Germany, I was a kid and it was the loneliest I had ever felt in my life
lgjrouse1 1 month ago
@lgjrouse1 Hope things are better bro. 1989, Rome, cassette on repeat on large orange buses, tough times.
MikaShelley99 1 month ago
I love their music and have a lot of it; but I humbly disagree with them at the end of this song;
Rocks ALWAYS feel pain, and islands ALWAYS cry. Loneliness stinks ! :-(
cschoon1213 1 month ago
@cschoon1213 Yes, ultimately the rocks and islands hurt more.
MikaShelley99 1 month ago
what?? how could anybody in the world dislike this?
melian06 1 month ago
I can explain the 33 "dislikes"....There isn't an "over my head" button.
garymichael1950 1 month ago 4
This is just so fantastic I cannot even comprehend it.
arryarrfiddledeedee 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I used to be a rock like you, then I took and arrow in the knee
Radders123 1 month ago
What are you?
TheSyrupMan 1 month ago
I am a towel.
TheSyrupMan 1 month ago
People who do not like it might get touched..........seriously by this great song
teecman 1 month ago
The very existence of Justin Bieber makes me ashamed of humanity and all of the modern generation...
Bloodyvains71 1 month ago
33 people are pathetic for disliking this
osu67 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hi i see there are millions of YouTube comments but please Read anyway. I write original songs and sing , they are ruff but real, we are acoustic but will go electric for most songs Getting a fanbase is really difficult for artists and bands, still undiscovered by the big music labels, so it would really mean a lot to me if you could check out my channel and listen to my songs. If you could Llike' This Comment, that would be great too, so other people can see this comment thanks
APEXchannel1 1 month ago
An island never cries.
nllleonard 1 month ago
greatness in all its glory
ushudnobettr 2 months ago
on what fret is that capo
majerlet 2 months ago
@majerlet capo is in 4rt fret. chords are G-C-G-Am-D-C and back to G. Am-D- Am, D- Am-C- D...chorus is G- D.
poeticjustice074 2 months ago
@GirlFromlpanema1966 we don't want anyone to tamper with this beautiful song. Especially someone whose voice doesn't work with Simon and Garfunkal's type of music.
ninja4beast 2 months ago
and an island never cSSHHRR...
Duskworker 2 months ago 2
Never what?!!! NEVER WHAT??!!!
panchobehrmann 2 months ago 2
@panchobehrmann an island never dies. :)
bigworldsmallperson 2 months ago
@bigworldsmallperson an island never dies :(
benji07 2 months ago
I love Simon and Garfunkel but their songs always upset me slightly
humouriseverything 2 months ago
Not bad boys. With a little more practice you should be able to sell a few 8 tracks.
coolanddark 2 months ago
Are you saying that Justin Bieber isn't good enough to sing this song ( I Am a Rock )?
GirlFromIpanema1966 2 months ago
@GirlFromIpanema1966 Yes!!!
Dinuzzoandrea 2 months ago
@GirlFromIpanema1966 YES!!! BY ALL THAT EXISTS IN THIS WORLD YES!! JUSTIN BIEBER WILL NEVER BE WORTHY OF SIMON OR GARFUNKEL AND HIS NAME IS A STAIN ON THIS PAGE!!!
keep in mind, no offense to you personally. just to justin bieber, who deserves every offense I can give him.
bigworldsmallperson 2 months ago
full circle
hangemhigh2000 2 months ago
the end was clipped off too soon. Kinda ruined it.
swampzoid 2 months ago
@swampzoid yep
"and an island feels no pai-
gdunde 2 months ago in playlist Simon and Garfunkel
it hurts that i wasn't in that audience
Terrapin243 2 months ago 13
@Terrapin243 I know, right?
morningstar241 2 months ago
this is my theme song.
miss9starr7 2 months ago 2
Bloody marvellous! :) Live as well!
ravrik 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I want to hear Justin Bieber sing this song ( I Am a Rock ).
GirlFromIpanema1966 2 months ago
@GirlFromIpanema1966
die
thebadbrains10108 2 months ago
@GirlFromIpanema1966 I want to hear no one even try to make a cover of this song. And I want to hear Justin Bieber no more on ANY classic videos, for God's sake... Just talk about the music you just listened to and how it changed your life and stop bringing up another artist...
TheVampireist 2 months ago 4
i feel like people in the 60s felt a lot smarter than they actually were.
titmouse0hehehe 3 months ago
who wrote the majority of the songs?
NANDO218 3 months ago
@NANDO218 Paul Simon wrote most of the songs. Art Garfunkel supplied the high harmony. Pure magic.
MrMiker 3 months ago
I am amazed that this song has become so timeless as to touch the newest generations today.
dc7995 3 months ago
i am an island lol
MrRuffnecks 3 months ago 3
started school my girl of 3 yrs tells me she isnt interested in me or men in general anymore and wants a woman....If I never loved I never would have cried
SongHooks1993 3 months ago
Holy harmonies Batman :)
pyranology 3 months ago 71
Story of my life.
50centuries 3 months ago 5
is it a premiere of this song ?
prawicowyPawel 3 months ago
Why do people think every human being wants company constantly. I love this song. I love my alone time.
mrwells111 3 months ago
@mrwells111 Kind of feel like the point of the song is that this person doesn't love alone time, but it's safer than the risk of loving somebody.
calliope720 1 month ago
@calliope720 To you maybe....
mrwells111 1 month ago
@calliope720 okay
mrwells111 1 month ago
The lyrics are SO FRIGGIN GOOD!!!!
KatherineSolan 3 months ago 2
What year was this?
doctim11 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
So much good
alayduhh 3 months ago
Are you saying that Justin Bieber can't sing?
GirlFromIpanema1966 3 months ago
31 people either don't like this song, don't like Simon and Garfunkel or just don't like the quality of this video.
MyTeenageyearzz 3 months ago
" I won't disturb the slumber
Of feelings that have died
If I never loved I never would have cried "
Tell me why I love this part of the song..
Oh, I've seen that S&G are better in live than studio...Tell me why the actual singers aren't so good!
SophiaLaiho 3 months ago
I have no need for friendship, friendship causes pain.....can u dumb humans stop fucking ruining every great song with comments about Justin beiber. It's fucking lame. Thanks:)
blondiXblue 3 months ago
@blondiXblue You'd be happier if they made comments about Lady Gaga?
Alikah1 3 months ago
"and a rock feels no pain,and an island never cries"
TheKevo01 3 months ago
Are you saying that Justin Bieber couldn't sing this song ( I Am A Rock )?
GirlFromIpanema1966 3 months ago
@GirlFromIpanema1966 Yes i would say that
JonitTaskForce2 3 months ago
GirlFromIpanema1966 you are out of your mind there is no comparison with such class with such trash
MrTubeman11 3 months ago
I would really love to hear Justin Bieber sing this song ( I Am A Rock ); I believe he could give a good rendition of it.
GirlFromIpanema1966 3 months ago
@GirlFromIpanema1966 you're kidding right?
grungecollectorSCE 3 months ago 3
@GirlFromIpanema1966 I agree with MrTubeman11 How can you compare such wonderful musicians with that abomination?
88Gregory88 3 months ago
if i didin't know better, i would have thought that paul wrote this about me
rigbyfin 3 months ago
Fantastic Harmony...
JRastinator 3 months ago 27
Go read "meditation 17" after listening, this was a response to that poem. Everyone can relate to this song at a point in their life...but read the poem and you'll see there are always two sides in life.
FritzMeisterUTube 3 months ago
and an island ne--
holypigs 4 months ago
this is my song
xXKittyxCat 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This looks like a pretty rough crowd! I hope the Boys had some decent security that night. God forbid someone should get "Reefer Madness"!
PoutinePete 4 months ago
i'm so glad my dad introduced me to this type of music when i was younger. (:
laurahobo 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If you are a truth seeker, search "Truth Contest" in Google and click on the 1st result, then open The Present and read what it says. Everyone needs to see this. The Present will turn this world right-side up if it reaches enough people. You will see what I mean when you read the first page.
77Listen 4 months ago
From 1:22 TO 1:26 cHiLls... then from 1:34 to 1:44 EPIC CHILLS.... There really is no other likeness to the harmonies of Simon and Garfunkel. And God said, "Let there be melody and harmony to perfection" And BAM! There was Simon and Garfunkel.
TheNomnomnomnombabie 4 months ago 3
This is good music, geniuses
elsaidst 4 months ago
This song got me through Chindits in IMA?
HarryKant 4 months ago
it's a shame that the poetry of today consists of "bitches and hoes" there is no music, no melody, and no depth. So glad I am 61 and experienced all of that, I have been a poet since I was 14. Never let real music die please.
rfranklinw1 4 months ago 3
@rfranklinw1 We, the people of the younger generation with actual musical taste will never let real music die. NEVER!
InsaneaTann 4 months ago 2
to chavadude
You are so, so funny! But don't question their gift in singing and songwriting. The two of them deserve all the kudos in this world. Since the 70's (?), and they are still loved by fans - where I am no. 1!
794mila 4 months ago
to chavadude
You are so, so funny! But don't question their gift in singing and songwriting. the two of them deserve all the kudos in this world. Since the 70's (?), and they are still loved by fans - where I am no. 1!
794mila 4 months ago
amazing poetry! one of the poems im analyzing for homework in english class!
GirlyGirl1818 4 months ago
just a guitar and voice makes such an amazing song
yaaki7 4 months ago
absolutely sick... so fucking genius
jpprindle 4 months ago
hahah lol i heard this song in my class in L.A Lol
Rainbowsluvdemons12 4 months ago
@Rainbowsluvdemons12 so did i!!! that would be so weird if it was CMS :D
PDAFAEWTS 4 months ago
@Rainbowsluvdemons12 This song is actually used by alot of english teachers. Not only is it an amazing song, but it's an amazing peice of poetry.
ASoapyWaffle 4 months ago
Would be great to know:
Were was this recorded?
Is it avaible on CD, DVD or Vinyl, I mean officially released?
If it isn't were there bootlegs avaible?
Would be great if someone would share his knowledge with me.
IncasRevenge 4 months ago
@IncasRevenge Hey, I only know the answer to one of those questions, and it is that is available to buy on CD, it is officially released.
Hope this helps...
marshmallow661 4 months ago
@IncasRevenge its on their album "sounds of silence" available for like $8 U.S. currency
MrSheetnose 4 months ago
@IncasRevenge I recommend the cd from "Greatest hits"
Siem828 4 months ago
where was this recorded?
mdaharris 4 months ago in playlist Work
Like this song... A lot! I am going to keep listening to this until someone yanks the headphones apart. Thank you Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel.
jennydaawesomeness 4 months ago
i love this song, even though i think the idea of being a rock is preposterous. i agree with arty! haha
liveslowlivesimple 4 months ago
If I never loved I never would have cried.
Love the kind of sadness in Pauls eyes.
matilde891 4 months ago
Wise and talented beyond their years.
LorenzoNW 5 months ago
and an island never .......
responses on a postcard please ...!!
mrbinkybonky 5 months ago
@mrbinkybonky
.... cries
1penguin99 5 months ago
Story of my life...
Cadet985 5 months ago
Am I the only one who is incredibly annoyed that the last word is cut off?
Thanks for the upload anyway :D
Cheekytriangle 5 months ago 2
Simon was only 22 when he wrote this. Phenomenal. Little known Simon fact: he also wrote "Red Rubber Ball," which was a big hit for the Circkles.....
mobydoug 5 months ago
Forever a rock
SuperHairyDick 5 months ago
@chavadude. more like chevy chase, but i get where you're coming from )
stillwaiting4godot 5 months ago
fantastic post cheers m8
stillwaiting4godot 5 months ago
A rock feels no pain and an island never cries
wendys120 5 months ago 3
Memory of 1975 when I was in first year. This song was played in religion class JESUS how cool was that!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1Twizzel 5 months ago
Simon and Garfunkel are the gods of music. Legends.
DestinationTruthTV 5 months ago 3
tumblr theme song..
miss9starr7 5 months ago
This song gives me a boner
MASAI97 5 months ago in playlist Simon & Garfunkel
Very good Simon and Garfunkel Cover you can find at:
graceland-online.de
thoger51 6 months ago
I believe that if you could somehow combine Simon and Garfunkel into one person, that person would look like WIll Ferrell.
YThorr 6 months ago 102
@YThorr Paul looks like Chevy
lionellogan 5 months ago
@YThorr willferrellsaysitalllolwearearock
72chilled 4 months ago
@YThorr totally! but with about 1000 times more talent. LOL
PithyMe 4 months ago
@YThorr
a really small will ferrell
bplumser 4 months ago
@YThorr Haha now that you mention it...
gman1225 4 months ago
@YThorr
I totally agree.. funny
ray3mma 3 months ago
And the Stones........sorry Mick and Keith!
docmeister1 6 months ago
A great song of alienation, angst and plain old bummed out LOW! Simon plays a great guitar and Art doesn't mind blending his beautiful voice to Paul's vocal. Up there with the best as was said in 1968 with the Beatles and the Doors - tremendous!
docmeister1 6 months ago
Damn it!! Now we'll never know what an island never does!! ;(
Amazing song, from amazings singers and writers, what did you expected?
CacoButignol 6 months ago 4
@CacoButignol and an Island never flies!
Daveparts 5 months ago
I like listening to this song when I'm depressed
RasberryIce13 6 months ago 23
@RasberryIce13 for me= Pretty much all the time
bloodsuckern 3 months ago
@RasberryIce13 Me too. A guy a liked just told me that he liked someone else. This song is on repeat. Just to make me feel a little better :)
sagaelgenstierna 3 months ago
I have books and my poetry to protect me I am shielded in my armour!
mysticlawlotus 6 months ago 4
And queue Phil Spector........
wobblydangly 6 months ago
@wobblydangly what do PS has to do with this song?
Irwiin161 6 months ago
@Irwiin161 - he ressurected many of their early songs including sounds of silence
wobblydangly 6 months ago
I feel this way a lot sad to say.. Great song! ; )
myangelmyall 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
●▬▬▬▬▬▬▬ஜ۩۞۩ஜ▬▬▬▬▬▬▬●
xwz25685 6 months ago
whahhhht
thisismy5thacount 6 months ago
1969-Freshman English class and the introduction to this pair of outstanding artists- the beginning of a love affair -remembering the paper we had to write on this and the Sounds of Silence....
Sylentiger 6 months ago in playlist Oldies and Goodies 2
Hey...I lived that...And still do a lot. Great song !!!
YankeeRhoad 6 months ago
es tremenda
lavacalechera9 6 months ago
Always loved this tune. I know Artie and Paul didn't care for it, but I really liked the folk rock dressing of this song on the album.
bughead3 6 months ago
love it
mikeb270 6 months ago
I know I can apreciate a Simon and Garfunkel song before I even listen to it,because they cannot dissapoint me.Love them!
Xenobarbarul 6 months ago
Autotune... Go fuck yourself, this is singing,warts and all,timeless.
fatknacker46 7 months ago 2
Does ANYONE know what this was for? A tv show or something? Anyone?
ericmsandoval 7 months ago
@ericmsandoval its a song, sung for those that feel lonly
mikeb270 6 months ago
@mikeb270 haha. Word. But i was just wondering if this was for a tv show.
ericmsandoval 6 months ago
@mikeb270 I am not lonely and live my life like this as a choice because of things happening in the world right now.
mikeb270 5 months ago
I just learned this :). Awesome song to know.
Litterboxer529 7 months ago
This song is so beautiful! Amazing
ZetVenori 7 months ago
and a rock feels no pain...and an island never c(CUTS OFF)
Zargon314 7 months ago
@PoutinePete .. no ones gunna get a laugh at that except maybe your ignorant ego
FMJFortunateSon 7 months ago
love this song, because at one point i was having a breakdown, went to the beach with in my headphones with this song on and there so happens to be a mewstone rock there and i sat there and listened to this song ,thinking i was the rock , and its true its an island it touches no one and no one touches me ,and the rock feels no pain ,and the mind wonders, very theraputic,anyone understand?
chrish73866 7 months ago
Imagine Paul Simon's ego and how Artie must have been dealing with it all the time .. Don't get me wrong, I love both of these guys, went to a Paul Simon concert a few days ago and it was AMAZING, but the guy was not made to share the spotlight ..
notpeterhansen 7 months ago
My english teacher used this teach us about conveying emotion and an idea in our writing....it worked.
GetStencilD 7 months ago
cries
sonofman23 7 months ago
Are they singing: "I'm in Iraq , I'm on an island" ?
PoutinePete 7 months ago
I touch no one and no one touches me.
This made me laugh and I can actually take the line literally as just the other day I thought about how long it was since I touched another human...
swkninja 7 months ago 2
i love paul's voice <3 could listen to him talk for hours!!!
lazymadonna 7 months ago
Their best song. Great rebuttal to "It is better to have loved and lost then to have not loved at all." It is laughter and it is loving I disdain. Great great song.
indiansbleeding 7 months ago
if this song is about being alone why are 2 people singing it? I love it though
hudybudy3 7 months ago
Island never "cries"
jimifx64 7 months ago
AND AN ISLAND NEVER WHAT????
ShamanicDpreshun 7 months ago
@ShamanicDpreshun and an island never cry's :)
Lozosos 7 months ago
I tried liking this multiple times
SteveStucks 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
⎝⏠⏝⏠⎠ - Smilin' for a realz reason! Wahahaha!
Gorgeous video, deep powerful music, strong heart!!!! <33 A++
Rare talent.
Dare you to see this disturbing messed up video!!
WARNING: Exceedingly Hypnotic Music and Film, that will TRULY Blow your Mind!
((btw))
** DO NOT watch entirety while under the influence of ANY drugs.**
/watch?v=5BqGYZ4fKOI
SunnyLovetts 7 months ago
The anthem for all antisocial people worldwide.
GermanOperaSinger 7 months ago
I've always identified with this song.
irenicum 7 months ago 3
Story of my life.
chavadude 7 months ago 59
@chavadude Sadly
stevnated 7 months ago in playlist Music
@chavadude Totally my theme song, too.
JohnAdams1735 4 months ago
Fantastic! thank you so much for posting this!
jinjanjane 7 months ago