This was the B side of "New York Mining Disaster", their first English single, and a much better song. Their first album was the best. Bonus points for naming the fourth guy on the album cover-he was their drummer, initials C.P. (Even more points for naming their guitarist, who was also a Bee Gee for awhile...initials V. M.)
@interestingfailure OK the drummer was Colin Peterson, and the guitar player was Vince Melouney,and the third thing that you are right about is this track,as good as "Mining Disaster" was, this tune was so ahead of it's time and the melody and changes in the intro were so eerie and haunting. One of my favorites from them. I'm glad I grew up in the 60's,I actually had a chance to see them 4 times,and once with a 52 piece orchestra,so you can imagine how this tune came off. The song is in E .
i never the times when artist like Bee Gees , the Beatles , Hollies and others hits te charts .Listen to the 45 singles was so mighty ... we were happy and had so many .....
the radio on a pirate station and our first sigaret ... but that was a big mistake lol
I first heard this song on a juke box in an RAF hanger in Goose Bay, Labrador. RAF crewmen had already heard of the Bee Gees. It was in the SPRING of 1967. It was one of those songs that stopped you in your tracks. I was only 19. Robin and Maurice are younger than me, so, to appreciate just how good they were and are, they might have been as young as 17 when they RECORDED this GREAT song, because it would have taken a while before a song got put on a juke box way up in Goose Bay, Labrador.
before Saturday Night Fever there was the Bee Gees featuring the unique vocal talent that is Robin Gibb - timeless music not the over produced electronically enhanced rubbish that seems to dominate the music scene today
Bonjour, vous aimez les sixties ? écoutez et podcastez mon émission "le super son des 60's" sur le site de plumfm. You like the 60's ? please, listen and podcast my broadcast "le super son des 60's", connect to "plumfm". Salut et faites gaffe au rock and roll.
@maskellenge5 They were on the album "To Whom It May Concern" released in 1972 it shouldnt prove too difficult to obtain, actually I believe I have a mint copy CD unplayed.
how could you not fall in love with the sound of his voice and the words of the song..? if only robin had to sing this song for me.... i could have married him everyday of my life.
the best nad ever the bee gees, brothers Gibb were and forever be the best ones, no doubt, not even tne beatles are superior. noooooo way!!!!!!!!!!!!! how many wonderful songs such as this beauty, I can´t see nobody
Am I really the only one who wishes the Small Faces had gotten royally pissed one night and ripped into this one at twice the tempo with the tape rolling? Think "Tin Soldier"....
Am I really the only one who wishes the Small Faces had gotten royally pissed one night and ripped into this one at twice the tempo with the tape rolling?
@narozzz Marriott had a great voice, he could have done a great cover of this, its right up his street, it has been recorded over 250 times! Bee Gees =genius.
Awesome, it sounds as though it could have been written from the point of view of someone who had no vision, or on the flip side, someone who'd been lost and desired to be reunited with a lost loved one maybe?
WOW!!!!, how the years have made me old, damn. so so many years ago in my mind sometime i just remember all these songs that i grew up with. and my first love, i really miss. so-so many years ago. i still love you Lisa... but it's been a lifetime ago, and we move on. but still a great band and songs are timeless. they take me back to lost love...
WOW!!!!, how the years have made me old, damn. so so many years ago in my mind sometime i just remember all these songs that i grew up with. and my first love, i really miss. so-so many years ago. i still love you Lisa... but it's been a lifetime ago, and we move on. but still a great band and songs are timeless. they take me back to lost love...
WOW!!!!, how the years have made me old, damn. so so many years ago in my mind sometime i just remember all these songs that i grew up with. and my first love, i really miss. so-so many years ago. i still love you Lisa... but it's been a lifetime ago, and we move on. but still a great band and songs are timeless. they take me back to losted love
Actually, this photo must be from the late 60s like 69 etc because this song is from the First album and they were a 5 piece up until their 3rd album.
NelsonHat, you said it all....when these guys started out, they were all....it got no better! Raw, passionate and soulful! I love this era of their music!!!
bands no matter what they have going for them at first have to keep up with the musical trend of the day or face a hard come back depending on how long the new trend lasts or if a better one they can deal with comes along. Isleys followed pfunk with who said and was able to keep going in their own style
The very best song off of this great album. Just listening to it again brings back terrific memories of the BeeGees when they were cranking out the hits.
The Bee Gees have no parity, I would urge anyone that is just starting to listen to them, to get all of their albums, they are the best band I have ever seen live, or indeed listened to.
They aren't my favorite17DJ but they sure got my attention with their many hits. This is one of the top 10 albums of all time. So many hits from one album.
This one of my favorite Beegees song..its the B side of New York mining Disaster 1941...but I always played it more (45's) ..I still don't understand why this was not a bigger hit... very haunting....
ich würde so gerne ,nur einmal in meinem leßen , neßen roßin gißß stehen ,ich währe dann super stolz !ßin ein großer fan von ihm ,wünsche ihm und seiner familie ,gesundheit und ein langes leßen !!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i wonder if peteboy remembers reagan and ollie north giving arms and cash to iran for the release of the hostages and paying for it by running dope into americas inner cities thats what i remember about the early 80s
Robin and Maurice were only 17 when this song was recorded. I first heard it over 42 years ago. Each time I listen to it, it brings back memories of the first time I heard itn amazing song. Fantastic writing.
takes me back to 1979-80-81. the iran hostages crises. when i hear this song i think of bill obluckner, he was the one we saw for 444 days blindfolded on all the mag covers time- newsweek-ect. they are not forgotten. and thank you to the people at the canadian embassy, for hideing 6 of the americans for almost 3 months, and getting them out safe.and for risking there own lives.
It's a unique voice, but it went very well with the songs and the group. This is one of my favorite BeeGees songs. Brings back memories from hearing on my dad's 8track.
How can this be too akward? his voice his soulful and haunting, simply unique. What on earth do people want from a singer? should they all sound like Westlife? please...the Bee Gees different vocal ability is what sets them apart from other bands, its stunning!
He's a vibrato singer, so he makes his voice constantly change pitch and tremmor, vibrating it, as you can see when he goes high here.
A contrast is 'And The Sun Will Shine' and, of course, 'I Started a Joke', thats his normal voice, it does all of that but he doesn't put the soul effect on.;)
There is no other singer who mildly resembles Robin, and he was only 19 for this, pretty unique.:)
This is probably his weirdest piece of singing from 1997 on the first bit of this video, he would of been aware that it sounded very odd even for him! watch?v=XsYt_B048g0
Special.
Have you seen I Started A Joke live? Thats normal.
He also has the worlds most feminine falsetto, only used solo once.;)
great song love robin voice does anyone have the song -lion in winter- it was on the trafalgar album robin sings his heart out in that song I cant find it anywhere on the net someone please post it.
Does anyone know who the guy is on the far right on the album cover picture? I remember seeing him in early photos of the group, but he wasn't shown after 1968 or so. I know he's not a Gibb brother. BTW I love this song!
WOW!!!! i thought that "Fanny be tender" was their best lyrical song, but now since i really looked at the lyrics of this song I think that maybe, just maybe, it takes the prize!!!!
Mojave888 The Bee Gees never considered themselves a disco band, that was a label given to them by the media, they simply wrote songs that represented the era they were living in. It was never planned, its just the way things worked out.
very well said kiss me!they never used the word disco in their songs-come to think of it neither did donna summer-and she was dubbed the queen of disco.
Fantastic song, spoilled only by the crap transmittion system you tube uses to send it. It would be nice to here a song right through without those dead stupid gaps.
this song is a great song. BGs are the best, I am a gov. employee and live in US, have no idea how the two are related.America does not suck, but the way it is going, it will. Dear Sarcastic Bitch, When you one of these days woke up and found out that US dollar is worthless, and your job sucks, remember not to blame me, by then I'd be long gone. remember all corps in Wall Street & Silicon Valley that moved to India and China all the good jobs and all the investments, gone with them.
I cannot believe this song never charted, anywhere in the world, for any artist. That is just inconceivable, because it's such a well known song.
SecretTimeWarp 1 week ago
BEE GEES for ever.
pordostubos 1 week ago
watch?v=K0Q62O65FZA
dimges 1 month ago
Fashawn & Exile "The Ecology"
DJCalCuttah 1 month ago
Love u ,Robin -more than u can imagine. I'd say - you are the song. You've got a very classy style.
violet640 1 month ago
actually, they were born in England, but grew up in Australia
URDEggMen 1 month ago
@URDEggMen They were born on the Isle of Man, not England. The island is not part of the United Kingdom.
MoviMakr 4 weeks ago
@MoviMakr bien pues al menos esa isla ya tiene idolos .
napsterr99 3 weeks ago
This was the B side of "New York Mining Disaster", their first English single, and a much better song. Their first album was the best. Bonus points for naming the fourth guy on the album cover-he was their drummer, initials C.P. (Even more points for naming their guitarist, who was also a Bee Gee for awhile...initials V. M.)
interestingfailure 1 month ago
@interestingfailure OK the drummer was Colin Peterson, and the guitar player was Vince Melouney,and the third thing that you are right about is this track,as good as "Mining Disaster" was, this tune was so ahead of it's time and the melody and changes in the intro were so eerie and haunting. One of my favorites from them. I'm glad I grew up in the 60's,I actually had a chance to see them 4 times,and once with a 52 piece orchestra,so you can imagine how this tune came off. The song is in E .
MrKite053 1 month ago
CHEF SUKA YE.ADA PENINGKATAN.
TheAZMAN83 1 month ago
Best of Bee Gees came out in 1969 and this song was on Bee Gees 1st which came out in 1967.
ivaro3 2 months ago
Inqualifiable
MegaAndreNo 2 months ago
great tune, I have this on vinyl
MetalandHotRods 2 months ago
@MetalandHotRods I have the Odessa album. Original 2 LP in the red velvet case
asitphoto 1 month ago
Can someobdy please inform me on when this album was released
karana808 2 months ago
Comment removed
17DJLOVER 2 months ago
@karana808 1970
17DJLOVER 2 months ago
I heard this track when this best of bee gees album was being played.
I liked it so much I bought the entire album. I still have it...
sexyeyes1969 2 months ago
old time bee gees....nothing beats this.
powerlinestreet88 3 months ago 2
can sit on the whole day just listening to their songs...brings back a lot of sweet n bitter memories of yesteryears...
Mel1957100 3 months ago 2
I bet Canada is right in front of them.
Mouse7991 3 months ago
Fashawn - The Ecology
hugeri 3 months ago
Can anyone please tell me what the lyrics are twixt 3:23 & 3:25?
CactiTrio 3 months ago in playlist CactiTrio's favorites
i never the times when artist like Bee Gees , the Beatles , Hollies and others hits te charts .Listen to the 45 singles was so mighty ... we were happy and had so many .....
the radio on a pirate station and our first sigaret ... but that was a big mistake lol
now i m not smoking no more for 16 years
walter4092 4 months ago
this one makes you want to dance..... even alone.
harleyluvrable 4 months ago
i,love,you,wait,for,me,handsome
mollysangelique 4 months ago
Compare this with ghetto crap we get today.
casper1918 4 months ago 16
@casper1918 no ay comparacion con una joya y la vomitada de perro que nos quieren vender hoy en dia.
napsterr99 3 weeks ago
TOP RANKED ROCK GROUPS ARE, # 1 BEATLES #2 BEEGEES, # abba , ACCORDING TO MOST RECORDS SOLD IN HISTORY OF ROCK NROLL
stalkingwolf1954 5 months ago
one of the best songs ever
moderntalkingfan1 5 months ago
@Cawabear I started a joke always gets me going. It's hauntingly beautiful.
ThatGirlTyson 5 months ago
Brits with such soul
STUNNING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
TheIncredibleDrAss 6 months ago
@TheIncredibleDrAss Their actually from Australia doc.
MrKite053 1 month ago
@MrKite053 he didnt say they wernt he said english single
JordanDinstrumentals 1 month ago
So does this mean they CAN see SOMEBODY?
ecnalubma696969 6 months ago
ชอบอย่างแรง เพลงโปรด
The500miles 6 months ago 3
Their best music period; in my opinion!
thisboy1964 6 months ago
Unbelievable! Life takes someone like Maurice Gibb and leaves someone like loone248? Damn you, life!!!!!
riffmagos 7 months ago 2
@loone248 You have the IQ of a fucking sunflower!
GeorgiiiiRaWK 7 months ago
The Bee Gees Before Disco were fantastic !!!!!!
Steve1861 7 months ago 20
BG always in mee.......
niaacute 8 months ago
@loone248 - Dear fucker, tell me which song do you think is better than this one ?
eurasiatse 8 months ago
To : loone248, Dear fucker, tell me which song do you think is better than this one ?
eurasiatse 8 months ago
I first heard this song on a juke box in an RAF hanger in Goose Bay, Labrador. RAF crewmen had already heard of the Bee Gees. It was in the SPRING of 1967. It was one of those songs that stopped you in your tracks. I was only 19. Robin and Maurice are younger than me, so, to appreciate just how good they were and are, they might have been as young as 17 when they RECORDED this GREAT song, because it would have taken a while before a song got put on a juke box way up in Goose Bay, Labrador.
sikorskiS55 8 months ago
"I Can't See My Friends" was a song By The Dominos In 1968.
gibsosgerbil 8 months ago
I will any day prefer the Beegees as they were before Saturday Night Fever
originalpauper 9 months ago 4
Need more of this sound in the world~damn!!! They were so smooth/good~if you know their history~you would truely unstand all great bands~j
mobeers1 9 months ago 3
bee gees will always be on my memories till the end of time. melody fair film songs reminds me of my school days
soosay1955 9 months ago 4
@soosay1955 Dear lord thank you for mentioning that movie,I thought I was one of just a few who remember that movie! Me born 56!
5evad2 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Shit
JayElliot2k7 10 months ago
4 ppl cant see nobody
ThePhantomX18 10 months ago 2
amazing tunes they were some band before they started 2 sing like alvin and the chipmunks even tho staying alive is class 2
andrew406 11 months ago
no offence bliss n eso are better lonely streets
Alex29Black 1 year ago
Beautiful....I love the background strings too.
Sauceywalker 1 year ago 2
Ecology
cisneros927 1 year ago 2
before Saturday Night Fever there was the Bee Gees featuring the unique vocal talent that is Robin Gibb - timeless music not the over produced electronically enhanced rubbish that seems to dominate the music scene today
MrKevinsweeney 1 year ago 2
@MrKevinsweeney Well said sir.
cudaj2 9 months ago
this goes back to my early teens, GOD long ago and far away
stalkingwolf1954 1 year ago 2
Get back to sleep Rip Van Winkle, you are in the wrong lane.
slugman2000 1 year ago
Very good song, reminds me a bit of Van Morrison
mdmejia67 1 year ago
They made great records....this is the Bee Gees!!!
BeatleJim55 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Bonjour, vous aimez les sixties ? écoutez et podcastez mon émission "le super son des 60's" sur le site de plumfm. You like the 60's ? please, listen and podcast my broadcast "le super son des 60's", connect to "plumfm". Salut et faites gaffe au rock and roll.
supersondessixties 1 year ago
oks na oks
chammytheor 1 year ago
is this the version used in the simpsons movie?
SnowIsMyName 1 year ago
I have this album on an 8 track tape I bought in 1969........Bee Gees and Creedence Clearwater were my life's soundtrack back then.
casper1918 1 year ago
@casper1918 What great soundtracks to have as a backdrop to your life, both brilliant bands!
GeorgiiiiRaWK 1 year ago
i'm looking for the songs,"I must have lost the road?" and "Billy had a bomb?"
maskellenge5 1 year ago
@maskellenge5 They were on the album "To Whom It May Concern" released in 1972 it shouldnt prove too difficult to obtain, actually I believe I have a mint copy CD unplayed.
17DJLOVER 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Did Barry do the orchestral arrangements on their early work? They were stunning.
pborrellij 1 year ago
Did Barry do these orchestral arrangements on their early work? They were just beautiful?
pborrellij 1 year ago
@pborrellij It was Bill Sheperd that produced the early work, I think they began producing their own albums in 1976
TENRECORDS 1 year ago
lovely song
stopomaniak1 1 year ago
finely i found it,i've searched for this song for like 1 year :S
p.s. check out theroserosalie :D :D
kika0508 1 year ago
i love you robin and that's all i can say..
leilalovesrobin 1 year ago
lol@bliss and eso telling me bout this song.
nishy100 1 year ago
how could you not fall in love with the sound of his voice and the words of the song..? if only robin had to sing this song for me.... i could have married him everyday of my life.
leilalovesrobin 1 year ago 4
Thank you for upload this sweet song.
TheGrogol 1 year ago
My favorite Bee Gees Song
GypsyFullMoon 1 year ago
no doudt bee gees r still a band they are not past
khan00411 1 year ago
...meraviglia...
piopomponio 1 year ago
50 Cent made a rap with this called 50 Bars Of Pain he did a good job using the beat for reals
SirLucio10 1 year ago
whos singing? i cant recognize the voice, is it barry? =/
sharpi22 1 year ago
@sharpi22 Its Robin.
GeorgiiiiRaWK 1 year ago
the best nad ever the bee gees, brothers Gibb were and forever be the best ones, no doubt, not even tne beatles are superior. noooooo way!!!!!!!!!!!!! how many wonderful songs such as this beauty, I can´t see nobody
beethomozart 1 year ago
Shame the title is gramatically incorrect
noahwayne 1 year ago
Cool!! this is a good bee gees song and its the sample to "The Ecology" by Fashawn.
MichaelWED 1 year ago
All of my Bee Gees got blocked. This old Bee Gee stuff is good.
NcicHit 1 year ago
Barry and Robin should be held in the same reguards as John and Paul!!
univibe23 1 year ago 12
@univibe23 Without a doubt
calalilygirl 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Am I really the only one who wishes the Small Faces had gotten royally pissed one night and ripped into this one at twice the tempo with the tape rolling? Think "Tin Soldier"....
narozzz 1 year ago
Am I really the only one who wishes the Small Faces had gotten royally pissed one night and ripped into this one at twice the tempo with the tape rolling?
narozzz 1 year ago
@narozzz Marriott had a great voice, he could have done a great cover of this, its right up his street, it has been recorded over 250 times! Bee Gees =genius.
TENRECORDS 1 year ago
awesome !
dbetters 1 year ago 2
Awesome, it sounds as though it could have been written from the point of view of someone who had no vision, or on the flip side, someone who'd been lost and desired to be reunited with a lost loved one maybe?
crocodile1374 1 year ago
Simply the best.....forget the rest.
HK019 1 year ago 3
OMG Who ever flipped this.....Amazing. 50 Owns this instrumental..
ALevelMedia1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WOW!!!!, how the years have made me old, damn. so so many years ago in my mind sometime i just remember all these songs that i grew up with. and my first love, i really miss. so-so many years ago. i still love you Lisa... but it's been a lifetime ago, and we move on. but still a great band and songs are timeless. they take me back to lost love...
ConditionOfAnonymity 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WOW!!!!, how the years have made me old, damn. so so many years ago in my mind sometime i just remember all these songs that i grew up with. and my first love, i really miss. so-so many years ago. i still love you Lisa... but it's been a lifetime ago, and we move on. but still a great band and songs are timeless. they take me back to lost love...
ConditionOfAnonymity 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WOW!!!!, how the years have made me old, damn. so so many years ago in my mind sometime i just remember all these songs that i grew up with. and my first love, i really miss. so-so many years ago. i still love you Lisa... but it's been a lifetime ago, and we move on. but still a great band and songs are timeless. they take me back to losted love
ConditionOfAnonymity 1 year ago
Comment removed
ConditionOfAnonymity 1 year ago
Oh I'm sorry, it's FoShawn
tr763 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hey it's Jay-z
tr763 1 year ago
like they were at the time 18 or 20 years of age..remarkable...don,t know how those 4 scousers got to be so revered???? how old were they....
chasam1234 1 year ago 5
Actually, this photo must be from the late 60s like 69 etc because this song is from the First album and they were a 5 piece up until their 3rd album.
This photo is missing Vince, the lead guitarist.
VoodooFlintstone 1 year ago
NelsonHat, you said it all....when these guys started out, they were all....it got no better! Raw, passionate and soulful! I love this era of their music!!!
beannacht1 1 year ago 31
It tells of a love that's powerful. Written in the stars; just meant to be.
cactusqueendarlene 2 years ago
Such a beautiful haunting song, the lyrics are stunning, what a band the Bee Gees were.
NelsonsHat 2 years ago 370
@NelsonsHat do not use were. They're forever together no matter what in our minds and heart. BEEGEES FOR LIFE!!!!!
darkjaychou 1 year ago
Cello in this?
6364gg2 2 years ago
Het blijft geweldige muziek die je ook een beetje doet terug denken aan toen
corneel49 2 years ago
I've never been a big fan of the Bee Gee but this album is unreal much better than that later disco stuff.
cookiekooke 2 years ago 7
@cookiekooke I agree completely. The Bee Gees were much better than the thrash they insisted to play in the 70s.
ChivaInvencible 2 years ago
bands no matter what they have going for them at first have to keep up with the musical trend of the day or face a hard come back depending on how long the new trend lasts or if a better one they can deal with comes along. Isleys followed pfunk with who said and was able to keep going in their own style
ElderPharoah 2 years ago 4
The Opposit of the "Stones".. Chart toppers, just same, on OPPOSIT side of the spectrum... Gotta love 'um.. ;D
MATUSOWNED 2 years ago
The very best song off of this great album. Just listening to it again brings back terrific memories of the BeeGees when they were cranking out the hits.
newhotman1001 2 years ago 8
I agree with you. An amazing album , and this song is very much underrated.
benmart5 2 years ago 8
the bee gees' brightest times!!!!!!!!!!!!
mulheriu1 2 years ago
The Bee Gees have no parity, I would urge anyone that is just starting to listen to them, to get all of their albums, they are the best band I have ever seen live, or indeed listened to.
17DJLOVER 2 years ago 10
They aren't my favorite17DJ but they sure got my attention with their many hits. This is one of the top 10 albums of all time. So many hits from one album.
newhotman1001 2 years ago
They really were incredible, weren't they?
bruceok 2 years ago 7
Again I say, this Bee Gees music is more enjoyable to listen to, than their disco stuff. It is only my opinion, but this is way, way, way better.
5*'s
rubyredlipstick71 2 years ago 4
yeah when THOUGHT of the beegees i thought of disco cocain and orgies but i just found this album and wow this is a beautiful work of art
ilooklikeppl 2 years ago
agree ilooklikeppl. I'm thinking about purchasing this album now. I never knew them outside of their disco era and I'm glad to discover these gems.
rubyredlipstick71 2 years ago
This one of my favorite Beegees song..its the B side of New York mining Disaster 1941...but I always played it more (45's) ..I still don't understand why this was not a bigger hit... very haunting....
Thank you Robin great job on this song
Barry
roanokebarry 2 years ago 4
robin sang this one
wildfirejs 2 years ago
ich würde so gerne ,nur einmal in meinem leßen , neßen roßin gißß stehen ,ich währe dann super stolz !ßin ein großer fan von ihm ,wünsche ihm und seiner familie ,gesundheit und ein langes leßen !!!!
HeXeN5 2 years ago
who did the lead vocals,
urchill1 2 years ago
Robin Gibb did lead vocals on this track.
slugman2000 2 years ago 4
THANX.
urchill1 2 years ago
I wonder if my grandma forgot to feed her cat Horace in 1982.
Goblinshead 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i wonder if peteboy remembers reagan and ollie north giving arms and cash to iran for the release of the hostages and paying for it by running dope into americas inner cities thats what i remember about the early 80s
zachisbackfu 2 years ago
The opening sounds like the beginning of " To Love Somebody".
Wonder if this was a follow up?
MIKECNW 2 years ago 2
Robin and Maurice were only 17 when this song was recorded. I first heard it over 42 years ago. Each time I listen to it, it brings back memories of the first time I heard itn amazing song. Fantastic writing.
sikorskiS55 2 years ago 4
Love your HD with Bee Gees.
Wish you have more of them in HD!
inogi339 2 years ago
i was in love with my first girlfriend....
Maldoror123 2 years ago 3
takes me back to 1979-80-81. the iran hostages crises. when i hear this song i think of bill obluckner, he was the one we saw for 444 days blindfolded on all the mag covers time- newsweek-ect. they are not forgotten. and thank you to the people at the canadian embassy, for hideing 6 of the americans for almost 3 months, and getting them out safe.and for risking there own lives.
peteboy1113 2 years ago
for an 18 year old teenager to write a song this awesome is godlike!!!!
GawakitaArts 2 years ago 14
I always thought it was Maurice Gibb's only solo song as a Bee Gees member. The accent is quite strong and unique though.
TimHowardII 2 years ago
I just love this song. I love Robin's voice on this one. Very unique I must say.
Farrah300 2 years ago 4
The O N L Y Group more HAUNTING,and TRAGIC than ANY others !
MATUSOWNED 2 years ago 4
Great song from great group.
saasokee 2 years ago 4
It's a unique voice, but it went very well with the songs and the group. This is one of my favorite BeeGees songs. Brings back memories from hearing on my dad's 8track.
ucenic1 3 years ago 6
HAHAHA, thats to funny thats how I got my first taste of the Bee Gees
moxin29 2 years ago
How can this be too akward? his voice his soulful and haunting, simply unique. What on earth do people want from a singer? should they all sound like Westlife? please...the Bee Gees different vocal ability is what sets them apart from other bands, its stunning!
slugman2000 3 years ago 129
@slugman2000 what's westlife?
roscogre 1 year ago
@roscogre Its a place in Scotland.
slugman2000 1 year ago
@slugman2000 what? why should a band sound like a place?
makes no sense at all.
roscogre 1 year ago
Robin sounds really weird. But the Chorus is good.
Sephiroth20066 3 years ago
Yeah, as always, this is one of his soul voices (he uses it on Still Waters for example), sort of reverbed in, strange but he makes it interesting.;)
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Why does he sing like that?
Sephiroth20066 3 years ago
He's a vibrato singer, so he makes his voice constantly change pitch and tremmor, vibrating it, as you can see when he goes high here.
A contrast is 'And The Sun Will Shine' and, of course, 'I Started a Joke', thats his normal voice, it does all of that but he doesn't put the soul effect on.;)
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is just too akward to me.
Sephiroth20066 3 years ago
:D Thats a relatively recurring theme.
There is no other singer who mildly resembles Robin, and he was only 19 for this, pretty unique.:)
This is probably his weirdest piece of singing from 1997 on the first bit of this video, he would of been aware that it sounded very odd even for him! watch?v=XsYt_B048g0
Special.
Have you seen I Started A Joke live? Thats normal.
He also has the worlds most feminine falsetto, only used solo once.;)
LukeShoveller 3 years ago
Two words. CARL WILSON.
Sephiroth20066 3 years ago
great song love robin voice does anyone have the song -lion in winter- it was on the trafalgar album robin sings his heart out in that song I cant find it anywhere on the net someone please post it.
coltripwired 3 years ago 2
Just been listening to "Lion in Winter" this morning.I can email you an mp3 if you haven't already got a copy:)
mutchkatsonga 2 years ago
FANTASTIC!!!!!
carolmary43 3 years ago
Its colin Peterson, he was a drummer with the Bee Gees for a few years.
NelsonsHat 3 years ago
Does anyone know who the guy is on the far right on the album cover picture? I remember seeing him in early photos of the group, but he wasn't shown after 1968 or so. I know he's not a Gibb brother. BTW I love this song!
romo937 3 years ago
who sings most of the song?
it is such an amazing voice.
thanks
Toto7Berlin 3 years ago
Robin
gunkler1 3 years ago
magnificent...their early music is far superior than SNF or anything later
Lisasmessageservice 3 years ago
WOW!!!! i thought that "Fanny be tender" was their best lyrical song, but now since i really looked at the lyrics of this song I think that maybe, just maybe, it takes the prize!!!!
smooovieee 3 years ago
Some dj's thought this was the Beatles when it first came out! Great classic 60's love song! Where have they gone???
malikacc 3 years ago 2
Fantastic! So early Bee Gees it almost seems like self parody. As an American I can barely even understand it.
wilbar2922 3 years ago
Thanks for that comment tomasdoyle, when you get to 60 you are a bit slow picking new technology, regards aajlrrecruit.
aajlrrecruit 3 years ago
Thanks for the upload...
thanksforthemusic 3 years ago
Mojave888 The Bee Gees never considered themselves a disco band, that was a label given to them by the media, they simply wrote songs that represented the era they were living in. It was never planned, its just the way things worked out.
XkissmeXkillmeXMCR 3 years ago
very well said kiss me!they never used the word disco in their songs-come to think of it neither did donna summer-and she was dubbed the queen of disco.
charliedontsurf70 3 years ago
So cool, why on Earth did they go Disco???
Mojave888 3 years ago
@Mojave888 It was all the rage back in 1975 and for a few years after.
calalilygirl 3 months ago
Fantastic song, spoilled only by the crap transmittion system you tube uses to send it. It would be nice to here a song right through without those dead stupid gaps.
aajlrrecruit 3 years ago
sorry i wouldnt normally reply but dude its your connection not how your tube 'sends it'...
tomasdoyle 3 years ago
sorry i wouldnt normally reply but dude its your connection not how you tube 'sends it'...
tomasdoyle 3 years ago
Nothing beats the crisp sound off of a record player.
archernewb 3 years ago
YESSSSSSS!!!
ilovechickenmeat 3 years ago
this song is a great song. BGs are the best, I am a gov. employee and live in US, have no idea how the two are related.America does not suck, but the way it is going, it will. Dear Sarcastic Bitch, When you one of these days woke up and found out that US dollar is worthless, and your job sucks, remember not to blame me, by then I'd be long gone. remember all corps in Wall Street & Silicon Valley that moved to India and China all the good jobs and all the investments, gone with them.
eftekhar2006 3 years ago
IT'S FASCINATING
I LIKE bee gees so much
but i hope to get this song with lyrics or karaoke
mido1977alex 3 years ago 3