(Part2)If there had been slaughter in Nanking of a magnitude so great (300,000 civilian victims) as to prompt the description “holocaust of the century,” there is not the slightest chance that he would have been silent on the matter.
(Part1)Chinese Communist Party Chairman Mao Zedong never referred to a massacre in Nanking. He made exactly one mention of the Battle of Nanking during a lecture delivered at Yan’an six months after the conflict, reproduced in On Protracted War. Chairman Mao criticized the Japanese for failing to annihilate Chinese troops after having surrounded them.
China has no right to accuse Japan of crimes such as the Nanking Massacre because the massacre was made up story using fabricated evidence. Obviously what China says is pure fiction! Demonstration of this story by the Chinese government is libel and slander. It is natural that Japanese raising an objection.
@qwan1231 I can't believe what China said. Even the official conference about the Nanking Massacre research, Chinese historians showed their collections as evidence of the massacre. The photographs, which Chinese showed are known to be fabricated, or from different areas and different times, continue to be used to "prove" Japanese guilt in the winter of 1937-38 at Nanjing
three alls policy, unit 731, forced labor, comfort women, killing of war prisoners, Manila massacre, Sook Ching massacre, Bataan Death March, Burma Railway...
Do you know the fact that the Nanking city was controlled by Chinese government after the Japanese occupied the city? The Reformed Government of the Republic of China (Chinese: 中華民國維新政府) was a Chinese provisional government protected by Japan that existed from 1938 to 1940. 梁鴻志,温宗尭,陳群,陳籙,陳錦濤,王子恵,江洪杰,陳則民,任援道,許修直,朱履龢,高冠吾 and 傅筱庵 controlled the Nanking city until 1940.
Haven't you learned the history in school?
Chinese propaganda is still on going! We have to be careful about China.
@undertakerRach The government is not our true government,it was actually a ‘偽政府’ the people who controlled it were called'漢奸‘. and they were killed by the true government after the war because of helping the japanese.
@(Part1)The Japanese stationed troops in South Manchuria for protect it as the same as another countries under the boxer protocol. In fact, at that time, China was unsafe country. A book which name is近現代史集中講座 written by Kou Bunyu, he is a Chinese, said before Japan occupied Manchuria in 1932, Chinese government had extracted taxes from people strictly for Civil War. Moreover, other authorities had solicited a bribe and seized their people’s properties.
@ (Part2)Many soldiers had taken opium and used violence on people. The Communist Party of China, which was led by Mao Zedong battled the Chinese Nationalist Party or Kuomintang, which was led by Chiang Kai-shek. The Chinese Civil War began in April 1927, amidst the Northern Expedition. American journalist, Frederic Williams, and Chinese historian Kou Bunyu said Japanese created a new modern country Manchuria and kicked out corrupt military soldiers who were bandits and authorities from there.
@katongche (Part3)Many Chinese must have been living in peace. Their life changed to affluently society after Japanese occupied Manchuria. Approximately 1,000,000 Chinese moved to Manchuria in every year. 干沖漢, he was a man of powerful of economic in China, said, “Good bye China and we will make a new country with Japanese.” Moreover, many autonomous regions tried to make new political systems. In short, Chinese people were tired from Chinese politicians.
@katongche (Part4)However, almost 3000 Chinese who were friendly with Japanese killed by KMT while July, 1937 to July, 1938. If they weren’t killed by KMT, we can hear what a true story was in China. 漢奸？Oh I think so. Peaceful people 漢奸, they were also Chinese people, were killed by Chinese government, which was the same as Tiananmen Massacre in 1989.
@qwan1231 Some foreigners wrote the Japanese rape stories in documents during the war. However, these cases were what these Westerners heard about from the Chinese. After Minnie Vautrin wrote it, Chinese officers were caught by police for rape crimes. This story was written in an article of the New York Times on January 4, 1938. After they were caught, conspicuous cases of rape, looting and other atrocities did not take place. Therefore, these crimes were definitely caused by the Chinese.
@undertakerRach I was just pointing out that one of your evidence was not true according to Wikipedia and its reference. Now, you want to argue with me by more unjustified evidences that you learned from your history books. GET A LIFE DUDE ! Nanjing massacre was verified by a public trial holding by the UN. You want to deny it. Try disprove all those evidences in a serious place.
@qwan1231 (Part1)I know Chinese people who were brainwashed by Chinese communists send a lot of wrong stories to Wikipedia, so what has been written in Wiki is not true. After year of 2000, many new facts are revealed by historians. For example, many Nanking pictures edited by China, and Nanking population were increased after Japanese troops set up a new Chinese government which president was a Chinese guy. That’s why we have been appealed the new fact!
4. Maybe there are some of brainwashed Chinese can access to Wikipedia, but those pages are edited by public. Do you mean that all people in the English world are brainwashed?
5. There are books, movies and documentary publicly available in the western world. Are they brainwashed?
6. if you are arguing that number are exaggerated, I can still talk to you. If you want to deny the Nanking Massacre completely . The only thing I can say is that you don't have a concept of right and wrong. You are here only to repeat those Japanese books you read and accepted without thinking
@qwan1231 (Part2)What China said was already refuted by historians and computer technology. The Nanking Massacre was a false story. The massacre was created by China to ask help to the United States. China has no right to accuse Japan of crimes such as the Nanking Massacre because the massacre was made up story using fabricated evidence. Demonstration of this story by the Chinese government is libel and slander. It is natural that Japanese raising an objection.
Nanking massacre is not an isolated incident. It is only a small fraction of Japanese war crime during WWII in China. try google: three alls policy, unit 731, forced labor, comfort women ... Don't tell me these were never happened, Victims are till alive.
@qwan1231 (Part1)Chinese nuclear tests began on Oct. 16, 1964, with the above ground detonation of a 20,000-ton bomb, followed by two-megaton surface explosions in 1967. The largest was a four-megaton explosion on Nov. 17, 1976. China changed to doing atmospheric tests in 1980 and underground tests from 1982 to 1996. Professor Takada said China is the only country in the world that carries out these large-scale surface tests in living areas.
@qwan1231 (Part2)The Japanese Uyghur Association criticized the tests. "The former Soviet Union would carry out nuclear tests in an enclosed barb-wired area, but the Chinese regime didn't even inform the local residents,” he said. “The victims included not only the Uyghur people, but also Han Chinese. The authorities disregarded any semblance of humanity and treated the people living there as lab rats."
@q (Part3) He urged Japan, the first victim of nuclear weapons, to share the information with the rest of the world and help the victims.
In July and August of 1998, the British Channel 4 broadcasted a special documentary, “Death On the Silk Road.” A team of doctors and filmmakers posed as tourists in order to assess the possible effects from the nuclear tests in China. From the interviews conducted in local villages, they found a large number of infants with cleft lips or mental retardation.
@qwan1231 (Part4)Among the Uyghur people, many were suffering from malignant lymphoid leukemia. Incidences of cancer in Uyghur began rising in 1970 and by 1990, it was more than 30% higher than the national average. The cancer incidence in the capital city Urumqi doubled that of other areas during 1993 to 2000.
In china so many citizens are being killed by government. However, citizens are accusing Japan because kids have been taught how much the Japanese are barbaric.
It's not surprising that Japanese have trouble trusting the Chinese Communist Party. CCP is notorious for their propaganda efforts especially with the historical subjects. Matter of the fact they have managed to erase the entire Tienanmen Square Massacre from the Chinese textbook.
The Bottom line is that the CCP will have to Clean up their action before Japanese can trust them.
Fitch wrote in his "My Eighty Years In China" published by Mei. Ya Publications in Taiwan, "The DIGEST story brought such a storm of protest from readers who thought "unbelievable" that three months later the editors published excerpts from my diary and those of others who went through the occupation, which verified my observations."
The Nanking diary by George A. Fitch, from December 17 to the new year's day in 1938, parallels to Rabe's diary and they have no conflicts with each other. Fitch's Nanking diary anonymously appeared in H.J.Timperley's "Japanese Terror in China" published in 1938, which was translated in Japanese in the same year and read by limited numbers of Japanese, and then in Reader's Digest of July 1938.
@acmuser ■(Part1)It was clearly proved by their testimonies at the IMTFE that no committee members had witnessed 'illegal murders by Japanese soldiers at all. O. Wilson, who made many testimonies as to atrocities, did admit that all of his testimonies were hearsay. Magee, who lived with Bates and worked for the Safety Zone Committee, testified that he had just eye-witnessed only one case.
@acmuser (Part2)As a matter of fact, neither Rabe nor other westerners of the Safety Zone Committee members, who might have been able to walk around freely in the city with Nazi Swastika armband on, had ever witnessed illegal murders by Japanese soldiers during six weeks.
By February 5, 1938, the International Committee had forwarded to the Japanese embassy a total of 450 cases of murder, rape, and general disorder by Japanese soldiers that had been reported after the American, British and German diplomats had returned to their embassies.
@qwan1231 (Part1)In fact, how bad was the damage? It was on the morning of January 6, 1938 when foreigners entered the walled city of Nanking under the Japanese occupation for the first time. They were James Espy, the vice consul at the American Embassy to Nanking and the third Secretary John M. Allison. Allison immediately investigated the damage made against the U.S. interests. In spite that the correspondent reported the residence of American Embassy was one of the targets of looting, ///
@qwan1231 (Part2)///Allison sent a telegram on January 8 to the Secretary of State in Washington that 'American property in the so-called Safety Zone received relatively small damage, except for occasional looting or thefts. The record written by the Safety Zone Committee endorsed this report, and it detailed the 'damage due to looting committed by the Japanese soldiers', from December 12 through 18 when a massive looting was supposed to have occurred, as follows:
@qwan1231 (Part3)Five automobiles, six bicycles, several motorbikes, two cows, one pig, several ponies, three sack's of rice, 500 futon mats, two gloves, a bottle of milk, a handful of sugar, one pan, one trash box, six fountain pens, a half can of kerosene, and a few candles. From this list, would anyone be able to say that a large scale looting had taken place? Moreover, how many cases of rape were (including attempted) reported in the documents by the Safety Zone Committee?
@qwan1231 (Part4)The total number was 361. And among them, there were only 61 cases, which definitely clarified who witnessed the cases, who heard and reported. Among these cases, only seven cases were clarified to be crimes committed by Japanese soldiers and notified the Japanese Army of the crime in order to disclose the fact and to capture the suspects. Out of these records, how could Bates have calculated the number 8,000 on rapes?
@qwan1231 (Part5)There was the International Committee for Nanking Safety Zone. This committee consisted of 22 Westerners. This committee wrote reports regarding the security situation of Nanking city 61 times from Dec.13, 1937 to Feb.9, 1938 and sent the same reports to Japanese Embassy, Embassy of the United States, British Embassy and Germany Embassy. According to these 61 reports, they reported murder: 41, mayhem: 44, rape: 361, taking: 390, plunder and others: 170 for 2 months.
@qwan1231 (Part6)However, all of these reports were “hearsay”. In other words, nobody of this committee witnessed them actually. The International Military Tribunal for the Far East (Tokyo Trial: 1946-1948) summoned 4 members of this committee included Magee, Ashmore Fitch, Bates and Wilson. They testified they did not witness any murder and heard from someone. This trial proved nobody witnessed murders actually and they wrote reports on the basis of”Hearsay”.
Rabe's diary is the outstanding testimony of the witness of the Nanking atrocity, though he was limited to move around only in the safety zone except some occasions. Rabe describes what happens around him day by day, before and after the fall of Nanking by the Japanese.
@acmuser ■(Part1)John Rabe was a member of international Safety Zone Committee in Nanking. Many Chinese people said he was a witness of the Nanking Massacre with confidence. However, he had never witnessed even one case of murder. In spite of that, he sent many reports to Hitler and wrote the stories to his diary. In fact, his diary and reports to Germany were written different number of victims. Why?
@acmuser (Part2)For Fear of counter objections, he reported to the Japanese authorities in Nanking city the number of casualties to be 49 based on some extent of reliable information. But on the other hand, to journalists, German diplomats and A. Hitler who were all absent in Nanking, he reported figures with an enormous difference, as if no less than tens of thousands civilians had been killed by Japanese troops. Why did Rabe make a false report of the massacre to Hitler?
@ (Part3)According to German historian Gerhard Krebs, the reason was based on power politics in his German homeland. “Defeated and depressed in World War I, Germany knew that china was a significant trade partner. Particularly Chiang Kai-shek, who was fighting against the CCP, needed a large number of weapons, while Germany was able to import raw materials that were indispensable for the postwar reconstruction.” The Sino-Japanese War forced Germany to reconsider its foreign policy toward China.
@acmuser (Part4)The Japanese government repeatedly demanded that Germany stop the export of weapons to Japan's enemy Chiang Kai-shek. As the result, Hitler decided to take advantage of containment against the Soviet Union by promoting strong relationship with Japan. Germany refrained from exporting weapons to the Chiang Kai-shek. (In fact, it was in l940 when Germany reached an agreement with Japan.)There were someone strongly resisted the change of policy taken by Hitler.
@acmuser (Part5)They were Von Falkenhausen, the head of the military advisory group in China, and Rabe, who represented an interest of Siemens in the Chinese munitions industry as a pro-Chinese group. Rabe exaggerated the Japanese Army’s atrocities and requested Hitler to reconsider the alliance with Japan. Rabe's anti-Japanese reports had been thought suspicious since then.
@acmuser (Part6)Moreover, P. Scharfienberg, the secretary general of the German Embassy to China, who returned to Nanking city on January 9, tried to investigate the fact about 'Japanese Army's atrocities Rabe reported' by himself, and wrote to the German Embassy at Hankow on February 10: “He [Rabe] is still actively trying to counter the bloody excesses of Japanese looters, which have unfortunately increased of late.
@acmuser (Part7)To my mind, this should not concern us Germans, particularly since one can clearly see that the Chinese, once left to depend solely on the Japanese, immediately fraternize. And as for all these excesses, one hears only one side of it, after all.” That report is called untrustworthy story after people defined the fact.
Most of comments which are written by Chinese does not have any logical (historical) points. They have just piled up scornful language against Japanese here. This is the China. During the war, Chinese soldiers killed many Chinese people. They comitted many crimes in China. They were like bandits. Chinese government pinned thier crimes on Japanese soldiers.
GERMANY ALWAYS STAND ON WAR CRIMINAL ACTIONS WERE NOT BELONG TO GERMAN CIVILIANS ONLY POLITICS AND NAZIS REASONS!
U R IDIOT!
GIVE US BACK ODA MONEY ASAP!
WE SUPPORTED CHINK ECONOMY SINCE 1979, HUGE MONEY WE REND U!
NOW PAY BACK TIME, GIVE US BACK ALL ODA MONEY!
HEY CHEAL SHIT GIVE US BACK ODA(THIRD WORLD UNDER DEVELOPING NATION BENEFIT SUPPORT) U PRETENDING NO THIRD WORLD ANY MORE SO U DON NEED THIRD WORLD BENEFICIAL!!
16:05Watch these killed children ! They are not Chinese ! They are all Japanese children massacred by Chinese troops in Tongzhou on July 29, 1937. The Chinese Communist government has exploited photos of the slaughtered Japanese corpses in Tongzhou incident as photos of the Chinese corpses in Nanjing Massacre !!
★４－１★ " 通州事件=Tongzhou incident " occurred on July 29, 1937. Chinese self-government troops attacked the Japanese troops and the Japanese secret military agency, and this Chinese troops also massacred the denizen Japanese. " 通州=Tongzhou city " was a town east of Beijing. At that time Japanese troops were stationed there to protect the Japanese denizen.
★４－２★ 1937, from July 07 to July 28, Chinese troops attacked the Japanese troops several times. July 29, about 3,000 of Chinese troops suddenly attacked about 110 of Japanese troops and about 420 of Japanese denizen. And about 230 of Japanese people were massacred. Brutal bizarre sight of the murder were seen here and there. Some Japanese women were raped and killed in the genital bites a broom. Other Japanese women were killed, and their breasts were cut off.
★４－３★ Severed heads of Japanese female clerks were arranged along on the coffee table. Some beheaded Japanese women were raped. Some Japanese men were killed, and their intestines were out of their bellies. Japanese children were killed and their noses were pieced through with wire rings. Some Japanese men were killed, and their ears and noses were cut off, and their dead bodies were pieced together through with steel wire, and lastly thrown into the lake.
★４－４★ But the Chinese Communist government has not disclosed this unusually brutal massacre of Japanese at all to the Chinese people. Moreover, the Chinese Communist government has exploited photos of the slaughtered Japanese corpses as photos of the Chinese corpses in Nanjing Massacre !!
The jap govern would never show you the real pics, why would they admit this shame? Maybe only when you walk out from ur land, you can find more in the museum, some things can never be faked out: babies cross on japanese swords,thousands of bodies, human tails and dissections, eating human fresh BBQ, in every pic you can see ur armies with ur fucking national flag! Japanese lack human nature, no wonder they act as animals!
For those people, who claim Chinese made fake evidences, here is a good suggestion, go to Nanking to watch in person, in the museum you can find things not only provided by China, but more from western medias.
Jap sarumai have guts to the war, and they claim that for the country they can sacrifice with no hesitation. IF they never did the thing why would they admit, if they admit the thing they never do, they are still dead, or even worse, traitor then. Attention, jap pigs not only raped Chinese, but ppl from Indonesia, Mayla, Taiwan... Maybe say "Asian" is better!
Maybe we could force one, but NO ONE cannot force all of them if it never exists. No. of those victims survived from the Nanking massacres are 1247, each of them can tell the same story, show the scars and most important is, their feelings are so true,they are not actors! And how do you think to find 1247 actors who are old and with knife scars and willing to play the show? Not to mention those old american christians' dairies and photos.
Definitely, the Chinese government needed Japanese evidence about committing many massacres in China. After the Japanese wrote in the diary which shows Japanese raped many Chinese women and killed many civilians, they could be free and go back to Japan. From the perspective of psychology, if people are forced to write false stories for long time, the false stories could be true memories.
Chinese government created many Japanese testimonies after the WW2 finished intentionally. After WW2, many Japanese soldiers who were dispatched China returned to Japan temporarily. However, they were caught by Chinese government as criminals. Many Japanese were in Chinese jails after finished the WW2, and they were tortured by them. The Japanese were forced to write what they did in China. In short, they had to write false diary stories which were directed by the Chinese.
★Former Japanese soldiers have already died, but they left a testimony that there was no massacre in Nanjing.
They said Chinese soldiers immediately surrendered without resistance at that time, and they said they did not see Chinese common civilians because Chinese people were already evacuated to distant from Nanjing when Japanese soldiers arrived in Nanjing.
Nanjing Massacre is a vicious big lie by Chinese government !
Japanese need not to apologize for malicious hoax !
Japan should have happily received more atomic bombs from USA in 1945, not only onto Hiroshima and Nakasaki, but also all across the whole Japan. Someday Japanese will receive more and more from, this time not from USA, but from Mr. Kim Jung Eun, brave young man. Japanese had killed a million women and children in Nanking and in Korea. Even sex slaves.
Japan should have happily received more atomic bombs from USA in 1945, not only onto Hiroshima and Nakasaki, but also all across the whole Japan. Someday Japanese will receive more and more from, this time not from USA, but from Mr. Kim Jung Eun, brave young man. Japanese had killed a million women and children in Nanking and in Korea. Even sex slaves.
Why can't they prove? There is LIVING PROOF OF IT YET YOU DON"T ACCEPT IT. THE PEOPLE WHO LIVED THROUGH IT, PROVIDED THEIR EXPERIENCE. WE CHINESE DID NOT HAVE CAMERAS, WE WERE LOSING THE WAR WTF YOU WANT US TO DO? " Hey look my dad is dying lets take a photo of it so i can give it to UNTFE?
U WANT DEAD BODIES? THAT WAS BURIED 70 YEARS AGO? ARE YOU A FUCKING RETARD? DID YOU EVEN HAVE COMPETE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?
SON OF A BITCHES LIKE YOU SHOULD DIE AND BE SHOT IN THE HEAD
@undertakerRach are you a retard, how dare you claim Nanking massacre was fake. What right do you have? based on what? Retard dont talk shit. Respect the ones who have died.
how can you SHOW EVIDENCE IF THE CHINESE PEOPLE ALL DIED? ARE YOU A RETARD? EVERYONE WAS FLEEING. THESE PHOTOS WAS TAKING BY FKING EUROPEANS AND JAPANESE. FKING GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT U PIECE OF SHIT.
In the U.K., the Nanking battle became public criticism, too. Referring it, Sir Charles Addis mentioned on Nov 10, 1938, as follows: Between two countries at war there was always a danger that one or other of the combatants would seek to turn public opinion in his favors by resort to a propaganda in which incidents, inseparable alas - from all hostilities, were magnified and distorted for the express purpose of inflaming prejudice and passion and obscuring the real issues of the conflict.
Anyone on the allied side of WWII can attest to this, so do I have to show you conclusive evidence on this too??? If you think about it, EVERY country in the world can attest to the atrocities of Japanese forces, and the only country denying it is your country! While you may think that this is protecting Japan's pride and honor, it's really doing the opposite!! I'm sure you are 100% that I'm BSing this, and if so, I would be willing to admit it. Just my 2 cents.
After 70 years the Japanese government (not even its prime minister or emperor) to apologize to Canadian soldiers who fought in Hong Kong. With this attitude I find it not surprising for the government to deny any responsibilities in WWII, let alone Nanjing massacre, and this, I believe is why you are denying it with blanket statements and individual trivial statements, while dodging my most critical questions.
"Why many Chinese people came back to Nanking after Japanese occupied the city?" How do you prove that?? By trusting only the pro-right wing Japanese sources? That sounds like a general blanket statement.
Look, I like Japan, but this thing being so obvious but constantly denied is... just incredible, I mean, it's like the Germans denying the holocaust ever occurred.
It's not just China and Korea which your government is brainwashing you guys to think, but recently after 70 years...
How can Japanese admit the wrong history such as the Nanking Massacre? Analyzing Photographic “Evidence” of the Nanking Massacre by historians and other recent scientific research reveal that there are no photographs attesting to a massacre in Nanking. You know, at least 143 pictures are distorted by Chinese government.
At 143 pictures are distorted... so what about the ones that aren't? Do they prove what you say that the Nanking Massacre was completely wrong? I would really like to verify this "analysis". Are you arguing for the pride of your country or for human compassion? Even Chinese people who found out about the atrocities of their government would admit it. Japanese people seem to be the only ones who routinely deny it completely, and blame it 100% as a plot of the Chinese government.
@undertakerRach The thing is, you're implying that because 143 pics have been manipulated by the CCP (which you do not have 'conclusive evidence' either), then that means that the massacre never occured even if there are the rest of the pics to prove it? And don't those other pics provide ample conclusive evidence? How do you prove the exact whereabouts of all these bodies after all these years? Anything could've happened to them afterwards right?
@pakon81 (Part1)People should be careful to watch Chinese propaganda which has been shown Japanese atrocity. I’d like to show a film which is called The Battle of China. This wartime propaganda film is directed by Frank Capra, American famous director of 1930's, and comes out in l944. In the film, there are ten-second scenes of the description of Nanking Massacre. However, these can hardly be the true description, because of the following reasons.
@pakon81 (Part2) 1 An officer is taking a woman by force. His epaulet is different from that of the Japanese officer. The medal he wears on the breast is not of the Japanese Army in terms of design.
2 A man wears a revolver belt. But, the then Japanese soldiers don't wear it, since they didn't use a revolver. Also, he doesn't wear a saber but a parade sword. But, in war, a parade sword has never been used.
@pakon81 (Part3) 3 Chinese inhabitants in the film are in shirts with half sleeves in the cold wintertime. A piece of paper which says 'Three People's Principles' is on the chest of a woman who is being buried alive, but Japanese do not have such a way of thinking. On the other hand, this custom was still observed in the 1930s in China. The whole things are forged pictures!
@pakon81 (Part4)A photo has displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. The explanation says, "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers."
@pakon81 (Part2)Why Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for writing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?
Why Mao didn't announce about the massacre in the international mass media conferences from 1937 to 1938?
Chinese government can't tell a lie.
If you think the Nanking Massacre was true story, you should show me your conclusive evidence.
Chinese people are telling lies enthusiastically even their story was ridiculous theory, so some people will be mind controlled by their lies. The Chinese believe that telling lies 100 times, this could have lead to becoming true story from the lies. We have to be careful.
毛澤東曾經說過:感謝日本侵略中國,否則沒有今日的共產黨建國!
蔣介石在戰後放棄對日侵華的賠償,曰:以德報怨!並聘請侵華的皇軍軍官代訓敗退在台灣的草鞋部隊,受美國正式軍事教育學院畢業的孫立人將軍卻被軟禁.
這是甚麼天理?!
TheLADancer 19 hours ago
(Part2)If there had been slaughter in Nanking of a magnitude so great (300,000 civilian victims) as to prompt the description “holocaust of the century,” there is not the slightest chance that he would have been silent on the matter.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
OPEN QUESTIONS FOR HIS EXCELLENCY HU JINTAO,
PRESIDENT OF THE PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA
May 5, 2008
(Part1)Chinese Communist Party Chairman Mao Zedong never referred to a massacre in Nanking. He made exactly one mention of the Battle of Nanking during a lecture delivered at Yan’an six months after the conflict, reproduced in On Protracted War. Chairman Mao criticized the Japanese for failing to annihilate Chinese troops after having surrounded them.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
China has no right to accuse Japan of crimes such as the Nanking Massacre because the massacre was made up story using fabricated evidence. Obviously what China says is pure fiction! Demonstration of this story by the Chinese government is libel and slander. It is natural that Japanese raising an objection.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
@undertakerRach now, you are being unreasonable.
qwan1231 1 day ago
@qwan1231 I can't believe what China said. Even the official conference about the Nanking Massacre research, Chinese historians showed their collections as evidence of the massacre. The photographs, which Chinese showed are known to be fabricated, or from different areas and different times, continue to be used to "prove" Japanese guilt in the winter of 1937-38 at Nanjing
undertakerRach 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
three alls policy, unit 731, forced labor, comfort women, killing of war prisoners, Manila massacre, Sook Ching massacre, Bataan Death March, Burma Railway...
qwan1231 1 day ago
The Nanking Massacre was created by Chinese government for asking help China to the U.S.
These days Chinese government has used the fake of Nanking story for hiding their human rights problem from civilians.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
Do you know the fact that the Nanking city was controlled by Chinese government after the Japanese occupied the city? The Reformed Government of the Republic of China (Chinese: 中華民國維新政府) was a Chinese provisional government protected by Japan that existed from 1938 to 1940. 梁鴻志,温宗尭,陳群,陳籙,陳錦濤,王子恵,江洪杰,陳則民,任援道,許修直,朱履龢,高冠吾 and 傅筱庵 controlled the Nanking city until 1940.
Haven't you learned the history in school?
Chinese propaganda is still on going! We have to be careful about China.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@undertakerRach The government is not our true government,it was actually a ‘偽政府’ the people who controlled it were called'漢奸‘. and they were killed by the true government after the war because of helping the japanese.
katongche 2 days ago
@(Part1)The Japanese stationed troops in South Manchuria for protect it as the same as another countries under the boxer protocol. In fact, at that time, China was unsafe country. A book which name is近現代史集中講座 written by Kou Bunyu, he is a Chinese, said before Japan occupied Manchuria in 1932, Chinese government had extracted taxes from people strictly for Civil War. Moreover, other authorities had solicited a bribe and seized their people’s properties.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@ (Part2)Many soldiers had taken opium and used violence on people. The Communist Party of China, which was led by Mao Zedong battled the Chinese Nationalist Party or Kuomintang, which was led by Chiang Kai-shek. The Chinese Civil War began in April 1927, amidst the Northern Expedition. American journalist, Frederic Williams, and Chinese historian Kou Bunyu said Japanese created a new modern country Manchuria and kicked out corrupt military soldiers who were bandits and authorities from there.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@katongche (Part3)Many Chinese must have been living in peace. Their life changed to affluently society after Japanese occupied Manchuria. Approximately 1,000,000 Chinese moved to Manchuria in every year. 干沖漢, he was a man of powerful of economic in China, said, “Good bye China and we will make a new country with Japanese.” Moreover, many autonomous regions tried to make new political systems. In short, Chinese people were tired from Chinese politicians.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@katongche (Part4)However, almost 3000 Chinese who were friendly with Japanese killed by KMT while July, 1937 to July, 1938. If they weren’t killed by KMT, we can hear what a true story was in China. 漢奸？Oh I think so. Peaceful people 漢奸, they were also Chinese people, were killed by Chinese government, which was the same as Tiananmen Massacre in 1989.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@undertakerRach so what? did your school gave you the names of Japanese communists who joined Chinese army and fought against Japanese army?
qwan1231 2 days ago
@qwan1231 Some foreigners wrote the Japanese rape stories in documents during the war. However, these cases were what these Westerners heard about from the Chinese. After Minnie Vautrin wrote it, Chinese officers were caught by police for rape crimes. This story was written in an article of the New York Times on January 4, 1938. After they were caught, conspicuous cases of rape, looting and other atrocities did not take place. Therefore, these crimes were definitely caused by the Chinese.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@undertakerRach I was just pointing out that one of your evidence was not true according to Wikipedia and its reference. Now, you want to argue with me by more unjustified evidences that you learned from your history books. GET A LIFE DUDE ! Nanjing massacre was verified by a public trial holding by the UN. You want to deny it. Try disprove all those evidences in a serious place.
qwan1231 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part1)I know Chinese people who were brainwashed by Chinese communists send a lot of wrong stories to Wikipedia, so what has been written in Wiki is not true. After year of 2000, many new facts are revealed by historians. For example, many Nanking pictures edited by China, and Nanking population were increased after Japanese troops set up a new Chinese government which president was a Chinese guy. That’s why we have been appealed the new fact!
undertakerRach 1 day ago
@undertakerRach
1. there is a reference for that message, try to disprove it.
2. There are hundreds of pages of trail record with evidences. try to disprove them
3. there are hundreds of thousands of evidences and body remains demonstrating in Nanjing now. Try to disprove them.
qwan1231 1 day ago
@undertakerRach
4. Maybe there are some of brainwashed Chinese can access to Wikipedia, but those pages are edited by public. Do you mean that all people in the English world are brainwashed?
5. There are books, movies and documentary publicly available in the western world. Are they brainwashed?
qwan1231 1 day ago
Comment removed
qwan1231 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@undertakerRach
6. if you are arguing that number are exaggerated, I can still talk to you. If you want to deny the Nanking Massacre completely . The only thing I can say is that you don't have a concept of right and wrong. You are here only to repeat those Japanese books you read and accepted without thinking
qwan1231 1 day ago
@undertakerRach
go to wiki, see the picture of Contest to kill 100 people using a sword. Tell me, is that picture edited.
qwan1231 1 day ago
@qwan1231 (Part2)What China said was already refuted by historians and computer technology. The Nanking Massacre was a false story. The massacre was created by China to ask help to the United States. China has no right to accuse Japan of crimes such as the Nanking Massacre because the massacre was made up story using fabricated evidence. Demonstration of this story by the Chinese government is libel and slander. It is natural that Japanese raising an objection.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
@undertakerRach show me what kind of computer technology you are talking about. I have a CS master degree. I can tell how solid your technology is.
qwan1231 1 day ago
@undertakerRach
Nanking massacre is not an isolated incident. It is only a small fraction of Japanese war crime during WWII in China. try google: three alls policy, unit 731, forced labor, comfort women ... Don't tell me these were never happened, Victims are till alive.
qwan1231 1 day ago
@qwan1231 (Part1)Chinese nuclear tests began on Oct. 16, 1964, with the above ground detonation of a 20,000-ton bomb, followed by two-megaton surface explosions in 1967. The largest was a four-megaton explosion on Nov. 17, 1976. China changed to doing atmospheric tests in 1980 and underground tests from 1982 to 1996. Professor Takada said China is the only country in the world that carries out these large-scale surface tests in living areas.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
@qwan1231 (Part2)The Japanese Uyghur Association criticized the tests. "The former Soviet Union would carry out nuclear tests in an enclosed barb-wired area, but the Chinese regime didn't even inform the local residents,” he said. “The victims included not only the Uyghur people, but also Han Chinese. The authorities disregarded any semblance of humanity and treated the people living there as lab rats."
undertakerRach 1 day ago
@q (Part3) He urged Japan, the first victim of nuclear weapons, to share the information with the rest of the world and help the victims.
In July and August of 1998, the British Channel 4 broadcasted a special documentary, “Death On the Silk Road.” A team of doctors and filmmakers posed as tourists in order to assess the possible effects from the nuclear tests in China. From the interviews conducted in local villages, they found a large number of infants with cleft lips or mental retardation.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
@qwan1231 (Part4)Among the Uyghur people, many were suffering from malignant lymphoid leukemia. Incidences of cancer in Uyghur began rising in 1970 and by 1990, it was more than 30% higher than the national average. The cancer incidence in the capital city Urumqi doubled that of other areas during 1993 to 2000.
In china so many citizens are being killed by government. However, citizens are accusing Japan because kids have been taught how much the Japanese are barbaric.
undertakerRach 1 day ago
兄弟们，记住这些画面吧，血债必须要 用血来偿。我们的宽容和忘却，带来的是人家的嘲笑和鄙视。日本不亡，我们如何对得起死难的兄弟姐妹。
phoenix19771002 3 days ago
@phoenix19771002 但問題是有這種理念是無法解決事情的 報仇來報仇去只會讓戰爭無線擴大而已 而這些嘲笑和鄙視的人就是引發戰爭的主要罪人
s36343221 2 days ago
It's not surprising that Japanese have trouble trusting the Chinese Communist Party. CCP is notorious for their propaganda efforts especially with the historical subjects. Matter of the fact they have managed to erase the entire Tienanmen Square Massacre from the Chinese textbook.
The Bottom line is that the CCP will have to Clean up their action before Japanese can trust them.
Amagusdrop 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Don’t you know “Tongzhou incident” ?
It’s a massacre of Japanese denizen by Chinese troops.
CNN-Photos document brutality in ShanghaiSeptember 23, 1996
↑ Look at the site of the above title.
シナ（中国）人による日本人捕虜の残虐処刑 (1996 CNN)
↑ Watch the video of the above title.
Tungchow Mutiny【Evil doing by Chinese soldier】
↑ Watch the video of the above title.
oneofthejapanese 1 week ago
Comment removed
oneofthejapanese 1 week ago
Fitch wrote in his "My Eighty Years In China" published by Mei. Ya Publications in Taiwan, "The DIGEST story brought such a storm of protest from readers who thought "unbelievable" that three months later the editors published excerpts from my diary and those of others who went through the occupation, which verified my observations."
acmuser 1 week ago
The Nanking diary by George A. Fitch, from December 17 to the new year's day in 1938, parallels to Rabe's diary and they have no conflicts with each other. Fitch's Nanking diary anonymously appeared in H.J.Timperley's "Japanese Terror in China" published in 1938, which was translated in Japanese in the same year and read by limited numbers of Japanese, and then in Reader's Digest of July 1938.
acmuser 1 week ago
@acmuser ■(Part1)It was clearly proved by their testimonies at the IMTFE that no committee members had witnessed 'illegal murders by Japanese soldiers at all. O. Wilson, who made many testimonies as to atrocities, did admit that all of his testimonies were hearsay. Magee, who lived with Bates and worked for the Safety Zone Committee, testified that he had just eye-witnessed only one case.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@acmuser (Part2)As a matter of fact, neither Rabe nor other westerners of the Safety Zone Committee members, who might have been able to walk around freely in the city with Nazi Swastika armband on, had ever witnessed illegal murders by Japanese soldiers during six weeks.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@undertakerRach They had witnessed
By February 5, 1938, the International Committee had forwarded to the Japanese embassy a total of 450 cases of murder, rape, and general disorder by Japanese soldiers that had been reported after the American, British and German diplomats had returned to their embassies.
qwan1231 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part1)In fact, how bad was the damage? It was on the morning of January 6, 1938 when foreigners entered the walled city of Nanking under the Japanese occupation for the first time. They were James Espy, the vice consul at the American Embassy to Nanking and the third Secretary John M. Allison. Allison immediately investigated the damage made against the U.S. interests. In spite that the correspondent reported the residence of American Embassy was one of the targets of looting, ///
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part2)///Allison sent a telegram on January 8 to the Secretary of State in Washington that 'American property in the so-called Safety Zone received relatively small damage, except for occasional looting or thefts. The record written by the Safety Zone Committee endorsed this report, and it detailed the 'damage due to looting committed by the Japanese soldiers', from December 12 through 18 when a massive looting was supposed to have occurred, as follows:
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part3)Five automobiles, six bicycles, several motorbikes, two cows, one pig, several ponies, three sack's of rice, 500 futon mats, two gloves, a bottle of milk, a handful of sugar, one pan, one trash box, six fountain pens, a half can of kerosene, and a few candles. From this list, would anyone be able to say that a large scale looting had taken place? Moreover, how many cases of rape were (including attempted) reported in the documents by the Safety Zone Committee?
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part4)The total number was 361. And among them, there were only 61 cases, which definitely clarified who witnessed the cases, who heard and reported. Among these cases, only seven cases were clarified to be crimes committed by Japanese soldiers and notified the Japanese Army of the crime in order to disclose the fact and to capture the suspects. Out of these records, how could Bates have calculated the number 8,000 on rapes?
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part5)There was the International Committee for Nanking Safety Zone. This committee consisted of 22 Westerners. This committee wrote reports regarding the security situation of Nanking city 61 times from Dec.13, 1937 to Feb.9, 1938 and sent the same reports to Japanese Embassy, Embassy of the United States, British Embassy and Germany Embassy. According to these 61 reports, they reported murder: 41, mayhem: 44, rape: 361, taking: 390, plunder and others: 170 for 2 months.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@qwan1231 (Part6)However, all of these reports were “hearsay”. In other words, nobody of this committee witnessed them actually. The International Military Tribunal for the Far East (Tokyo Trial: 1946-1948) summoned 4 members of this committee included Magee, Ashmore Fitch, Bates and Wilson. They testified they did not witness any murder and heard from someone. This trial proved nobody witnessed murders actually and they wrote reports on the basis of”Hearsay”.
The massacre was a false story
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@undertakerRach from wikipedia
qwan1231 2 days ago
Rabe's diary is the outstanding testimony of the witness of the Nanking atrocity, though he was limited to move around only in the safety zone except some occasions. Rabe describes what happens around him day by day, before and after the fall of Nanking by the Japanese.
acmuser 1 week ago
@acmuser ■(Part1)John Rabe was a member of international Safety Zone Committee in Nanking. Many Chinese people said he was a witness of the Nanking Massacre with confidence. However, he had never witnessed even one case of murder. In spite of that, he sent many reports to Hitler and wrote the stories to his diary. In fact, his diary and reports to Germany were written different number of victims. Why?
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@acmuser (Part2)For Fear of counter objections, he reported to the Japanese authorities in Nanking city the number of casualties to be 49 based on some extent of reliable information. But on the other hand, to journalists, German diplomats and A. Hitler who were all absent in Nanking, he reported figures with an enormous difference, as if no less than tens of thousands civilians had been killed by Japanese troops. Why did Rabe make a false report of the massacre to Hitler?
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@ (Part3)According to German historian Gerhard Krebs, the reason was based on power politics in his German homeland. “Defeated and depressed in World War I, Germany knew that china was a significant trade partner. Particularly Chiang Kai-shek, who was fighting against the CCP, needed a large number of weapons, while Germany was able to import raw materials that were indispensable for the postwar reconstruction.” The Sino-Japanese War forced Germany to reconsider its foreign policy toward China.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@acmuser (Part4)The Japanese government repeatedly demanded that Germany stop the export of weapons to Japan's enemy Chiang Kai-shek. As the result, Hitler decided to take advantage of containment against the Soviet Union by promoting strong relationship with Japan. Germany refrained from exporting weapons to the Chiang Kai-shek. (In fact, it was in l940 when Germany reached an agreement with Japan.)There were someone strongly resisted the change of policy taken by Hitler.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@acmuser (Part5)They were Von Falkenhausen, the head of the military advisory group in China, and Rabe, who represented an interest of Siemens in the Chinese munitions industry as a pro-Chinese group. Rabe exaggerated the Japanese Army’s atrocities and requested Hitler to reconsider the alliance with Japan. Rabe's anti-Japanese reports had been thought suspicious since then.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@acmuser (Part6)Moreover, P. Scharfienberg, the secretary general of the German Embassy to China, who returned to Nanking city on January 9, tried to investigate the fact about 'Japanese Army's atrocities Rabe reported' by himself, and wrote to the German Embassy at Hankow on February 10: “He [Rabe] is still actively trying to counter the bloody excesses of Japanese looters, which have unfortunately increased of late.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
@acmuser (Part7)To my mind, this should not concern us Germans, particularly since one can clearly see that the Chinese, once left to depend solely on the Japanese, immediately fraternize. And as for all these excesses, one hears only one side of it, after all.” That report is called untrustworthy story after people defined the fact.
undertakerRach 2 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Most of comments which are written by Chinese does not have any logical (historical) points. They have just piled up scornful language against Japanese here. This is the China. During the war, Chinese soldiers killed many Chinese people. They comitted many crimes in China. They were like bandits. Chinese government pinned thier crimes on Japanese soldiers.
undertakerRach 2 weeks ago
日本人就是没有德国人勇于面对自己错误的勇气！！！！
Japanese is not courage to face their own errors，look at German！！！
Les Japonais n'ont pas de courage de faire face à leurs propres erreurs,
regardez les allemands!!
lulu19830606 3 weeks ago 3
@lulu19830606
LOOK AT GERMANS? WHAT ABOUT THEM?
GERMANY ALWAYS STAND ON WAR CRIMINAL ACTIONS WERE NOT BELONG TO GERMAN CIVILIANS ONLY POLITICS AND NAZIS REASONS!
U R IDIOT!
GIVE US BACK ODA MONEY ASAP!
WE SUPPORTED CHINK ECONOMY SINCE 1979, HUGE MONEY WE REND U!
NOW PAY BACK TIME, GIVE US BACK ALL ODA MONEY!
HEY CHEAL SHIT GIVE US BACK ODA(THIRD WORLD UNDER DEVELOPING NATION BENEFIT SUPPORT) U PRETENDING NO THIRD WORLD ANY MORE SO U DON NEED THIRD WORLD BENEFICIAL!!
GIVE US BACK!!
LovefuckChinkcunt 2 weeks ago
Chinese people should know "Tongzhou incident".
It's a massacre of Japanese people by the cruel Chinese troops !
中国人应该知道的“通州事件”。
这是中国军队残酷屠杀的日本人民！
中國人應該知道的“通州事件”。
這是中國軍隊殘酷屠殺的日本人民！
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
@oneofthejapanese
These troops were recruited by Japanese as guard force , but they mutinied against the Japanese. These troops were not under KMT Chinese commands.
Thak11 2 weeks ago
@oneofthejapanese stupid jap, where is 通州, when and under what situation that happened? stupid jap
acmuser 1 week ago
@oneofthejapanese All war criminals are enemies of Human Being. My family lives in a small town not far from Tongzhou. I apologize for what happened.
qwan1231 1 day ago
過沒多久，不爭氣的國民黨就被共產黨打敗，逃到台灣.....唉! 辛酸。
ysw6511 3 weeks ago
畜生日本人。
當初日本被美國用原子彈轟炸而無條件投降時，蔣中正應該把日本的軍人通通殺光才對。
ysw6511 3 weeks ago
變態日本人
vul3c060403 3 weeks ago
16:05Watch these killed children ! They are not Chinese ! They are all Japanese children massacred by Chinese troops in Tongzhou on July 29, 1937. The Chinese Communist government has exploited photos of the slaughtered Japanese corpses in Tongzhou incident as photos of the Chinese corpses in Nanjing Massacre !!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Tungchow Mutiny【Evil doing by Chinese soldier】
Watch the video of the title above.
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
@oneofthejapanese stupid jap
acmuser 1 week ago
war is so curel
2011leung 3 weeks ago
◆２－１◆
Chinese Torture Atrocities: Beheadings Death by a 1000 Cuts. Note: Mao's Wife Demands the president of China be tortured to "death by 1000 cuts."
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch the video of the title above.
Everyone will be surprised to know a lot of atrocities by the brutal Chinese Communist Party and the past cruel Chinese.
The Chinese should be ashamed of the fact that they originally love the bloody corpse.
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
◆２－２◆
CCP fabricated a malicious fake story "Nanjing Massacre" in order to unfairly disparage Japan in the international community.
Dirty ways of plots by CCP are always same.
First, CCP thoroughly deceives the Chinese people by fake pictures and fake movies.
Next, CCP incites anti-Japanese movements to completely fooled and furious Chinese people across China.
Then, CCP delivers to the world a lot of news of violent riots by angry Chinese people.
CCP is more crafty than former Nazis !!
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
★４－１★ " 通州事件=Tongzhou incident " occurred on July 29, 1937. Chinese self-government troops attacked the Japanese troops and the Japanese secret military agency, and this Chinese troops also massacred the denizen Japanese. " 通州=Tongzhou city " was a town east of Beijing. At that time Japanese troops were stationed there to protect the Japanese denizen.
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
★４－２★ 1937, from July 07 to July 28, Chinese troops attacked the Japanese troops several times. July 29, about 3,000 of Chinese troops suddenly attacked about 110 of Japanese troops and about 420 of Japanese denizen. And about 230 of Japanese people were massacred. Brutal bizarre sight of the murder were seen here and there. Some Japanese women were raped and killed in the genital bites a broom. Other Japanese women were killed, and their breasts were cut off.
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
★４－３★ Severed heads of Japanese female clerks were arranged along on the coffee table. Some beheaded Japanese women were raped. Some Japanese men were killed, and their intestines were out of their bellies. Japanese children were killed and their noses were pieced through with wire rings. Some Japanese men were killed, and their ears and noses were cut off, and their dead bodies were pieced together through with steel wire, and lastly thrown into the lake.
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
★４－４★ But the Chinese Communist government has not disclosed this unusually brutal massacre of Japanese at all to the Chinese people. Moreover, the Chinese Communist government has exploited photos of the slaughtered Japanese corpses as photos of the Chinese corpses in Nanjing Massacre !!
oneofthejapanese 3 weeks ago
The jap govern would never show you the real pics, why would they admit this shame? Maybe only when you walk out from ur land, you can find more in the museum, some things can never be faked out: babies cross on japanese swords,thousands of bodies, human tails and dissections, eating human fresh BBQ, in every pic you can see ur armies with ur fucking national flag! Japanese lack human nature, no wonder they act as animals!
MrTru1212 1 month ago
For those people, who claim Chinese made fake evidences, here is a good suggestion, go to Nanking to watch in person, in the museum you can find things not only provided by China, but more from western medias.
MrTru1212 1 month ago
Jap sarumai have guts to the war, and they claim that for the country they can sacrifice with no hesitation. IF they never did the thing why would they admit, if they admit the thing they never do, they are still dead, or even worse, traitor then. Attention, jap pigs not only raped Chinese, but ppl from Indonesia, Mayla, Taiwan... Maybe say "Asian" is better!
MrTru1212 1 month ago
Maybe we could force one, but NO ONE cannot force all of them if it never exists. No. of those victims survived from the Nanking massacres are 1247, each of them can tell the same story, show the scars and most important is, their feelings are so true,they are not actors! And how do you think to find 1247 actors who are old and with knife scars and willing to play the show? Not to mention those old american christians' dairies and photos.
MrTru1212 1 month ago
Definitely, the Chinese government needed Japanese evidence about committing many massacres in China. After the Japanese wrote in the diary which shows Japanese raped many Chinese women and killed many civilians, they could be free and go back to Japan. From the perspective of psychology, if people are forced to write false stories for long time, the false stories could be true memories.
koyukimika 1 month ago
Chinese government created many Japanese testimonies after the WW2 finished intentionally. After WW2, many Japanese soldiers who were dispatched China returned to Japan temporarily. However, they were caught by Chinese government as criminals. Many Japanese were in Chinese jails after finished the WW2, and they were tortured by them. The Japanese were forced to write what they did in China. In short, they had to write false diary stories which were directed by the Chinese.
koyukimika 1 month ago
從明朝倭寇入侵開始總清算大貉倭賊欠我中華血債，血債血償，讓你得了便宜還賣乖，把倭匪連他乾爹美國雜種一塊湊死
mrwugang 1 month ago
我是國民革命軍第七十四軍五十八師鍾學棟將軍的孫子，老兵子孫不死！我祖父抗戰打足十四年！九死一生地活著看到日寇無條件投降，我要正告日本鬼子，你敢不服就再來幹一場！萬世光榮的中華兒女再抗你萬世羞恥的倭寇賊種一趟，做個百年老賬總清算，
把日本三島從地圖上抹去，讓日本大貉賊種成為馬雅遺跡
mrwugang 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
★Former Japanese soldiers have already died, but they left a testimony that there was no massacre in Nanjing.
They said Chinese soldiers immediately surrendered without resistance at that time, and they said they did not see Chinese common civilians because Chinese people were already evacuated to distant from Nanjing when Japanese soldiers arrived in Nanjing.
Nanjing Massacre is a vicious big lie by Chinese government !
Japanese need not to apologize for malicious hoax !
oneofthejapanese 1 month ago
人家德國多好...有錯就認就改,當年就是因為老美當年放了日本一馬的錯
應該給天皇也一粒原子彈這不就完了..
當年國民黨真是死了一堆將級= ="還是說國民黨的將級太多?
show316316 1 month ago
推背圖有說了，日本還會再打他們的祖國(中國)，所以要提防日本。
tenrans 1 month ago
＜南京大虐殺は捏造だった＞
ロシア科学アカデミー極東戦史研究所のアーラヤ・ピズダ氏の発見した文書によれば、
「南京大虐殺」の証拠として中国政府が公表している写真の一部は上記の撮影所で撮影されたもので、
ブリヤード人やシベリアのマイノリティーなど日本人そっくりの人を日本兵役で出演させ、
「中国人にひどいことをする日本人」という構図の写真を撮ったそうである。
この研究所の副所長で新潟の大学で教鞭をとったこともある親日家のイヴァン・ドラチョク氏は
「冷戦時代は西側陣営に失点を与えるために、こういうおかしな協力もソ中間で行われていたようだ。
しかし、今はそんな時代ではないし中国に協力する謂れもない。
また、これに関心のある日本の歴史家の皆さんを是非お助けしたいと思う」と語った。
kuniwoaiseyo 1 month ago
@kuniwoaiseyo fuck off japanese faggot
liuboren1992 1 month ago
不是要仇恨日本人,但要記住曆史,因現在部份日本仍是要打中國,有些日本人仍是有優越感,所以要提防日本.
lhm9417 1 month ago 6
What kind of kids shall u bring up? How will a criminal teach his grand children?
samsonwtl 1 month ago
U have no conscience and heart. U are less than animal.
samsonwtl 1 month ago
シナの捏造
kuniwoaiseyo 1 month ago
@kuniwoaiseyo god fuck u japs.
samsonwtl 1 month ago
@kuniwoaiseyo Better to try again. U will be terminated.
samsonwtl 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@kuniwoaiseyo What kind of kids shall u bring up? How will a criminal teach his grand children?
samsonwtl 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Japan should have happily received more atomic bombs from USA in 1945, not only onto Hiroshima and Nakasaki, but also all across the whole Japan. Someday Japanese will receive more and more from, this time not from USA, but from Mr. Kim Jung Eun, brave young man. Japanese had killed a million women and children in Nanking and in Korea. Even sex slaves.
MegaNorthkorean 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Japan should have happily received more atomic bombs from USA in 1945, not only onto Hiroshima and Nakasaki, but also all across the whole Japan. Someday Japanese will receive more and more from, this time not from USA, but from Mr. Kim Jung Eun, brave young man. Japanese had killed a million women and children in Nanking and in Korea. Even sex slaves.
MegaNorthkorean 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Japan is a small country. no money. no bullet.
This is a lie.
kikuzirous 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
圓明園..該燒!!!燒掉這些亡國的建築
OSCARCHEN0324 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
所以古人建長城是為了什麼大家都知道了吧???只是被清庭主政以後搞臭了中國...
OSCARCHEN0324 1 month ago
Only dumb Japanese deny it,the normal ones accept it!!! Thank goodness this evil empire was defeated!
Hirohito,the war criminal,should have been hung!!!!!!!!!!!
bess1953 1 month ago
国殇
yliang1688 1 month ago
Why can't they prove? There is LIVING PROOF OF IT YET YOU DON"T ACCEPT IT. THE PEOPLE WHO LIVED THROUGH IT, PROVIDED THEIR EXPERIENCE. WE CHINESE DID NOT HAVE CAMERAS, WE WERE LOSING THE WAR WTF YOU WANT US TO DO? " Hey look my dad is dying lets take a photo of it so i can give it to UNTFE?
U WANT DEAD BODIES? THAT WAS BURIED 70 YEARS AGO? ARE YOU A FUCKING RETARD? DID YOU EVEN HAVE COMPETE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL?
SON OF A BITCHES LIKE YOU SHOULD DIE AND BE SHOT IN THE HEAD
cheng5210 1 month ago
@undertakerRach are you a retard, how dare you claim Nanking massacre was fake. What right do you have? based on what? Retard dont talk shit. Respect the ones who have died.
how can you SHOW EVIDENCE IF THE CHINESE PEOPLE ALL DIED? ARE YOU A RETARD? EVERYONE WAS FLEEING. THESE PHOTOS WAS TAKING BY FKING EUROPEANS AND JAPANESE. FKING GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT U PIECE OF SHIT.
cheng5210 1 month ago
In the U.K., the Nanking battle became public criticism, too. Referring it, Sir Charles Addis mentioned on Nov 10, 1938, as follows: Between two countries at war there was always a danger that one or other of the combatants would seek to turn public opinion in his favors by resort to a propaganda in which incidents, inseparable alas - from all hostilities, were magnified and distorted for the express purpose of inflaming prejudice and passion and obscuring the real issues of the conflict.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
Anyone on the allied side of WWII can attest to this, so do I have to show you conclusive evidence on this too??? If you think about it, EVERY country in the world can attest to the atrocities of Japanese forces, and the only country denying it is your country! While you may think that this is protecting Japan's pride and honor, it's really doing the opposite!! I'm sure you are 100% that I'm BSing this, and if so, I would be willing to admit it. Just my 2 cents.
pakon81 2 months ago
After 70 years the Japanese government (not even its prime minister or emperor) to apologize to Canadian soldiers who fought in Hong Kong. With this attitude I find it not surprising for the government to deny any responsibilities in WWII, let alone Nanjing massacre, and this, I believe is why you are denying it with blanket statements and individual trivial statements, while dodging my most critical questions.
pakon81 2 months ago
"Why many Chinese people came back to Nanking after Japanese occupied the city?" How do you prove that?? By trusting only the pro-right wing Japanese sources? That sounds like a general blanket statement.
Look, I like Japan, but this thing being so obvious but constantly denied is... just incredible, I mean, it's like the Germans denying the holocaust ever occurred.
It's not just China and Korea which your government is brainwashing you guys to think, but recently after 70 years...
pakon81 2 months ago
南京の事件は、何万人もの中国兵が軍服脱ぎ捨て、民間人の中へ隠れたのが原因。
誰が何万人もの中国兵かわからず、いつ背後から撃たれるかわからない。
こんなことをすれば、こうなるのは低脳か中国人じゃなきゃわかるはず。
sabroohzz 2 months ago
@undertakerRach
Look at the eyes of the victims in this video, are they faking anything ?
Definitely not, I believe what they have said.
Thak11 2 months ago
樓下那個講笑話的是矮軍的孫子
psalm1604 2 months ago
How can Japanese admit the wrong history such as the Nanking Massacre? Analyzing Photographic “Evidence” of the Nanking Massacre by historians and other recent scientific research reveal that there are no photographs attesting to a massacre in Nanking. You know, at least 143 pictures are distorted by Chinese government.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
At 143 pictures are distorted... so what about the ones that aren't? Do they prove what you say that the Nanking Massacre was completely wrong? I would really like to verify this "analysis". Are you arguing for the pride of your country or for human compassion? Even Chinese people who found out about the atrocities of their government would admit it. Japanese people seem to be the only ones who routinely deny it completely, and blame it 100% as a plot of the Chinese government.
pakon81 2 months ago
@pakon81 The Nanking Massacre was a false story which was created by China.
Give me your conclusive evidence about these questions.
Why Chinese government edited at least 143 pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum?
Why Chinese government could not prove the murder of 340,000 when the IMTFE was opened?
Where were 300,000 of dead bodies?
Why many Chinese people came back to Nanking after Japanese occupied the city?
undertakerRach 2 months ago
@undertakerRach The thing is, you're implying that because 143 pics have been manipulated by the CCP (which you do not have 'conclusive evidence' either), then that means that the massacre never occured even if there are the rest of the pics to prove it? And don't those other pics provide ample conclusive evidence? How do you prove the exact whereabouts of all these bodies after all these years? Anything could've happened to them afterwards right?
pakon81 2 months ago
@pakon81 (Part1)People should be careful to watch Chinese propaganda which has been shown Japanese atrocity. I’d like to show a film which is called The Battle of China. This wartime propaganda film is directed by Frank Capra, American famous director of 1930's, and comes out in l944. In the film, there are ten-second scenes of the description of Nanking Massacre. However, these can hardly be the true description, because of the following reasons.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
@pakon81 (Part2) 1 An officer is taking a woman by force. His epaulet is different from that of the Japanese officer. The medal he wears on the breast is not of the Japanese Army in terms of design.
2 A man wears a revolver belt. But, the then Japanese soldiers don't wear it, since they didn't use a revolver. Also, he doesn't wear a saber but a parade sword. But, in war, a parade sword has never been used.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
@pakon81 (Part3) 3 Chinese inhabitants in the film are in shirts with half sleeves in the cold wintertime. A piece of paper which says 'Three People's Principles' is on the chest of a woman who is being buried alive, but Japanese do not have such a way of thinking. On the other hand, this custom was still observed in the 1930s in China. The whole things are forged pictures!
undertakerRach 2 months ago
@pakon81 (Part4)A photo has displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. The explanation says, "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers."
undertakerRach 2 months ago
@pakon81 (Part2)Why Chinese government paid money to Harold Timperley for writing book What War Means which was written about so-called the Nanking Massacre?
Why Mao didn't announce about the massacre in the international mass media conferences from 1937 to 1938?
Chinese government can't tell a lie.
If you think the Nanking Massacre was true story, you should show me your conclusive evidence.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Chinese people are telling lies enthusiastically even their story was ridiculous theory, so some people will be mind controlled by their lies. The Chinese believe that telling lies 100 times, this could have lead to becoming true story from the lies. We have to be careful.
undertakerRach 2 months ago
生存法則，弱者、強者分別中國人兩千年了還是如此，雖然強了但沒的人該有的自由可悲呀！日本那時可恨，但也是沒法事那時窮國家才開始不久，人多卻軍事裝備不夠能打敗日本算不錯了！
kitten1up 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
《中華人民共和國蘇維埃社會主義共和國聯盟友好同盟特別協定》
luyahharli 2 months ago
日本人到现在都不承认，也是中国的悲哀吧
vasiliyJ 2 months ago
南京外围丢了，应该打城市战，像莫斯科保卫战。
中国人很不了解日本人的本性，和民族文化。
一个小国侵略大国，手段就会很极端。
mackintosh828 2 months ago
對中國人來說日本人絕對是可惡的，中國人至今恨意未消是合理的。但是對台灣人來說中國國民黨更是可恨，因為中國國民黨當分也是用這種方法在台灣殺台灣人，口口聲聲噁心地喊什麼同胞不同胞， 逃難來台灣卻四處姦淫擄掠，228大屠殺、白色恐怖虐殺、暗殺……國民黨政權殺人如麻不比日本人、中國共產黨好到哪去，然後…中國國民黨卻要台灣人不能恨他們，因為要大和解要原諒大時代的錯，絕對不能提起，要追究反而是台灣人不入流，挑起仇恨…，請問在中國的中國百姓，若要你們不能憎恨日本人，不能追究南京大屠殺的罪行，給你一個挑起國際仇恨的罪名，你們覺得合理嗎？不要忘了國民黨當初在中國，殺你們的親人也不少，在上海以剿共名義殺了許多無辜百姓，為躲避日軍追擊，黃河花園口大決堤更淹死了數十萬居民，南京大屠殺更是國民黨間接造成的(封住退路要百姓死守南京，結果軍隊在日軍兵臨城下時主帥先逃，軍隊也四處潰散，為活命還換穿便服躲進民房中。
reg3122010 2 months ago
當獅子闖入羊群~中國送堆羊群壓死獅子~中國為什麼送羊給獅子?因人很多
jim19771008 2 months ago
日本的野心永遠都不會滿足的 就算到現在也是
dsdsdsds33 3 months ago
向井根野田最後都被槍斃在雨花台!耶好呀
聽說他們兩個最後被槍斃時嚇到尿褲子憋
A123757058 3 months ago
日本這個民族是有心理變態且很自大的民族,
A123757058 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
是淞滬會戰最後的潰敗導致南京保衛戰成為噩夢。
而淞滬潰退主因是日軍金山衛登陸，當時軍方為何沒防備此一日軍側翼登陸呢？ 據楊天石先生數年前關於淞滬會戰的考證文章，有下列一段文字：
-----8月20日，蔣介石得報，金山衛有日本水兵登陸偵察，指令“嚴防”。10月18日，軍事委員會第一部作戰組的情報提出，日軍有在杭州灣登陸企圖，但估計登陸部隊最多一個師，不會對上海戰局有什麼影響。 11月5日，日軍第10軍司令官柳川平助以三個半師團的兵力，在艦炮掩護下，於杭州灣北岸的金山衛登陸。------
當時軍事委員會第一部作戰組組長：劉斐
應該是這則奇怪的情報，導致淞滬戰場國軍被金山衛十萬登陸日軍背後包抄而導致潰敗。 如果不是這則情報評估，國軍應該不至於慘敗過快。
因為 1 關於日軍杭州灣登陸，其實前有戴笠沿杭州灣沿岸調查勘測，評估金山衛登陸可能性最大，並將嚴防之建議提交給蔣知曉。
2 遲直至10月22日第三戰區司令顧祝同將軍還曾反映：聞敵將有3個師團來滬增援，其先頭部隊有(26)日可抵滬。 可惜似乎向何應欽反映卻未傳達至委員長處。
有興趣者請深入研究以慰國殤
twelvemast 4 months ago
怎麼會空前絕後？
非洲那些國家，種族滅亡戰爭
也是用這些殘暴的手段、強姦、放火、殺人、集體屠殺等等
喊者超英趕亞的日本人，原來和非洲人一樣呀！
ffiva 5 months ago
我真的不知道日本人是狗還是狗都不如 `
Xplenovo 8 months ago
国民政府枪毙倭寇畜生谷寿夫，活该！
今天日本菅直人政府必须好好反省！ 如果不承认历史，让你们尝尝中国大陆的超级炸弹！
TheUsforce1 11 months ago
是啊 ！ 在国内很多地方都还是看不到《阳光卫视》。
中共当局领导人应该要有博大的胸怀！ 早日在大陆解禁！
TheUsforce1 11 months ago
感谢阳光卫视制作了这么完整的纪录片，让我们这些年轻一代有更深入的了解这些真正的历史，可惜在国内很多还看不到~
我们永远要牢记历史，国弱被人欺~!
chenyh2008 1 year ago