Added: 2 years ago
From: subrataalways
Views: 34,293
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (51)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • misjudgement by Salil Chowdhury by not recording this song with Sir George Biswas

  • uff ki gola. pranta dhore rakhi duhate.tarit,

  • Ami jantam na ei gaan ta onnar gaoa. Oh! ki odbhut gala aar ki apurbo composition. Thank you Subrata (ami-o Subrata :))

  • Thanks for sharing!

  • are bah. debabrata biswas e gan geyechhen jantam na. e rakam aro kicchu thakle din-na bhai.ami kritartho hoi. abashya jeta diyechhen tar jonye-i kritajnatar sesh nei

    .mangal hok apnar.

  • Ei ganti sonanor janya dhanyabad. Ami jantam-i na je Debababrata Biswas adhunic gan geyechhen.

  • dhanyabad post karar janya

  • Who did the music arrangement?

  • This song reaches to another dimension...No words to explain.. 

  • Debaproto adds a dimension to Shymol Mitra's original song .mesmerizing

  • With all due respect to Debabrata Biswas (of whose Rabindrasangeet I am an admirer), I find the Shyamal Mitra version far superior.

    This is not a statement to incite arguments, just a personal preference.

  • @avix007

    Probably bcoz of the music arrangement. In Shyamal Mitra's version guitar takes over from the antara and remains very loud throughout. The tempo is faster too. In case u have a music system/software that can suppress the music and allow only the vocals to be heard I'm sure u'll change ur view. Again not to contradict you.....just an opinion....kathar pithe katha

  • @vogchod: Debabrata. You should know that Debabrata, in the 50s especially, was far more popular for adhunik bangla gan and ganosongit than Tagore's songs. The greatest example will be Salil Chowdhury's "Abaak Prithibi", which is originally sung and made popular by Debabrata, although our generation relates this song with Hemanta (which is a far later recording). Other examples will be "Alor Pathojatri".

    Personally, Debabrata is a far better Ganosangit singer than the more popular Hemanta......

  • Comment removed

  • who sang this song first, Debabrata or Shymal Mitra? i'm bit confused. Can anyone please let me know..

  • @vogchod1 Shymal Mitra

  • Perhaps the only Adhunik George da ever recorded and how heartfelt was it done ! Did that other genius Salil persuade him to sing his song because of their mutual IPTA connection?

  • E ki opurbo jugalbondi!

  • @sadhan8--- I think we all feel the same way as others, about The Great Debabrato Biswas. We are mesmerised n immersed in a strange, silent, a bit painful emotions while listening to a classic like this ! No wonder there is a coincidence between our thoughts.

  • One of the best....sotti e apurbo...

  • simply APURBO

  • George da tomake amra bhulchi na bhulbo na....

    jodi kichu amare sudha wo.....

  • one of the best performance of Jorge Da

  • অপুর্ব ! ধন্যবাদ।

  • Bharotiyo Gana Natya Sangher Swarno Juger Shilpider anyotomo ak tara. Jekono ganei uni asadharon. Onar gaoa, "Kichu Rong Diyo" gaantio anyrakom. Onar shes je gaan ta suney chilam "Ora Kara Amay Gaitey Dilo na, Ami Gaitam Parlam na". Sambhabato Maymansing er bhashay gaoa. Anek din khunjechi, kintu gaanta kothao paini.

  • Why can't our generation produce moments that we could hit our souls any more?

  • KHUKU 41----Shurer jaadukor Salil Chowdhury aar ei bhorat golay praan-kaarha awaajer maalik Debobroto Biswas ! Sara din gaantar resh thheke jaay.Kee shob sonaar songeetmoy din chhilo shob. Debobrato aar hobeh naa --ek upekkhito protibha !

  • @Khuku41 ...What a strange coincidence between your and my thoughts ! Thanx Khuku. He touched my soul in his every wonderful compositions.

  • Thanks for this wonderful upload.

  • bhora thak sriti shudhay. Thanks.

  • ei gola ar hobe na.....

  • ei gaan sudhu gaan noy .... ateet-er paane ure jaaoaar daanaa ... apooooooooooorbo abhigyota .....

  • George da amar rahe...tomake amra bhulchi na bhulbo na...

    amar rahe...

  • onek rabindrasangeeter bhir e ei gaantio hothat geye uthte dekhechhi ei asadharon manushtike,sei sob anushonge monta bhore gelo

  • George da ekjon e hoy.... Sei chotto bela thekey e onaar gunomugdho... Onaar konthey "Obaak Prithibi" ta o shunechi.... Out of the world feeling.... Jodi o Hemanta babu o oshadharon geyecheyn, taholey o George daar golaay gaan ta onnyo maatra peyechey

  • satii i katha nei ebong chokhe jol. Thanx for uploading. Old salil chowdhury gana natyo songs were also sung by the "God"

    with others. Pls upload if somebody has it.

  • kotha nei, harie geche !!! Geogrgeda Je kono poribeshan Sublime !!! Kotha hariye jay chokhe jal

    Thanks bhai eai swargiyo anado ke bilabar jonnya

  • I did not know this song had a rendition by him. Collector's item!

  • ato opurbo...

  • wish it never ended.......George da is unique.....it is so euphoric to hear him.......

  • Debobrotor golay aagey adhunik gaan shuni ni. This is the first one. Robindronaath Bhogobaan, but Debobroto is no less Bhogobaan. One is incomplete without the other. Like Raam and Hanumaan.

  • @bahitra ... ekta samay Viswa Bhaarati taader adhikaar proyog kore Debebartar Rabindra sangeet gaaoaar upor nishedagga jaari kore .... sei samaye uni kichhu adhunik gaan gyechhilen ... "braatyo joner ruddha sangeet" naame ekti pustikaao likhechhilaen ...

  • what is the gist of this song?

    it is very melodious

  • @chandra015

    The gist is - "I won't be able to say a word if you ask me anything. You have to understand my pain and longing for you".

  • @chandra015 .. "you say a lot without uttering a sound! for conveying your thoughts you don't need words, you need the passion and emotions! " ... i feel THAT is what is the gist of the song ... one of the many wonderful creations of Salil Chowdhury

  • kichu bolar nei!!

  • Amon asadharon ekta composition ekjon asadharon silpir kanthe kato undor hote pare, tar anobaddo udaharon.....

  • gurudeb...ashadharon...abosso shyamol mitra o bhalo geyechen..

  • thnx for the post...

  • sublime.................

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more