Arthur Grumiaux - Bach Partita No.3 in E major, BWV 1006 (II. Loure)

[natsfan44]

Any idiot who says this is boring or lacks finesse is a complete and utter idiot. It's a dance, playing it too slowly completely ruins the entire point of the piece.

[robertkeithkennedy]

are you crazy? @guidc...... or just a novice at musical understanding. Hillary has a lot to learn in my estimation...... I've never felt an iota of connection with her.... bless my heart. Sweet, nice, cute..... does not cut it with me.

[TheComedydude1]

@robertkeithkennedy OK, fine, Hilary can be a little cold, especially with her Barber. But hers is less boring and more beautiful than this. This sounds like a military drill. BORING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Legofreak57]

@TheComedydude1 You have much to learn about music.

[TheComedydude1]

@Legofreak57 Yak, yak, yak. You sound like yoda. speak for yourself!!! This is HORRIBLE! Go listen to Hilary's version! XP

[guidc]

the best romantic version ive heard!

milstein´s is good, but this sounds more like a loure. and that undanceble hillary´s version is completely out of the game.

[TheComedydude1]

@guidc well, hilary's is really beautiful, and a million tons more expressive. I agree with bourbakis... I don't think this version is the best AT ALL.

[vivace60]

He definitely accentuates the 2 beats in a bar. Enjoyed this but till prefer Milstein's version

[He1120]

Amazing!

[bourbakis]

Prefer Hillary Hahn's slower and more meditative version.

[FinaleFantasy]

Beautiful playing.