Added: 7 months ago
From: KirbyStompFilms
Views: 8,221
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (279)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Luna id never abandon fluttershy

  • Arg

    Lunar republic has good ideals.

    But Rainbow is on the solar side.

  • Luna republic

  • you guys can take sides...all i know is i'll be playing battle music with vinyl scratch

  • Hmmm... Well, I guess it depends on Luna's side. But in general, I can't trust Nightmare moon. All species being equal could also lower them to the status of insects. Much as it pains me to oppose Fluttershy, I'd have to go with the Solar kingdom. Celestia's proven herself a competent and kind ruler, and I'd trust her over Nightmare Moon (The video makes it seem that NMM is still in control of luna.).

  • I'm siding with Luna. Why? Because if you see me play Ace Combat: Assault Horizon, you'll see that all my planes and helicopters are in an NLR paint scheme :)

  • RAINBOW!!!!!! HOW COULD YOU!??!!!!?!?!?!!!

    Plus, if you search up "New Lunar Republic vs Solar Empire" on google images there is a pic of RD siding with the NLR. Just saying.

  • watch?v=Ys_0vmWLqqM

  • i join the lunar republic i am princess Luna`s to command

  • Me and my Flight of bombers are at the ready Princess Celestia 

  • do you have a transcript of this?. wanna try my hand at doing a voice over myself.... giving YOU credit of course.

  • I remember watching this before ponies entered my life. I went, "Huh... that's interesting..." but I never did anything else.

    So sad... I could have known about ponies that much earlier.

  • S2EP02

    Rainbow Dash: I'll always be loyal to the Princess!

    Yup, he predicted it.

  • Can I be neutral? I still can't decide

  • @KirbyStompFilms I think you need to make a better case for the Solar Kingdom. You portray Celestia too much as a tyrant. Who is gonna want to join a tyrant?

  • @KaptenN I agree. KirbyStompFilms, I suspect this is an issue of wording. Each side ought to put their best foot forward, the SK seeking to 'maintain the peace and prosperity of equestria' and the NLR seeking to 'Bring a new more fair order for all beings' Of course both sides would point out the others downsides too. The SK is ruled by 'nobles' and specist, while the NLR claims democracy but is ruled by the will of one, and the threat of eternal night hangs unaddressed.

  • @Sorain1 I've realized recently that I kinda rushed the whole development of this thing, and I got in over my head. The "choose your own adventure" format is appealing, but I just don't have the time to create something like that. So instead, the whole project is being torn down and rebuilt from scratch. The new story will incorporate Season 2 elements that will make the whole thing much more sensible, and it will be more along the lines of "interactive cinematic fanfiction" than this.

  • @KirbyStompFilms no worries. People seeing sense is never a bad thing.

  • Do not be fooled by this Lunar Propaganda! Celestia had the chance to create eternal day, yet she did not. This is not Luna's fault, but yet another attempt to take over Equestria perpetrated by Nightmare Moon! Fight for the return of the rule of both sisters together under a Democratic Monarchy once more! (And no i don't actually take this seriously.)

  • What ever happened to harmony...

  • FOR THE NEW LUNAR REPUBLIC! For those who have now sided with the lunar republic, (you rock by the way) you absolutely MUST become a member of the official site. Go to w w w . l u n a r r e p u b l i c . w e t p a i n t . c o m (no spaces.) Check out news, chat with other luna followers, and roleplay as a pony. BY THE MOON WE'LL FIGHT BY THE MOON WE'LL DIE!

  • @embarandshadowlegend The Magnificent Princess Luna is dissapointed by your attempted spam.

  • @KirbyStompFilms Um, it's not spam. It's the truth. The website needs members. Otherwise, it won't please Luna. Every part of my body would bow to princess Luna (if brains and internal organs could bow, they would.) Besides, that's where military tryouts are going to happen! ^.=.^

  • @KirbyStompFilms

    ExpdtnrAdmiral. Grant Gerard DuGalle Calliope: Greetings, i am Expeditionary Admiral Grant Gerard DuGalle Calliope. I was watching this video, and i'll ask you: Can i fave it and like it?

  • @embarandshadowlegend WE SHALT HAVE NO CIVIL WAR, THOU UNGRATEFUL WHELPS!

    -Luna

  • I pledge my appegiance to Trixie. She'll probably side with Lunar Republic. So do I.

    For the New Lunar Republic, my wings at your command, Princess Luna!

  • @signer0001 Actually, think about it: Trixie considers herself superior to EVERYTHING, INCLUDING other ponies. It wouldn't surprise me in the least if she actually decided to form her OWN empire based around her worship as a god-queen.

  • @hotelmario510 I think she'll wait before Solar Empire is crushed before putting dagger in Luna's back.

  • @signer0001 "Et tu, Trixie?"

    "SIC SEMPER TYRANNIS!"

  • @hotelmario510

     - You order Trixie around... making her obey your slightest whims... always talking like you better than her... No, goddess, Trixie think she'll take matters into her own hooves now. Equestria will be MINE, not yours! - This is madness! - Madness? THIS IS TRIXIE!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • I should probably ask if that's ok shouldn't I?

  • @GeoRyukaiser I say go for it, it sounds awesome. I'm curious though, what species make up the faction?

  • @KirbyStompFilms I'm basing them on Australia so Ponies from Equestria that have gotten alot tougher in the last 200 years spread across all forces, probably griffon variants (based on wedge-tailed eagles) for the air force (with a culture based on native Australian culture), and kangaroos for extra infantry (similar culture as the griffons though). They where going to be fewer in number but generally stronger then Solar Kingdom or Lunar Republic forces.

  • @KirbyStompFilms After some consideration I've narrowed it down to just Brumbies (Terra Australis Ponies) and Wedgies (Terra Australis Griffons) with the possibility of forming alliances with nations near to Equestria later on.

  • While I'm personally more inclined towards Luna... I'm writing a fanfic that could easily work as an 'expansion pack' introducing a third faction... the Terra Australis Brumbies.

  • I'd pledge allegiance to the Pink Federation.

  • I'd say that Equestria has never been surperior to other creatures. I could give examples if anyone wants them.

    But, as long as Celestia isn't a tyrant (or is only one in the Lunar Republic's eyes but not really) I have no complaints.

  • I would most likely join the Imperial Solar/Celestial Kingdom. Crops need light to grow.

  • I'll fight for the side that fields this kind of Technology:

    legacy350 deviantart com/art/Royal-Guard-G2-concept­-197630140

  • lunar republic all day. i wasn't sure about AJ's alignment but then i thought: redneck- the south- secession- similarities.

  • LOST MOMENT NEWS: I'm working in a custom campaign in SW: Galactic Battlegrounds based upon this video.

    In fact, its gonna be two campaigns, one for each side. Of course you will only control humans, as there aren't any pony units in the game, but all of them will be under control of one of the Mane 6.

    You can fight for the Solar Kingdom as Twilight and the Naboo, or fight for the Lunar Republic with Rarity and the Imperial Forces (kinda ironic).

    I'll bring further news about it later.

  • "Lauren Faust responded to these claims, stating that while Rainbow Dash was a tomboy, "nowhere in the show is her sexual orientation ever referenced" and "assuming [tomboys] are lesbians is extremely unfair to both straight and lesbian tomboys", and further stating that "Color has never, ever been depicted as a race indicator for the ponies."

  • Cant we settle this over a pint?

  • @Drearier No. ALL HAIL PRINCESS LUNA! FOR THE LUNAR REPUBLIC!

  • simply epic, you deserve some sort of medal for this, its way too epic

  • Comment removed

  • i will FOREVER be indebted into the new lunar republic.

  • As Pinkie Pie, may I use my abilitiy of breaking the fourth wall in order to teleport (jump out of the screen and back again) and do other awesome things?

  • just one complaint, shouldn't it be the solar empire instead, 'cause Celestia takes the title of princess not king, just saying....

    anyway cool vid and interested in seeing where this might go

    P.S. ONLY THE SUN CAN BRING TRUE LIGHT TO EQUESTRIA!! ONLY CELESTIA IS FIT TO REIN SUPREME!!

  • The sun shall fall, the moon stand tall.

  • For the Pink Federation!

  • for the lunar republic!

    porro ago luna!

  • All hail Celestia!

    Vivat Solis regni!

  • Due to the debate surrounding the Mane Six's alliances, I have posted a breakdown of how each pony was placed , in the video description. Please give this a read if you have any questions.

  • Applejack sided with Luna and Rainbow Dash stuck with Celestia O.o?

    A-heim Sorry, wut?!

    Did you even watch the whole Season1?

    In "Over a Barrel" it's RD who sides with the dispriviledged Buffalo while AJ supports the Establishment!

    Get yer facts straight Brony! >:|

  • @neferiusnexus

    That's a good point but, what I think he's doing is have an earth pony, a pegasus and a unicorn on each side to create a sort of balance.

    Rainbow Dash definitely would have gone with the Lunar Republic, but not as strongly as Fluttershy would for obvious reasons. So fluttershy trumps Rainbow Dash there (going off the balanced sides thing).

    Though if anything Pinkie Pie and Applejack should be switched around, as you probably know the reasons why.

    :)

  • Veeeery interesting idea.

  • All must bow to Princess Celestia! And not some weakling who got banished to the moon for a 1000 years!

  • Comment removed

  • Celestia's tyranny has gone on for long enough, it's time to put a stop to it. Allons-y!

  • For the Solar Kingdom, all hail Princess Celestia. May her light shine across the land as the rightful ruler. Do not believe this propaganda she is a just ruler who cares for all living creatures.

  • ungratfull foals calling celestia's reign a tyranny, they forget all to quickly of the 1000+ years of peace and progression ponykind and our partner species have experienced under her rule.

    ONLY THE SUN BRINGS TRUE LIGHT AND LIFE TO EQUESTRIA!!!!

  • Ponies must be superior to the other races because they are the most morally stable.

    Griffons are brash, arrogant, and violent, and the Diamond Dogs brutish, unintelligent slavers, who kidnap ponies to do their work.

    I stand with the Solar Kingdom. May Celestia's light shine on us all.

  • I don't care how important equality is, I love a good troll! Trollestia all the way!.

  • Equality or Tyranny?

    There is no question here, Celestia must be defeated.

  • Me and my squad would be honored to fly for Luna, we're always ready to dance with the angels! (God damn, it's impossible to make that sound cool)

  • @ArbiterRevan117 I see you're new to the Lunar Air Force. Her Majesty of the Night, Princess Luna, will pardon you this time, but be aware that the use of that phrase is punishable by 1000 years banishment to the sun.

    :)

  • Crap! On one hand I agree with Luna, but on the other hand Pinkie Pie's siding with Trollestia. I'm now sad. :(

  • On a side note, I'm really sick of seeing "TYRANT TROLL CELESTIA HERP" everywhere...

  • @sonicboom454 says the guy with rape-face celestia as his channel picture.

  • Ugh, is anyone else tired of seeing Luna, the Lunar Republic, etc. portrayed as the "good guys"?

    ...no?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • LONG LIVE THE LUNAR REPUBLIC! FOR LUNA!

  • Luna all the way.

  • There should be a third party, a socialist pony party looking to establish the United Equestrian Socialist Republic. A new order of equality, a workers paradise, no aristocrats or plutocrats stealing the sweat and blood from the brow of the common worker! From each pony according to their abilities, to each pony according to their needs! Viva la Proletariat!

  • Down with the tyrant troll Celestia! Let the moon rise as a new republic is formed! All hail Princess Luna! ( Oh and sidenote, if Docter Whoof becomes a side choice, I'm with him. Allons-y!)

  • Celestia could be like the government in Animal Farm.

    All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.

  • Luna! Luna! Luna! Bow down to the rightfull Queen, sun lovers!

  • Celestia's reign has ensured peace for a thousand years. The Solar Kingdom must continue to exist in order for magic, happiness, and rainbows to continue in our hearts. I side with the Solar Kingdom. I can only hope that the Lunar Republic does the right thing and lays down their arms peacefully. Fighting will get us nowhere.

  • All Hail Luna!

    Also, we'll trade you Rarity for Rainbow Dash

  • I say all for equality. Down with the tyrant queen

  • Damn it, It's so hard to choose!

  • Oh, I don't care. Undertakers and morticians are the true winners of modern wars. So I'll just sit on the sidelines and wander the battlefields afterward and do what I do. May not get paid much extra, but I love my job. Besides which, we tried the whole Celestia or Luna thing before. That's what caused Luna to be exiled in the first place.

  • I know the crackle was intentional, but I wasn't a fan. Sorry :/

  • Trollestia has, for too long, ruled with the harsh glare of the sun! Down with the tyrant! ALL HAIL LUNA! ALL HAIL THE LUNAR REPUBLIC! The Night Owl Division stands ready to fight by the true ruler of Equestria's side.

  • FOR THE REPUBLIC!!!! Sorry, that's just so fun to yell. 1000 more years for Celestia.

  • FOOLS, only ignorant minded fools choose one side or another. True power lies with united goddesses and this stupid squabble will only harm equestria.

  • THE NIGHT

    WILL LAST

    FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!

  • Sounds cool. I'm in.

  • You know what this calls for: /watch?v=sf0tYs5U5RI

    FOR THE NEW LUNAR REPUBLIC.

  • By Celestia's beard, what have I unleashed...

  • @KirbyStompFilms It has begun....

  • Check your messages, fellow brony ;)

  • The Lunar Republic shall rise! Unfetter yourselves, ponies: the time for revolution is come!

    (I like this idea. ^_^)

  • I suppose I'll have to throw my cards in with the Solar Kingdom. Ponies are just so superior.

  • currently the two least like ponies (and this is not my personal preference just going by EqD polls) are on the same team, so i suggest that rarity and pinkie get switched to even it out a bit. that and the other reasons that have been listed as to why they should get switched.

  • If Rarity and Pinkie were to be switched, I would go with the Lunar Republic. Otherwise, I stand undecided. Besides, if I recall, Pinkie appeared to sympathize with Princess Luna. I would have agree with Aidinthel about Pinkie's character...

  • I think you should've switched out Fluttershy and Rainbow.

  • Join the lunar republic. We have plushies.

    For more info go to bakki's deviantart /gallery/#/d3h3s98

  • ALL HAIL THE SOLAR KINGDOM! TWILIGHT AND RAINBOW DASH WILL NEVER LOSE! SINGLE MINDEDNESS FOREVER!

  • There shoudl be a third faction under the power of The Great and Powerful Trixie!

    That could make things interesting.

  • Side with Luna and beat down this tyrant Celestian age!

    For Luna!

    lol.

  • Forgive me, but I'm loyal to the Element of Loyalty, as Equestria has proved to be superior and more powerful that all other who want to steal what they get with great efford.

  • also: ALL HAIL THE LUNAR REPUBLIC!

  • EGRGRRGRGGAGAGAGRR audio crackle! If you are't going to get a new mic, distort the video so I can imagine that this is a historic recording after the bombs dropped and the world ended.

  • @Fordarz I actually used a high-quality stereo condenser microphone for the voiceover. The crackle is intentional. It’s meant to simulate the sound of a military radio. I’m still fine tuning it, trying to get something that sounds good.

  • Avalon. My favorite song from ACZ.

  • You should redo this with a microphone that doesn't assault my eardrums

  • @weylin6 I actually used a high-quality stereo condenser microphone for the voiceover. The crackle is intentional. It’s meant to simulate the sound of a military radio. I’m still fine tuning it, trying to get something that sounds good.

  • @KirbyStompFilms It sounds like the audio is just badly clipped. Try messing with the equalizer instead, or lowering the data type to something way lower than the 16-32 floating point, then it'll sound more like what you'd hear over a radio. the program Audacity might suffice for this task

  • @KirbyStompFilms If you like, you can send me the sound file, maybe I can work something out with it.

  • This needs to be made.

  • Lunar republic because Fluttershy

  • @mistahodst Agreed my friend

    

  • All hail the Lunar Republic! Defy!

  • Sir, this is amazing. I can totally see this turned into a Command & Conquer style game with the ponies as commanders. It would be GLORIOUS.

  • LUNAR REPUBLIC ALL THE WAY

  • The Lunar Republic must achieve victory, if not for the spirit and ideals of Princess Luna herself, then for the impoverished denizens of Equestria that the Solar Kingdom has left in the dark.

  • The Lunar Republic shall triumph!

  • Down with the tyrannical and bourgeois regime of Celestia! Freedom shall reign and the working class shall be freed from the shackles of monarchical slavery!

  • I follow Captain Rarity!

  • A THOUSAND MORE YEARS!

  • The light which makes your Moon shine is nothing but the reflection of our mighty Sun.-Hail Celestia.

  • I am a loyal subject to Celestia, may her reign never end!

  • The Lunar Republic shall prevail, even though having to deal with Rarity (#6) being on the same side, it'll be nice to have more magic. Applejack (#1) and Fluttershy (#2) more than make up for that, though.

    Honestly, Luna's gonna turn? That's a good argument? Huh. Celestia hating every species but ponies? Yeah, that'll work in her favor.

  • Burn in the heretics in Solar fire! Blood for the Sun God!

  • @SirLadette be bathed in everlasting darkness, foal, you are blind to the truths given by the lunar republic!

  • We may be divided But of you all, I beg To remember we're all hoofed At the end of each leg No matter what the issue Come from wherever you please All this fighting gets you nothing But hoof-in-mouth disease Arguing's not the way Hey, come out and play It's a shiny, new day So what do you say...
  • The Lunar Republic shall bring equal rights to all!

  • FOR THE NEW LUNAR REPUBLIC! Not a clever pony, hit it. *music starts*

  • FOR THE PINKIE PIE BRIGADE!

    ...

    Oh, that's not a fraction? Ahem, then FOR THE SOLAR KINGDOM! Who has Pinkie Pie! Which is honestly all I care about, what are we even fighting for anyway, yeah~!

  • HAIL LUNA! FOR THE NEW LUNAR REPUBLIC!

  • For the Solar Kingdom! All hail the Sun Queen!

    PS Pinkie's my fav, glad to see she's on the sunny side ^_^

  • Equality for all! For the Lunar Republic!!

    This is a fantastic concept to try and go for, very ambitious, and extremely interesting to see the sides go at it. I will avidly follow this should you continue it (which you definitely should!)

  • HAIL LUNA!

  • FOR THE SOLAR KINGDOM!

    Seriously, that's not the real Luna. I mean, come on. She's gonna betray everyone.

  • I side with the Lunar Republic, natural.

  • Princess Luna will prevail, equality for all!

  • For the Lunar Republic!

    ... Even if my favorite 2 of the mane 6 are with Celestia ;w;

  • The Lunar Republic shall prevail!

    (Somehow we need to obtain Rainbow Dash's loyalty...>.>)

  • On this day, we shall bring forth an age of peace for all!! DOWN WITH THE SUN TYRANT!! ALL HAIL THE LUNAR REPUBLIC!!

  • Brothers! We must stand by the side of our beloved princess! For it is she who raises the sun for its heat to embrace us all! So grab your swords, your shields, your AK-47s, or whatever weapon of destruction you poses, and together we shall defeat this nighttime menace! We are the proud Solar Kingdom! For the Queen! For Celestia! ALL HAIL THE SUN!

  • Oooh, exciting! I hope this becomes a reality!

  • FOR THE SOLAR KINGDOM!

  • The lunar republic will only bring war and death to our peaceful land.

    Long live the Solar kingdom, long live the sun princess, long live Celestia.

  • I want this to happen, I truly want, so you have my full support!

    Oh, and all hail the solar kingdom!

  • People always go 'LUNA OH YEAH EVEN THOUGH SHE HAS ZERO CANON PERSONALITY SHE'S OBVIOUSLY BETR TH4N CELESTIA'

    Let's get one thing straight. Princess Celestia saved Equestria from a future of eternal night, from darkness where the crops would wilt and die and a darkness where ponies and all these other races would suffer: that's the only 'equality' that would be involved in Princess Luna's regime. Either you stand with the forces of order and clear-mindedness or some ponified French Revolution.

  • The supporters of Luna offer little other than chants and blind fanaticism, eager to burden generations to come with their naivety. Under the rule of the Lunar Witch war and famine will reign. Those who stand with her taint their hooves with the blood of their own foals. It is your duty, not only as Equestrian but as a parent to support Celestia, the one and only Queen of Equestria.

  • I'll side with... The Doctor and Derpy!!! All Hail the TARDIS!

  • @TSEpictures I'M WITH YOU BRONY! ALL HAIL THE TARDIS

  • @TSEpictures Then i side with you. The Doctor knows, so i side with him as well.

  • @4goman Onward with the Pony from Gallopfray then, Allons-y!

  • This is amazing! I hope this happens!

    also since pinkie is with the solar kingdom... LONG LIVE THE SOLAR KINGDOM!

  • I would go to the Lunar Republic...if it had my three favorite ponies of the mane six in it. so yah GO SOLAR KINGDOM.

  • confound these ponies they drive me to war

  • I DON'T CARE WHAT SIDE IM ON! I'LL JUST NUKE EM BOTH!

    But I do like the Lunar Republic's idea of equal society.

  • I really think Rarity and Pinkie Pie need to be switched. Rarity is so out of place among the proletariat and I don't see her so much as modern and forward thinking as high-class and elegant. I think she would prefer a time-tested order over pie-in-the-sky dreams of equality that may very well plunge into chaos. Pinkie Pie, on the other hand, is much more impulsive and wants everyone to be happy and so she'd be more attracted to the idealism of the Lunar Republic.

  • @Aidinthel If Pinkie were to be changed it should be with Applejack. Applejack seems like the most old- fashioned out of the 3 and she has been shown to be very stubborn so she probably not want things to change.