Added: 3 years ago
From: 66shadymilkman
Views: 296,858
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Could anyone reupload Gnashville by this band please? It was deleted and it was such a good song.

  • This song gives me a good feeling

  • Hell the union bra all day haha. Iv'e smoked weed before i know what it does says the news guy haha

  • what are some other songs by these guys?

  • Yoni Wolf's voice is a world wonder.

  • wow i remember hearing this song on myspace years back, it's so great to hear it now such a awesome song.

  • This is what the ghost of someone's dad says...

  • Just got back from Germany, can relate to the part where he loses his money to the guy with the walnut shells and a marble.

  • someone post lyrics?

  • I've known them for a day and i feel no need to listen to anyone else.

  • @IAmCaptainPlastic Indeed

  • @IAmCaptainPlastic I've known them for 3 years and I have no need to listen to anyone else

  • This is the first time I've listened to Why?

    And now I ask myself "Why? Why did I not listened to Why? sooner?"

  • Such a fuckin' great song

  • Really like this. Clever lyrics, great song arranging too. Reminds me a little of Cursive, another band who I really like!

  • @trubblemuffin GOD! Remind me of cursive too! i never thought someone else would say it! cursive - best active band worldwide

  • so fucking good

  • does anyone know where to download this?!

  • @ilovekissing24 google youtube to mp3 shhhh

  • This is great.

  • 19 people are dipshits.

  • u guys are poop heads and i like this song lots. specially with all these loose tooths.

  • i've never overdosed, nor am i inebriated at the present moment. am i still allowed to love this?

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite well. i guess there is such a thing as a stupid question.

  • @ferociousflounder11 <-------- this guy doesn't get the joke

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite no i do. it was just very very lame.

  • @ferociousflounder11 what's the punchline? what topic is the joke addressing?

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite ha. there's a punchline? good one.

  • @ferociousflounder11 ok, so what i'm picking up on is that you didn't see the punchline. which means you didn't get the joke. which means you just lied to me when you said "no i do" in relation to getting the joke. which means i was correct in typing "this guy doesn't get the joke". QED

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite I guess stupid is what stupid does :/ But yeah liking this song doesn't require you to be a junkie.

  • @HYSM90s goddamnit, does no one get the joke? it's funny, i swear to God!

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite I guess you should just explain it, I was assuming it was making fun of the fact that alot of people are posting about there drug problems.

  • @HYSM90s pretty much yeah. especially since probably more than half are not really drug users but want to sound cool

  • @HYSM90s pretty much yeah. especially since probably more than half are not really drug users but want to sound cool

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite your name is ironic

  • @agedskate3000 i know. i was smoking alot more when i made the account. i've cut down since then though

  • @PhillyBluntsDoItRite your name is ironic

  • This is fuckn wack!!! aha I rather kill myself or overdose on heroin

  • Can't wait to see this live in 1.5 months!

  • yay. music by and for mentally ill kids who are obsessed with being smart and poetic. neat. you are indeed genetically superior. now FUCK OFF!

  • @andywarstarforever you are clearly a fucking moron and don't have any idea what mental illness is, he is not trying to to be superior, just stating a fact. you FUCK OFF U TWAT!!!!

  • @merrydown2011 Ah ha!!! I've weeded out at least one mentally ill fan of a mentally ill band. HAHA!!!

  • OH FUCK YEAH HARDCORE PARKOUR

  • @DrAbeGelly Thank god, its our thing. ;D

  • What an unique amazing band !! From South Africa \o/

  • CAN SOMEONE OUT THERE UPLOAD ME ON BEER, OFF OF THE EARLY WHITNEY EP. I CANT FIND IT EVEN THOUGH PREDICTIVE SEARCH LISTS IT.

  • I love the part "I curse the last six months I've been hiding behind a mustache, to those last two years I've been howling a paper moon...well fuck you"

  • @thatsrachelle It's actually 10 years, not 2 . :P just saying.

  • @thatsrachelle but its: "...to those last TEN years..." but its a great song anyway.

  • Wow these lyrics confuse me so badly.. I'm not even sure I can come up with my own meaning, anyone care to share theirs?

  • @Shamadamun i dunno i guess just try to lead an even slightly interesting life and then respond to them originally based on your own experiences?

    or is that too much to f***ing ask for?

    I imagine given the context of this conversation that the answer is yes.

    goodnightmuchlove

  • i overdosed on weed while listening to this...

    5 kilos in 1 minute fucking killss....

  • @cykotoxick Talking utter bullshit on Youtube makes YOU look like an asshole too.

  • houseofteeth.bandcamp.com

  • Only fucking morons overdose, drink your drugs like a man you cocknecked fucknuts.

  • Yoni, just give me time. i promise ill bloom. just a little more time. and i will fully see the light that shines on me.. give me time. i love you.

  • 1:20-1:23= me. srsly. my dad is a pentecostal pastor.

  • Comment removed

  • Can't stop listening to this track !

  • 0:43 :)

    

  • holy shit.. real music. so happy i found them

  • if your bartender puts on why? and tells you to buy everything they've ever made, and is over 6 ft 5. well I mean, I didn't need that much of a push. but yeah. you do it. cause why? deserves it. and so do you.

  • flerkin

  • best. song. evar.

  • this song is depressing and hilarious at the same time...

  • i am in love with theis song...<3

  • I don't get why people argue about comments on a VIDEO. Get over it already and just listen to the god damn song!

  • I always think I'm about to hear "In Berlin, I saw two men fucking a dog"

  • @MrDrSmithJr l always though it was "fuck in a dark corner of a basketball court"

  • @iskate953 It is. That's what I always suspect I'm going to hear.

  • Can't figure out where I've heard this. fuck you.

  • No matter how good the lyrics if the "guitarist" can't play for shit then the music sounds crap, real musicians never take this shit seriously

  • @Ihatemyusernamemore: i don't give a shit about the so-called real musicians' shredding wankery when i listen to this.this shit is all about raw entertainment, pop music at it's best. no overplayed stupid clichés, no dumb lyrics, but still popular music. and i do listen to contemporary classics as much as meshuggah, just to mention some. i hope you got the point. open your mind and have a nice life! ;)

  • @ewanbasswah Meshuggah is a contemporary classic? What has the world come to??? Surely someone who can appreciate the value of entertainment in music over pure technical wank can should realize that Meshuggah is pure wankery technical bullshit, for actually entertaining technical music listen to Fall of Troy, Protest the Hero's Kezia, Cryptopsy's None So Vile, Gorgut's Obscura, Burst and The Number 12 Looks Like You's Put On Your Rosy Red Glasses

  • @Voidworshipper it was my bad english. i wanted to say from contemporary classics to meshuggah. that swedish machinery just works for me. whatever, thanks for the recommendations, the number 12 ... is the only i knew of 'em. cheers!

  • @Ihatemyusernamemore You sir, are not a real musician.

  • @drummtb333 Cause you've totally seen me play and know what I'm about from one comment right? for all I know you could be an amazing jazz pianist but I'll just do the same to you and assume you're an unattractive pretentious insufferable hipster douchebag

  • @Ihatemyusernamemore The fact that you wrote me a paragraph backs up what I just said.

  • lyrical genius....food for thought,much love.x

  • oh no, those gypsies probably got knives :}

  • @rapedbyzebras Actually its those gypsies probably got nikes At least thats what my friend wants me to believe

    cause he always likes to be right.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • 3:06 is the best picture ever.

  • This is what the ghost of someone's dad said.

  • I am raping my replay button - possibly one of the best of WHY? Thumbs up!

  • "WHAT IS THIS BAND CALLED?

    wHY?

    why is it called that tho?

    why?

    ahah i love messin with people:]

  • @rainbow3rain Yea messing people on youtube is hilarious, you petty little person.

  • @seancooley petty little person?!????!???

  • @seancooley petty little person??????? ha..

  • WHY? Isn't this band on the radio?

  • @crohns4life because the radio plays complete garbage

  • @MO6ful Try using torrents if you can't buy it in your country.

  • esta de lujo su musica donde se puede comprar su musica en mexico ,bueno muchas ,muchas gracias por estar ...

    

  • usually not my taste at all but damn, this was crazy good

  • This band is fucking amazing. I mean, you can listen to them 24/7 and not get tired.

  • Just the slight jingle of pocket change pulsing

  • these guys will never go main stream

  • @DrAbeGelly  you never know the worlds changing(hopefully) people are getting sick of stupid bullshit music

  • @budd420man not really

  • @DrAbeGelly It's better that way. Mainstream would ruin it all.

  • @flytrappedinajar1 im really gay

  • @DrAbeGelly Even if they do; fuck it, they deserve it.

  • in berlin once saw to men fuck in a dark courner of a basket ball court

  • I hop on the Macarthur bart every day - I wonder if i've seen Yoni or Dose or any of those guys...

  • i could not love this band more.

  • This was the last song I listened to before I overdosed and went to a mental hospital. Listening to it again 3 months sober is fucking intense.

  • @nolongereatsshit Good luck to ya

  • @nolongereatsshit wht did u overdoes on?

  • @peanutpeople0077

    A combination of cocaine, heroin, ecstasy, adderall, oxycotin, weed, and booze.

  • @nolongereatsshit GOOD GOD! DUDE YOU WERE FUCKING HARDCORE

  • @peanutpeople0077 Nah man, I was miserable and pathetic. If that makes me hardcore, I never would wish being hardcore on anyone. Sure, I'm only 17 and I've got stories that would make you shit your pants, but when you're living it it's the furthest thing from cool possible. Thanks though, haha!

  • @nolongereatsshit hahah really i bet u do lol

  • @nolongereatsshit i'd love to hear some stories about incontinence, please

  • @nolongereatsshit been on all of those at one point or another. XDD

  • @nolongereatsshit So a Jeffrey? Ha nah I'm kiddin bro. Shit overdosing on coke sucks, for real.

  • @nolongereatsshit you can't OD on weed you fucking nut, it would take 1000 joints to kill somebody, and they would die of Carbon Monoxide from the smoke, not from the actual weed.

  • @carbonv9 Duh. Notice that wasn't the only drug I said. But when you're on all those other things, weed certainly doesn't make you feel any better.

  • @carbonv9 Actually, I think to 'overdose' on THC to the point of it being lethal you'd have to smoke something like 20,000 Cuban strength joints in under 15 minutes... I challenge anyone to do that ahah

    Ask yourself if the same can be said for alcohol and why the fuck is it illegal aha

  • @Meatlock I think you have to smoke your body weight in under a second or some shit. It's ridiculously impossible to od on THC.

  • @Meatlock dude. wtf is a cuban strength joint? u clearly do not smoke pot. "cuban" is not a measurement of marijuanna potency. now sit down and stop speaking.

  • @prettyflyforagothguy I meant a blunt the size of a cuban cigar, I don't even remember typing that out. I'm high right now lol so.. that's just like your opinion man!

    I saw it on a documentary called "the union the business behind getting high" watch it, it's all backed by the document names of the files of research they did so.. I'm not wrong.

  • you all are dumb. just listen to the music you turds

  • @chiefwahoo123 Chill cocksmoker!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @nolongereatsshit how pills

  • @nolongereatsshit muscle memory's the shit

  • @nolongereatsshit 

    hope your still doing well man, it'm my 2 year clean anniversary today

  • I lost 50 euros to a guy with the walnut shells and the marble, it really pissed me off so oh I thought id go back to get my money!

  • Been following these dudes since '02(14 years old).. Check out my uploads, I'm from the same city as WHY?.

  • not bad foshay

  • great whe on acid

  • LOVEE THISSS SOONNNNNGGGG

  • they're so good. their badass/funny combination is unique. & they sound so good!!!!! can i say so good again? so good. they are so good. (this is what the ghost of someone's dad says)

  • amazing.

  • I love this song soo much Yoni wolf<3

  • Beard envy.

  • fucking great

  • this song is so weird but so hypnotizing why cant i stop listening to it?

  • The very first time I heard WHY? I was hooked!

    I havn't stopped listening to them since, and that was months ago.

  • favourite Why? album stoked to see them @ the thekla

  • Love. <3

  • WHY?... Because they can and they are great. Why? Because they are WHY?

  • i want a beard like them

  • Comment removed

  • peanutbutter

  • @mejohn96

    ...apple dumpling?

  • i´m not sure if this lyrics are from WHY, but knows anybdy a song where the singer sings "On the run from Nazi-Paparazzi" ? if anybdy knowS this.. PLeeeeaaaaseee PN

    greets to all fans

  • yesssssssssssssss

  • Cool sound , reminds me of CAKE and CAKE is cool too

  • This song is fucken rad!!!!

  • nize

  • all us earth growths some planted some pulled :D chorus

  • I think I may have been one of those two men he saw in Berlin.

  • @FredR023 I appreciate coming onto youtube and laughing at people being funny instead of them just being idiotic. I congratulate you on making me laugh at your funny (honest...? :o ) statement.

  • @FredR023 was that you?

  • arguing over interpretation is about as effective as cooking eggs out of termite larva

  • I love this band. extremely talented, good lyrics, and fun to listen to.

  • I like the song, but lol @ good lyrics

  • Very obviously the main theme is a pregnancy scare.

  • noooo its nonsensicle cool details. He is like painting a picture with words

  • Shine a flashlight in an empty hat box and spin an empty oyster shell and celebrate the hollows.

    He's talking about a pregnancy scare.

  • You know what there some lines that provide for both of our answers but in reality the song is probably lefy up for interpretation

  • @johnwashere22 dood youre one of those fags who fights people on youtube? haha f*uck dat $hit. u a fool lol. good luk with ur lyfe, ur wife will prob hate u haha like "johnwashere stop yelllin @ da computer! get off utube!" LOL

  • @trevbrochill hey you fucker i poop in your mouth, and trevor do you know who this is rofl copter!!!

  • @johnwashere22 lol i kno wu it iz fag n ill fuk up ur shit bitch fuck. also, i got a backstage pass to portugal the man tomorrow. so suck my fat dick. douche.

  • @trevbrochill : by chance are you black? lolllllllllllllllllll

  • "And to those last ten years I've been howlin' a paper moon.. Fuck you."

    <3

  • The line about the Berlin men jarred me, but I otherwise like this song.