Dude! That was AWESOME!! I LOVE " From the Top " !!! I've been listening to the show on the radio for years, and now I can SEE Christopher O'riley online. Darwin be damned! God bless the little prodigies !!
@ABookwormAndProud From the Top at Carnegie Hall presents a piano extravaganza featuring Alice Burla, 10, one of the youngest students at Juilliard; Jeremy Jordan, 17, from Chicago; and 14-year-old Peng-Peng from New York City, in solo performances. Host Christopher O’Riley joins them for a spectacular four piano finale: Wagner’s famous “Ride of the Valkyries.”
Great transposition, superbly played. However, it just doesn't have the same impact as the original, I just can't see the Americans bombing vietnam to this
Why is it that they barely show the fourth piano(the dark guy) and whenever they do show him, its a close up of his face for like a second, instead of actually showing his piano skills like the other 3? Bad cameraman I guess? Just seems weird.
Really? I always thought it was the group of Norse godesses who rode white horses through battle-fields in search of dead warriors who were worthy of Valhalla.
this sounded like a symphony, flawless as usual...it's an amazing show. I find it hard to believe how incredibly talented some people are.. truly a gift from god.
yeah, tons of it..but it takes a lot more to have "that" kind of perfection at such a young age...great teachers, enormous amounts of raw talent, and yes, tons and tons of practice. But, it takes all of it.
yes, but talent and skill are not the same things, and skill has a time dependent component to it...those with great talent, except for the one in 10,000 prodegy, still have to elapse time prior to the aquisition of the best skill.
Spoken like a true non-musician, "red balls." Those of us that have sacrificed countless hours in front of the piano for the sake of capturing the pure intensity of a Beethoven sonata or the agonizing melodies of a Rachmaninoff prelude or the technical nightmares of a Chopin etude can fully grasp the pure ignorance of such a comment.
Different art. Different talent. That's like saying true courage isn't reporting in a war zone, it's being in the military. Garbage.
Firstly, you've completely misinterpreted what I meant. Not to mention, your analogy was ridiculously inaccurate.
If anything, "being in the military" would be the equivalent of learning someone else's composition. Basically, the music doesn't come from your artistry, unless it's a variation.
It's like learning to paint the Mona Lisa. It's not your work and as such it doesn't come from your passion and artistry. It's like a Beatles impersonator-band in rock-music. Big deal!
Oh I get it. You aren't passionate or an artist unless you composed the music. Man, where were YOU when Horowitz, Arrau, Richter, Brendel, Rubinstein, Volodos, Ashkenazy, etc. were spending hour after hour, day after day learning piano repertoire when they could have just made a piano roll from the music so everyone could pack into Carnegie Hall and listen to a player piano?
"Red Balls" could have saved everybody a LOT of time. What a waste!
I stand by what I've said. I don't see how playing someone else's piece makes you a great musician. You can make all the pig-headed "Mr.Arrogant Music Major" remarks you want. I think the fact that a young child can play Ride Of The Valkyries speaks for itself. Music, like any art, requires an artistic and creative mind.
Would you say that this young girl is a greater artist than Richard Wagner as she can play his work at such a young age? If not, explain.
Of course you don't see why performance of the greatest classical works of the piano repertoire makes you a musician. You live inside a box that around 1/10 non-musicians fit into.
As far as age goes, Mozart composed his first work when he was 4. There goes that.
Composition? One art form. Performance? DIFFERENT art form. Dude, you're fighting a losing battle. Beethoven, Mozart, Liszt, and all the rest of the masters were constantly performing the works of others.
I'm not a music major, but it's flattering that you assumed that.
You see Balls, the trouble is you equate "playing" music with "duplicating" music. If you can honestly listen to Horowitz play Rachmaninoff and then listen to Lang Lang play Rachmaninoff and say that there is no such thing as a "great pianist", then I'll just let you carry on with your denigration of pianists.
The artistry doesn't lie in putting notes on a page, it is what one DOES with those notes.
It is the first time I watch it ! WOW ! Good players , congratulations,(Sorry my english I m spanish)4 pianos playing my favourite Wagner ,thank s a lot!Very Nice video,thanks!
♥ it *-* I'm playing this song but this is a lot of better ...
MaTzZe98 1 month ago
Simplesmente belo,maravilhosa interpretação
alexpbarbosa1 3 months ago
everyone uses sheet music apart from the guy in the black suit. he's using an ipad if i'm not mistaken lol
TheMysterypianoboy1 5 months ago
was alright, but it doesn't have the same inflection that comes with the brass and strings...
TheLordOden 6 months ago
they are amazing , bravo :)
LailaBecef 7 months ago
Racist motherfuckers, always it must be one nigger, one asian, one white ??
Crox300 7 months ago
YEAH GO ASIANS!!!!!!!
lakers1221369 8 months ago
@lakers1221369 ASIANS!!! ASIANS!!!
john79341 7 months ago 2
SPLENDIDE !!!!!!!!!!!
TheMaximekiki 10 months ago
hhghghghghghgg
nana0846 10 months ago
Now THIS is talent!!!!
ArchHighLordOmega 11 months ago
Dude! That was AWESOME!! I LOVE " From the Top " !!! I've been listening to the show on the radio for years, and now I can SEE Christopher O'riley online. Darwin be damned! God bless the little prodigies !!
ArchHighLordOmega 11 months ago
4 heads are better than 3
draklorian 11 months ago
sounds so much.......less thretaning on piano
axxaxaxx 1 year ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Lol @ the slanted eyed bastard.
NickForelli 1 year ago
How old are these kids? They're awesome!
ABookwormAndProud 1 year ago
@ABookwormAndProud From the Top at Carnegie Hall presents a piano extravaganza featuring Alice Burla, 10, one of the youngest students at Juilliard; Jeremy Jordan, 17, from Chicago; and 14-year-old Peng-Peng from New York City, in solo performances. Host Christopher O’Riley joins them for a spectacular four piano finale: Wagner’s famous “Ride of the Valkyries.”
Hjoranna 1 year ago
Not being Mean but peng-peng is mad at the song it seems
nerakalove 1 year ago
Gee I would love to hear this live
Medafets 1 year ago
Can't you get page turners for these poor kids? ;)
drtmuir 1 year ago 5
Brilliant!
pitcalco 2 years ago
this is awesome
tommy9882 2 years ago
OMFG The little girl playing?? I know her!!!! Its ALICE shes in my French class!! Oh i'm so bombarding her with questions in French tomorrow
twilightgirl257 2 years ago 2
Great!
Maybe it's interesting as a kind of "contrast" to give a look in my video of the same piece played in an arrangement for the left hand alone
please see on my video section ;-)
ArturCimirro 2 years ago
sounds better with 4 people than 1
SovietSpymaster17 2 years ago 24
Comment removed
arberdemaj1 2 years ago
Most likely because she is about 1000 times better than you hmmm..???
werq34ac 2 years ago
i wanna lern this D:
RandomPivotMaker 2 years ago
So here's the question. If you play Carnegie hall starting at 10yrs old, where do you go from there?
knightpg 2 years ago 3
@knightpg They will need to build a new hall in a class of its own.
pitcalco 2 years ago
@knightpg you can only go down from there
brettyfxu 1 year ago
Awesome digital page turner! Very good playing too!
Yaf0 2 years ago
Great transposition, superbly played. However, it just doesn't have the same impact as the original, I just can't see the Americans bombing vietnam to this
Crossovahh 2 years ago
a superb performance, I was sceptic but it is marvellous
lynmunt 2 years ago
Fantastic!!! Terrific job all around! And by the way, all you haters out there....just go crawl in a hole and die.
ddoyle11 2 years ago
Che schifo di versione.
vnusein 2 years ago
The man in the begginning was Le Chiffre, of james bond, cosino royal...
sharkfriend 3 years ago
Le Chiffre was played by Mads Mikkelsen, not this dude.
WiseGuy02 2 years ago
RUN CHARLIE RUN!!!!
BooRadleysGhost 3 years ago 20
what?
TheTurtleman9 3 years ago
LMAO
Israelipatriot92 3 years ago
RUN JEW RUN.
NaslundFurever 2 years ago
NO!
run charlie rus is a quote frome the movie "apocalypse now". in one scene, this music is played
Ahti333gm 2 years ago
GG.
Kratos330 2 years ago
@BooRadleysGhost
Funny cause there is an asian playing the melody :)
humpmeimapilot 1 year ago
@BooRadleysGhost ?? : P
iceburg008 4 months ago
total AWESOMENESS! I love this song
SS1v3k1 3 years ago
cool
kurusek123 3 years ago
epic music for epic people!
LazuhSniper 3 years ago 3
The Nordic Race?
Richardtheincredible 3 years ago
Is there any other?
dolofonos 3 years ago
Are there any other races?
Yes, hundreds. And the Nordics aren't superior.
Richardtheincredible 3 years ago
wow, those pianos are niiice
st3v33wunda 3 years ago
Why is it that they barely show the fourth piano(the dark guy) and whenever they do show him, its a close up of his face for like a second, instead of actually showing his piano skills like the other 3? Bad cameraman I guess? Just seems weird.
Ghettobaron 3 years ago
Beautiful!
Naapdaab 3 years ago
amazing
marylinks 3 years ago
gong peng peng's father is a great piano teacher. i couldn't learn from him because he lives too far
marylinks 3 years ago
does peng peng mean anything in any language? i want to know
yashil17 3 years ago
i think it means great eagle or something
operaghostnina 3 years ago
no it doesn't
marylinks 3 years ago
ok sorry! i never said i knew! does anyone know? i'm curious too. but i have another guess: peaceful.
operaghostnina 3 years ago
if anything it means "to war!"
spacegekko 3 years ago
Really? I always thought it was the group of Norse godesses who rode white horses through battle-fields in search of dead warriors who were worthy of Valhalla.
bomberchicken 3 years ago
this sounded like a symphony, flawless as usual...it's an amazing show. I find it hard to believe how incredibly talented some people are.. truly a gift from god.
sidthinker 3 years ago
its called practice
katie97z 3 years ago 2
yeah, tons of it..but it takes a lot more to have "that" kind of perfection at such a young age...great teachers, enormous amounts of raw talent, and yes, tons and tons of practice. But, it takes all of it.
sidthinker 3 years ago
Age is irrelevant to talent
derefis 3 years ago
yes, but talent and skill are not the same things, and skill has a time dependent component to it...those with great talent, except for the one in 10,000 prodegy, still have to elapse time prior to the aquisition of the best skill.
sidthinker 3 years ago
True talent isn't playing, it's composing.
RedBalls101 3 years ago
Spoken like a true non-musician, "red balls." Those of us that have sacrificed countless hours in front of the piano for the sake of capturing the pure intensity of a Beethoven sonata or the agonizing melodies of a Rachmaninoff prelude or the technical nightmares of a Chopin etude can fully grasp the pure ignorance of such a comment.
Different art. Different talent. That's like saying true courage isn't reporting in a war zone, it's being in the military. Garbage.
vladimirhorowitz 3 years ago
Firstly, you've completely misinterpreted what I meant. Not to mention, your analogy was ridiculously inaccurate.
If anything, "being in the military" would be the equivalent of learning someone else's composition. Basically, the music doesn't come from your artistry, unless it's a variation.
It's like learning to paint the Mona Lisa. It's not your work and as such it doesn't come from your passion and artistry. It's like a Beatles impersonator-band in rock-music. Big deal!
RedBalls101 3 years ago
It's still beautiful to listen to, yes, but it doesn't blow my mind to see this type of thing.
A parrot can mimic melodies, it takes a true musician to create their own.
RedBalls101 3 years ago
Oh I get it. You aren't passionate or an artist unless you composed the music. Man, where were YOU when Horowitz, Arrau, Richter, Brendel, Rubinstein, Volodos, Ashkenazy, etc. were spending hour after hour, day after day learning piano repertoire when they could have just made a piano roll from the music so everyone could pack into Carnegie Hall and listen to a player piano?
"Red Balls" could have saved everybody a LOT of time. What a waste!
vladimirhorowitz 3 years ago
I stand by what I've said. I don't see how playing someone else's piece makes you a great musician. You can make all the pig-headed "Mr.Arrogant Music Major" remarks you want. I think the fact that a young child can play Ride Of The Valkyries speaks for itself. Music, like any art, requires an artistic and creative mind.
Would you say that this young girl is a greater artist than Richard Wagner as she can play his work at such a young age? If not, explain.
RedBalls101 3 years ago
Of course you don't see why performance of the greatest classical works of the piano repertoire makes you a musician. You live inside a box that around 1/10 non-musicians fit into.
As far as age goes, Mozart composed his first work when he was 4. There goes that.
Composition? One art form. Performance? DIFFERENT art form. Dude, you're fighting a losing battle. Beethoven, Mozart, Liszt, and all the rest of the masters were constantly performing the works of others.
vladimirhorowitz 3 years ago
I think you should listen to vladimirhorowitz
SS1v3k1 3 years ago
I'm not a music major, but it's flattering that you assumed that.
You see Balls, the trouble is you equate "playing" music with "duplicating" music. If you can honestly listen to Horowitz play Rachmaninoff and then listen to Lang Lang play Rachmaninoff and say that there is no such thing as a "great pianist", then I'll just let you carry on with your denigration of pianists.
The artistry doesn't lie in putting notes on a page, it is what one DOES with those notes.
vladimirhorowitz 2 years ago 3
Wagner or Liszt were smiling.Specially the little girl!what a genius girl!
ArturoAlejandroS 3 years ago
Beautifull!!! Thanks for posting"!!!!Greeting From Brazil
Jualmir 3 years ago
Comment removed
peiwenviolinist 4 years ago 7
@peiwenviolinist Wow... How good for you!
Very compromising for such an important school as Juillard to allow that kind of information breaks...
LordMgls 1 year ago
hey ppl!
this is alice burla, the pianist!
thanks for watching this!
enjoy!!
alicepianogurl96 4 years ago 4
I enjoyed it very much! You all did such a great job.
TheBlackPage1 3 years ago 2
it's amazing that some one so little could play so well. my sister is 18 and hardly can play so well.
she's still good though.
uogb 4 years ago 3
omg i cant imagine how much fun that would be!!! 4 pianos in carnegie hall...
lol and i love christopher's faces when he plays :p
Tuttiplaya 4 years ago
I really like the little girl... she's very talented!
Really nice =)
0OoFACUoO0 4 years ago 2
Bravo!
pianogirl98 4 years ago
bravisimo :D wow ke hermoso
aloneriz 4 years ago
no less than incredible...
omritoker 4 years ago 2
Wonderful: four pianos! Great play!
Euroman002 4 years ago
They most be Gods!
alexofhoth 4 years ago
dude i know alice!!! the girl playing it(kinda)
Jozazzo47 4 years ago
it takes 4 pianos to play this but only one organ
MeZZosOpRaNOz 4 years ago 2
Extremely talented musicians there, however I still prefer the orchestral sound. Anyway great video.
TheKokuya 4 years ago 2
Absolutely brilliant!
DJPsYkik 4 years ago
that was amazing! thanx for posting this. ride of the valkyries is one of my favorite tunes
DamoclesPhoton 4 years ago
It is the first time I watch it ! WOW ! Good players , congratulations,(Sorry my english I m spanish)4 pianos playing my favourite Wagner ,thank s a lot!Very Nice video,thanks!
DRSinte 4 years ago
Brilliantly synchronized!!! A masterpiece played to perfection!!!
04111 4 years ago