i'll say the JP is still the best. Too bad the english version were not released(it was dubbed). If there was an English version..I believe it would be beautiful as Luci Christian is a great voice actress and singer.
Oh come on!!!!!!! they've dubbed it in so many languages, how hard would it be to do a good english dub for this??? i mean yeah, i like the japanese, but i would kinda like to see what it would be like in english (hopefully not sounding too american.....)
I wonder why Italian has their own beat while the other songs have the same music and beat I like japanese and Italian the best because of the singers and hippos voice
Don't worry about it. She(or some hacker posing as her), replied to a bunch of commenters here saying that. I removed all of her comments and blocked her.
I want to do a fandub of this in English. But don't worry, it won't be a crappy 4Kids or Dic dub with crappy/unoriginal lyrics. I'll try to base it on the original translations of the Jap version.
the italian version was good but, somehow it doesnt sound like the luchia i know...it sounds like a totally different person. i love the japanese version the most
everyone has been hating on the italion one but i think thats actually the best(behind japanese of course) she has a pretty voice and they were brave enough to change the song which makes them unique:)
usally i looooveee the italian dubs of japanese animes (just look at the tokyo mew mew dubs - they are amazing) but i don' like that they canged luchias song in this :/
I looooveeee the italian song, but it'snot the same song and i find that annoying :/ so i guess that the japanese one is my favorite ^^
I know but since I don't really know anyone who's willing to translate at the moment, I had to put them up without the subs. I'll put subtitles on this video through annotations whenever someone decides to send me a translation.
I have to say, I am impressed with Japanese, Korean, Mandarin, Italian, and Hebrew in this comparasion. Wow, Serbian actually did awesome here. Portuguese and Spanish? No comment. >_>;;;;;
ADV had the rights to it but since it's a kids show, it had to be on TV in order for it to be successful. Unfortunately, no TV channel wanted it since it was a girl show. The Japanese currently has it but since ADV is no more, no one's sure what's going to happen with their dub of the show.
@HikaYagami: "no TV channel wanted it since it's a girl show." that is SO true! I hate how America can't market girls' anime well or any girl show for that matter, unless it's some Disney-fied junk. And even if it did air, it would air when no one could watch-at seven in the morning. Oh and in my opinion, it doesn't have to be on TV to be sucessful, nor is it a complete kiddy show. And some companies dub shows and just release DVDs. (i.e. Ultra Maniac or Ouran High School Host Club.)
@maddyredpearlvoice wow lol well they need to find a channle or what ever that wants to put it on tv or something like that so they get money then put out dvds
japanese and italian are my favourites without a doubt !!
airachica 4 days ago
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
TheTutozestar 6 days ago
supeerXD
TheTutozestar 1 week ago
i LOVE all her singing voices!
kittyinatux 2 weeks ago
cool
tutozestar 2 weeks ago
kaito is so cute
MusicalMusa1 2 weeks ago
Itallian dosent eve go with the tune of the rest, it made it its own song...... i like that 0v0
Melodyroxmysox2 4 weeks ago
i love italian
ixDanime123 1 month ago
My top 3 :
1.Japanese-The best so no need to comment
2.Italian-WOW where did they find this voice it sounds so Lucia like XD
3.Serbian-i am speechless SO WONDERFUL
the rest were ok...
djoxyYT 1 month ago 2
for me:
1. Japanese= the best one
2.Chinese version was really sweet and made me jealous >~<
3.Korean version sounded wayyyy older O_O
4. Serdian was enchantingly beautiful
5. Hebrew was beautiful and inspiring
6. Spanish sounded REALLY weird no offense
7. I didn't like the portugese one...=_=
8. italian....WTH was that??? but it was a beautiful song ._.
vamprincessjustlikeu 1 month ago
i'll say the JP is still the best. Too bad the english version were not released(it was dubbed). If there was an English version..I believe it would be beautiful as Luci Christian is a great voice actress and singer.
karenxlunaxzakuro 2 months ago
Oh come on!!!!!!! they've dubbed it in so many languages, how hard would it be to do a good english dub for this??? i mean yeah, i like the japanese, but i would kinda like to see what it would be like in english (hopefully not sounding too american.....)
MewMewMe2U 2 months ago
wow this is good
MegaAmethyst13 2 months ago
the italian voice is actually really good... ^ ^
meebandungalways 3 months ago
is it me or does the spanish version sound like her trouth hurts XD
but it's really nice in almost every language. Note almost :p Hebrew just isn't meant of such songs :p I've nothing against the language though
Ouranlover8 3 months ago
1.Japenese~Totally the best
2.Italian~Very good
3.Korean~Perfect
4.Spanish~Not bad
5.Chinese~Wonderful
6.Portuguese~Weirdly Good
7.Hebrew~Horrible
8. Serbian~ Not Horrifically bad
winterbells1 3 months ago in playlist All Mermaid Melodia comparsions
Wow most of these give Lucia an older voice and its soooooo BEAUTIFUL!!!
Pinkiecat101 3 months ago
original japanese dub is best to dub in any other language is shame
gnak2 4 months ago
omfg the hebrew dub has a beautiful voice :D
kyoxkagura808 4 months ago
the dolphin!! so cuute x3
kyoxkagura808 4 months ago
i only fully understood the korean version
105diva 4 months ago
I understand the Italian version and a bit of Spanish version
Vivianadove 4 months ago
whats weird is that i got from watching naruto vids to here 0.o
narutokun1090 5 months ago
the chinese sounds like japanese luchia singing in chinese ^_^
prettykittygal 5 months ago
i like the japanbese the the manderain and i liked how the italiaan was different
psikumatora11 5 months ago
defiantly italian :D
stellalunastardust 6 months ago
i <3 the japanese and korean but the chinese is ok.
WhiteDoveWing 6 months ago
Why dosen't Rina get to sing this to Masahiro. :( IT'S NOT FAIR!!!!!!!!!!
TheAmazingSuki 6 months ago
I love the spanish version ♥
Mermaidmelodydubs 6 months ago
japanese and italian are the best!!!!!
DanaiChan 6 months ago
@DanaiChan and serbian
SoulDrainer2106 4 months ago
I wonder why Italian has their own beat while the other songs have the same music and beat I like japanese and Italian the best because of the singers and hippos voice
119438hm 6 months ago
Italian Hippo sounds so funny xD
DixyHipo 7 months ago
The Italian and the Japanese are the best *___*
LadyShinigami96 7 months ago
the italian verisons r always good, but the voice doesnt fit the character, cuz hanon and luchia hav "cuter" pitched voices
kawaiiluna99 8 months ago
@Kamikity96
Don't worry about it. She(or some hacker posing as her), replied to a bunch of commenters here saying that. I removed all of her comments and blocked her.
HikaYagami 10 months ago
luciaxkaito永遠に:) i speak english xD
BessAdventureBear98 10 months ago
the japanese and italian were the best
princessbloom15 11 months ago
Serbian and Italian have the best songs...all songs are beatifull... <3 :)))))
Alexandrica98 11 months ago
Italian was very original and really good =D Do you know if theres a full version?
xChiyukix 1 year ago
the italian one is really nice <3 but it wasnt the same melody, but it was still good :3
S2marlenexS2 1 year ago
i loved the song! oh my god ^^ but seeing the guy staring like that... xD
ryemae1316 1 year ago
I want to do a fandub of this in English. But don't worry, it won't be a crappy 4Kids or Dic dub with crappy/unoriginal lyrics. I'll try to base it on the original translations of the Jap version.
3cheers4Ger 1 year ago
The opening song was haunting and so beautiful on piano
greenq618 1 year ago
the italian version was good but, somehow it doesnt sound like the luchia i know...it sounds like a totally different person. i love the japanese version the most
jluvsdogs126 1 year ago
I really wish I could understand what they're saying
greenq618 1 year ago
I like the Italian song better. Do you have the lyrics and the translation anywhere, or know where to find it?
shikamarusgirl17 1 year ago
Okay, so my other comment came off kind of rude. It's been bothering me for a while. :/
Basically, my favorites were Serbian, Italian, Hebrew, and Portuguese. And still, I love your videos Hika Yagami!
MissLoveTantei91 1 year ago
Italian is arguably the most admirable
greenq618 1 year ago
What episode was this from?
greenq618 1 year ago
The chinese was absolutely gorgeous and sweet.
Not a big fan of the Korean
Spanish was ok but not great
Didnt like the portugese
hebrew was pretty
Serbian was gorgeous
LOVE LOVE LOVE the Italian. I like that it evan changes the tune to suit it better.
Overall my fave was the Chinese
SakuraXxXIchigo 1 year ago
I ADORE the Italian dub. I may even like it more than the Japanese. But Dolce Melodia really does not fit there.
mewcherry1996 1 year ago
I like the Italian one......
Webkinzpeson101 1 year ago
everyone has been hating on the italion one but i think thats actually the best(behind japanese of course) she has a pretty voice and they were brave enough to change the song which makes them unique:)
jackiekay123 1 year ago
@jackiekay123 I love the songs in the Italian dub
RyokoUeda 1 year ago
@RyokoUeda :)
jackiekay123 1 year ago
usally i looooveee the italian dubs of japanese animes (just look at the tokyo mew mew dubs - they are amazing) but i don' like that they canged luchias song in this :/
I looooveeee the italian song, but it'snot the same song and i find that annoying :/ so i guess that the japanese one is my favorite ^^
airachica 1 year ago
the chinese ones pretty good.. :)
vizard9800 1 year ago
Whats wrong with Portagese (forgive my spelling)? I think it sounds very nice~
And omg, Italian is waaaay better than the Japanese~
Invaderkibachan2 1 year ago
I think that the Japanese, Korean, and Serbian dubs where really good, and the Italian dub just didn't fit the melody of the song at all.
renakawaiichan 1 year ago 6
@renakawaiichan
The Italian dub wasn't trying to. The song was totally changed along with the other songs as well.
HikaYagami 1 year ago 5
Lol , Japanese , in my opinion , is the only one that fits . ;D
Junies489 1 year ago
Ooh I love Mermaid Melody's manga, I can only imagine what all the anime is like. Mmm... I gotta say Japanese is the best one...
MoonlightKitty3 1 year ago
Lucia is the name of my mother ^^
SugarofChocolate 1 year ago
be better with subs to tell us what she is saying ;)
emo102492 1 year ago
@emo102492
I know but since I don't really know anyone who's willing to translate at the moment, I had to put them up without the subs. I'll put subtitles on this video through annotations whenever someone decides to send me a translation.
HikaYagami 1 year ago
i think hippo's serbian voice fits him very well
futurezoovet 1 year ago
I have to say, I am impressed with Japanese, Korean, Mandarin, Italian, and Hebrew in this comparasion. Wow, Serbian actually did awesome here. Portuguese and Spanish? No comment. >_>;;;;;
garfieldturtle 1 year ago 11
japanese beats ALL XDDD
ChibiCatinc 1 year ago
1. italian=WOW O.O on a scale of 1 to 15 i say 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000
2. Serdian= the same as hebrew
3. hebrew = beautiful
4. chinese sounded so cute and pretty
5. Korean sounded like luchia was older than she should be but still pretty ^-^
6. spainsh. . . . i have no comment (note it was OK)
7. same with portugese (that just sounded really werid)
NOTE:) Ive already seen this anime in the japanese so it was cool hearing luchia in all the different subs
katanng13 1 year ago 38
@katanng13 I agree so much! Im portuguse and i have to say i hate mermaid melody in portuguese xD
NokinhaNoka 8 months ago
Chinese version is adorable!!
zomg The Korean, Serbian, and Hebrew versions were simply beautiful. Do you have the mp3s for those languages??
Italian gave me goosebumps!!
neofeliss 1 year ago
the Japanese has to much "ohuh" on the boy. it sounds like he is being raped or something LOL srry
Winxhoney 1 year ago 2
I had no idea there were so many dubs of Mermaid Melody. I hope you do more comparison videos of this show, I'd love to see more!
Mattimati0n 1 year ago 3
I think that the Chinese version is the cutest and the Korean version is the prettiest.
EpicFaerietale 1 year ago 2
Where did you get the music that plays in the very beginning?
EpicFaerietale 1 year ago
Where is the english one?
mihane100 1 year ago
@mihane100 Theres not one. One company TRIED to make one but it failed and never came on.
mewlemonwoof 1 year ago
The sad thing is that I don't really like her Japanese voice. -.-
Oh and HOLY CRAP SOMETHING NOT RELATED TO TMM.
MarsRepepsi 1 year ago
@MarsRepepsi That's not very polite :P >.<
maddyredpearlvoice 1 year ago
@maddyredpearlvoice
But she's just not that good in the original! >:I
MarsRepepsi 1 year ago 2
i wish they would make this show in english>.<
XanimekingdomX 1 year ago
@XanimekingdomX You are SO right! I heard some company made it, but their refuseing to broacsat it. Something about money I think...
maddyredpearlvoice 1 year ago
@maddyredpearlvoice
ADV had the rights to it but since it's a kids show, it had to be on TV in order for it to be successful. Unfortunately, no TV channel wanted it since it was a girl show. The Japanese currently has it but since ADV is no more, no one's sure what's going to happen with their dub of the show.
HikaYagami 1 year ago
@HikaYagami: "no TV channel wanted it since it's a girl show." that is SO true! I hate how America can't market girls' anime well or any girl show for that matter, unless it's some Disney-fied junk. And even if it did air, it would air when no one could watch-at seven in the morning. Oh and in my opinion, it doesn't have to be on TV to be sucessful, nor is it a complete kiddy show. And some companies dub shows and just release DVDs. (i.e. Ultra Maniac or Ouran High School Host Club.)
DropsOfIndigo 1 year ago
@HikaYagami Maybe they'll sell it??
maddyredpearlvoice 1 year ago
@maddyredpearlvoice
The problem is that kids anime needs a TV deal. I haven't seen one children's anime that wasn't on TV before a DVD release was made.
HikaYagami 1 year ago
@maddyredpearlvoice wow lol well they need to find a channle or what ever that wants to put it on tv or something like that so they get money then put out dvds
XanimekingdomX 1 year ago
My favorite is the Italian one but still really like all of them. the voices were amazing^^
ThePureheart100 1 year ago
@ThePureheart100
I think so too!
mihane100 1 year ago
Serbian is really lovely.
Of course, Italian is the best for me. I prefer Dolce Melodia.
Mandarin was also really nice. I like the Korean voice but the singing wasn't all too great. The singer was off-tune a lot.
Castrophii 1 year ago 3
YAY!
In my opinion I think Korean sounds more better for Rina or Sarah...
As for Italian, they didn't stick with the original rythm, but they totally pulled it off! LOVE IT!
I can't wait to see Hanon, Rina and Sarah comparisons!
fairydreamergirl 1 year ago
I can't fault any of them, the voice actresses all have such beautiful voices. It's hard to pick a favourite.
PotterChild 1 year ago
I loved the Serbian singing! It was awesome! And Italian.
seacat243 1 year ago 2
The Serbian version is beautiful, but my favorite will always be the Italian version :D
TsukiChiChan 1 year ago 3
Woah! It's NOT Tokyo Mew Mew! XD
epikphailbot 1 year ago
if that was me singing, i bet that prince woulda laughed and i would be pretty ashamed xD
taijutsugal 1 year ago
spanish rules the rest makes my want to lol :D
flowerpower138 1 year ago 2
the Korean one had a really nice voice, but it sounded a little old to be Lucia... Had a deeper more mature voice
tigressmelody 1 year ago 2
@tigressmelody I agree i think it sounds more like Rina Noel or Sara
zxzxrock 1 year ago
ughh I'm from Israel and can understand what they are saying and its SOO BAADD
I feel ashamed ):
mewkarny 1 year ago
amazing!!! the dolphin had the same voice actor each time!!! what a hard working voice actor he/she must be!! XDDDDD
LilChikyChan 1 year ago 2
I liked the Japanese one and the chinese/madrin ones best they were the nicest.
It seems like they completely changed the song in the Italian one, also Mikaru doesn't sing in the Italian one (I never understood why they did that,)
xSnowMikux 1 year ago
what is she singing in Italian? It's pretty...
What happened to the English version, is it not dubbed in English yet and if not, when?
spiritkitten 1 year ago
@spiritkitten I am not sure but the song is called Dolce Melodia (Gentle Melody). There is no English version of Mermaid Melody yet.
GothGemma 1 year ago
I love what she is wearing in the scene. She's the prettiest in this scene than she is in any other xxxxxxxxxx
TaintedAnglelWings 1 year ago
ooh, the italian one is different!
socks7890 1 year ago
I like japanese and italian♥
800julie 1 year ago
I Like it!!!
800julie 1 year ago
Do you have the subless transformations?
MewIchigo1234 1 year ago
YOUR SO AWESOME!!!! X)
animelovergirlwolf 1 year ago
The serbin and Italian girls who sing for Luchia have beautiful voices.
oppositeproduct 1 year ago 15
@oppositeproduct Very good comment =)
I totally agree =D
3rdChocolAnime 1 year ago
@oppositeproduct i liked all of them except for cantoncese, herbrew and the european portuguese. the portuguese was BAAAAAAD
taijutsugal 1 year ago
nice, i think Japanese was the best though
ablair24 1 year ago 2
:D love mermaid melody~ thank you so much xD now i can make fun of her in 8 diff languages :D ahhaa (never was a luchia fan)
mermaidmelody7896312 1 year ago