this remix is made up bouncy baselines , distorted thom yorke voice ....how caan we classify it as minimal :S i would go for PURE ELECTORNICA...neither house nor electronic koZ it got a DANCE beat n god like bass...Ps try it with some LSD :D
"This is really weird but in a good way. Sounds like something radiohead might actually produce unlike most of these other remixes that just sound waaaaay to technoish."
Yes, this is correct. James Holden chooses very carefully the tracks that he remixes. And he is still a genius "king of the pixies" even though his last CD was garbage, I still love his style.
This is really weird but in a good way. Sounds like something radiohead might actually produce unlike most of these other remixes that just sound waaaaay to technoish.
i think to be one the best holden's fan but i cannot appreciate this work.i love radiohead too and the original reckoner is fucking awesome but...i don't like this one.
Wow I can't believe how many people dislike this song! I hear it live march 20th it was amazing! First time I heard this song was the James zabiela remix personally I think both of them are good =] good stuff to listen to!
Favorite band... Favorite song... This song fits the electro-house genre Song. Song sounds very messy. I don't know if he's trying to make a dark song but its just sounds lifeless. Sounds like something I would produce.
The reason it is such a terrible mix is because you can't remix radiohead songs, their songs are pure and are not meant for remixing in my opinion, if thom yorke thought it would be better remixed he would of changed it to something more suitable.
@Rogerlesboules, JH's trance from what I've heard just sounds like his minimal stuff but with a faster BPM, which I don't mind at all, prog minimal house suits him better though.
@lebannerfan65, erm.. I'm pretty sure his remix of Breathe on me is minimal, as are a lot of the tracks on The Idiots are Winning, I don't know what your talking about.
@lebannerfan65, could Holden's music be called Tech House or Deep House? It seems as if a mix between Tech and Deep would be the most fitting genre that describes Holden's music, but in reality it's honestly just his own thing.
@MarkeliusMusicCAN No, I don't think so. His really old stuff is Prog Trance and Prog House, but then he went into his own little blend of house and techno and now electronic krautrock. From the idiots are winning on and the remixes he did leading upto that EP, he has been completely his own style. Genres don't fit him anymore :)
@Rogerlesboules Is that why I havent heard from him in years? IMO This is neither a good james holden track or a good remix of radiohead. If this representative of his current work, i'd suggest he switch back to trance. I say this even though i do follow trance anymore (but at least all his early stuff was good)
Mmmm okay... I like both, Radiohead and Holden but this didn't seem to work very well, I'd prefer the tune without Thom's voice sampler. Anyway it was worth to listen, thanks for posting.
nice synth
gatani33 20 hours ago
**Insert genre related opinion here**
cianmurphy52 2 weeks ago
Caribou"Bowls"のリミックスもそうだけど、似ても似つかない代物にしておきながら、なお「この曲はBowls」「この曲はReckoner」と言い切れる離れ業の持ち主だと思う。素晴らしすぎ。
maplespica 3 months ago
nice man, check my hip hop remix of reckoner it's on my page! i'll post a vid response to this too
JamesRussellMusic 3 months ago
its hard to remix the best band in the world but this is AMAZING
pushthetempo2 5 months ago
The bassline may well have influenced the recent track "Feral".
thetoy3 5 months ago
This is far the best radiohead remix that i ever heard, give me chills and shocks at the same time, I'm so addicted to this.
MusicianSmile 6 months ago
This one is really messing up my mind, but I like it!
rebugz 6 months ago
Comment removed
galmann 6 months ago
this remix is made up bouncy baselines , distorted thom yorke voice ....how caan we classify it as minimal :S i would go for PURE ELECTORNICA...neither house nor electronic koZ it got a DANCE beat n god like bass...Ps try it with some LSD :D
Neel45 7 months ago
@Neel45 house music is all about dancing
jailbreakir 5 months ago
no, this is not my thing. Very apart from the original....
miguel117 8 months ago
@miguel117 ..thats the sense of doing a remix...
DubsMood 7 months ago
@DubsMood no, it is not. Well, it depends on too many things. But, hell, whatever....
miguel117 7 months ago
james holden is the fukin man
lamardla 8 months ago
MALA LA WEA
thescientist00 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hey guys, check out my mashup/remix of Reckoner and The Eraser =)
nightspringmusic 1 year ago
i'm sure this would sound good to me too if i took dmt or ketamine..... please email me some
dallas2denton 1 year ago 6
i had a couple of really dope tracks from holden but these were really old progressive trance tracks. this is a bad remix.
MSNGR415 1 year ago
@MSNGR415 this is trance???? huh.... i never knew i liked trance
gomachols 1 year ago
@gomachols No this is electronica.
Norskah 1 year ago
@gomachols lol
miguel117 8 months ago
scary. very dope!
lightmode 1 year ago
I really like this, Nosaj Thing also does a great remix.
st9mm 1 year ago
james holden remixed reckoner under DMT effects!
jeli780 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"This is really weird but in a good way. Sounds like something radiohead might actually produce unlike most of these other remixes that just sound waaaaay to technoish."
Yes, this is correct. James Holden chooses very carefully the tracks that he remixes. And he is still a genius "king of the pixies" even though his last CD was garbage, I still love his style.
mrscottybizzer 1 year ago
too much noise
zipaovo13 1 year ago
wow! this is really bad
blzakk 1 year ago
This is really weird but in a good way. Sounds like something radiohead might actually produce unlike most of these other remixes that just sound waaaaay to technoish.
Dave12815 1 year ago 4
i love radiohead and i love techno music too...so i love this:P
praterzen 1 year ago
Definitely sounds like Holden experimental but Zabiela's remix is sitting as the current favourite of Reckoner.
anebanane83 1 year ago
@anebanane83 I have to say that the Henry Saiz's verson rests as my personal favorite
ggaladzhyan03 1 year ago
There was an interview were he described how he made this track.
When you hear him talk about it, you realise how genius this actually is.
Zombiefied68 1 year ago
i think to be one the best holden's fan but i cannot appreciate this work.i love radiohead too and the original reckoner is fucking awesome but...i don't like this one.
batebordisov 1 year ago
Wow I can't believe how many people dislike this song! I hear it live march 20th it was amazing! First time I heard this song was the James zabiela remix personally I think both of them are good =] good stuff to listen to!
jgmanutd00 1 year ago
Favorite band... Favorite song... This song fits the electro-house genre Song. Song sounds very messy. I don't know if he's trying to make a dark song but its just sounds lifeless. Sounds like something I would produce.
yellowman88 1 year ago
@yellowman88 wtf man r u saying? electro house? the kind of stuff u would produce, man stfu
parkour1001 1 year ago
@parkour1001
wtf is your problem... its called an opinion
yellowman88 1 year ago
messed it up
hemlt23 1 year ago
How could anyone not find this insane??
perricida 1 year ago 2
The reason it is such a terrible mix is because you can't remix radiohead songs, their songs are pure and are not meant for remixing in my opinion, if thom yorke thought it would be better remixed he would of changed it to something more suitable.
Notsosimplebrian 1 year ago
@Notsosimplebrian Thom Yorke started a competition for Reckoner to be remixed, so therefor: You are wrong :)
172superman172 1 year ago
@Notsosimplebrian Check out Reckoner Above & Beyond Remix. That worked
paulalex17 1 year ago
Comment removed
laeccc 1 year ago
ich liebe das original!radiohead is einfach genial und der rmx is klasse!!! hat der james aber fein gemacht...
xxSelle77xx 1 year ago
This is really great.
For those who don't like this remix, just keep in mind that James Holden is not doing trance anymore, wich is a good thing.
Rogerlesboules 2 years ago 24
@Rogerlesboules when was he doing trance?
knate68 1 year ago
@knate68
in his early career when he was on silver planet! ( with tracks like horizon )
Rogerlesboules 1 year ago
@Rogerlesboules, JH's trance from what I've heard just sounds like his minimal stuff but with a faster BPM, which I don't mind at all, prog minimal house suits him better though.
MarkeliusMusicCAN 9 months ago
@MarkeliusMusicCAN How exactly can you call James Holden minimal? You obviously know NOTHING. Bah.
lebannerfan65 5 months ago
@lebannerfan65, erm.. I'm pretty sure his remix of Breathe on me is minimal, as are a lot of the tracks on The Idiots are Winning, I don't know what your talking about.
MarkeliusMusicCAN 5 months ago
@MarkeliusMusicCAN If anything his music is maximalistic. 'Simple' but definitely not minimal...
lebannerfan65 2 months ago
@lebannerfan65, could Holden's music be called Tech House or Deep House? It seems as if a mix between Tech and Deep would be the most fitting genre that describes Holden's music, but in reality it's honestly just his own thing.
MarkeliusMusicCAN 2 months ago
@MarkeliusMusicCAN No, I don't think so. His really old stuff is Prog Trance and Prog House, but then he went into his own little blend of house and techno and now electronic krautrock. From the idiots are winning on and the remixes he did leading upto that EP, he has been completely his own style. Genres don't fit him anymore :)
lebannerfan65 2 months ago
@Rogerlesboules Is that why I havent heard from him in years? IMO This is neither a good james holden track or a good remix of radiohead. If this representative of his current work, i'd suggest he switch back to trance. I say this even though i do follow trance anymore (but at least all his early stuff was good)
moshie61 2 months ago
@moshie61 that was supposed to be "Don't follow trance" :P
moshie61 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks. listen to the twelves remix
mclepracaun 2 years ago
listen to it twice or thrice
radioalex1 2 years ago
It's an acquired taste!
perricida 2 years ago
One of holdens worst remixes, It's really ploddy and soulless with no groove to the bassline as you usually can expect from holden. 4/10
09fowler09 2 years ago
PS: you have to listen the entire mix: James Holden - 4 years of full spectrum
blendmode 2 years ago
i like them both: the original and this remix
blendmode 2 years ago
just completely fucked up the original.. dont rate it at all..
bigtravisoner 2 years ago
I love James Holden and all, but this remix is terrible!
ShaunyP26 2 years ago
great stuff. best version of this is paul keeley's though
alexanderhjerten 2 years ago
amazing!!!
Fred Hush*
fredhush 2 years ago
Base is important ...
nabuhodenozor1 2 years ago
so,so twisted. genius
reddy1984 2 years ago 16
love holden, but what he did with voice? sounds awful.
Aloizza 2 years ago
temazooooo q bonitooo!!!!
chiky702 2 years ago
personally the Rune RK Remodoodle remix is smoother and better, but this is good
opeybear 2 years ago
i don't like it as remix but the original single is amazing.
arminvanbuurendbest 2 years ago 2
i'm down
SJamesGray 3 years ago
so great
Rogerlesboules 3 years ago 2
stark
dirup3 3 years ago 2
Pissing in an ocean of win. D:
AnotherRandomGeek 3 years ago
amazing.
DannyTen985 3 years ago
this is music
zlatanorcam 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
YOU'RE DOING IT WRONG.
jchinwamo 3 years ago
where can i find this one ? pls help me if you can ...
tahchish 3 years ago
I agree, this is liking mixing maple cyruppe with steak sauce..
reinierdepeinier 3 years ago 3
Mmmm okay... I like both, Radiohead and Holden but this didn't seem to work very well, I'd prefer the tune without Thom's voice sampler. Anyway it was worth to listen, thanks for posting.
audiolandscape 3 years ago 2