Added: 4 years ago
From: maulwurfchen
Views: 123,108
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (399)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I saw her doing this in person in Dresden. Was the weirdest set/costume design I'd ever seen!! But she was great then and great now!

  • Demonic singing pencil? ^ ^

  • I think the tempo is too quick. In that some of the diction clarification is lost. Also, some of the high Fs are less clear. Those may also have to do with tempo.

  • 2:11 she scares the sh1t out of meh ^^

  • Comment removed

  • @fscii hahahaha really

  • "The Queen of the Coneheads" Aria

  • Golliwogg APPROVES of this rendition, and he knows what it's like to have difficult hair, too.

  • ok the lady sings very good, but the costume sucks

  • Victoria Juyce sings really well... but her look... she's too scary. Don't like this make-up. Looking like zombie ( soory if someone thing that this comment is rude)

  • an alle, die der deutschen Sprache Herr sind:

    schaut mal ins Mozartforum(dot)com in den thread "Mozarts Death Mask?"

    da werdet ihr einzigartige (teilweise bis heute verschwiegene) Quellen und Dokumente einsehen können, welche einen anderen Grund für Mozarts frühes Ableben vermuten lassen als heute so gängig geglaubt wird (siehe Wikipedia die Hauptquelle der falschen und verzerrten Geschichtsschreibung, welche so viele heute aus "Faulheit" oder welchen Gründen auch immer blindlings übernehmen)

  • Uhm, what?

  • This seems to be the missing love child of Alice in Wonderland, The video "Stay" by Shakespeare's Sister, and The Opera Singer from 5th Element. All together awesome as shit :)

  • This is completely, totally and utterly AWESOME! Don't read those stupid comments by people who have never seen an opera in its full context and base their opinions on YouTube snippets! The diction is impeccable, the intonation is to be envied by any coloratura on the planet. I love the bit when she leaves and comes back ("and another thing!"). As for the production, unless someone has seen it from start to finish, they have no right to judge. Haters back off!! Greetings from a fellow Queen! CG

  • The costume design is totally unacceptable!

  • @0001848 AHAHAHAHAHAHA that was funny

  • Jesus... what they´ve done with this lady??

    She was supposed to be singing it to her daughter, wouldn´t she?

    But her voice is amazing...

  • The only thing worse than her acting is her German diction.

  • Everyone's a critic. If only those critics were constructive instead of a bunch of smart-ass brats

  • totally awesome.

  • Great perfomance for such a young girl but the acting could not be worse! XD

  • Is it me or does Ms. Joyce rush through the F-major arpeggio?

    

  • @owemunar You would too if you had to sing that high...

  • what the hell does rape face mean!!

  • 2:11 Rape face.... :S

  • A real Diva would have told the hairstylist to go to hell! im not having that hair style and tainting the Queen of the Night name! I would have >:)

  • We found Marge Simpson again.

  • In the first few seconds she looked like Natalie Portman from Black Swan.

  • She sings beautiful, but acts bad.

  • This is worst than the Broccoli dress when Diana Damrau was in it a few years ago.

  • A cone-head Queen of the Night?

  • If you scroll down and just listen its not bad, if you watch you can't help but laugh.

  • I love how she leaves and then comes back!! LOL! "And another thing young lady!!"

    haha!! Nice voice........... just too much to laugh at.......

  • How do you dress the Queen of the Night? Put a moon on her head, and make her look like a blind nun on acid dressed her.

  • @MercifulMe How do you succeed in focusing on the visual only, in a presentation of the voice?

  • bah.... pues me parece una puesta en escena original.... a mi me gusta mucho

  • I thought they did a very terrible job conceptualizing. I thought for once that Queen of the Night was supposed to be grandiose? Or is this a poor man's version?

  • I thought they did a very terrible job conceptualizing. I thought for once that Queen of the Night was supposed to be grandiose?

  • Here's my theory: they had an awesome costume designed, but an hour before the curtain rose a cat peed on it, and all they could find was a kindergarten A&C box. And then they called Marilyn Manson in to do the makeup.

  • Custom: FaiL!

  • Singing: A. Hair: A+. Costume: F.

  • the styling is crap but she sings the way it should be sung (IMHO)

  • I can't decide whether I'm more disturbed by the hand choreography, or the platform shoes...

  • ha una voce stupenda e mi piacciono i suoi capelli la sua luna in fronte e le sue unghie.. ma non il costume!!

  • ha una voce stupenda e mi piacciono i suoi capelli la sua luna in fronte e le sue unghie.. ma non il costume!!

  • i love her voice and her hair is different I like it to

  • Pause at 00:30. METAAAALL!!!

  • Voice is beautiful but costume and acting is very poor!

  • No es la mejor interpretación, pero que onda con ese peinado de cono

  • Mozart is a BASTARD for writing a song as hard as this! But he was such a musical genius!

  • sorry but the costume = garbage.

  • So, how does a pencil have a clown as a daughter?

  • I agree... the costume designer... what were you thinking....

  • Her singing is... meh... I hate that vibrato. It's like she's using to cover up flaws...

  • Голос хороший, а костюм убил.........

    Прическа в виде инструмента, которым в асфальте долбят)))) Вот уж извращаются как могут. Так что это лучше слушать, а не смотреть. ИМХО.

    (Простите, что не по-английски, не владею языком :Ь)

  • FAbulous singing, but oh GODS, that costume! Looks like something from a 70s B-sci fi tv show. :( Still, close your eyes, and the music is awesome!

  • the only good thing here was her voice

  • Voice: 9.5/10

    Costume: 1/10

    Staging: 0/10

    Congratulations, Ms. Joyce. You sang beautifully and did the best you could with a ridiculous costume and staging.

  • очень красивый голос

    !!!1БРАВО

    

  • i love this version, but the costume.....eeeewwww :/ x

  • Look! It's Queen Amidala before her illustrious career in politics.

  • A bit less colorful had also reached and look after her nails OMG they like Zombie fingers !! But she still have a beautiful voice !! =]

  • I actually think the costumes and set are awesome! Look at Pamina's makeup, they're clearly trying to go for a creepy, german expressionist look. She reminds me of Cesare from the Cabinet of Dr. Caligari. I really like these more artsy interpretations, it adds a whole other level

  • She really does look like a singing pencil!!! but her coloratura is wonderful!

  • I love the hair.

  • I think she doesn't understand the text. Even with that dress she could at least try to act properly with more than just two face expressions and not just stand there like a bi-color pencil weaving with its...its hands?

  • too vanguardistic for me

  • I feel like I just want to grab that conehead and choke it like Homer Simpson.

  • I feel so bad right now. I couldn't stop laughing the whole video not because of her voice, she's indeed fantastic, but because of the outfit. It's sooo terrible.

  • Well... she sings the hell out of the aria, and her acting is on point too (except I'm not getting the hands.) But, this clip should be used as an educational tool highlighting how an otherwise excellent performance can be ruined by terrible costuming and/or set design.

  • A beautiful song ruined by an ugly outfit.

  • amazing voice, but yeah... the direction and costume AWFUL! not her fault tho...

  • without commenting on the horrid costuming/makeup/directing... very nice voice! clean and crisp, and the triplet section was handled with grace. well done!

  • that costume reminds me of the pantomime or circus

  • Didn't know Harley Quinn could sing...

  • Excellent voice but costumes? Hey, is a queen!! not a clown!! O_O

  • I really really like her voice and the way she sings this aria. But the costume is kind of strange although I like her hairstyle. The gesture however is a complete disaster.

  • It's said that a true artist must suffer for their art. Poor Victoria is suffering through the director and the costume designer. Strike a pose!  Strike it again! Pretend that you're a bad swimmer! Run out the doors, then run back in like you forgot to say something. This poor girl deserved more than the director could produce.

  • good voice, but such a creepy costume  o.O ahaha a pencil?? ahahaha totally agree

  • very gaga...

  • I love her voice, but it looks like the opera version of an alien movie.

  • Sweet mother of God who came up with the idea to that costume and make-up? And the coriography? What´s up with that hand-thing she does?

    Who would do such a horrible, horrible, horrible thing?

    The vocal performance is really good thou, Victoria has a lovely voice.

  • what type of hair is that

  • @ladyizzybelle It's Little My from Mumin.... :D

  • Young and fantastic. Wonderful singing. There is something about the detachment of her facial expression that makes this queen scary, scarier than if she had tried to act it out.

  • Que cómico vestuario! es cierto lo que dicen de que parece un lapiz! y luego pamina con su ropita de niña! jajajajaja

    Muy buen video para reir un poco...canta bien pero si que tuvieron un exceso de creatividad con el vestuario!

    salU2!

  • Good voice, appalling costume.

  • @DazFromOz

    In the head, 5 times...

  • It is truely cruel to make Victoria Joyce to go out in front of hundreds of people and make her sing wearing that outfit.

    Here's an idea: get the costume designer, dress him up like a demonic singing pencil and see how HE likes it.

  • She sounds fabulous AND she kept a straight face. I'm officially impressed. Good Lord

  • Is that the Queen of the Night? Looks more like Pagliacci?

  • If the hair hadn't been so big, it would have been okay.

  • What the heck is with that red arm of hers? Brilliant voice but I think the costume designer was on crack.

  • What's with the hand formation lol so weird

  • LOl what the hell this is the funniest queen of the night I've seen! what's up with the custom and the little hand thing going on... love it.. so funny

  • 00:30 L of?? of Loser?...

  • She actually gets behind tempo durring this rendition. Beautiful on the top notes though.

  • the singing was great... everthing else was CRAP

  • I love her singing but wat's wit the "Boogie Man" pose wit her arms i the air the whole song?

  • Oh look, a singing pencil...

    It's singing most beautifully, but it's still a pencil...

  • you made my day. your comment will make me laugh for the rest of the day.

    and is it just me, or she looks like nina hagen here?

  • @Musicalandmore

    Ok, I'm dying laughing, ahahahaha the singing pencil!

  • @Musicalandmore  Brilliant, nearly burst myself laughing.

  • @Musicalandmore LOL, she truly looks like a pencil:D

  • @Musicalandmore The Queen of the night was not written to be a clown, but apparently the costume designer missed that bit.

  • @Musicalandmore revise your remarks!!!

    Fokus on the voice and the singing..........and comment accordingly

  • @franzgrabe1 I would like to... But the bloody costume keeps distracting me... I said: She sings nice....but IT'S STILL AN F-ING PENCIL!!!!

  • @Musicalandmore hahahahahahahhaahha 

  • I like her tone and quality of singing. I didn't enjoy the battle for tempo. I thought the musicianhship during Mrs. Miklosa's performance was better and stylistically correct.

  • She has an exceptionally good tone throughout her range. Her tone is bright and open and clear. Rythmically precise.

    Homemade recordings can fool you.

    German pronunciation is excellent.

  • Is it just me, or at around 00:56, the camera is kinda... Pulsing with her singing? It's pretty scary. XDD

    Amazing though, but the costume is... wtf. Oh, but I love the hands. XD

  • what the hell is she wearing!and that hair!YUCK!

  • ¿ què sucede en 0:28, lo hace en grave ??????

  • great voice, but try to use more of the stage and bring out the full character

  • Comment removed

  • La reina super star, buen vestuario!

  • I think she does a great job but the director and costume designer should be SHOT.

  • i second that...

  • I agree. Poor woman. If I were her, I'd be sitting in a jail cell if I had signed to do this production and saw the costume after the fact. The designer would be dead. LOL! (And the director who allowed this!)

  • @DazFromOz Hey, they had some left-overs from Batman the opera, what were they SUPPOSED to do?!

  • @DazFromOz completely agree xD

  • @DazFromOz You let me know when and i carry the ammo LOL!!!! ^_^

  • i agree.... terrible outfit. lovely voice!

  • @DazFromOz

    twice

  • @DazFromOz I couldn't agree with you more.

  • Is she English or Irish?

  • Beautiful voice. A few of the very high notes could be better but I loved this performance. It is full of color, beauty and life.

  • her voice is brilliant!

    the costume makes her looks like a clown

  • very fabulous!!

    except those arpeggios.... :(

  • fantastic!

  • I think she raises her arms to assit the breath is the highest passages.

  • No, she raises them because the stupid director told her to do so. So many of the goofballs ruin what otherwise could be good productions with their idiotic "concepts"!

  • I agree with comments, what a great voice ! But what a horrible costume !

  • i love that costume!especially the cone hair do!

  • Wenn sie die Intonation verbessert, ist sie eine gute Königin. Die Töne sind in der Tiefe und Mittellage leider sehr oft etwas zu tief. Die ganz hohen stimmen. Es wirkt so, als ob sich die Sängerin nicht auf die Orchesterstimmung einstellen kann.

  • great voice, dead behind the eyes like khloe kardashian. pity.

  • i thought the whole thing was awesome. a truly demented queen makes for a good flute.

  • AMAZING voice-- terrible costume XD I suppose this might be considered "experimental"? Also-- she's kinda dead behind the eyes don't you think? She has this immense expressiveness in her voice and it just does not translate into her body or face. Do you think that was her or her director, I wonder?

  • Fuck off...again! What a load o shit! Not in a nasty way...the singer is great... but WHF?

  • Fantastic voice...really something spectacular.

    How come Queen of the Night costumes are always so absolutely hideous?

  • Fuck off! What is this, she has a great voice, shoot the producer/director!..... shamefullllllll

  • Great voice, but the costume... :S

  • Gosh... what a horrid costume. She has great potential. Such a beautiful voice now. Think what maturity will give her performance

  • she doesnt look young there

  • scaaaaaaary!!!!!!

  • She needs acting classes, both facial and body expressions. Like now!

  • Her voice sounds great but she could've put more into the performance =/ It looks like she's just going through the motions

  • love her fingnails quite good interpretation

  • Not a bad performance. But that hairdo makes her look like one of the Coneheads.

  • Or a bit like Marge Simpson, maybe?

  • C'est très bien si on ferme les yeux.

  • this woman here rushes because the high notes might be uncomfortable for her but it sounds good and the voice is great so dont be bighead douchebags all-together!!

  • I am a classical music student and opera singer. This woman sings the aria far better then many others on youtube. but I am not as bothered from the high notes as from the coloratura-notes which are shortly before. nobody does them correct as written in the notes. Singers start them always to late and change it to a tremolo instead of singing note by note. Even Damrau does it correctly only at every 3rd try.

  • shes totally does rush the high notes

  • is it only me who think that she rushes the high notes???

  • Nope, I think so too.

  • No, you're right

  • molto brava

  • i think vocally this is a great performance...as some others have said however the costume and acting are not upto the standard of the performers vocal. It seems as though at some points she doesnt know what the text means IMHO

  • Mr. Sandman, bring me a night-mare.... the costume is horrible... she really looks like a sandman from hell...

  • I liked that costume

  • Comment removed

  • voice: good

    costume: aweful

    hand motions: priceless

  • Must have been some modern interpretation..

  • Voice : Good

    Act : Embarrassing

  • Her voice is great, but unfortunately her hands ,acting and costume are awful !!!

  • haha the voice is nice but i feel like her blocking with her hands has more to do with the placement inside her head for the tone than it has to do with the words.

  • diana damrau is "IS THE QUEEN OF THE NIGHT" but this girl is ok..

  • I've heard over 25 executions of this aria.

    Natalie Dessay excels in acting, but her costume on the youtube clip wasn't threatening. Diana Damrau is the

    ultimate performer of this aria. Her acting is non-pareil. Utter praise to the costumer and director. Diana was REALLY scary. Others never dastardly enough. It's hard to believe she's blonde.

    If you watch Diana Damrau's youtube of

    Caro Nome her acting is PERFECT.

    Damrau as Gilda is an AUTHENTIC giddy teen in love.

  • I watched the film of that Diana Damrau and she's simply horrible !!! Maybe the colorful scenario and the clothes make people find Diana Damrau good in that film but sincerely.... horrible.

    And the costume of Victoria Joyce is nice.

  • If I were Pamina I'd be more afraid of that costume than of what she is saying! This is a mix of Edward Scissorhands and the Coneheads! And her acting is not very good either...

    But the voice is very good! If you just listen to her singing and forget the rest you will get a very nice rendition of this masterpiece!

  • voice is  too nice ^^ but costume :S .....

  • Absolutely amazing voice!!

    Horrible acting! 8(

  • Totally agreed. She starts out looking like she's directing air traffic robot style to a becoming a mime....Really not sure about the costume...I would expect that of an anime or Disney character, but not for opera. O.O I do love her voice though.

  • qanthaa mOii biien sii alcanzaa tonos ii toodo peroo qe Ondaa con esos colores las uñootass ii el peiinadoo ? ?

  • Her acting is terrible and she needs to get some rhythm so she can stay with the music...the costume makes me laugh.

  • me encantó *-*

  • Beutiful tone, great delivery, needs to work on the posing a bit.

    BUT~ bad,bad, very bad costume..... worse than the english national opera's... and that was terrible.... XD

  • XD I saw her and I was like "wtf is she wearing?!?!?" Was this a professional show? If so, they wasted their budget on something other than costumes.