Amy Macdonald - 22 - Sweet Caroline (Live on ITV's Guilty Pleasures 09-02-2008).avi

[magictrickem]

Neil's songs are very safe in her talented hands. Have you heard her sing Shiloh? Makes the hairs on the back of my head stand up.

[Boatman607]

Love it.. When are you coming to Ireland ??

[Synchronicety]

Could Your majesty bring Amy MacDonald and Mark Knopfler bring together - lovely voice and a good guitar. Her guitar is sometimes a bit out of tune but she sings very nice.

[matthewhewitson80]

tremendous!

[MixedNutsMs]

Grandma Mary

[championsofeurope5x]

she oozes sex appeal.

[TheACLJ]

This is a cracker! So's she!

[thinkofme14344]

first time i watched & heard this version.. it pretty good.

[Mciltm]

Daveeeed, you are correct. I LOVE Amy Macdonald, but this tune sucks. But, I do welcome her to Fenway Park anytime to sing this silly song between the top and bottom of the 8th inning. Actually, let me rephrase that....screw the Sox, Amy please come to Boston, stay the summer. If Fenway doesn't appeal to you, my backyard is large enough for a stage and about 22 people...perfect, no?

[BreehMonster]

Amy is the second best version that I heard... The first is Elvis Presley

[daveeeed]

the worst song in history

[2003Casi]

I love the music from Amy.... beautyful women....

[haywoodjblomi]

Got to love it - no one could refudiate that!

[dancigqueen1994]

can anyone tell me the chords she is playing? neil diamond does it different.

[robbie2737]

Exactly,We are all entitled to an opinion.....I just find it a little strange why you would actually take the time to go onto about 5 of her Vids & bash just about everything she does...However you admit you somewhat like her voice....Just does'nt make sense That's all!.....Besides...you're full of crap if u say your a teacher....A real teacher of music or any "Art" would never knock another Artist!..so who's bullcrappin who?

[realdiamondshow]

@robbie2737 you are right ...I do quite like her voice.but she cants sing as well when she tries to play guitar ...she struggles to play well and this is breaking her concentration ....As for not critisizing another artist..thats not true...all forms of art LEARN from being appraised...painters, singers musicians get TOLD by people who have taught them HOW to improve!! As for not being a teacher or performer myself..google Real Diamond show yourself.

[realdiamondshow]

Robb2737 We are all entitled to our opinions....I think she is very over rated...a reasonable singer and a crap guitarist...as a pro for over 25 years and a guitar player and teacher...I am guessing you dont like my opinion because you dont agree with it...I am also guessing I know far more about music than you do!!

[robbie2737]

@realdiamondshow Read comment..I forgot to click "Reply"

[magictrickem]

E' bellisssima! Che voce! Che capacita' d'interpretare le canzone degli altri insieme con le sue. Troppa bella, lei!

[realdiamondshow]

Learn the words!!!....1st chorus....its touching ME...touching you...she sings YOU both times!!!....BOTH TIMES!!!!

[robbie2737]

@realdiamondshow So she messed up some Lyrics...big deal!! no one cares what you have to say!!....Besides,You commented on about 5 of her Vids & have nothing good to say....everything Negative...So I'm now thinking maybe the problem's with you.

[29DJFanch1]

@robbie2737 well said !

[pappy15445]

o yes!!

[leeBwatson]

she's immense in every sense o the word

[Mr46MCGEADY46]

wow wow wow respect from holland 

[scallly64]

Those who like this Neil Diamond cover from Amy....type in: NEIL DIAMOND/ AMY MACDONALD "SHILO"  awesome job by Amy!

[uper0]

A real scottish beauty

[begobep5]

she was so beautiful here..

[Nickdo1]

@begobep5

She IS si beatiful :-)

[xxxmroldiesxxx]

Shes A Hottie!!

[adeeboy]

fantastic