Indian girls singing and playing on the train

[piazzafun]

you can not sing and play under the train?

[gsayanta]

I wish I could help them!

[akkiumre]

Yes these girls are real heroz...but indian goverment cant see this.these little girls are beggers.we should help them.cause they got so much talent but they are begger...i mean simple NO MONEY FOR FOOD ....shame on our indian goverment and thanks to this guy 'sutekh2'who upload this clip........

[jollygursharan]

the real heros of this country ...making a living against odds .

[rounakmindamds]

great ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

[reway7]

the girl really is in tune!! she is real gud. you indians have your channels infested with talent hunt shows. y not help such voices. she sounds like tht jst because she is untrained. a few tips by a pro and she will be good to go

[Ecka0007]

Should get a contract with Sony Music lol!

[debonier07]

her version of song has music so so much better than the original one !!!

[TheGwaen]

nice music!

greets from germany..

[damn437]

dunya banay walay kya tere mann mein samai, thats a complain of these girls i guess,

[bassleerey]

real nice bollywood rendition, the busking musicians always do it better than the pro's.

[jaldimethner]

I love India.

[mrtubeforall]

Beautiful voice with talented music play. May Allah keep them in peace and Happy

within their constraint and difficulties of life.

[jabroify]

Wise people...They're beautiful at soul. It's a shame I am part of a race that is such a disgrace to all nature. Wen they say "white man is devil" they don't mean to offend anybody...They just speak the truth.

[xingfenzhen]

nice, these girls definatly got talent. Hopefully there will be develop them further and have a sucessful career in music.

[utubepredator]

man, indian music is just as nice in studio, on film or in a noisy crowded dirty train, lol

[lsdvine]

fucking paedophile

[utubepredator]

the second song, Dunya bananewale, sounds like a Lata song, the same style anyways.

[SDFCreations]

The song is Duniya bananewale kya tere man me samai, kahe ko duniya banai. It is sung by Mukesh Kumar.

Another thing is, these poor girls are beggin for money, but the stubborn passengers arent opening up. I wonder if the person who made this video actualy gave them something?

[utubepredator]

the person who made the video certainly gave them a bit of immortality, thanks to youtube.

but yeah, hopefully also something real, in recognition.

[sutekh2]

actually some passengers do cough up some cash at the end. Of course, I gave something too.

[Nenie]

that train bus looks crowded

[galaxyyellow]

Yep. Trains in India are crowded!

[RP626466]

Great player and singer Feel sorry about thier hard life NZ

[goodboyla]

talent goes a begging on the streets ....lets raise awareness...so that someday these people will get the recognition they deserve..and neednt have to beg...please forward to as many people as possible

[4yoreyes]

Its both beautiful and sad!

[justaname5]

Next time I go to India, ima make few of these videos along with the names and addresses of these kids, and post'em on YouTube so ppl can send them some dough. lol.........Duniya bananewaale, kya tere man mein samayi?.......Iove you sisters. :)

[MartialArtistWannabe]

Or they'll send them a bomb or a bag full of dog poo.

In other words: bad idea.

[justaname5]

I haven't given up hope on this humanity of ours. I am sure there are bombs being sent in mail to someplace by someone, but I doubt anyone is mindless enough to send a bomb or dog poo to innocent little kids.

[jotibains]

wow...

its nice to listen to :)

[nedjocro]

beautiful...so sweet :-)

[punnu09]

i luv this videooo so muchh she is gr88

[hubris2008]

On peut déplorer qu'une jeune fille comme elle en soit réduite à chanter devant ce type de clientèle pour survivre, mais en Inde, il y a bien pire. Alors, moi, ce qui me frappe, c'est la similarité de la ligne mélodique avec certaines pièces gitanes d'occident.

[gharison]

brilliant!

[hyderabadboy20]

sad!

but its real!

[missnoorbhangu]

VERY GOOD JOIN AMERICAN IDOL

[oppvu]

pyar means "love"

[oppvu]

contrairement à ce qu'il y a écrit, il ne s'agit pas d'un wagon de 3è classe:mais il en a tous les aspects (c'est du politiquement correct;Gandhi critiquait la vétusté des wagons de 3èm : les gouvernements ont trouvé La "solution":changer le numéro sur les wagons!) mais le trajet peut devenir éprouvant sur les longs trajets, on en dort par terre, et c'est par expérience que je dis ça...

[oppvu]

une barde qui a beaucoup de mérite(un harmonium cest lourd)et de talent(pas rétribué à sa juste valeur;quand on voit la famdesarko, ça m'écoeure qu'on ose appeler ce gadget"chanteuse";c'est ça l'Injustice, s'il n'y a pas de loi karmique je préfère me buter! Hê Râm, toi tu sais...)

[yeahmiss]

i look farward that india also become richer like eu contrys and indian government provides social security(through work)to all ,compulsory education and child benifits should come to real despite race and caste.there should be a proper charitys(not religion oriented)to save and help & educate needy children and the corporate sector should take steps to encorage arts from gross level.there should be a proper extra currycular policy and children should be encoraged for their talents.love india

[CrazyJatt88]

does anyone know what song they sang first?

[archi451]

Its from Movie Raaz (first one) Tum agar saamne aa bhi jaya karo

[CrazyJatt88]

if they were in the nyc subway....theyd make mad dough

[Psychowiszy]

God bless them

[vanpat1987]

OMG god bless them !! ... people were cheap ... only 1 gave money in 5 minutes!!..have a big heart yaar !!!

[Tosun88]

hehe n

[alex9nanc]

We are cheap and hard working

[ruwan27]

wow, they sing very well to me.I enjoyed this vey much

[presism]

wndrful. look how she plays multiple notes by using four fingers. telent is nobody's property. jai hind

[balishious82]

damnnnn..hope these girls become singers....and become successful....its a hard world for girls especially indian girls in india....

[balishious82]

thanks to peoples moral beliefs in the developed world...kids are forced to beg instead of finding proper work (thank you for banning children from working) so therefore they r forced to beg...its so disturbing and stupid really...atleast if they work they will get the experience and atleast earn an honest living...even graduates find it hard to find a job nowdays...trust me im a graduate...i wish i was a kid agen so i cud work n never mind the bloody education...

[rajkiran1982]

Though I dont blindly criticise the developed world, I agree with you in this context. Policies are made without foreseeing the future. Banning child labor is good becoz it gives power in the hands of ppl who want to stop it. However, that ban should have been followed up with setting up agencies checking child labor and providing food and amenities to those children

[balishious82]

i wasnt blindly critising the developed world...i was just stating the mere facts of life. But hey its u good u agreed cuz i agree with u too. Its a shame that kids still have to beg but if child labour is banned then they shud be given the right kind of help to come up in life.

[MikeyLalo]

the second one is duniya banaane waale from teesri kasam (mukesh)

[andi84chen]

Hey Sutekh,

there was something going wrong with the video of the two girls in the train. I loved the song and maybe you could try to load it up again. Hopefully I can hear them playing once more.

[shortdevil2]

this is so sad. were in the 21stc century yet we still have our trains decked in 3rd class. and these poor girls. instead of having books in their hands, theyre begging... so sad

[pureNdesi]

hw thy gnna study if thy aint gt money to study? its money who makes them do all this to feed their family n stuff.

[adityabose26]

Where do you see them begging? They are singing....that's an art. If that's the way they are earning their living, kudos to them. Better than turning out prostitutes as in some other 3rd world countries. They aren't taking the easy way out.

People like you will always keep commenting.."so sad", "so sad" and not do a thing about it.

[swastikstar2000]

Great girls. At least they keeping self respect and earning by showing their art not working as prostitute like girls doing in developed countries.

[CriterionCoIIection]

@adityabose26 the easy way out? because prostitution is so easy. those lazy victim of human trafficking! 12 year old girls raped daily...the easy way. shame on you.

[hallnoats4ever]

@CriterionCoIIection my ears are bleeding

[darsh101]

@adityabose26 fact of the matter is that the real aim here is to torture people with HORRENDOUS singing till they cough up money but you are right this is probably one of the better ways of begging but here is an idea... and I know it is EXTREMELY tough for females of such backgrounds but how about getting a job. maid jobs in India can be blessings in disguise

[bhogala]

they need to get CD Players :)

[gerundio1]

LOVE IT, WISH I WAS THERE IN PERSON.

[norfwestchic]

lllooollll nananananaananaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[sourabh0912]

the song is from a movie called raaz...its called "tum agar saamne aa bhi jaaya karo"

[uwebvarga]

I really want to see India with my own eyes. This is just wonderful! Thanks, Sutekh2!

[ribhkum]

i love india!

[nipponized]

One of the finest videos taken on YouTube. Sutekh, you've done a great job.

[drumultau]

Yooo_niku

[abialikhan]

GOD . makes this world nice and beautifull , and send these childerns as angel to us .. we should

help them in open heart....

[rahulrathan]

This sweet voice will beat the crap out of those American sluts in reality shows !!!

[ARVINDVITTAL]

i broke down after seeing this video. God bless this wonderful kids.....

[kabulian]

wow great just funtaastic this girls made me cry god bless them and save them from bad ppl .i hope one day the become a play back singer and thy never see this days amin.

[YahyaGhamudi]

galaxyyellow and sujeet2k, i dont know what ur arguing about, but u guys are so primitive...

[pathakindiaa]

this is sad

[jerin121]

heart breaking video....they are doing this for their food n water !!!

[Art7962]

Bravo!!Edih Piaf in the train of Indian...

[beejaym]

Details of the songs:

1st 3 minutes, song is from Movie Raaz, mai.n agar saamane aa bhii jaayaa karuu.N ... tuum agar saamane aa bhii jaayaa karo,

After 3 minutes, the song is Duniya Banane Wale from movie Teesari Kasam.

[anthony858]

The music sounds beautifull!!

[gampolaya]

Its a great place. They live more happier over there than sucking

[sujeet2k]

they are beggars.

[alexaxksrk]

I LOVE INDIAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

[wickedsjsidescotts30]

shes hella cute

[m119]

Indian government could do something systematic to support people like these.For example in many London metro stations there is a place reserved for singers/artists and they can make money legally there.

It is not illegal and it is not begging. People only give money if they feel entertained.

It brings tears to my eyes because it reminds me of the time when I used to live in India. I don't find this to be shameful. They are using their talent to earn money and are not thieves/criminals.

[sujeet2k]

Do you know what the population of India is? And how many people are below the poverty line ? I commend the enterprising nature of these girls and many other Indians like them. It takes a lot of gutts to do this.

[sujeet2k]

teri maa ki chut chatte ke chingur !

[sujeet2k]

do u even know what the fuck you are saying you motherfucking retard. you look like the clan from which these girls hail from ! LOL

[taurusvish]

wish it was ur sis or u mum doing d show!!

[ARVINDVITTAL]

wish it was ur gf doing the show...

[futurceleb]

lol!!! these 2 are retarded!

[swastikstar2000]

@futureceleb. And what about you. You are not the future celeb any way because instead of knowing her art you are just sarted abusing the art. I think you are the one what you are saying here.

[TheMaheshshah]

@futurceleb .its you who is retarded,u hav no shame.these girls have more sense than u will ever have.go home and sleep

[cibieldho]

SHAME OF INDIA

[yogishiva]

WHAT ARE THEY SINGING??

[StubbyPecker]

It's a song about curry.

[futurceleb]

lol thats all u kno i guess i sympathise u!

[kingbashers]

dayam lolz dese girls cant sing fo shizzel hahaha na sur na taal

[bigbtripathi]

They are not competing in any compition. They are doing to for money. It's like begging. Whatever they know they try to make a living out of it.They dont have necessary money or time to learn music..It's not a issue to laugh at. It needs serious thinking as to how to solve the underlying issue of our country. Still whatever they are singing , I will say good.

[mrkorn91]

derka derka derka mohhhhammmmed jihhhhhaaad

[springfield29]

Incredible India..,Feel like missing my country more....

[icejin12]

talented girls. really nice. just trying to make a living.

[khanny1]

the first song

[khanny1]

what song is she singing

[afghan619]

NICE SONG!!!!

[saiflon]

incredible india,hope we all indian should look deep in to this matter,this is the real face of india,why these girls doing this matters more then any thing else

[smodass]

shut up and enjoy the music.

[yogishiva]

HARIBOL!!

[eelamtv]

saiflon says "hope we all indian should look deep in to this matter,this is the real face of india,why these girls doing this matters more then any thing else" hahaha omg: look into wat matter? why this girl doing this? haha man where u been living? in Mars? R u one of those stupid theoretical professor?

[bigbtripathi]

They are doing it for money. To live..

These are our future..And we cannot even feed them forget about educating them..

When will poverty go away from India ?

[smodass]

If you are so concerned about poverty in India then do something about it. And what gives you the idea that this girl is starving ? or that education will make her a better person ? You want her to go to college and write computer programs for foreign companies ??? That is called progress ???

[heartoflyon]

very nice i love their voices pauvertu around the world hope to do something for that one day insha Allah thx for the vid

[TJohnC]

nice

Train still looks like sardines packed together though same as when I was there 30 years ago

[KoolChora]

tough living carrying such heavy instrument. sad.

[smodass]

Actually its not that heavy..just a few pounds.