That first note was flat, and so was a lot of it. The jerky movements and slut dance creeped me out. I didn't like it. I liked 阿妹's version better. :/
張惠妹's movement doesn't reflect the lyrics or the story behind the song. She IS supposed to be seductive and drives men crazy. In that sense, 王雅婷's dance fitted better. I didn't notice much jerky movements either. Thought it was a pretty smooth dance. 張惠妹 sang better than 楊蒨時 and 王雅婷 though.
表演的很專業 ,好厲害!!
playajoke001 4 days ago
楊倩時的聲音比較渾厚有力
但是
王雅婷的表演真的比較好看
kristy988 5 months ago
this is a bit slutty... voice is good. no offences intended. fans of wang ya ting plz dun take offence.
cutiepie123XD 7 months ago
覺得王雅婷唱的比楊倩時的好多了
baroque5050 7 months ago
和葛兰比较真是差太远了太远了
oliversamm 8 months ago
好聽 ~~
silence0983 9 months ago
好油哦~ 让我怪不舒服的~ 虽然声音很好,表演和声音完全两个世界。。。
skyluvdbsk 1 year ago
she destroyed the classic terribly.
xRollercoasterx 1 year ago 2
有沒有人覺得他化這樣的妝很像容祖兒啊
acancanicancan 1 year ago
C'est bien ^^
Boulederiz77 1 year ago
That first note was flat, and so was a lot of it. The jerky movements and slut dance creeped me out. I didn't like it. I liked 阿妹's version better. :/
jenna2122170 1 year ago
Comment removed
sylennah 1 year ago
Comment removed
sylennah 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@jenna2122170
張惠妹's movement doesn't reflect the lyrics or the story behind the song. She IS supposed to be seductive and drives men crazy. In that sense, 王雅婷's dance fitted better. I didn't notice much jerky movements either. Thought it was a pretty smooth dance. 張惠妹 sang better than 楊蒨時 and 王雅婷 though.
sylennah 1 year ago
Comment removed
jenna2122170 1 year ago
羅文-卡門Live 仲正^0^/
miu3288 1 year ago
@bomberboh楊蒨時 / 卡門 <<<<好d
miu3288 1 year ago
2009.09.05超級偶像3 楊蒨時 / 卡門 (44.4分)
聽聽這個 , 如何 ?!!
bomberbohk 1 year ago
她唱得不比阿妹差
但所有人加起上來都不及一個葛蘭
dingding123 2 years ago 10
沒錯
葛蘭真的超絕的
他把這首歌唱得很騷
而且騷的很到位
完全不會討厭
反而像我是女生都很喜歡他
真的沒有人可以把這首歌詮釋跟葛蘭一樣
youtube上有 大家真的可以看
payment1234 2 years ago 8
超有味道的!!
dwmhogvyrn 2 years ago 3
歌很好地是美人。
希望在日本成为歌手。
satoumituo38 2 years ago 5
超級~~~~棒的啦!!!!!!!
may88552 2 years ago 8
我想讲句公道话... 没意要和谁过不去,
只不过在听了阿妹, 雅婷, 和瑋庭的版本,
我个人觉得雅婷揣摩得比较有阿妹的风范, 瑋庭唱得有点粗糙...带出来的意境...没有卡门的味道. 当然阿妹还是最棒的!! 相信大家会认同.
xx8REALITY8xx 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
天啊!這女人幹嘛糟蹋了卡門這首歌??
diubigbiglove123 2 years ago
哪裡糟蹋要講出來啊
apolucas 2 years ago 3
王雅婷是不錯
但阿妹全身擅發出的自然魅力還有超水準的唱功
是王雅婷遠遠不及的
sexythicklip 2 years ago 3
請你評論之前先清楚且明確的瞭解
何謂"唱功"
higherms12 2 years ago 2
很讚!!!!!!!!so sexy so hot!
yvette74731 3 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
low class...= =
r19740101 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
跟葉瑋庭差還是很多!!!
warren8778 3 years ago
是啊 比她好多了
abysstw 3 years ago 24
王雅婷比較好
請不要以個人立場
評論人的好壞好嘛?
請尊重一下其他支持王雅婷的迷
y7793119 3 years ago 35
@y7793119 “王雅婷比较好”
你好像也设定了自己的个人的立场。
usdream 10 months ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
both are good
but i like 葉瑋庭's version better
just my opinion
jacky800514 3 years ago
她卡門真的唱的超棒的~!!
一聽就愛上~!!
xcza0526 3 years ago 15
真的好經典
cutejosephina 3 years ago 13
哇哇哇~王雅婷身材超好的耶!而且我超喜歡她的眼神喔,帶有一點點的狠意...整個就是超經典!歌聲好、身材好、人也镸的超正!永遠的第一名啦!(在我心中)
y7793119 3 years ago 19
王雅婷超棒的阿~~
love5566tony 3 years ago 9
音色好漂亮~!
levis501tw 3 years ago 14
超級棒的啦!巨星架式!
xweb0417 3 years ago 13
很棒
tto0o 3 years ago 11
perfect
htm540 3 years ago 11
眼神辣,歌聲棒,整個是完美的演出
王雅婷超棒
94501023 3 years ago 19