If you think Beach House's cover lacks feeling, think about it in a different light (whoa, a cover). Perhaps it is meant to evoke different feelings reflected only in the first verse... a steady and swollen, lasting pain and the beauty in letting it be. Johnston's evokes more of agonizing and enveloping depression that quietly eats away at the soul. I love both versions.
i really like beach house but this is a bad cover. it lacks all the heart of the original. beach house is dreamy and ethereal. daniel johnston is raw and painfully real. total opposites. that's why this doesn't work; beach doesn't step outside of their sound to play a song that requires them to.
wow this is pretty awesome! Makes my cover look like rubbish haha! I would never of even thought to do this song in such a unique fashion like this. Well done :)
I love Daniel Johnston and Beach House...when this cd came out I was pleasantly surprised by how good they did with it. If you are a Daniel Johnston fan, you should respect such a great cover as this...considering not a lot of people cover him very well.
If you think Beach House's cover lacks feeling, think about it in a different light (whoa, a cover). Perhaps it is meant to evoke different feelings reflected only in the first verse... a steady and swollen, lasting pain and the beauty in letting it be. Johnston's evokes more of agonizing and enveloping depression that quietly eats away at the soul. I love both versions.
easteastside 1 week ago
A nice piece to listen on a Forever Alone Day tomorrow. Guess I have my playlist ready and waiting for that special occasion.
redyossarian 2 weeks ago in playlist Beach House Devotion
trash
gareth209 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Broken915 3 weeks ago
Interesting but lacking feeling
SilenceBroken23 1 month ago
@SilenceBroken23 don't you fee like it should be longer? or maybe it's just me. I suppose all good things must come to an end.
moniqe123 4 weeks ago
i really like beach house but this is a bad cover. it lacks all the heart of the original. beach house is dreamy and ethereal. daniel johnston is raw and painfully real. total opposites. that's why this doesn't work; beach doesn't step outside of their sound to play a song that requires them to.
TheFoundation123 1 month ago
prefers johnston's version to this version by the hipsters
astroboirap 2 months ago
I don't get people calling this hipster trash or whatever. Like, what do you even define "hipster music" as being? Good music?
Kiwiseathumans 2 months ago
awful cover of an otherwise amazing song
Whodawhadadoda 2 months ago
Great song. Perfect for a rainy day
CoolVideoCrap 2 months ago
Ah! I had to hear it to believe it. One of the purest songs ever written, given a hipster soulless makeover.. what has this world come to?
nihlamanichodgepodge 3 months ago
@nihlamanichodgepodge calm down bro. you're full on mad.
whilwheaton 2 months ago
Beautiful, my heart hurts.
joseph72790 4 months ago
Beach House are so talented. They are quickly becoming my favourite band.
DJBailey815 4 months ago
I usually hate covers, This is great.
aljr0 4 months ago
An excellent version. Built to Spill did the best cover of this song though.
artysmokes 4 months ago
gorgeous cover
cadanmccann 5 months ago
This cover did not last a long time.
mcgurkov 6 months ago
it doesn't move? it's just one image? did i miss something?
coldbacon 6 months ago
@paranoidandroid505 very true
heystopit123 8 months ago
daniel johnston's cover so pretty
seavoyagerful 10 months ago
wow this is pretty awesome! Makes my cover look like rubbish haha! I would never of even thought to do this song in such a unique fashion like this. Well done :)
findacanarymusic 11 months ago
best cover ive heard of this one
trilobite3339 1 year ago
no one can top daniel johnston, sorry, as much as I love beach house.
michellejesica 1 year ago
............... Only part i didnt like was 2:32
whohasthisname5 1 year ago 6
Built to Spill does a great cover, picks up in the second half.
also
doug martsch, of built to spill, does a great acoustic version
rorydesesseintes 1 year ago
that is awesome!!
sillybighat 1 year ago
Totally awesome! Every song Beach House does is!!!!!!
nostalgiahistoria67 1 year ago
I love Daniel Johnston and Beach House...when this cd came out I was pleasantly surprised by how good they did with it. If you are a Daniel Johnston fan, you should respect such a great cover as this...considering not a lot of people cover him very well.
LucidDream 1 year ago 2
This is a good version, the best in youtube, better than the one of Beck, but still I prefer Daniel´s original.
racpembertondual 1 year ago
nice!!
fatfrankblack 1 year ago
who wrote the original?
imraw17 1 year ago
@imraw17 Daniel Johnston.
Tyoki07 1 year ago
Fucking rad cover
If beach house can do a cover this good im going to actually start checking out more of their music.
Jerdna3 1 year ago
I prefer 10000 times Daniel Johnston original
rafaelmadferit 1 year ago
@rafaelmadferit you can't measure your preference or opinion its your nobody ever ever gonna have it sorry man suck your on balls inside out
domingoflores 1 year ago
Comment removed
lordkurenai 2 years ago
This my favorite song of all time, and they did sooo much justice, man this is a great cover.
vergarihno 2 years ago 20
this is a fucking goood cover.
welcometheplagueyear 2 years ago 15
idem, great great!
rominindc 2 years ago
every title just goes with the mood of the music. it's outstanding.
JayRocks311 2 years ago
Thanks for posting. I couldnt find it anywhere.
icecoldkarl 2 years ago