Christina Aguilera Vs. Beyoncé (Vocal Battle: Third Albums)

[losers0are0on0utube]

From a person who is in the music business having 7 years vocal training, i know that Christina aguilera slays her voice and it sounds like a cat dying. It's not about how high or low you sing it's about the notes in-between to get there. Beyoncé is by far better than christina.

[MissLalaland89]

Christina aguilera just....screams

[wozniacki15]

beyonce may have better vocals but Back to Basics is a way better album than IASF the production was absolutely amazing that IASF cant compare

[edwardmatias]

Christina tried too hard.

Beyonce kept it simple...

[k266597]

lool christina duh,, again i wanna point out that beyonce had vocal coach maybe the best which made her this way made her better in singing lol but christina didnt and she slays beyonce lol thats a true talent, christina didnt need anyone to tell her how to sing she just opens her mouth and her heart and just chillis to everyone who listens but beyonce just another singer in this world

[AlwaysAbeyoncefan]

BEYONCE WINS IT ALL!! 

[emmawatson1997fan]

There are no notes that beyonce can sing and christina can't reach but there are plenty of notes that christina sings and beyonce can bever dream of reaching them))

[BritneySpearsFan445]

Christina slayed Beyonce on every album.

[k266597]

i admit that beyonce is a great singer but nothing like christina okay beyonce can sing and dance, but christina SINGS she makes you cry while watching her, she makes you feel the passion beyonce is kinda lame and her songs are boring but christina is a the master of singing she was porn to be the only one to bring you tears thats why willl all respect she wins and she deserves to be called the voice of our generation

[Xnico29]

No hay competencia entre beyonce y christina

beyonce cantará siempre igual y christina demostro en este cd que puede cantar de todo

[marlenestrawberry]

Christina Aguilera in my heart <3333

[hopeless20312]

True. Christina Aguilera is so flexible in terms of singing. But Beyonce is the true package, the true diva. Beyonce can sing and dance while your ass watches her live. Have you watched Christina sing Fighter live? She can't sing the high notes and it's like disappointing. Watch Beyonce, she's like on the music video when you see her live. She's workaholic and humble. One more thing, you spelled Beyoncé wrong. It's Beyoncé with é. Like a diva é

[k266597]

hahahhhahhhahaha poor beyonce, she got SLAYEDDDDD i dont get it why to compare them!!!!!!! christina is the queeen of music with out even listning i know christina will outshine beyonceeeeee

[Dafny878]

Where is Beyonce?

I only hear X-tina <3

[dspark38]

Again I have to go with Christina on this one.

[9738858]

of course, christina

[meowmeow2905]

hmm the thing is their vocal technique is around the same level, but christina is winning out because her voice is naturally stronger. not to say beyonce's got a weak voice or anything (cuz let's face it...can YOU sing like that?) but christina definitely has the strongest voice i've ever heard. ever. XD

[Titanic1986]

Christina slays all.

[griik123]

ohh gawd..i feel bad for baysicyonce....back 2 basic is d most ambitious album of xtina, so every song would shit on bey's discography

[yahiie]

It sounds like Xtina is the black woman on the video lol

Such a POWERFUL voice.

[tarmoul1]

Christina Aguilera by far Beyonce is good but her voice is basic

[StasiaDenisova]

xtina the best!!!

[AaliyahDawnTeam2]

Christina María Aguilera!!!!!!!!!

[enzo96thebest]

WIN BEYONCE!!

[tarmoul1]

beyonce is good but christina aguilera is the best singer of all the time

[sisi13333]

Christina!!

[SuperSuperalgerien]

ALL MY RESPECT TO béyoncé 's voice but CHRISTINA IS HUGE NO REGARDLESS TO HER BAD technique HER VOICE IS JUST INSANE

[MrArnoldPhilippines]

Back to Basics is the best!!!! I don't like beyonce's voice is boring and unpleasant.. Christina's vocal was very catchy..

[maybesomeday1]

Those top two comments must be Christina herself. I can't see anybody else being that damn delusional.

[bnmcfadden]

where are the competition? Christina wins All The Way!

[TheZoRetro]

no! beyonce is way better than christina in technique! beyonce voice is so much clearer plus christina does too much runs and riffs she trys to show off to much! so my vote is for beyonce!

[lourdezzly]

Baby Jane is better than Sasha Fierce..

[calispartan]

xtina wins this hand down. this is her best album vocally. her belts are so clear and crisp.

[iloveXtina94]

Christina ^^,

[jakes48162]

Christina wins, no competition

[aguilerafanaz]

Xtina just a class above the rest. Love you tho B

[jafet23ful]

@aguilerafanaz this what im get mad i love xtina but the only thing christina got above bey is her power but beyonce got more stamina technique and controle than christina and i love xtina but since it a vocal batler i got to say bey because her note are more convincent but if were talking about power christina will win but still im waiting for a collaboration!!!!!!

[fffeeemmm]

Beyonce's voice can come every decade or so maybe. Christina's voice will never ever come.

[belifan09]

@fffeeemmm I agree with you...

[Wagnerlover777]

@fffeeemmm Only because it'll fall into disrepair in the next 2 or 3 years thanks to the excessive straining.

[bnmcfadden]

que vergüenza beyoncé, no tienes E5 en sasha fierce jajaja... a lo mejor porque no alcanzas esa nota! o sea la mas alta al parecer.. =D

[chan2005123]

i think xtina :D

[Martimp7]

I like both albums, but Back to Basics is absolutely amazing !!

Beyonce and Christina are true singers !!!!!!

[musicishope15]

I like Christina's album just a little bit better, but Beyonce's voice is amazing on her album.

[xxxTIN0xxx]

In live performances both these girls scream too much! I do not like them at all. Amy Winehouse was a real vocalist, love her!!

[Efedin]

Why am I even watchin' these videos. Christina's voice is unique. It's almost better than Whitney Houston's or Aretha Franklin's one and remember at least Christina is white!

[ablackguy123456789]

christina all the way! bey's belts have more clarity but that's it. christina will always be better

[Stefano94x]

@00host She didn't well indeed. She sucked major ass on every single attempt. Her singing is all about splattering her voice and going out of tune in the simplest notes. Sit.

[whitneythequeen92]

wow, beyonce got SLAYED by christina, I like beyonce but she shouts too much when she belts, I don't like that, it sounds ugly and hard for my ears.

[iheartwillandgrace]

@whitneythequeen92 lmao what a laugh that you think you're fooling people with your whitney fan disguise! go die ;)

[Wagnerlover777]

@whitneythequeen92 Hate to point this out to you, but beyonce never screams. She has great training, and to the best of my knowledge has the most relaxed voice in the industry. Christina screams any note in a belt above a D5- lately the comparison is becoming almost sad. Poor Christina- if she would train up her voice a bit...I shiver at the thought of her voice unrestrained by...well...straining.

[chesleycareystar]

@whitneythequeen92 Christina did that TOO MUCH

[Aqua793]

@whitneythequeen92 christina shout too much not beyonce

[stardusth2o]

@Aontiverozol No. Beyonce does have a great tone. Whether you enjoy it or not is the personal opinion. But TECHNICALLY her tone is great.

[stardusth2o]

@Aontiverozol LOL! It's not an opinion though...it IS a fact.

[stardusth2o]

@Aontiverozol I thought you were over xtina and onto bigger and better Whitney things :P Anyways, Beyonce has a beautiful tone with an operatic quality. Listen to her C5 in Ave Maria. Her tone is even better than Mariah's. And even if Xtina does have a prettier voice, it's gone now. She starts to get screamy at Bb4. Everything Xtina does pales in comparison to Beyonce. Beyonce's singing is more dynamic, and healthy. Simple as that. Beyonce>Xtina

[charmd1818]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA!! though i like Beyonce too, but for CA has the voice that no one can reach. :)

[xXKRileyXx]

And how can a voice not be natural?

both started singing at a young age.

[xXKRileyXx]

I love beyonce's voice. she can sing unlike alot other singers. however, you can find a voice like beyonce anywhere. but with christina, i highly doubt there will have someone who can belt out the notes like her and as strong as her.

I love both of them but christina is obviously better in my opinion.

[JAIONTEE]

@xXKRileyXx Jennifer Hudson, Patti Labelle, Ledisi and more...

[kelvinpyaeko]

i can't at all those xtina musically loon stans trying to write comments with vocal pedagogy and terms as if they know it and use them to set some valid points. lmfao

[iheartwillandgrace]

@kelvinpyaeko lol like misses18yearold?? she's so pressed! she'll say anything to prove that xtincta has talent, but it'll never work XD

[kelvinpyaeko]

@iheartwillandgrace bahaha did you see that xtinadisciple disguise accounts always roaming around videos where xtina is featured? so pressed! then she called mariah fans have many accounts lol

[iheartwillandgrace]

@kelvinpyaeko lol ik! xtinadisciple's broke ass keeps saying "oh the mariah fans are making multiple accounts to bash christina" i'm pretty sure she made like 20 accounts to bash mariah, whitney, screamline, and kelly clarkson. shameful! i wouldn't be surprised if misses18yearold is one of xtinadisciple's accounts lol

[kelvinpyaeko]

@iheartwillandgrace no no misses18yearold is one of those rare xtina SANE fans. and he/she likes mariah, too lol why? did you guys have some beef? lol true, all whitneythequeen92, primmofag, vampirictatoo, cowriahsluteray are all his accounts. then he would come out like innocent and keep stating how the other fan bases are so unfair and cruel to bash xtina. seriously, you hypocrite? lmfao

[iheartwillandgrace]

@kelvinpyaeko lol beef is a strong word, we just argued on a few different videos but yes i'm familiar with all those xtinadisciple puppets. whitneythequeen92 betrayed me!! lol i saw her video dissing SCREAMline and i can't stand SCREAMline so i was quick to comment on that video. later i find out, xtinadisciple is at it again -_- i felt so used

[CAguileraHD]

The fact that the two are even being compared offends me. Xtina is better than everyone.

[calvin9999999999]

Christina's C#5 here is actually pretty good. At least she has vibrato in these belted notes unlike Bionic.

[Xtina2BabyJane]

Both Christina and Beyonce are legends and they are both the best voices in music today and probably will be for a long time. Both of these albums are amazing. But I love Back to Basics, and Christina so I have to go with Christina, even though I love Beyonce.

[bdanielkgb]

XTINA by far...

[iheartwillandgrace]

watch both their live performances during these eras and you'll know who the real winner is...

[mariahforever1990]

@iheartwillandgrace christina ;) but your comment probably would've made more sense on the sophomore albums comparison

[Stefano94x]

@mariahforever1990 A singer who is always in tune and sings effortlessly will always be superior to an overrated amateur who shits herself on B4s and is always off tune. Beyonce slays The Noise. You will deal.

[mariahforever1990]

@Stefano94x beyonce is currently better than "the noise" but from 1998-2010, the noise slayed beyonce. beyonce's voice is common and her singing has always been boring as hell and uninspired. i've watched plenty of the noise's performances and she really doesn't go off key that often so you saying she's always off key just shows how much you xtina haters like to exaggerate. the noise has natural talent and her singing is much more captivating.

[Stefano94x]

@mariahforever1990 Beauty of tone is irrelevant, since it's all up to personal opinion. It doesn't define the greatness of a singer. Christina has always sucked. Her voice is destroyed by a decade of screams. Hell, she can't project a B4 without straining anymore. Poor child.

And yes, Christina is always off-key. Her intonation is a zoo. Only her delusional fanbase could deny this.

[mariahforever1990]

@Stefano94x tone is irrelevant? you're just saying that because xtina's voice is more powerful than bey's. xtina's range is more limited than it used to be but that doesn't mean her voice is destroyed. she can always get a vocal coach to help her fix the damage and learn new technique. vocal damage doesn't have to be permanent. there's a difference between going out of tune on high notes and going off key. erykah goes out of tune a lot and mary j. & alicia tend to go flat on upper belts.

[Stefano94x]

@mariahforever1990 You don't know anything about vocals, right? Vocal power is not loudness. It's resonance, which can be achieved only with proper technique. Bee is resonant, Christina's is just loud and screamy. Nothing more. And please get your facts straight because Christina has pitch problems in the 4th octave.

Bye.

[misses18yearold]

@Stefano94x but darkness of tone is relevant and christina's tone is darker than beyonce's. that's a fact

[Stefano94x]

@misses18yearold Darker doesn't mean better.

[misses18yearold]

@Stefano94x tbh it kinda does. don't tell me you'd take tamia's light, girlish tone over mahalia jackson's dark husky tone

[Stefano94x]

@misses18yearold Beauty of tone, unlike technical issues, is completely subjective. Don't judge everything on your standards.

I take Beyonce's tone over Christina's. At least Beyonce's is natural.

[misses18yearold]

@Stefano94x christina's tone is natural too. she's had a big tone since she was 13

[Stefano94x]

@misses18yearold No way. There's nothing natural in Christina's singing. Her tongue is never relaxed. It's always pushed back, because she always wants to make her tone 'bigger' (being a soul singer wannabe). Beyonce is absolutely natural when she sings.

[iheartwillandgrace]

@Stefano94x lol she had nothing to say after that comment! #dismissed

[mariahforever1990]

@Stefano94x xtina's recent performances make me want to cover my ears but that doesn't change how amazing she was from 1998-2010

[danna22]

Both singers are wonderful, I love their uniqueness. If all singers sounded like Beyonce or all singers sounded like Xtina, the world would be really boring. They both win, because they are great singers that convey emotions through their voices that autotune voices cannot. Lets appreciate their talent instead of insulting and calling names that make things just plain childish and immature .

[Fangir120]

Next battle : ) Beyonce loves vibrato : ) Now I think Beyonce was better, better head voice, better low register, nice upper chest : D

[alxalxfrv]

Okay, they are both good, but I HONESTLY think Christina is better and has more of a raw and unique voice and has more soul and passion. Beyonce is AMAZING though, but I feel like beyonce's voice went through alot of vocal training (which is why she is better at technique). Christina sounds real and raw. She's a real singer from birth (watch old clips when they were little)

Btw, Christina has way higher notes in this album ("Mercy on me" is one). Beyonce sounds auto tuned or something ( 1:28 )

[bluedragonz100]

IN ORDER TO BE CALLED/DEEMED THE TITLE "VOICE OF THE GENERATION" ONE MUST HAVE CONTROL OVER THEIR VOICE COMPLETELY SHOWCASING THEIR VOCAL SKILLS. ANYONE GOING AROUND CLAIMING SUCH A TITLE WITHOUT SERIOUS VOCAL CONTROL/SKILL SHOULD HAVE THAT TITLE REVOKED...

[ColombiaSV]

WTF??!! Christina's Back To Basics against a Beyoncealbum??? Listen Hurt,Mercy On Me(!!!),CandyMan,Oh Mother.... . come on now people ..Beyoncé is GREAT but can NEVER sing one of those Christinasongs!!

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@ColombiaSV

Clearly she can. Beyonce can sing every Christina song with ease (Minus the Whistles). Can Christina sing 'Listen'. 'Forever To Bleed' 'Dangerously In Love' ?

[ColombiaSV]

@WhitneyElizabethH You are crazy, Beyonce NEVER can sing Mercy On Me,Hurt or Candyman!!! IF Christina sing listen she will KILL Beyonce!! Fuck Off with your dumb comment idiot!!!

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@ColombiaSV

And prove she can't Sing it. Go on. Beyonce has wayy more control over her range then Christina. Christina's Vocal chords would Break trying to sing a Beyonce song

[VeraGrubanov]

XTINA!

[StrippedGoesBionic]

back to basics!

[juddsta313]

@bconsitt

if christina wasnt a good singer how come shes in the rollingstones top 100 singers of all time and wheres beyonce??? NOWHERE??

[TheVocalPower]

Sooooo

Are you gonna make Bionic Vs 4?

Lol

[MimiDahhling30]

@TheVocalPower Of course, its coming in the next couple days.

[Maria000Teresa]

BEYONCÉÉ

[Stefano94x]

@SteveCapSud Beyonce has a full head voice, she resonates up there. Christina has a tiny falsetto. Get your facts straight. 

[Stefano94x]

I can't wait for 4 Vs. Bionic. It's gonna be the best way to make Xtina become Xtincta.

[MimiDahhling30]

@Stefano94x Hahaha yes! thats coming really soon, stay tuned ;)

[kolossal17]

@Stefano94x

Just because Bionic didn't perform well commercially it doesn't mean that Christina's vocals deteriorated.

[Stefano94x]

@kolossal17 Who cares about sales, her voice is clearly deteriorated.

[Stefano94x]

@kolossal17 With deteriorated vocals or not, she loses anyway. She has always been inferior to Bee, in both technical skills and intonation.

[SheLovesXtinAguilera]

Christina!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Ronni98]

TOLLL!Aber Christina ist besser!

[loversland2010]

Love them both, but Christina's voice is so much fuller.

[poperline]

i love them both !!!!!!!!!!!!! they are 2 last great voices in america

[MrDaniel1821]

Whats the song on beyonce's Eb 5

[MimiDahhling30]

@MrDaniel1821 Forever To Bleed

[makaleva24]

Christina obviously is one of the best singers there is now. Beyonce is different and she's can SANG but not compared to Christina. is Christina made the Best 3 Mariah, Whitney & Celine the Top 4. Just saying !

[uceflucas20]

beyonce duh

[alex801sol]

Christina Aguilera ..... Hands down ! Beyonce has a good voice and is better then all the main popular singer out now , but when it comes to Christina you just cant compare Beyonce !

[ColombiaSV]

@alex801sol perfect said!!

[Stefano94x]

@bconsitt LMAO

[JamaaJaan]

christina !!

[starz280]

LUV BOTH OF THEIR VOICES!!

[kokobins]

Two beautiful voices!!

[BritneySpearsAngelic]

Christina :)

[DrefordGemini]

I give it up for both of them!! :)

[ekiiim]

For me, Bee wins I like it a lot <3

[lovegxx]

before christina wins but this album beyonce' wins christina kinda sorta loss her voice but she still has a soulful deep one love her still

[ManOfBamboo]

Beyonce wins! Just the more talented human being in this video.

[Vampirictattoo]

dog shit >>> bacteria on dog shit >>> beyonce's vocals, tehehehe

[Chimier]

@bconsitt HAHAHAHAHA #DEAD

[lc0309]

@bconsitt i'm years away to get there. Hey who do you like in american idol? i mean if you're watching it, you know since you're a beyawnce stan you must think that nobody else in the entire world has talent

[lc0309]

@bconsitt hahaha you rock 30 year old fairy! You seriously rock!

[lc0309]

@bconsitt could you please tell the other side of your twisted mind to shut the f up? i thought he wasn't hoing to read my comments! come on bconshit tell chimierda to stop it!

[lc0309]

@bconsitt That was me in my unusual stan-ish behaviour so what??? you have your days and yours are pretty much everyday #LOL

[Chimier]

@bconsitt Blooming like a dead flower haha!

[Chimier]

@bconsitt Mic in her cleavage? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

[lc0309]

@bconsitt hahaha i love stans you guys are hilarious living in denial so cute and funny =) i see the mini-mic because i'm not a stan why can't you see it? because you'd rather live denyin a truth that speaks loud and clear and no it isn't FRAUDyawnce's voice telling that it is Christina's poor thing i really feel sorry for you promoting a singer that's a miniscule voice and it is ugly it must be very uncomfortable to be you. What a fake chick i can't even her copyright infrigment issues =(

[Xhaterlover]

@lc0309 ignorant

[lc0309]

@Xhaterlover and you are????

[Xhaterlover]

@lc0309 lol just another beyond stan...who happens to like christina as well...and who also happens to find your comments rather ignorant...p.s. the mini mic comment gave me a good little laugh; thanks for that :) have a nice night :)

[WestVoice]

@lc0309 Those are air spaces between her breasts -_- common sense please?

[Chimier]

@WestVoice Don't ever ask him for such a thing. He doesn't know what it is lol.

[WestVoice]

@Chimier LOL indeed... Next time, he'll say Beyonce has a mic in her undies -_-

[Chimier]

@WestVoice LOL #ICANT

[lc0309]

@bconsitt ohhh yes! i think your mad... is it because you can't stand the fact that even you one of beyawnce's more deluded stans haven't heard her really sing? you know it's sad to promoto a singer when all you have heard from her is an audio machine amplifying her miniscule voice poor you! =(

[lc0309]

@bconsitt you mad???? FRAUDyawnce stan?

[lc0309]

@bconsitt watch?v=7rq3DDglaYA Beyawnce got owned! #LOL por FRAUDyawnce's stans

[daiell09]

What does Demi Lovato have to do with beyonce and xtina?

[kelvinpyaeko]

may be xinta's voice sounds kind of rare, but beyonce's power and resonance just killed her...lol

[Wagnerlover777]

I think Christina strains her voice too much, but Beyonce is a little bit too limited in her emotional expression and Christina has more outpour. The best pop singer is always judged by opinion (and I take Christina's side), but I hate to say that Christina is losing her voice because she keeps on making the same PAINFUL mistakes, while Beyonce will not. Damnit.

[Stefano94x]

@bconsitt Now, I am inspired. I think I'll do a Christina VS Anastacia battle like this, divided into the single CDs. What do you think about it? :P

[brucioz]

christina's more mature album (in vocals)

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@bconsitt *exits room, leaves you talking to yourself* #DISMISSED

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@bconsitt i have better things to do than click on your dumb links sweetie Ke$ha, Britney, Gaga aka shitty whore pop tarts >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> CRACKney you are #DISMISSED booboo STAY FAILING !!!

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@bconsitt sweetie you're a CRACKney stan LMFAOOOOOOO, Ke$ha could outsing HER TROLOLOLOLLO BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@bconsitt babe anyone who listens to Lord CaCattenion whore and CRACKney live and finds there voices anywhere near acceptable and then trys to come for Godtina Godguilera will never be talking to me about ANYONES vocals sweetie *sips tea* #STAYPRESSED

[XTINASDISCIPLE]

@bconsitt *goes to watch my whitney video* #Oop you #FAIL again sweetie, how bout you go back to running your hate pages on twitter gurl, you sad lonlely 30 year old gay queen.

[lc0309]

@XTINASDISCIPLE hahaha that's great keep going after those bitches

[TheVocalPower]

Beyoncé wins once again.

Are you gonna make a new video when Beyoncé makes her new album?

[kavatuz]

Ill give Straintina's cracked out voice about 3 more good years, sucks how Beyonce is only just now in her vocal prime (more resonance, dynamics, cleaner, character, soul, scales, heavy) while Straintina is long past it witnh her over used horrid runs & cracked out vocals

[kavatuz]

WTF at that 1st note by Xtina?? LMAO, she sounds a mess these days. Beyonce wins then, there & now

[primohomme]

@bconsitt

LOL, like my friend LohengrinT said...Her highest good note is G4 and her lowest good note is F4. LMAO

[quents]

i dont get how xtina fans DO NOT HEAR how xtina sounds like shes vocalizing and then needs a run up to her high notes. THEY SO DEAF AND DUMB.

[LifeisMusic07]

Christina > Her vocals always do it for me. & they're always raw, deep, passionate, & emotive.

[BRONXPEPE]

Christina of course has a deeper stronger voice but I also enjoy Beyonce voice she is more smooth vocalist

[TheVanessaCruz]

they're both sooooo good.