Guys, this video is old. This was back in February when the Broadway show wasn't even in previews yet. When they recorded this, it was only a few weeks after the cast was casted. Look at more recent videos, they sound amazing!
West end has too many talented casting directors/producers who actually have their mind in making a good show for people to watch and not for bucket loads of cash, the only reason they took it to broadway is because one of the producers ears pricked up when they heard it was doing well in England, quite frankly New york often doesn't have that to offer, apart from that it's never easy to translate something that works amazing on stage to moving camera!
I'm sure the West End and Broadway are just as good. Hearing Katie sing that part on video clips is nothing like hearing her sing it live. She was my favourite thing about the London show.
Well I just heard the London one on Paul O'Grady show and I much prefer the American one. Her belt is stronger and I've seen her in person. TV does her voice no justice.
i saw the West End, and they were amazing. I still think they were better somewhat vocally, but I do love the extra energy that the slight change in choreography is shown in Broadway. Just watch their performance in the Tony Awards!
The UK Cast was NOT! You cannot judge a Broadway show from the a show T.V. version of the song! Patina is obviously saving herself for the actual show. I saw the show and she is better than she was in London! So was Mary Robert. You can't judge a whole show by an appearence on T.V.
I see a lot of people saying the UK version of this was much better, which could be seeing as I haven't seen the show live yet (on West End or Broadway,) BUT I hope people aren't making that judgement based on a performance on THE VIEW.
Listen. Marla Mindelle (Sister Mary Robert) is on of the fierecest musical theatre actresses out there. She's a wonderful actress and has one of the most felxible voice ranges out there. Not only his her belting absolutely incredible or soprano head voice and whistele range are just as strong. Sh'e incredibly versatile and i can almost promise you that no one can do that belt as well as she can. Just saying.
What a lifeless sound mixing!!! It could've been so much better. I'm sure the performances were actually good, had it not been for the toned down sound.
UH stop comparing it to the UK version. jesus all you brits need to calm your tits. its nominated for a few tony awards be at least grateful for that.
OMg.. Leave Marla alone.. she is doing fine and sounds wonderful.... CCM represent! You want to hear a voice too.. her sister Lisa.. (OMG). The whole Weiner/Mindelle clan is freaking amazing!
Agree with what everyone else is saying. The London cast was SO much better. Some notes here were REALLY sharp! Also Agree with what people are saying about Mary Robert and Mary Lazarus. Normally actors on Broadway do it better than London by far but this seems to be an exception to the rule.
People, Patina did this for maybe more than 200/300 times and there is alot of presure. First West End, now broadway. Please chill out. Patina is good, And I bet the Broadway cast will be bigger
I just saw it yesterday.. it was absolutely amazing... this clip does no justice at all... Patina was amazing as usual and Marla Mindelle was absolutely stunning.... she sounds nothing like this clip.... it's amazing how much they have grown as a cast in just short 3 weeks !! GO SEE IT!!
Very much agree, get katie over there also the old sister need to change she looks to young, i think posibbly they all need a rocket up there arse to it was not good, i though broadway was supposed to better than london,
Just saw this on broadway. The version of this is NOTHING compared to what I saw tonight. I guess they weren't well rehearsed during this show because omg this was my favorite number tonight it was epic!!!
Good Luck For When It Opens :-) x Of Course It'll Be Compared To The London Cast..But They Are Different And Have Different Abilities... I Personally Think This Is Pretty Good :-) x And The Woman Playing Mary Robert Is Lovely :-) She Replied To My Question On Twitter With Advice And Not Many "Celebrities" Do That..
I know that they've only just started rehearsals and all that, but I found that extremely painful to listen to. Patina doesn't seem to have the energy that she had in London and everything in general was bad!! Katie Rowley Jones and Claire Greenway are a million times better. I really hope for the sake of the show it gets better.
early days yet but no where near as good as the UK version :) Even patina seemed fed up :( even her 'fabulous' line which is usually awesome wasn't very good in comparison :(
I LOVE sister act the musical, but Patina sounds really vocally worn out here :/ Not sure if it's a wise choice doing a major stint on the West End to begin another on Broadway - look what happened to Julie Andrews. The whole cast sound very dissappointing so far :/ but it's still early days :) They'll probs be whipped into shape by opening night
Saw this on Broadway it was awesome!!!
CrazyRandomCuzos 1 week ago
.........Anybody else waiting for Whoopi to come on stage and tell Patina, "Move over honey, this is how you conduct a choir!!!" lol
lenzino7383 2 weeks ago
This does it no justice. This was great live
Pakman717 3 weeks ago
eeew. way too nasal.
heartbeatsinger 1 month ago
New dream role right there!!
DancerLuv199 2 months ago
Carnegie Mellon grad. Go girl.
loislane7825 2 months ago
Boring. Belt please!!!!
jarvisantonio 2 months ago
both broadway and west end performances of sister act must be marvelous, but DON'T forget..... it was made by A DUTCH man!!! HAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHA
lilithmoon1979 2 months ago
Marla sounds terrible.
IanMcPatrick 3 months ago
bless me father for i have sinned!
milozzy1 3 months ago
Whoopi is better in this?
Goatfeet2007 3 months ago
judge it by the actual Tony performance, not this one.
judge it by the performance on a Broadway stage. its amazing
harajukukevin6657 4 months ago
Guys, this video is old. This was back in February when the Broadway show wasn't even in previews yet. When they recorded this, it was only a few weeks after the cast was casted. Look at more recent videos, they sound amazing!
cdgunzz97 4 months ago 8
seeing the Uk tour in Edinburgh on 5th nov, cant wait!
stephen9478 4 months ago
Mary Roberts hurts my ears ..
misstears002 4 months ago
The London cast were just... Wow.
This cast, not so much. Only Patina Miller :)
Jonnyriffic 5 months ago
West end has too many talented casting directors/producers who actually have their mind in making a good show for people to watch and not for bucket loads of cash, the only reason they took it to broadway is because one of the producers ears pricked up when they heard it was doing well in England, quite frankly New york often doesn't have that to offer, apart from that it's never easy to translate something that works amazing on stage to moving camera!
BillzProductions 5 months ago
i think my theater group did a better job look up yapi 11 raise youre voice
fredmeyerbro 6 months ago
Mary Lazurus starting up kills me every time! :D
seregon07 6 months ago
I just saw this in NYC and really didn't like the lead. I didn't like her singing or acting.
The show was entertaining but mediocre at best.
SuperSandraMay 6 months ago
1978? "MOJO"? one of the MANY, sloppy anachronisms in this show.
pudgeuncle 6 months ago
I'm sure the West End and Broadway are just as good. Hearing Katie sing that part on video clips is nothing like hearing her sing it live. She was my favourite thing about the London show.
WeCanNeverMeetAgain 6 months ago
Mary Robert I mean...
sephyr2006 7 months ago
Well I just heard the London one on Paul O'Grady show and I much prefer the American one. Her belt is stronger and I've seen her in person. TV does her voice no justice.
sephyr2006 7 months ago
this si different from the play i saw today their voices were much stronger they sound different hear but the play was really good
Soccergirly9100 7 months ago
yall need to watch them perform on The Tony's...they were sooooo much better there than on here.
dc3fan2003 7 months ago
Keep in mind this was a TV performance, I saw them about a week ago on Broadway and it was AMAZING!
fluffmymuffin1 7 months ago
This is good but West End takes it for me...
Lol, not being rude but this Mary Lazarus looks likes Matt Lucas LOL
TheRealMacStahh 7 months ago
i saw the West End, and they were amazing. I still think they were better somewhat vocally, but I do love the extra energy that the slight change in choreography is shown in Broadway. Just watch their performance in the Tony Awards!
rtablada 7 months ago
marla mindelle reminds me sooo much of kerry butler! love this.
imlamesowhat 7 months ago
i thnk the west end cast is better personally xxx
OLIVIA1998ist 7 months ago
The UK Cast was NOT! You cannot judge a Broadway show from the a show T.V. version of the song! Patina is obviously saving herself for the actual show. I saw the show and she is better than she was in London! So was Mary Robert. You can't judge a whole show by an appearence on T.V.
TheJMSmovies 7 months ago 3
Don't confuse the TV studio version with the live energy of a stage production. They are not the same! Broadway is awesome!!
GreaterTorontoTV 7 months ago
I see a lot of people saying the UK version of this was much better, which could be seeing as I haven't seen the show live yet (on West End or Broadway,) BUT I hope people aren't making that judgement based on a performance on THE VIEW.
Kevtastical 7 months ago
Listen. Marla Mindelle (Sister Mary Robert) is on of the fierecest musical theatre actresses out there. She's a wonderful actress and has one of the most felxible voice ranges out there. Not only his her belting absolutely incredible or soprano head voice and whistele range are just as strong. Sh'e incredibly versatile and i can almost promise you that no one can do that belt as well as she can. Just saying.
RyanBernier93 8 months ago
LOVE PATINA MILLER IN THIS SONG!!
ActingBug28 8 months ago
Just saw a few hours ago, amazing performance, they were given a stannding ovation. amazing show, i hope it lasts on broadway for years to come
couturebabex33 8 months ago
the west end version is SO much better...
CoNnOr17rEd 8 months ago
why? whats so wrong with mary robert? and what is backrub??
ncisforever15 8 months ago
There really not the West end cast!!
ScottOliverFitness 8 months ago
I <3 Roberta Burger Wall!
stephaniepressman 8 months ago
I don't understand why all the ensemble are young in this...? In the UK, most of them are OAPs and they sure knew how to rock up that stage!
danielhopeuk 9 months ago
What a lifeless sound mixing!!! It could've been so much better. I'm sure the performances were actually good, had it not been for the toned down sound.
alfiebyrne123 9 months ago 3
UH stop comparing it to the UK version. jesus all you brits need to calm your tits. its nominated for a few tony awards be at least grateful for that.
faggyboy2 9 months ago 20
The British one was much better it really made you fell good.
penninefilms 9 months ago
This girl's got nothing on Katie Rowley Jones.
MrAlltheworldsastage 9 months ago 3
Why do america make everything higher lol!!!!
BillzProductions 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I saw this yesterday on braodway, it was extremely good...I loved it!!! =)
4evr97dancer 9 months ago
I went to see the show and I thought it was incredible! The singing was like WOW lol. I thought it was super fun :)
daris2kewl4u 10 months ago
OMg.. Leave Marla alone.. she is doing fine and sounds wonderful.... CCM represent! You want to hear a voice too.. her sister Lisa.. (OMG). The whole Weiner/Mindelle clan is freaking amazing!
TorrRJ 10 months ago
In my opinion, yes the UK cast were better, BUT i think Patina is still incredible here!! And the Sister mary roberts is just DIFFERENT to Katie x
mrjcb91 10 months ago 2
Agree with what everyone else is saying. The London cast was SO much better. Some notes here were REALLY sharp! Also Agree with what people are saying about Mary Robert and Mary Lazarus. Normally actors on Broadway do it better than London by far but this seems to be an exception to the rule.
DCW39 10 months ago 2
People, Patina did this for maybe more than 200/300 times and there is alot of presure. First West End, now broadway. Please chill out. Patina is good, And I bet the Broadway cast will be bigger
MrRealVoices 10 months ago
What is up with this cast? And especily Mary Robert, those riffs were just messy...
MrAlltheworldsastage 11 months ago
hehe "sister mary patrick"'s mom is my drama teacher :) her name is Sarah Bolt, guys, and she's such an amazing new addition to Broadway!!
MissWings460 11 months ago
@MissWings460 She isn't a new addition to Broadway she was already in Wicked. She is great!
KrayonL 11 months ago
@KrayonL yes i know, i was talking about having a main part, kind of breaking into having a name in broadway. and yes she is!
MissWings460 10 months ago
I just saw it yesterday.. it was absolutely amazing... this clip does no justice at all... Patina was amazing as usual and Marla Mindelle was absolutely stunning.... she sounds nothing like this clip.... it's amazing how much they have grown as a cast in just short 3 weeks !! GO SEE IT!!
TyChiStudio 11 months ago
.. what was that?
clevm002 11 months ago
Very much agree, get katie over there also the old sister need to change she looks to young, i think posibbly they all need a rocket up there arse to it was not good, i though broadway was supposed to better than london,
cuteenglishboy 11 months ago
Nah, mate. This is nothing on London.
Get Katie over there. Trust me, you lot need her.
ZiggzHSMrules 11 months ago
Just saw this on broadway. The version of this is NOTHING compared to what I saw tonight. I guess they weren't well rehearsed during this show because omg this was my favorite number tonight it was epic!!!
imwithavril2000 11 months ago 2
Comment removed
imwithavril2000 11 months ago
sorry to say but london cast nailed this.
TonyTyler28 1 year ago 2
OHMYGOD. IS THAT MARLA MINDELLE?!
fhowardh 1 year ago
If you go to Broadway .com for the press they have really improved espically mary robert but needs to hold it a little longer !
V6able 1 year ago
Good Luck For When It Opens :-) x Of Course It'll Be Compared To The London Cast..But They Are Different And Have Different Abilities... I Personally Think This Is Pretty Good :-) x And The Woman Playing Mary Robert Is Lovely :-) She Replied To My Question On Twitter With Advice And Not Many "Celebrities" Do That..
Keep Up The Good Work!!
The Show Will Be FABULOUS!!
x
Defyingg 1 year ago
Sister Mary Lazarus was so much better in London
909Ashman 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
the cast of london was much better than this
saruschka96 1 year ago 25
@saruschka96 couldn't agree more =) x
simplelife730 10 months ago
@saruschka96 I couldn't agree more! As much as I love Patina, the others need ....... "help"
dch4mpi0n 9 months ago
@saruschka96 no WAY!!
XxLittleMissCheekyxX 4 months ago
@saruschka96 calm your tits. this show is great. both versions are great. this show was nominated for tony awards so hah
TheJDuoBand 4 months ago
@saruschka96 fyi that is the cast from london get ya facts straight
DezzyDee100 3 months ago in playlist Liked
I don't like Mary Robert
soylakekagalindo 1 year ago 4
Alrightt, Mary Roberts quite strange, and kinda soundss like BACKRUB:L
mazzisamazing 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
Defyingg 1 year ago 2
oh my, not terrible.. but compared to the UK cast.. this is quite scary.. what is that Mary Robert all about? talented.. but in all the wrong places..
can say the only thing i particularly enjoyed was patina' riff at 2:23 ish.. LUSH!
PARAWHORExHERE 1 year ago 3
I know that they've only just started rehearsals and all that, but I found that extremely painful to listen to. Patina doesn't seem to have the energy that she had in London and everything in general was bad!! Katie Rowley Jones and Claire Greenway are a million times better. I really hope for the sake of the show it gets better.
sweetdreams1405 1 year ago
They dont open till the end of march, so give them a bit of slack. Plenty of time for them to get it up to speed and find their characters.
DDTC 1 year ago
early days yet but no where near as good as the UK version :) Even patina seemed fed up :( even her 'fabulous' line which is usually awesome wasn't very good in comparison :(
johnawhitney 1 year ago
Marla Mindelle is magical. :]
derogatony 1 year ago
I LOVE sister act the musical, but Patina sounds really vocally worn out here :/ Not sure if it's a wise choice doing a major stint on the West End to begin another on Broadway - look what happened to Julie Andrews. The whole cast sound very dissappointing so far :/ but it's still early days :) They'll probs be whipped into shape by opening night
wiccaryan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The UK Cast were so much better than this - Patina seems to have taken a step down, and sister mary robert wasn't a touch...
bolty1704 1 year ago 21
@bolty1704 Haggered comes to mind...
bolty1704 11 months ago
@bolty1704
patina did not take any step back here, she sounds just amazing as usual...yes sister mary robert is not as good, ill give that one
bwayindaburbs23 10 months ago
Brilliant, except that Sister Mary Robert's mic was set slightly too loud and was unbalanced from everyone else.... but it was still fooking awesome!
TeenageTheatreTalk 1 year ago