Your arrangement is fantastic. Really warm and well played. You have a very special talent: taking a song with vocals and multiple instrumental tracks and distilling it down to the essence and adapting it to a guitar instrumental. You are very good.
I hope you don't mind...I just shared this on Facebook. Your rendition is hauntingly beautiful. I could listen to this all evening long. Thank you so much for sharing your talent with all of us!
I hope you don't mind...I just shared this on Facebook. Your rendition is hauntingly beautiful. I could listen to this all evening long. Thank you so much for sharing your talent with all of us!
One of my all-time favorite songs, and to say you did it justice is a huge understatement. I cannot say enough good things about your arrangement and your playing...really, really nice!!!!!
Time and again I keep returning to your rendition of this Rundgren composition,( one of his best works, I guess) and time and again I am stunned and keep just sitting still for a couple of minutes after hearing you play so sensitive. You 've given me a lot of precious moments, thanks!
My God, this is so good. Shame you don't have a tablature :( Your playing is so beautifullllll :) This was so easy on the ears. Keep on playing, good sir! If you ever have a tab, I'd love to have it sent my way :)
This stuff makes me cry man. I would buy a cd of just you playing your guitar to Todd's more beautiful and romantic tunes such as this. It wells so much emotion deep inside of me. You are a wonderful player who obviously appreciates great music.
I told a muso friend of mine who knew nothing of Todd Rundgren's music, to check out this clip (and the original of Todd at the piano) and he thought this version was BETTER!!!! I am a HUGE Todd fan and I consider this rendition to be beautifully faultless. Great stuff.
well....i don't know about the 'better' part. Actually i've worked from time to time to make this better by adding some vocal harmony parts but haven't ever put the finish on it. thanks!
My apologies, Tony... didn't mean to call you by another name & the chords were sent to David. But my comments for you remain true, my friend! Be well...
Such impeccable technique, David! A very, very worthy cover!
I had sent you the chords w/ lyrics, but the chords are bunched to the left side. I can resend in a pdf file formatted, just need another address. Send internally, like before, to keep it private.
Man, that was actually really awesome. Great playing. I played the piano part to it just to see what it would sound like and everything was dead on. :)
the lyrics tell a tale of unspeakable loss and that loss for me is my precious son who was taken on his 25th b/d so if you dont mind I would like to dedicate this to Jordan.
So much crap gets dumped on YouTube by talent-free individuals, but this acoustic version of Todd Rundgren's beautiful song is the exact opposite of all that. Really lovely, troubleclef. You've got the gift.
Did I comment before about this? I forget. Just watched and listened again. I SOOO love this song, and wish my guitar skills were equal to your rendition; nice chord voicings.Have you given Todd notice of it? He'd love it too, I'm sure.
Whoa! Well done. Bravo sir! Wonderful arrangement of a wonderful song. I may have a go at this one myself if you dont mind me keep pausing your video to look at your fingers. I might send you my rendition in a couple of years. If I can master it that quick.
I don't see anything 'lame' in liking one of the very few rock artists to whom we can apply the term 'genius' without using that word in a very indulgent way.
I don't think people will ever realize how much Todd Rundgren has contributed to the music world and how many big name bands he has both produced and has led into super stardom, Hall and Oates being only one of those. This track by troubleclef is truly a beautiful rendition!
I don't think your lame, when I was 12 years of age I remember hearing "Hello, It's Me being played on a radio station, 96 Super Q I believe the name was, when I lived in Naples, Florida, and in an instant I became a Todd Rundgren beliver,
He writes and composes from the 'Heart', In fact Mr. Rundgren
is the only one that believed in the Meat Loaf/Jim Steinman 'Bat Out Of Hell' project, so if it wasn't for his insight and musical genius Meat Loaf would never have been.
*sigh* if only I could play this good someday. Well, I just started out and I play with a pick. Don't have a guitar teacher so i'm pretty much teaching myself lol. I'm trying my best to teach myself to finger pick, it seems so much more relaxing and nicer to listen to.
Nice, I've always appreciated fingerstyle playing. I'll definitely check out a teacher someday, but at the moment, money is a bit scarce, lame. I can't really take online lessons since I'm more of a, "Hands On" kind of learner. But none of that will stop me from practicing :)
Just tremendous. I am a Todd fan since the early 1970's. That was beautiful. I am so jealous (in a good way) of your skill and artistry. Thanks alot.
Tony, have you gathered by now that Todd has a slew of die-hard fans? They want you to do another Todd tune and I know of a tune that is truly custom-made for you to consider. He did a beautiful song on his first Runt album entitled Believe in Me. If you've never heard it, you're in for a pleasant surprise.
Yes, Tony. You are right on. Wailing Wall, Be Nice To Me and Marlene! They're all great. I like that you think Marlene is a neat song. Great minds think alike!
Hi, there, I really like your work. just wanted to tell you that it's weird because almost every song I searched on youtube(mostly beatles song, but others too) you covered them,, thx.
All I can say is; more power to anyone willing to do a cover of Todd's Marlene. I have never heard anyone else attempt it. WAIT TIL YOU HEAR THIS ONE TODD FANS. Thanks!
This has been flagged as spam show
Todd, Ry, Nils, Eric, Carlos and now you, have provided a perfect excuse not to learn. I could'nt do it better!
Exquisite.
deltanine100 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
deltanine100 2 weeks ago
my favorite song! done so beautifully! thank you!
lunasoffio 3 months ago
This is well good!
HandsomeMario 3 months ago
Very pretty troubleclef!
8doublehelix8 3 months ago
I just heard it a couple days ago and have played it over and over. Great arrangement.
lunatik9696 3 months ago
Fabulous... Keep it coming my friend....
Tony
primeent 4 months ago in playlist todd rundgren
nice.
tiowally 5 months ago
Your arrangement is fantastic. Really warm and well played. You have a very special talent: taking a song with vocals and multiple instrumental tracks and distilling it down to the essence and adapting it to a guitar instrumental. You are very good.
davejazzanova 5 months ago
@davejazzanova
thanks, Dave.
troubleclef 5 months ago
wow...Awesome...
I cant find the word to praise you
You are great guitar player
Kazz0929 6 months ago
thank you, very nice...
wolfgirlie52 7 months ago
really sweet - thank you!
jackdaddyfbomb 7 months ago in playlist Karioki
sounds like you love this song as much as i do...
badmuddy 7 months ago
very nice...
airethor 8 months ago
BTW, have you figured out We Gotta Get You A Woman? I am sure ou would play that beautifully.
1mrbuddyboy 8 months ago
@1mrbuddyboy
I haven't worked it out before, but i've thought about it. thanks
troubleclef 8 months ago
I am a huge Todd fan and just met him last week during a soundcheck in Atlantic City. Your rendition of A dream is fabulous.
1mrbuddyboy 8 months ago
I really should put the computer down and pick up the guitar. Excellent work feller !
johnnybadshirts 9 months ago
Wow, your arrangement seems to be perfect!
Estudiado 9 months ago
@Estudiado
I appreciate it. still working on it though. far from perfect! cheers.
troubleclef 9 months ago
Wonderful.
Punktowner 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I hope you don't mind...I just shared this on Facebook. Your rendition is hauntingly beautiful. I could listen to this all evening long. Thank you so much for sharing your talent with all of us!
meadowlarkacres 9 months ago
I hope you don't mind...I just shared this on Facebook. Your rendition is hauntingly beautiful. I could listen to this all evening long. Thank you so much for sharing your talent with all of us!
meadowlarkacres 9 months ago
@meadowlarkacres
no problem. thanks!
troubleclef 9 months ago
Absolutely beautiful. Thank you.....
I owe you - I've learned much from your videos. You're an amazing player - do you perform?
ChickPetersen 10 months ago
A wonderful arrangement of a beautiful song, awesome.
ronnieboy63 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great version man!
dmloehr 10 months ago
Great version man!
dmloehr 10 months ago
Very tasty, indeed.
u2b4dumeze 10 months ago
wow. nicely played. brings out the cool harmonic structure of the song.
flickedoff 10 months ago
Thank you for this, tears in my eyes. A wonderful arrangement.
Ahomocide 11 months ago
I teared up listening to your arrangement, thank you for this.
Ahomocide 11 months ago
One of my all-time favorite songs, and to say you did it justice is a huge understatement. I cannot say enough good things about your arrangement and your playing...really, really nice!!!!!
300Marlin 11 months ago
@300Marlin
thanks. i've been working to add the harmonies to this though. i think it can be better. cheers.
troubleclef 11 months ago
thank you for playing such a beautiful song..............im blown away and tears in my eyes
hateangie 1 year ago
This is so lovely :) Nice cover, really like it :D
putabananainurear 1 year ago
This is so beautiful, what a lovely arrangement. Many thanks for the upload, I hope to be able to play this well someday!
bzzshht 1 year ago
too good ..... A +
Fubishay 1 year ago
Oh My...there are no words to describe the smile on my face...you place this with a glowing soul ♥
brunosmom1000 1 year ago
@brunosmom1000
thanks so much
troubleclef 1 year ago
well done your friend todd
johnycrime81 1 year ago
That was...I wish I could play the guitar
HeavenlySmokes 1 year ago
good heavens you are good
jonesisdying 1 year ago
Well done!
Urbs59 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is just so beautiful.
aledw 1 year ago
Amazing guitar playing. Absolutely beautiful.
forestdweller958 1 year ago
An amazing cover of an amazing song. Thanks for posting!
xlrwrite 1 year ago
Time and again I keep returning to your rendition of this Rundgren composition,( one of his best works, I guess) and time and again I am stunned and keep just sitting still for a couple of minutes after hearing you play so sensitive. You 've given me a lot of precious moments, thanks!
netherworldman 1 year ago
Wow, great way to start a Saturday morning! You nailed it on this song. Adding to my favorites.
buciman16 1 year ago
My God, this is so good. Shame you don't have a tablature :( Your playing is so beautifullllll :) This was so easy on the ears. Keep on playing, good sir! If you ever have a tab, I'd love to have it sent my way :)
mcmigz1 1 year ago
Sweet!
opptynox 1 year ago
Thank you. I think I love you!!! Seriously, just what I needed tonight.
Spiritsoar60 1 year ago
6 ppl's dreams are limited
UnstableUranium 1 year ago
Thank you old man for your fantastic playing and more so for choosing this song.
I dunno why i love this song so much but hearing on a guitar made me fall in love with it again. Thanks again for all your effort
shihabullah 1 year ago
Thank you old man for your fantastic playing and more so for choosing this song.
I dunno why i love this song so much but hearing on a guitar made me fall in love with it again. Thanks again for all your effort
shihabullah 1 year ago
génial
PRTALL 1 year ago
That is my favorite song and you just nailed it! Nice job!
jamesleg 1 year ago
beautiful!
BflatBlue 1 year ago
This stuff makes me cry man. I would buy a cd of just you playing your guitar to Todd's more beautiful and romantic tunes such as this. It wells so much emotion deep inside of me. You are a wonderful player who obviously appreciates great music.
chungiemunchin 1 year ago 5
@chungiemunchin
thanks for all the views and comments. really appreciate it.
troubleclef 1 year ago
I told a muso friend of mine who knew nothing of Todd Rundgren's music, to check out this clip (and the original of Todd at the piano) and he thought this version was BETTER!!!! I am a HUGE Todd fan and I consider this rendition to be beautifully faultless. Great stuff.
navarablue1 1 year ago
@navarablue1
well....i don't know about the 'better' part. Actually i've worked from time to time to make this better by adding some vocal harmony parts but haven't ever put the finish on it. thanks!
troubleclef 1 year ago
@troubleclef
Thank you old man for your fantastic playing and more so for choosing this song.
I dunno why i love this song so much but hearing on a guitar made me fall in love with it again. Thanks again for all your effort
shihabullah 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@troubleclef
Thank you old man for your fantastic playing and more so for choosing this song.
I dunno why i love this song so much but hearing on a guitar made me fall in love with it again. Thanks again for all your effort.
shihabullah 1 year ago
@navarablue1
True, but its not Todd though.
Wulfrig 1 year ago
@Wulfrig - ah yes I cannot argue with that yet imitation is the sincerest form of flattery and Mr Troubleclef takes it to another level.
navarablue1 1 year ago
Wow-----This is a "beautiful arrangement" indeed....Nice work..."Andy Pandy" :)
MsAndyPandy18 1 year ago
Hey Beautiful...
XGibbo 1 year ago
Hey... beautiful!
XGibbo 1 year ago
Lovely version, of a delightful song. Well done! Good quality sound too.
RATM4LYFE 1 year ago
My apologies, Tony... didn't mean to call you by another name & the chords were sent to David. But my comments for you remain true, my friend! Be well...
UncleYul 1 year ago
@UncleYul
no prob, man. thanks
troubleclef 1 year ago
Such impeccable technique, David! A very, very worthy cover!
I had sent you the chords w/ lyrics, but the chords are bunched to the left side. I can resend in a pdf file formatted, just need another address. Send internally, like before, to keep it private.
UncleYul 1 year ago
absolutely fantastic!
alliboo05 1 year ago
@ swing8th Yes, troubleclef's arrangement seems to follow the chords found on online chord charts for this song.
Not sure if I've commented on this before, tc, but wanted to let you know that I'm really enjoying learning this from you.
ColdEyeCast 1 year ago
@ColdEyeCast
thanks buddy
troubleclef 1 year ago
The makes me Happy ... Thanks
P39SpaceModulator 1 year ago
that was a joy to watch and listen. You are a true artist
loservillejim 1 year ago
Top notch Todd arrangements! thanks for posting
rbassettjr 1 year ago
Top notch Todd arrangements! thanks for posting
rbassettjr 1 year ago
Beautiful.
twinsmm1 1 year ago
Excellent arrangement and well executed. Your timing was spot-on.
PocoPortillo 1 year ago
great playing. Todds a genius
arundelthomas 1 year ago
excellent!!! Never heard it played on guitar. Todds a genius!
arundelthomas 1 year ago
Man, that was actually really awesome. Great playing. I played the piano part to it just to see what it would sound like and everything was dead on. :)
officialmikethompson 1 year ago
Very nice , great inversions
gravano2 1 year ago
Outstanding
Bufflekill 1 year ago
such a beautiful rendition - thank you!!
the lyrics tell a tale of unspeakable loss and that loss for me is my precious son who was taken on his 25th b/d so if you dont mind I would like to dedicate this to Jordan.
You're so long ago and so far away
But my dream lives on forever
I guess i believe that i'll see you one day
For without it there is no dream
You're so far away and so long ago
But my dream goes on forever
And how much i loved you you'll never know
'til you join me within my dream
dudehorner 1 year ago
So much crap gets dumped on YouTube by talent-free individuals, but this acoustic version of Todd Rundgren's beautiful song is the exact opposite of all that. Really lovely, troubleclef. You've got the gift.
caraphyllis 1 year ago
made me cry - and i'm a tough guy - thank you.
bigdaddygeee 1 year ago
Excellent
UltraWhammy 1 year ago
A great moving cover of a great song, I can hear the lyrics as you play so sweetly.
TDGeneral 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Did I comment before about this? I forget. Just watched and listened again. I SOOO love this song, and wish my guitar skills were equal to your rendition; nice chord voicings.Have you given Todd notice of it? He'd love it too, I'm sure.
All is silent within my dream. :o)
PhosphorDigital 2 years ago
Comment removed
PhosphorDigital 2 years ago
man, I honestly love covers. This is great. Thanks.
blacktopaz8 2 years ago
This is so excellent! You have captured my best song of all time!...
scodwyer 2 years ago
you got it down....PERFECT! Take a bow!!
hunkylynch 2 years ago
Thou art become a God, i have waited a very long time to cry this hard,fucking beautiful,clef
baggiewon 2 years ago
That was great ..one of my favorite songs too, real nice job, two thumbs up :)
smizzman 2 years ago
beatiful work!
JeffVolve 2 years ago
Very nice! Thanks.
ithastobe 2 years ago
Outstanding! Very nice version.
danstyk 2 years ago
That was just beautiful .
AUGUSTALLEN28 2 years ago 7
Very, very cool!
trickhound 2 years ago
Bravo. Awesome rendition. Thanks for sharing.
rallyraces 2 years ago
Truly beautiful-Lots of appreciation from Jerusalem-Dr. Scott
scottclawrence 2 years ago
Awesome sound!
jakerandall123 2 years ago
very, very, very nice. is that in the original key?
swing8th 2 years ago
not sure. don't remember. i can check later
troubleclef 2 years ago
@swing8th ......Both in C....at least one of Todd's live performances here is.
toobmes 1 year ago
i agree
arundelthomas 1 year ago
@swing8th
arundelthomas 1 year ago
nicenice nice!
perfectly played I think
Smooth sigh ---
JoeChrisMorris 2 years ago
I usually don't listen to covers of songs that are this unique,but that was very well done!! Just lovely.
Nancyjean24 2 years ago
awesome! ur guitar work is stellar!!
krazeerichard 2 years ago
Whoa! Well done. Bravo sir! Wonderful arrangement of a wonderful song. I may have a go at this one myself if you dont mind me keep pausing your video to look at your fingers. I might send you my rendition in a couple of years. If I can master it that quick.
FreedomsPrisoner 2 years ago
go for it. it's really not that hard though. good luck
troubleclef 2 years ago
Simply georgeous. Shows off your talent and Todd's very well.
ShaynaTV 2 years ago
Incredible! Even more inspiration!
joejoeweekend 2 years ago
感激しました
Good JOB man!!!!!!!
sissyaihara 2 years ago
That is just fantastic. Well done and encore! (How about an acoustic version of 'Pretending to care?')
awizardatruestar 2 years ago
bravo.
theauthorishere 2 years ago
Man that was sweet!
teddypgray 2 years ago
Beautiful separation of voices. Keep up the classics. I love this tune!!!!
bkelly515 2 years ago
True magic
rubyfredo 2 years ago
Wonderful color in your playing. Great job!
drmmrboy59 2 years ago
I loved that so much! Very moving.
malvavisco10 2 years ago
Man, that was outstanding. You done Todd proud.
mddalefan 2 years ago
One of my favorite Rundgren songs. A lovely interpretation.
martinz60 2 years ago
Great job on this song. Love your arrangement of it.
ithastobe 2 years ago
awesome. This is one of my favorite songs, and you nailed it! Brought a tear to my eye :)
datbirdie 2 years ago
Brilliant. Thanks. Todd for Godd!
LoveWarplanes 2 years ago
Leaves me breathless, every time I come here to listen to this masterpiece.
You are great.
DirkjeA 2 years ago
Ooh this is so pretty :)
Thanks for sharing
candiikillz 2 years ago
uh.... wow!
boldwater 2 years ago
Very nice
zoomantony7 2 years ago
Oh,oh,oh, fanastic man. Thank you very much for lightening up my day by playing so sensitive.
Brilliant transition from piano to guitar of this brilliant rundgren song
netherworldman 2 years ago
Talk about grace notes! Beautiful!
slidenote 2 years ago
GOOD♪
yoshio8uemura 2 years ago
Nice Work keep going will go on forever
browns171 2 years ago
Great Job ...one of my favorite songs
smizzman 2 years ago
Rundgren is so under-rated. But everyone I know thinks I'm lame for liking him. Oh well...
Regardless, he writes a damn good pop song when he puts his mind to it.
QueenyMcfaggot 2 years ago
I don't see anything 'lame' in liking one of the very few rock artists to whom we can apply the term 'genius' without using that word in a very indulgent way.
sra97ster 2 years ago 2
I don't think people will ever realize how much Todd Rundgren has contributed to the music world and how many big name bands he has both produced and has led into super stardom, Hall and Oates being only one of those. This track by troubleclef is truly a beautiful rendition!
hueydog99 2 years ago 3
thanks one and all. TR is the man, that's for sure
troubleclef 2 years ago
@hueydog99 Thank you thank you 4 truly GETTING it!! (There are too few of us! ;))
catgirl6717 1 year ago
I don't think your lame, when I was 12 years of age I remember hearing "Hello, It's Me being played on a radio station, 96 Super Q I believe the name was, when I lived in Naples, Florida, and in an instant I became a Todd Rundgren beliver,
He writes and composes from the 'Heart', In fact Mr. Rundgren
is the only one that believed in the Meat Loaf/Jim Steinman 'Bat Out Of Hell' project, so if it wasn't for his insight and musical genius Meat Loaf would never have been.
kozmicsurfer 2 years ago
A beautiful rendition!
steveb4 2 years ago
What a nice surprise!
The song aquires an ornate latin feel.
My humblest thanks.
andreaprodan 2 years ago
*sigh* if only I could play this good someday. Well, I just started out and I play with a pick. Don't have a guitar teacher so i'm pretty much teaching myself lol. I'm trying my best to teach myself to finger pick, it seems so much more relaxing and nicer to listen to.
Tayoballs 2 years ago
yeah, fingerstyle is the bomb. so much more you can do with it than with a pick, imho. thanks. maybe check out a teacher in your area. it can help.
troubleclef 2 years ago
Nice, I've always appreciated fingerstyle playing. I'll definitely check out a teacher someday, but at the moment, money is a bit scarce, lame. I can't really take online lessons since I'm more of a, "Hands On" kind of learner. But none of that will stop me from practicing :)
Tayoballs 2 years ago
Great song choice .. Lovely original style . you rock .
peterm3964 2 years ago
Simply beautiful...
daldoc76 2 years ago
Sending this to my guitarman husband to learn ASAP..he knows how I love todd's music. you rock man..seriously. !!!1!
newsy8 2 years ago
OMG Thank you. Beautiful.
newsy8 2 years ago
Tasty
asktoms 2 years ago
very solid playing.
good taste
sabueso32 2 years ago
Beautiful song, beautifully done. Thank you.
guyaripwnz 2 years ago
Thanks for checking the comments. A true star!
Grantalonus 2 years ago
Show off! That was great! You should jam with Todd!
Grantalonus 2 years ago
he never returns my calls (chuckle chuckle). thanks
troubleclef 2 years ago
todd should call you trebleclef and enjoy the way his
composition is caressed by your heart and fingers.
todd's bright light shines on
we enjoy it's glow.
kidderminsterbro 2 years ago
you are very good! Thanks for posting
mlqcmw 2 years ago
Had to come back and listen again.
davidlanghoff 2 years ago
Just tremendous. I am a Todd fan since the early 1970's. That was beautiful. I am so jealous (in a good way) of your skill and artistry. Thanks alot.
davidlanghoff 3 years ago
thanks.
troubleclef 3 years ago
Tony, have you gathered by now that Todd has a slew of die-hard fans? They want you to do another Todd tune and I know of a tune that is truly custom-made for you to consider. He did a beautiful song on his first Runt album entitled Believe in Me. If you've never heard it, you're in for a pleasant surprise.
fadguru 3 years ago
thanks. Yes that's a great song too. I think there's a number of lesser-known gems that would work. Like "Wailing Wall" and "Marlene" for instance.
troubleclef 3 years ago
Yes, Tony. You are right on. Wailing Wall, Be Nice To Me and Marlene! They're all great. I like that you think Marlene is a neat song. Great minds think alike!
fadguru 3 years ago
my version of Marlene is about finished. just need to get a couple things fixed and post a reasonable take of it. thanks again.
troubleclef 2 years ago
Hi, there, I really like your work. just wanted to tell you that it's weird because almost every song I searched on youtube(mostly beatles song, but others too) you covered them,, thx.
sky860716 2 years ago
that's weird, man. I'll try to anticipate your next search.....
troubleclef 2 years ago
(that's weird, man. I'll try to anticipate your next search.....)
=====
talented AND funny? no fair..
guyaripwnz 2 years ago
All I can say is; more power to anyone willing to do a cover of Todd's Marlene. I have never heard anyone else attempt it. WAIT TIL YOU HEAR THIS ONE TODD FANS. Thanks!
fadguru 2 years ago