Added: 3 years ago
From: joumannoe
Views: 40,681
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (153)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • looks like roger waters haha

  • Dude wats with the voice change an also ur chord sequence is wrong its g, c, d, am, g, d, c, am then back to g then repeat i do like the solo the way u change between the two but the 2nd solo dont sound rite, check mine out no singing on mine tho ha ha keep rockin dude

  • the SOLO doesnt sound like that ant its not the real tabs for the solo

  • Einstein bien atento ..

  • I like your voice but you changed to lower octave at one point. You could play a 2nd guitar on a separate track? (I've done that myself although not great)

    Cheers

  • I liked it.. but what about that switch voices ?

  • don't smile so much next time :)

  • cool u mixed both guitar parts

  • OMG david gilmour live@youtube xP #not

  • Buy a tablature book for that song because its not really close to the original.

  • ummmmmmm...... the guitaring was excellant, but maybe a different singing part...

    2.5/5

  • haste schön gemacht....

  • Omg...amazing cover.

  • I seriously thought i was looking watching David backstage for a minute! I like your guitars tone. nice job. Check out my cover!!

  • guys you should check out MIKE ZUBI 's version here on YOUTUBE. worth a listen!!

  • Damn you ARE David Gilmour .....but just because of the face

  • the solo is completely wrong

  • You look just the same as David :P

  • really nice voice but the guitar sounds like its being strummed to hard or maybe its just the camera?

  • sounds great !

  • schööööön ;-)

  • Comment removed

  • pretty good :)

  • too fast but still rlly nice

  • no rifas la neta,

  • too fast m8 but still good job

  • you go so fast

  • i liked it man not the same but still good job u know i like guitar and wish i could play like you but i dont get it jejejeje lazy u know bue congrat man nice job

  • wow! very good!

    dont pay no attention to the other guys below me.

    this is one of the best covers ive heard. you have talent dude.

  • you fucked up this song man and  jake 62194 is right you discraced the whole band

  • not very good

  • dude u suck balls!!! worst cover ever!! ur a shame to david gilmour and pink floyd

  • this is a fuckin' shit cover... there are some errors at the guitar and the voice is without any emotions and it's not a good voice... please don't play this song again!!!!!!!!

  • if you can play better .lets here you.Or shut the f..ck up

  • no emotion

  • i find he looks a bit like David Gilmour :D

  • just a bit too fast but great job man

  • yeah break the guitar!!

  • some improvisation in solo. but nice

    only too fast

  • Hahaha your voice went from like kinda David Gilmour, to Johnny Cash... haha nice

  • hey you don't need to smile for do that men ...from a person that plays guitar men i know how good you are....really good

  • Too fast, slow down. And why do you change voice

  • Great.

  • Wow, very nice!

    If you smiled, you would have made this feel alittle more happier, just saying...

    Nice cover though, nice voice though

  • its not a happy song anyway

  • exactly right!!

  • it was kind of sloopy in the beginning of the sollo but you cleaned it up nice job!

  • david gilmours brother???...i think u are into sience...the photo on the wall and ur mood tells it all..lol...quickly finish it and go to the lab...a test tube might blast..

  • Why So Serious????

  • almost..haha.

  • Einstein is looking at me!!!!

  • hehe xD

  • slow down a little... i think thats what make the song so heartfelt. theres no rush.

  • luv that thin acoustic... is it funner than a fat back ?

  • what is the rush ...... everyone plays it so darned fast.. cant enjoy

  • Great cover. you are playing really fast though. The song is supposed to be soft and comfortable. it would sound much better if you brought the tempo down a little and strum a bit softer.

  • I enjoy the cover alot. Just one bit of constructive criticism - I believe the attack is too much for this song. You're strumming with a really strong attack. If you strummed gently with quieter dynamics I think it would sound much better. Most floyd is very soft and comfortable, especially this song.

    Thumbs up though.

  • you look just like David Gilmore

  • great!!! 5*****

  • Man, I've never seen anyone play so mechanic as when you played that solo.

  • too fast

  • wow you look like david gilmore

  • sounds fantastic, ps: you look a litle bit like david gilmore now. Great performance. chris

  • nice cover. What's with albert in background lol

  • you not very good, me i am best and i speak in french (quebec)

  • relax and feel it, uv got the skill just slow down the solo a bit and it'll be perfection!

  • great job man.

  • he has david gilmour's face!!

  • lame pic on back there ,,, he is "so-what" face  hahahahhaha

  • These guys are too knit picky. You did great man, took the song and made it your own - thats real music imo :) Keep it up, your real good!

  • u need more practice.

  • no offence, i mean this in advice. you need to get a metronome , you keep speeding up and slowing down in the intro then go slow in the verses, also relax abit your too cramped together, music is about how you feel for it and show passion. i dont mean tht in a bad way, great voice btw

  • ok NICE TRY ! .... but MORE slowly the frist solo plz!

  • wow, great cover. 5 stars, i also covered it.cheers chris, stay tuned

  • WOW you are david gilmour

  • Really good.

  • Good job for sure, the intro doesn't sound exactly like it tho good tho.

  • dude d name of dis black beauty....it's sooo beautiful...

  • BOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • nice....amazing

  • Relax, and take it easy on your guitar, its not a drum. It is a nice guitar. Don't change the pitch of your voice so much. Nice try anyway.

  • good job...i like your try go on...:)

  • stop beating that guitar up!! don't change octives when you are singing. a lighter touch on that guitar will produce an even better sound.

  • way too fast and u added some nonexistant licks in there cant understand wat ur singing hardly and u jumped octaves it was kinda poopy. but for the guitar skill u get a 3/5. and yes to all u silly gooses out there who are gonna get all mad at this comment, I can do it better hahahahahahaaa look out for me i just have to get a USB chord that fits my camera and Ill prove it. view CurtisJ89's Channel. OI! OI! OI!

  • that is a beautiful sounding guitar. how much did it cost?

  • JAJAJA te pareces a David Gilmour... Buena

  • Excelent!!

    so good man

    congratulation!!

    nice one song!^^

  • You could play it so much better with few pills to slow you down! beautiful sound of the guitar btw! check out my version which is bit more chilled out like the original! good job!

  • too fast mate but a cracking job

  • You gotta a bit of a David Gilmour look to ya.

  • you look angry man ! why ? you rule.

  • gilmour or jim gaffigan

  • bravo

  • too fassttt.

    smile :)

    awesome guitar skillzz though :D

  • A tid bit monotoned with the vocals, but your guitar skills are amazing..

  • great sound.. but too fast lol.. GOOD JOB =)

  • ovo nista ne valja da jebe majku :-((

  • awesome cover, u look a bit like gilmour, if u dnt mind me saying

  • Dude, you look a lot like Gilmour.

  • lol he does

  • nice playing, and i think he actually sortof resembles David Gilmour!

  • heres a free lesson get some rythm or quite music

  • Sweet55lucy, here's a free lesson...learn how to spell or sell your computer. LOL

  • i hope his a fucken joke lol bc i dont even play guitar i play bass and picked this song up in like 5mins perfect its fucken easy as shit but also an amazing song but u fucken killed it

  • Great, just slow down a lil.

  • very good in the guitar ,and tha voice ..ejem..ejem...good intencion...but very good video,

  • wooww nicee ! :D

  • great!

  • nicely done aye

  • nice cover fav pink floyed song

  • its good but YOU NEED TO SLOW DOWN a bunch

  • yoy look like david guilmor.....great keep on!

  • dude slow down!

  • you sound great! you should slow down a little too

  • wayyyyy too fast

  • It doesn't sound all that bad, but you did it rather hurriedly, especially on the intro solo.  Not bad, though.

  • i noticed a couple of times you can't decide to go to C or Am...i always do that lol

    keep it up mate i appreciate people putting good covers on

  • BARRENT JEJEJE

  • AMAZING!! cover. my favorite song :) i have that cover too but my cover is noob ;D

  • wow, i like it. thanks for watching, you play like david gilmour. and look like him.(now)

  • woah woah slow down!

  • Mate, where's the the fire?, what's the big hurry?. This was just about average and you look more like the picture of Albert behind you than David Gilmour

  • your are quite good nice vioce and guitar playing

  • you make that solo look good all smooth

  • :O :O :O

    Its amazing ! ! ! ! ! !

  • you look like gilmoure

  • Are you brother of gilmour??..rs

    i like it

  • this is good. i liked it

  • great cover, to me it sounds like the tempo jumps

  • great cover, THx

  • MUY BUEENO LOCO!

  • lmfao long lost twin

    good job though :)

  • This is lovely.

    Very well done.

  • woah its David Gilmour's brother!

  • LMAO.

  • Nice...very nice

  • HIS BROTHER

  • great song

    great cover

  • check out my version please comment

  • Good guitar, the singing is kind of shaky. But I'll be damned if you don't look like david gilmoure.

  • Agreed! The resemblance is uncanny!

  • Amazing m8

  • nice

  • Hi!!!! Wonderful guitar!!!! Great playing!!! This is a Washburn Nuno Bettencourt Platínum EA22 Greeeat!!! Do you know anything about the WASHBURN EA10MB it looks like yours!!! Help me!!!!!! SALUT FROM BRAZIL!!!!!!

  • thats pretty good i played that song with my band. hey check out my vids and tell me how i did

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more