Tere Bin - Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan featured in 1999 film Kache Dhaage

[parrybal]

thumbs up if u love this song!!!

[rajendrajhariya]

Ustad ,  esa koi nhi Nusrat Saheb jaisa .

[sourav100rav]

yaar who mixed this version of nfak g!!! who done this video??? who produced this one.... this video is of remix version!!!

[akiiii1]

ritee ye song copy nahiii hai , ye nusrat fateh ail khan ki composition hai or usy Lata ji ne gaya.

but

hum bhool gaye har baat, & main jis din bhula dun tera pyar

copied by lata ji .

[akiiii1]

ritee ye song copy nahiii hai , ye nusrat fateh ail khan ki composition hai or usy Lata ji ne gaya.

but

hum bhool gaye har baat, & main jis din bhula dun tera pyar

copied by lata ji .

[kctrace]

is it just me or is that Johny Lever at 2:49

[nasirkhar80]

wonderful..



[tugay2003]

wo kann ich so ein intro machen

[TheKtiwana]

great

[adityapant]

That's not the point. This song is always referred to as composed by Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. He had finalied this song to be used for the film and signed on Lata Mangeshkar to sing it before he died. After his death Uttam Singh just recorded the song. Uttam Singh's name does not appear as the composer of this song in the film. In addition, Khan Saheb had composed 6-7 other songs for the film most of which were recorded after his death

[spsyed]

In anticipation of your new comments, I already said the due credits are not cited whenever the composition is played and archived on the media platforms (i.e YouTube, links, radio/TV etc) for the current and the future generations of consumers and historians. That is the legal point here for the global YT-Google archives for millions all over the world.

[adityapant]

First up, Lata Mangeshkar is a singer not a composer. So whenever her songs are played, no one from the current or the future generations should think that it is her composition. whenever her songs are played on the media, the composers are always identified. A copy is something where a person takes up someone elses composition and passes off as one owns. If a composer wants some other singer to sing his own song, how can the singer be accused of copying?

[spsyed]

In this particular case, there are hardly any refs on Lata Mangeshkar (on YT) following (copying) the original Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan (NFAK) composition. As a legal eagle and broadcasters, I know that most broadcasters dont give due credit to NFAK. Lata, also known as Anand Ghan, composed music for five films; received the best music director award, and made four films since 1950. So she is a bit more than just a singer.

[adityapant]

True that Lata Mangeshkar has composed for a few Marathi films, but that was years ago. She is primarily a singer. She sings compositions of different composers. She has sung songs composed by more than 170 composers, out of which Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan is one. I just don't understand how you can say that this song is 'copied' by Lata Mangeshkar. Here Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan hires her to sing his composition, and you accuse her of 'copying'. Weird!

[adityapant]

I wouldn't say that the song was "copied". The music of Kachche Dhaage was credited to Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, although he died before recording the songs from the film. Uttam Singh arranged and recorded the songs of the film after Khan saheb's death.

[spsyed]

Thank you, AdityaPant, for your comments. Legally speaking, a copy is a copy, with or without the due credit, even if "arranged and recorded" after the ostad Nusrat Feteh Ali Khan sahib passed away. The due credits are not cited whenever the composition is played and archived on the media platforms for the current and the future generations of consumers and historians.

[siffar]

@spsyed I've never came across any upload/media which does not cite Ustad jee as composer of this song.

[spsyed]

@siffar , thanks for sharing your experience.