This man is over the top fantastic. I love Johnny Contardo. He and Gene Pitney were in a league of their own. It just upsets me that Johnny as a solo artist did not have the same impact as Gene. And Gene didn't have the same impact as other less talented solo artists. Go figure. Timing has a lot to do with it.
The version I remember is them dressed up like Romeo and Shakespeare days. When they sang "Who who who". they would stop the song and do some ridiculous comedy skit before continuing the song again.
For any who may be interested: Sha Na Na first released this song on the excellent 1974 LP, "Hot Sox", with Jocko Marcellino on lead vocals. They redid it the following year, with Johnny on lead vocals, and a distinctly disco-esque flavor to the instrumental track, on 1975's "Sha Na Now". This performance sounds like it falls in between the previous 2, even though it was recorded 4 or 5 years later. Johnny also hit that high note on both album versions (& a couple higher ones on "Sha Na Now").
@wonteach I never understood it either. Bad management? I agree, he is one of the best tenors in the business. Sometimes people get pigeoned holed and I think that's what happened to Johnny. He was considered a cover artist because he was in a cover band. He did covers better than the originals. Why it didn't work out for him solo, I will never understand. However, he is the voice of Sha na na and that's no drop on the bucket.
@Tonithenightowl Hi tonighthenightowl just read your comment that Johnny was considered a cover artist ... absolutely staggered ... fools across the pond as well as here in U.K. ...just goes to show what idiots are out there in the music industry ... a big con. We recognise quality when we hear it. Stuff 'em . MM xx
@Medina29able Yes, I think that was the problem. Why he didn't go back to Broadway is beyond me. He was in Boston Broadway before SNN. Music was in a transition when he came out with his first solo album. Disco was dead, A new 80's sound was on the rise. Apparently the album did not reflect this. Did he give up too soon? Probably. This lead him to reject show biz until his fans drug him out once again. And I'm glad they did. Yes, fools bc they had a prize and didn't see it.
This man is beyond compare. Better than the original but doesn't he do that with every song he did? He's like watching a broadway production everytime he sings and moves.
Thanque Kryste, they did it twice, as this track does full justice to the original by The Reflections. Their original studio cut was a let down, considering how they could often ( - but not always) 'Improve' on the originals they covered.
@TheMerchantOfDeath37 Wow!!! Talk about timing so to speak. Here was a band that did Elvis songs and to be at their concert on that night well, talk about sentimental. Did they know he had passed and did they make mention? I would have loved to see them back then. I'm sure it was electric to say the least. I only ever got to see them on TV. I hope you saved something from that concert lol.
I'm on it right now!! I would make a joke but some people are SO touchy, wait touch, Johnny ,another joke!! We both got thumbs down on our Johnny comments. How funny is that!!
love the music and the group but i never ever want a love like romeo and juliet i will not commit suicide of some damn man hell no most all men are worse than hound dogs on a juicy bone they just are not worth it i do wish that true love were real but its not and never will be
Great song! I believe it is their best. I think the album is SHANANOW. I used to have the LP. Also like Flash Cadillac just as well. Some of their stuff is on CD. Johnny was fantastic. In those days, they had great singers, now days, only a few!
I always listened to Sha Na Na as a kid and really enjoyed them. Until watching some of their videos on Youtube the past couple of days, I never realized how truly great they really were.
I think it's one of the best covers ever done period I can listen to them all day too! I think Johnny was one the very best group singers ever. He DID look more than a little like Billy Crystal; and he sounded more than little like the great and phenomenal Johnny Mathis. Johnny and the group did, I think, do a slower, more melodic, and even better version of this song. The arrangement, I recall, really show what good musicians the band was. Can anyone find ANY recordin of this?
IF you love SNN as I do you can go to their official website and under LINKS at the bottom is a link to Sha Na Na Fan Pages by Cheryl and then on her site there is a link saying "HELP GET THE SHA NA NA VARIETY SHOW ON DVD!"
you should see clips ofhim performing now. there's one of him with bowser at mohegan and holy crap did contardo get old! he's still good but it makes you appreciate him at this time. the man had SKILLS.
I wish I could find, or someone make a copy of the 45 rpm version that played on the radio in the 60's or '70s. In that version, they are backed up by a full orchestra, and in fact, the recording begins with strings, heavy drum beat and horns.
Anybody familiar with this version? It was not on the album, the above version was.
I posted a 45 of the song on the 12th of December. Nothing fancy about the video, just a picture of the Kama Sutra label on the record while the song is playing.
I posted a question about this last week and someone replied that there's a lot of "red tape" involved with getting license for all the songs. **sigh** I wish they'd work it out because if they did I would buy every single DVD they put out!!!!
Johnny Contardo, what an incredible voice (not to mention body!). Such a cute lil' hottie he was back then! More scrumptious than any piece of bacon that Ive ever seen!
Very good observation. Yes, he's a little older now, but still very good looking and in very good voice. Not to mention, a very nice man. I got to meet him about three months ago; I'd see him again in a heartbeat!
@coyclown Yeah, I love Johhny's voice. IT is so gorgeous. I used to watch this show all the time and I always wanted him to sing! I had the biggest crush on him. :-)
There was quite a bit of talent from Sha Na Na. They all could sing pretty good. I remember watching the show and waiting for them to get through their comedy skits and just sing.
I wasn't commenting on the choreography. I think that Johnny Contrado had the best Doo-Wop lead tenor voice bar none. I also love the Reflection's version.
I know what you were commenting. I do agree that Contardo does have a great Doo Wop voice, he also backs up Santini's lead on their give on "Stay." Maybe we best agree to disagree to which is the better version, The Refs' or SNN's. I bought an LP called Hot Sox
which covered JLRAJ and was fast like the Refs'. The other LP SNN made in 1975 had Johnny doing a slooow melodic take on JLRAJ. :-)
Just wondering if they ever did this song more than once on their show. I seem to recall a version where Johnny is carried at the end of the song. Am I imagining this or was that something else I'm remembering?
They did it twice. =) You're not imagining it. It was a skit version of the song and Johnny was dressed up like Romeo and did, in fact, get carried away at the end.
Thanks for letting me know. I was very young when the show was on and wasn't sure if I was remembering it right. And another big thank you for posting all of these for us!
Johnny was shooting the dice. Bowzer was in the first group with the money; he, among others, was the guy in the middle covering his ears when Johnny hit the high note at the end.
Wow! Johnny Contardo catapulted me right into adolescence following this segment of the Sha Na Na show! Thanks for the memories, Johnny, and thanks so much for the video, faerydancer.
God! I remember when this show was on every week. What a great memory from the 70's (The show I mean) Thanks for posting this. Sha Na Na was so entertaining and talented.
I've always loved Johnny best, too, but Denny and Santini were no slouches in the vocals either. I also liked Lennie a lot. They're all a very talented bunch of guys, really. About Johnny's extra pounds, I think it's safe to say most of us have added some in 30 years. I found it was just all the more to hug!
Not only can I agree that I too have gain weight in the last 30 years, but look at Jon. He had to gain weight. He could not have gotten any skinnier. He may have gotten carried away with the weight, but so have so many of us.
EU VOU CONHECER ELE COM CERTEZA! AMOR!
MegaSajs 2 months ago
Johnny Contardo was HOT, HOT, HOT, HOT, HOT!!!!!!
Nemesis7293 3 months ago
@Nemesis7293 still is xx
noosmum 1 month ago
What a great singing voice this cute has, he looks like Billy Crystal
hidoll22 11 months ago
@hidoll22 Yes, one of those "separated at birth" things... the resemblance is amazing.
kb6kgx 9 months ago
What a great singing voice this cute has
hidoll22 11 months ago
This track cane from the album Hot Sox. I had it on vinyl but it has long disappeared. Can't seem to find a copy of it anywhere. Anybody help
boydweddell 1 year ago
@boydweddell Try amazon dot com, they have them new and used.......
kasagar 1 year ago
This man is over the top fantastic. I love Johnny Contardo. He and Gene Pitney were in a league of their own. It just upsets me that Johnny as a solo artist did not have the same impact as Gene. And Gene didn't have the same impact as other less talented solo artists. Go figure. Timing has a lot to do with it.
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
The version I remember is them dressed up like Romeo and Shakespeare days. When they sang "Who who who". they would stop the song and do some ridiculous comedy skit before continuing the song again.
GarthanSaal444 1 year ago
Wow, seems like yesterday that they did this on their show. I even remember the woman hangin' out the window.
doowopper1951 1 year ago
@doowopper1951 Jane Dulo
chrisst41 7 months ago
For any who may be interested: Sha Na Na first released this song on the excellent 1974 LP, "Hot Sox", with Jocko Marcellino on lead vocals. They redid it the following year, with Johnny on lead vocals, and a distinctly disco-esque flavor to the instrumental track, on 1975's "Sha Na Now". This performance sounds like it falls in between the previous 2, even though it was recorded 4 or 5 years later. Johnny also hit that high note on both album versions (& a couple higher ones on "Sha Na Now").
MegaNothin 1 year ago
Sha na na kicks butt!
belladeballe 1 year ago
@belladeballe Wow! they just kick me.
buddyeagle 1 year ago
@buddyeagle LOL
belladeballe 1 year ago
I don't understand why Johnny Contardo never made it big as a soloist. He had one of the most beautiful voices I ever heard.
wonteach 1 year ago
@wonteach I never understood it either. Bad management? I agree, he is one of the best tenors in the business. Sometimes people get pigeoned holed and I think that's what happened to Johnny. He was considered a cover artist because he was in a cover band. He did covers better than the originals. Why it didn't work out for him solo, I will never understand. However, he is the voice of Sha na na and that's no drop on the bucket.
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
@Tonithenightowl Hi tonighthenightowl just read your comment that Johnny was considered a cover artist ... absolutely staggered ... fools across the pond as well as here in U.K. ...just goes to show what idiots are out there in the music industry ... a big con. We recognise quality when we hear it. Stuff 'em . MM xx
Medina29able 1 year ago
@Medina29able Yes, I think that was the problem. Why he didn't go back to Broadway is beyond me. He was in Boston Broadway before SNN. Music was in a transition when he came out with his first solo album. Disco was dead, A new 80's sound was on the rise. Apparently the album did not reflect this. Did he give up too soon? Probably. This lead him to reject show biz until his fans drug him out once again. And I'm glad they did. Yes, fools bc they had a prize and didn't see it.
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
@Tonithenightowl Many thanks for that insight. Very interesting. Good night.
Medina29able 1 year ago
Can those pants get any tighter Johnny?
Not that I'm complaining or anything ;)
melanie8771 1 year ago 2
Just heard the reflections do this. Johnny takes it to another level. What a voice.
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
This man is beyond compare. Better than the original but doesn't he do that with every song he did? He's like watching a broadway production everytime he sings and moves.
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
Ah... those golden oldies <3
promisedeyes 1 year ago
Thanque Kryste, they did it twice, as this track does full justice to the original by The Reflections. Their original studio cut was a let down, considering how they could often ( - but not always) 'Improve' on the originals they covered.
lensman55 1 year ago
JOHNNY COULD HAVE BEEN A REPLACEMENT FOR FREDDIE MERCURY WITHOUT EVEN TRYING KUDOS JOHNNY
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
Man, I saw these guys in concert in 1977, the night Elvis died. They were amazing. Neigh, incredible.
TheMerchantOfDeath37 1 year ago
@TheMerchantOfDeath37 Wow!!! Talk about timing so to speak. Here was a band that did Elvis songs and to be at their concert on that night well, talk about sentimental. Did they know he had passed and did they make mention? I would have loved to see them back then. I'm sure it was electric to say the least. I only ever got to see them on TV. I hope you saved something from that concert lol.
Tonithenightowl 1 year ago
ok Johnny has a nice butt lol so does Danny but hey lol
savcdosavcdo 2 years ago
@savcdosavcdo Yay for Danny's butt!!
roguejulie 1 year ago
I have it downloaded...I watch it every day...lol
sweetipie1965 2 years ago
Adam Lambert needs to take lessons from JC
sweetipie1965 2 years ago
No kidding! You must see You Belong To Me. Sexy!!!
SkippyWalls 2 years ago
Every tenor needs to take lessons from JC!!!
65wendym 2 years ago 2
I want to see Sha Na Na! My mom was a HUGE fan of theirs since the late 60's and early 70's! RIP!
countryrockstar2008 2 years ago
I want to meet Johnny Contardo!!!!!!!!!!
vseas3 2 years ago 9
Johnny was a doll then and he's a doll now. Check out his MySpace pics.
tuppy20 2 years ago 2
Thanks for the info. I never thought of myspace and all I can say is WOW!!!! He just gets better with age. Why doesn't that happen to us women?
SkippyWalls 2 years ago
Comment removed
tuppy20 2 years ago
I'm on it right now!! I would make a joke but some people are SO touchy, wait touch, Johnny ,another joke!! We both got thumbs down on our Johnny comments. How funny is that!!
SkippyWalls 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i heard he is heavy set now?what happened to him since the brake up
scorzeny45 2 years ago
I want to meet Johnny Contardo!!!!!!!!
vseas3 2 years ago
Me too!! Would give up everything I own to meet that guy!!
tuppy20 2 years ago
Was johnny a puerto rican or italian?
scorzeny45 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Does it really matter?
SpiritBear12 2 years ago
love the music and the group but i never ever want a love like romeo and juliet i will not commit suicide of some damn man hell no most all men are worse than hound dogs on a juicy bone they just are not worth it i do wish that true love were real but its not and never will be
immaguardian 2 years ago
Great song! I believe it is their best. I think the album is SHANANOW. I used to have the LP. Also like Flash Cadillac just as well. Some of their stuff is on CD. Johnny was fantastic. In those days, they had great singers, now days, only a few!
norwaymale 2 years ago
I always listened to Sha Na Na as a kid and really enjoyed them. Until watching some of their videos on Youtube the past couple of days, I never realized how truly great they really were.
floyd76 2 years ago
Nice to see "Dirty Dan " taking a bigger part.
SkippyWalls 2 years ago
I think it's one of the best covers ever done period I can listen to them all day too! I think Johnny was one the very best group singers ever. He DID look more than a little like Billy Crystal; and he sounded more than little like the great and phenomenal Johnny Mathis. Johnny and the group did, I think, do a slower, more melodic, and even better version of this song. The arrangement, I recall, really show what good musicians the band was. Can anyone find ANY recordin of this?
Msmusic53 2 years ago
johnny's got a remarkable voice. I could listen to these guys all day.
j20tower 2 years ago 3
I would also buy eveything... Dreaming....
cevc918 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
IF you love SNN as I do you can go to their official website and under LINKS at the bottom is a link to Sha Na Na Fan Pages by Cheryl and then on her site there is a link saying "HELP GET THE SHA NA NA VARIETY SHOW ON DVD!"
I wrote my letter... PLEASE WRITE YOURS ☺
msdemme2 3 years ago
I agree, best ever and I too would buy every DVD probably the day they were released!!
SkippyWalls 3 years ago
Best cover of this song ever!
gnolt 3 years ago 3
Bowzer!
Mentallyawake568 3 years ago
It's Adam (Ant) and Marco.
Write it on a pound note, pound note.
And Burl Ives on saxaphone.
I watched this show every Saturday night back in the '70s, it came on right before Space: 1999 and the Muppet Show.
ShawnWolfe 3 years ago
you should see clips ofhim performing now. there's one of him with bowser at mohegan and holy crap did contardo get old! he's still good but it makes you appreciate him at this time. the man had SKILLS.
vlunney 3 years ago
Great song - incredible lead singer. 5 stars *****, and a new favorite.
goldenoldiesPete 3 years ago
I wish I could find, or someone make a copy of the 45 rpm version that played on the radio in the 60's or '70s. In that version, they are backed up by a full orchestra, and in fact, the recording begins with strings, heavy drum beat and horns.
Anybody familiar with this version? It was not on the album, the above version was.
bigdaddy28638 3 years ago
I posted a 45 of the song on the 12th of December. Nothing fancy about the video, just a picture of the Kama Sutra label on the record while the song is playing.
BLP1261 3 years ago
Thanks so much. That's exactly the one I was looking for!
bigdaddy28638 3 years ago
it was sung by The Reflections.
fwad23 3 years ago
Christa Mighty...please give us the DVDs. How much do we have to beg?
bikibitr 3 years ago
I posted a question about this last week and someone replied that there's a lot of "red tape" involved with getting license for all the songs. **sigh** I wish they'd work it out because if they did I would buy every single DVD they put out!!!!
kangadillo 3 years ago
Johnny Contardo, what an incredible voice (not to mention body!). Such a cute lil' hottie he was back then! More scrumptious than any piece of bacon that Ive ever seen!
coyclown 3 years ago 16
Very good observation. Yes, he's a little older now, but still very good looking and in very good voice. Not to mention, a very nice man. I got to meet him about three months ago; I'd see him again in a heartbeat!
angelsavage73 3 years ago
NO,THAT';S BILLY CRYSTAL
4463013 3 years ago
LOL!!! THAT is NOT Billy Crystal. OMG Thats hilarious!
coyclown 3 years ago
He does look like Billy Crystal, which is certainly not a bad thing. They're both cute!
kangadillo 3 years ago
@coyclown Yeah, I love Johhny's voice. IT is so gorgeous. I used to watch this show all the time and I always wanted him to sing! I had the biggest crush on him. :-)
TheCelestial108 1 year ago
this song is one of my all time favorites and I'm PISSED NO CONTESTANT HAS EVER done this for American Idol!!
vlunney 3 years ago 2
We loved watching there show every week.
almightywhitey 3 years ago
"Bill Brasky named the band Sha-Na-Na. They did NOT want to be called that!"
Sorry, I had to. Seriously, this is great! Did they have a show at some point? I'm clueless...
snidelywhiplash 3 years ago
yeah and Bill Brasky is #4 in AP College Football Poll!
Paulgr 3 years ago
There was quite a bit of talent from Sha Na Na. They all could sing pretty good. I remember watching the show and waiting for them to get through their comedy skits and just sing.
rlgdguy 3 years ago 2
This version is even better than the original Reflection's version!
fwad23 3 years ago 2
Better? Maybe the choreography makes it appear better but that is merely aesthetic. It rates second to the Reflections' in my book forever.
elveez54 3 years ago
I wasn't commenting on the choreography. I think that Johnny Contrado had the best Doo-Wop lead tenor voice bar none. I also love the Reflection's version.
fwad23 3 years ago 2
I know what you were commenting. I do agree that Contardo does have a great Doo Wop voice, he also backs up Santini's lead on their give on "Stay." Maybe we best agree to disagree to which is the better version, The Refs' or SNN's. I bought an LP called Hot Sox
which covered JLRAJ and was fast like the Refs'. The other LP SNN made in 1975 had Johnny doing a slooow melodic take on JLRAJ. :-)
elveez54 3 years ago
faerydancer: thanks so much for posting these Sha Na Na videos. They are really good!
donnys1girl 3 years ago 2
Just wondering if they ever did this song more than once on their show. I seem to recall a version where Johnny is carried at the end of the song. Am I imagining this or was that something else I'm remembering?
angelsavage73 3 years ago
They did it twice. =) You're not imagining it. It was a skit version of the song and Johnny was dressed up like Romeo and did, in fact, get carried away at the end.
faerydancer 3 years ago 3
Thanks for letting me know. I was very young when the show was on and wasn't sure if I was remembering it right. And another big thank you for posting all of these for us!
angelsavage73 3 years ago
do a search on here under Johnny Contardo, and they have the sketch!
65wendym 2 years ago
Johnny has a wonderful voice.
donnys1girl 3 years ago 2
Was that Bowzer shooting dice?
OboxerU 4 years ago
Johnny was shooting the dice. Bowzer was in the first group with the money; he, among others, was the guy in the middle covering his ears when Johnny hit the high note at the end.
angelsavage73 4 years ago
Can't wait to see both Johnny in Philly and SNN in PA and Vegas!!
tandybraid 4 years ago
Wow! Johnny Contardo catapulted me right into adolescence following this segment of the Sha Na Na show! Thanks for the memories, Johnny, and thanks so much for the video, faerydancer.
nytrayfl 4 years ago
God! I remember when this show was on every week. What a great memory from the 70's (The show I mean) Thanks for posting this. Sha Na Na was so entertaining and talented.
DanielRidener 4 years ago
Johnny was always my favorite too. I haven't seen any of the guys in ages. What fun to watch!
angelsavage73 4 years ago
love this song!
kittykat1216 4 years ago
Johnny was easily the very best vocalist in Sha Na Na. It's nice to see he is still singing, although he sure has packed on the pounds!
Genkimark 4 years ago
I've always loved Johnny best, too, but Denny and Santini were no slouches in the vocals either. I also liked Lennie a lot. They're all a very talented bunch of guys, really. About Johnny's extra pounds, I think it's safe to say most of us have added some in 30 years. I found it was just all the more to hug!
lorjokr 4 years ago
Not only can I agree that I too have gain weight in the last 30 years, but look at Jon. He had to gain weight. He could not have gotten any skinnier. He may have gotten carried away with the weight, but so have so many of us.
jenbanter 3 years ago
It was great to hear him sing this last year, after not singing it for 20 years! He hit every note perfectly!
sangria4 4 years ago