The idiots with the negative comments have no idea of what they speak of. I'm the biggest of Journey and Perry and I thought she had NO chance to pull this off and she DID for the 1:30 time she had.
Yeah, she did a good job. Lost a bit of the lyrics. The worst about this rendition is the country flavor added to it musically. She could sing it however she wanted, the musicians failed by abandoning the adult contemporary feel that the song so needed and would have complimented her voice more advantageously. I think Idol failed her on this piece.
wow. i never paid attention to this girl until at least top 8. I cant believe i missed this performance. she sang this song rly good but nothing compares to Steve Perry
One of the hardest songs to sing live! When I heard she was doing this song at the time of watching the show live, I figured she was going to go belly up in the surf. She actually did a great job on the piece. Obviously, she wasn't prefect, but I would have loved to hear others make an attempt. You would hear a lot of folks that sell many millions of records fall flat on their face with this in a live setting. She was actually one of the best on the show and she proved it this night.
What! How come I don't remember this?! Maybe it just didn't stand out; back when she sang l this I'd never heard of Journey =] I looooove this song, though!!! She actually didn't sing it too bad either! <333
I'm sorry guys but I LOVE her singing this. I thought she did great on this song. I actually can't get enough of listening to it. I think her voice sounds good & strong. Great job on this Kristy!
She sang the song well the only thing lacking as the high note. I remeber a friend who didn't care for her at the begining turn to me after that performance. She said Kristy has a nice voice. Nonetheless, Kristy had brochitis what do you expect. She improved alot since. Search here on the tube for Kristy lee Cook national anthem. She did an amazing job singing the anthem.
I don't want to bash her because she tries her best and that's great but it wasn't very good. I don't believe she has star power... I liked one of her later performances though.
She was sick here with brochitis. I noticed she got better top 11 onwards. She's a good singer great voice although its not shown here. Her lower register is on key throughtout the song it's just the higher notes. Like I said she had brochitis.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
ouch, that's the worst redition I heard of that song. There is a 10 year old fat boy clip singing faithfully that I can stomach better than this. too much drag on the words and the notes are too steep for her voice.
This has been flagged as spam show
I like this version, I really do, I don't like how American Idol does things though, little work to smooth out the bumps and this is a HIT!
rockstar6302 1 week ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I like this version, I really do, I don't like how American Idol does things though, little work to smooth out the bumps and this is a HIT!
rockstar6302 1 week ago
I like this version, I really do, I don't like how American Idol does things though, little work to smooth out the bumps and this is a HIT!
rockstar6302 1 week ago
her voice defines awesomeness!
jaxxxprincessfull 4 weeks ago
Beautiful Kristy LEE! Love it and you sure killed it girl! great job!
tammyjammy1 3 months ago
she is awesome...like haleyy
jasonsinanan 3 months ago
The idiots with the negative comments have no idea of what they speak of. I'm the biggest of Journey and Perry and I thought she had NO chance to pull this off and she DID for the 1:30 time she had.
ditkoasmpages 7 months ago
she akways had the ghettoest nails lol still good tho
vacant7andie 7 months ago
She sounds like LeAnn Rimes.
SelenaGomez00007 8 months ago
nice voice but it was a terrible attempt. I really don´t like it.
MrRenatol 9 months ago
Shes good...I didn't care for her because I was into Carly mainly, but she has a nice voice.
crystalrain87 1 year ago
Yeah, she did a good job. Lost a bit of the lyrics. The worst about this rendition is the country flavor added to it musically. She could sing it however she wanted, the musicians failed by abandoning the adult contemporary feel that the song so needed and would have complimented her voice more advantageously. I think Idol failed her on this piece.
roger9065 1 year ago
she was kinda pitchy when she when high, which ironically what she looked like at the end when she sang the last "lly"
thequipper89 1 year ago
i miss the season 7 so much...very talented season
bozjpop 1 year ago
great song, but it needs to stay classic, not country -,-
Tempclanleader 1 year ago
shes so hotttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt
bstate16 1 year ago
I think she knows how to sing great but she uses her vibrato for too long like on every note lol
DAVO360 1 year ago
This is def a hard song to do for a girl, so I give her props.
BUT no one can replace Steve Perry,
but they found the new guy right here on youtube, so he must be doin something right.
SaraMeganSCartist 1 year ago
Sharp voice... my ears hurt but she's talented.. good job girl...
killerblade007 1 year ago
good singer, nice version of this song, plus she's one pretty girl.
julianbrown1092 1 year ago
TERRIBLE
realityfreak29 2 years ago
This was her best performance, after this she stopped picking songs that suited her voice, this was good
wjs1710 2 years ago
kristy-lee cook omg im blown away ur my idol ily
emilia223 2 years ago
im a big fan of kristy but arnel sings it by a mile!
mnlsantacruz1 2 years ago
wow. i never paid attention to this girl until at least top 8. I cant believe i missed this performance. she sang this song rly good but nothing compares to Steve Perry
zjmadman 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
god she sucked
TheAerosmithLover 2 years ago
P.S. Steve Perry was alone at the top of all male vocalists that have ever recorded rock/pop music.
ditkoasmpages 2 years ago
One of the hardest songs to sing live! When I heard she was doing this song at the time of watching the show live, I figured she was going to go belly up in the surf. She actually did a great job on the piece. Obviously, she wasn't prefect, but I would have loved to hear others make an attempt. You would hear a lot of folks that sell many millions of records fall flat on their face with this in a live setting. She was actually one of the best on the show and she proved it this night.
ditkoasmpages 2 years ago 5
It's not as good as the original, but really, nobody could really compare with the original. She did a good job.
pokethunderdude 2 years ago
-puke-
thezachman 2 years ago
What! How come I don't remember this?! Maybe it just didn't stand out; back when she sang l this I'd never heard of Journey =] I looooove this song, though!!! She actually didn't sing it too bad either! <333
TwilightGurl1618 2 years ago 2
She's good ...But NOthing compares To arnel PIneda in this song...
judelaborte28 2 years ago
Haha don't try to do the Perry
Swemba 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
*throws up*
I'm sick from watching this video.
Journey Killer.
xANABOLlCx 3 years ago
I'm sorry guys but I LOVE her singing this. I thought she did great on this song. I actually can't get enough of listening to it. I think her voice sounds good & strong. Great job on this Kristy!
Stacestang 3 years ago 15
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Dammit, way to ruin one of my favorite songs.
satinangora 3 years ago
She sang the song well the only thing lacking as the high note. I remeber a friend who didn't care for her at the begining turn to me after that performance. She said Kristy has a nice voice. Nonetheless, Kristy had brochitis what do you expect. She improved alot since. Search here on the tube for Kristy lee Cook national anthem. She did an amazing job singing the anthem.
dolphinstravel 3 years ago 3
its also ment to be sung by a guy not a girl... she accually had to switch the word "girl" into "love"
spanishfat 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ruined a classic....
spanishfat 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trashed it
ix3a7x 3 years ago
this isn't her best performance...but i love herrrrrrrrrr
scherwynne 3 years ago
She needs to work on her range, but her ability to hold a strong note is excellent. I think she has a future.
Oafah 3 years ago
I don't want to bash her because she tries her best and that's great but it wasn't very good. I don't believe she has star power... I liked one of her later performances though.
LittleCloserBoi 3 years ago
She was sick here with brochitis. I noticed she got better top 11 onwards. She's a good singer great voice although its not shown here. Her lower register is on key throughtout the song it's just the higher notes. Like I said she had brochitis.
dolphinstravel 3 years ago
how do you know she had bronchitis?
bantaboxer6432 3 years ago
She me mentioned it in an interview, She said she was sick with brochitis and was painfuk on her throat at the time to hit the big notes.
dolphinstravel 3 years ago
I don't think its a bit shouty in the end part. Just like it, that's all.
imlance 3 years ago
As someone who can't stand KLC's voice, this was a better cover than most of her songs. Got a little shouty at the end, so it ended pretty weak.
hadxxenough 3 years ago
horrible
mikelmn 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ouch, that's the worst redition I heard of that song. There is a 10 year old fat boy clip singing faithfully that I can stomach better than this. too much drag on the words and the notes are too steep for her voice.
helisalazar10 3 years ago
lovely. i love kristy's tone!
ledhicks 3 years ago 8
10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000% wonderful
kelliepik 3 years ago 3