Added: 3 years ago
From: ZQanimefan
Views: 71,017
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (321)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i loved prim-- spot on:)

  • i totally agree with ur decisions. and megan fox for katniss and

    charlie hunnman for peeta

    loved loved loved your choices for cinna, prim, and haymitch especially.

    but dakotta fanning as rue is a nonono

  • effie and haymitch are perfect but dakota fanning and megan fox arelike a nonono

  • I love, love, LOVE your pick for Cinna, but I thought Rue was supposed to be black? Or at least tanner? The book mentioned that she had dark skin, I think.

  • the movie is coming out in 2011

  • i like it... i just really hope they nvr turn it into a movie

  • i know it's just the modern harstyles and clothes, but they're all too perfect. some of these people (like Catnip) need to be more rugged and less beautiful. they look... pampered. which is NOT the style of the book. but hey, weith a new wardrobe and some messed-up-ness you could be onto something.

  • i agree, some are a bit too old..

    but i really like who you chose for Cato.

  • hmm not really how i pictured it but i like your opinion....

    although i do think some of these actors are too old to play these characters

  • i like Charlie as peeta since he has blonde hair

  • Most are pretty good...but Clove? Well, I can't imagine Taylor Swift killing people by throwing knives at them. But, I think your choice for Katniss was perfect!

  • omg i totally agree espcially on some of them like cato, haymith and peta. although i think you should of picked darker skinned people for thresh and rue

  • rue is supposed to be really small and have dark skin and black/ brown hair but other than that good job!

  • I would put Channing Tatum as Thresh instead... but other than that, nice job!

  • i deff. prefer camille over meghan fox, she looks more like a katniss (povertish but tough) meghan just looks to 'sleep with me'. i also prefer charlie over kevin for peeta. kevin looks more Gale. I lovedd pretty much everyone! esp, haymitch and katniss's mom. true, we never 'see' katniss dad but brendan frasor would be perfect! he's good at the father roles lol. i love how everybody is picking hugh dancy for cinna. lol

  • Jared is too much of a pretty boy to be the huge, powerful thresh

    sebastian has that evil stare that cato has but i was thinking more of the guy off of never back down- the antagonist. i dont remember his name

    glimmer is perfect

    i always imagined fox face as a ginger lol

    didnt rue have blonde hair

    sienna guillory is a good choice

    i dont think brenden fraiser fits

  • Cinna was way off, and megan fox looks right, but is too old

  • not megan fox. shes to old and too pretty

  • yeah i think they could work.. they come close to what i imagine from when i read the book.

  • she means Clove the one who tried to screw up Katniss's face!

  • i see camilla bell, although megan is prettier, she seems as the better "impoverished" leading lady...

    charlie has the better build for peeta

    gale- can you say perfect?! :)

    haymitch- couldn't picture a face but jack would definitely fit the part!

    effie- that's how i pictured her

    glimmer-great

    prim-I LOVED IT!!!

    rue- definite no sorry....

    but the rest are decent

  • DEFINITELY HOW I PICTURED ALL OF THEM!!!

    awesome job!!!

  • I don't think kristen would be right, she just doesn't seem to have that kidn of character. Not saying shes not good shes just doesn't fit what katniss is supposed to be. A lot of these people are good, but way too old! dakota fanning is way too old for rue, and shes not really quite small and sweet enough. rue needs to be played by someone really young. The girl for prim was quite good but i think maybe she needs to be blonde. just my opnions I love

  • Camille definately, no offense to anyone who likes Megan Fox but i think she looks like too much of a sl*t too me

    Kevin Zegers for peeta is pretty good but Peeta was supposed to have ashy blond hair He's actually more like Gale in my opinion

    Gale - Gaspard: eh, don't think so

    Haymitch: PERFECT!

    other tributes: not how i imagined them. Rue and tresh definately not, too old. Cato and Foxface very good

    Prim: NO not how prim was described. she has blonde hair.

    Katniss mother: REALLY GOOD

  • thats how i pictured effie:D

  • CAMILLA no question.

    u got cinna and haymitch, spot on but i thought rue and prim should switch too

  • love the cast except for rue and haymitch

  • A lot of them look too old. They'd probably do a good job, but remember that the games are for people like 12 - 18...

  • some of them i didnt really see but most of them i could see perfectly!!! but i think that foxface should be that french girl from harry potter 4

  • Holy Shit !! thats exactially how i pictured peeta. (but with blonde hair... and the first dude.)

    And Gail !! + Haymich ( but w/ more hair )

    and Rue has Dark skin-so dakota...?

    i pictured Thresh like kelan lutz.

    lol. its a really good video. u hav good opinions.

  • i love your choice for gale!!!!

  • Effie is perfect! Lol. But most of them look to old... (Aside from Haymitch)

  • I like all the secondary cast, but don't know about Katniss or Peeta, I think Kristen Stewart would do a good job. My favourites are Haymitch and Rue and Prim, those are absolutely perfect! Good job mostly though.

  • I like all but no megan fox, I don't like either for Peeta or foxface the rest are good though ^^

  • i totally agree with gale, effie, and cato.

    though, i always imagined kristen stewart as katniss.

    p.s. isn't it Clove, not clover?

  • I think that the guy you suggested for Gale, at least from the pictures, looks younger than who you suggested for Peeta and IF Megan Fox does Katniss. She's almost too hot for the part though. I think Camilla Belle would be better in playing Katniss. The other stuff is good. Not a big Dakota Fanning fan, but I admit she'd do good

  • i agree, i love megan fox, but she's too pretty

  • I like how you included ALL of the characters, most of the other videos dont really include the minor roles. I definetly like your casting roles for all of them, except for clove. Taylor swift just doesnt look right for the girl who hinted she traded sex for the privlige of killing katniss

  • yea i agree but personally i think prim and rue should switch and jonny depp should play haymitch. he would do a great drunk rutine(jack serrow).

  • I always imagined Katniss and Peeta as darker skinned. Like Mexican-American type.

  • Cato and thresh need 2 luk more mean and stronger luking in my opinion.cuz thats the way they wer in the book

  • i think dakota fanning is too old and tall to be rue. and it's clove, not clover. not trying to be rude, though. The rest was perfect, except for effie in my opinion

  • Thoes people would be great!! I just think you might wanna switch dakota fanning as prim cuz prim's blonde and have Aieral Winter play Rue....

  • i always pictured glimmer as blake lively...

    LOL, I should make one of these.

  • katniss is perfect!!

  • the girl you sugested  for prim I think is perfect!!!!

  • Reall cool cast!

    I think Sterling Knight would be perfect for Peeta, he just just like how I imagined him.

  • Wow perfect... with some stage work, wig/dying, etc, they'd be SO perfect. All of them.

    It's just that I personally hate Megan Fox so much...but I agree with you, she looks similar to the Katniss I imagined too.

  • camilla belle would own as catniss megan fox is hot but wouldn't be able to pull it off... i can't for the movie to come out like in 2 years buy woo

  • aww hugh dancy as Cinna!! i <3 it! :D

  • at first i didnt know but, when i think about it, taylor swift would make a good glimmer, but she would be in-practicle for some one who is shown so seldomly and then dies from tracker jackers

  • btw its clove, not clover and fyi rue has dark skin, didn't y'all read the book?!?!?!?!?

  • all those people that you have previewed , i have to say, are exact peeopel i would have pictured them as:)

  • i think this would probably be the closest to how i pictured everyone,especially peeta and katniss.

  • well they are sixteen, i think they look okay thats about how old i pictured them.

  • haymitch shoulldn be him but effie white an dprim (exept he rhair color r chouces

  • they was pretty good except rue and thresh were supposed to be dark skinned

  • omg i picutered megan fox as katniss too!!!! and like everyone else the same way... oh and luv the song mcr is ahmazing really good vid....

  • WEIRDDDDDDDDDD....i pictured peeta the exact same way!

  • I HATE THIS

  • I HATE YOU SO FUCK YOU

  • i like charlie hunnam as peeta

  • u tell him

  • hmmm, those were pretty good choices, i could definitely see them...

    my friends and i were just talking about who would play whoh and we automatically thought of dakota fanning as rue :)

    jack nicholson...lol

  • i know that they're supposed to be relatively young but I DID imagine Katniss as Megan Fox the whole time!! super weird you had her as the star..

  • i think it would have to be all new actors who arnt known for other movies except for like the older people

  • Rue is dark skinned...

    i thought i read that in the book...

    correct me if i'm wrong

  • no, ur right.

    what is annoying 2 me is how everyone wants dakota fanning or her little sister to be rue, when they are both rly pale.

  • I like Bonnie Wright as Foxface. She plays Ginny in harry potter.

  • Good choices. But I think that all the actors should be a LOT younger. What makes the books so... compelling and creepy is the fact that it is about teenagers and kids who have to go through this awful game. It wouldn't be nearly as terrifiying if the players were older.

  • kevin zegers is brunette fyi peeta is blonde u know

  • yh i know, kevin zegers is naturally blonde so i'm sure they would change it.

  • I have to disagree with with both actors you posted as Katniss. They seem to old and are nothing like I imagined. I don't agree with either actors you chose for Peeta as well. Dakota Fanning as Rue seems kind of off for me. I pictured her more of a Brunette rather than a blond. I don't know why... Thresh and Glimmer I also don't see. Ariel Winter should be Rue in my opinion.

    But other than those I agree with the other actors/actresses you chose

  • i picterd them all alot younger

  • I think it would be har seeing Megan as Katniss. She looks too much like a super-model type and no offense but I can't see her acting as a 16 year old.

  • megan is too hot to be katniss. kat seems like a ugly girl.

  • yesssss

  • and i think that every body for the teenagers should look a little younger, you know , with out the rough beard

  • i think rue should be switched with prim for cast

  • Comment removed

  • okkkkkkkkk u were saying that peetas hair was curly and i said straightly flipped to tick ppl off but was kidding and gis isnt curly it i sin waves so ya i no u remember

  • ok. cool. i now understand.

  • now that i think about it i think if i saw a movie with (spoilers!!!) i warned ya)

    Rues death i would cry

  • I would too. I actually cry every time I read it... maybe a little lame, but true.

  • I like it some of the hair is the wrong color

    But nothing Dye cant fix that would be a good cast

  • The only ones that could work are Haymitch, Cato, maybe Glimmer, definetely not Clove, and maybe Foxface.

  • i think that is a good thresh but thats the only one i really like

  • thresh was crap hes supossed to be huge and buff not just some pretty face

  • NOT U..... Spid3rGirl we were arguring bout what peeta's hair is like

  • yes thank u im not a fricken retard i just say that to piss ppl off im a huge fan of peeta as u can see so i would no and u wouldnt and at least i can do something rite unlike u !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • what the hell did i do? i don't even remember.

  • I have no idea what you are talking about. I am also a huge Peeta fan, so I would also know what he looks like. I don't understand your comment about me not being able to do something right. WTF!

  • And it's Clove not Clover, just FYI

  • the person you chose for cinna is exactly how i imagined him too

  • u ppl r so mean to each other

  • Too bad everyone will be to old to do this when the movie actually comes out...

  • the music is terrible and you should be a nicer person and not swear at people you should not make videos anymore or you could make a new account

  • ummmmm..... peeta has straight flipped hair not curly and telling Spid3rGirl

  • "ashy blond hair that falls in WAVES over his forehead" page 25, last paragraph. I do not call waves "straight". they are far closer to curly.

  • i like camilla belle

  • The only ones I can actually see working are Prim, Cato, Effie, and Katniss's mom. Sorry but the others don't really fit to well, I mean they're not supposed to look like supermodels. Just an opinion, though.

  • i think haymitch should be hugh laurie from house

  • i think that was an awesome cast choice & pictured them something like that too.

  • I have a VERY different imagination!!!!!

    But i think Agnes Bruckner would be good as Clove and Taylor Swift would be good as Glimmer and i also think Dakota Fanning would be okay as Prim and Ariel Winter would be good as Rue.

    Well, that's somewhat my imagination.

  • Also, My chemical romance sucks

  • OK, im sorry (oh, no im not), but you suck! Peeta has CURLY hair, Rue and Thresh are BLACK, Prim looks like their mom, Brendan Frasier is the CRAPPIEST CAMPIEST actor ever and that girl who you picked for Katniss cant act for SHIT! Also, have you even read the book?! The girl from 2 is CLOVE not ClovER!!! STUPID!!! The one thing i do agree with you about is that epic is a shitty word so, how can I put this without using it... YOU SUCK!!!

  • Its called HOLLYWOOD.

    they can make people look like the character..thats #1

    #2 is if you think this cast sucks go make your own.

    #3 why are you wathicng this if you HATE all of the ppl and think the cast SUCKS?

    seriously.

  • Hi lame person. Are you protecting the person who did this abomination because you know them or just because you have ABSOLUTELY no life? I was watching because I was curious to see if it was possible that it be done right. Also, I will not make my own cast because I have this thing called an imagination, it means that my perception of characters is NOT based on Hollywood. I am against making movies out of books, so I will not encourage it.

  • Hi, I didn't have enough room the finish my response. So, here goes: Finally, Hollywood can make changes, but it is not at all organic and anyone who is smart enough can easily, I could get really into this subject, but it's probably a little too complicated for you. So, thank you for responding, I hope to hear from you soon.

  • OMG anyone has the right to post what they want and if this is the way they picture it thats fine. May you're own video if you don't like it. Stop being a A-hole

  • Yes, I know anyone has the right to post anything, that's why I'm posting a comment! =) Hypocrite. So, I don't know if you've read all of the comments I've written, but I've already said I do NOT want to make a video because I have an IMAGINATION and do not believe in movies based on books. And I'm not being an A-hole (by the way good job censuring yoursel), I am merely stating my opinion, which, as you said, anyone can do. Thanks or stopping by!

  • You're just plain rude.

    You know th-- oh, i think you do.

    My mistake.

    Go get a life.

    Whats that? Huh...so your life is just going on here a posting lame comments

    about you hating this persons cast.

    i have on word for you: W-O-W.

  • Ok, I'm not "just plain rude", I am aloud to have my own opinion and express. Did I ever say this person should not have posted their video? No. So I am simply expressing my opinion. Also, I do have a life, you know absolutely nothing about me except for the fact that I disagree with this persons cast and am not afraid to state my opinion, so stop making assumptions about me.

  • Again, not enough room to finish my comment. So Ill leave you with this thought: IF my "life is just going on here a posting lame comments

    about hating this persons cast.", yours is going around posting comments about hating me.

  • I never said I hate you.

    I just dont like negative comments

    about someone else's imagination-stuff

  • Well, it sure seems like you do. Also, I am aloud to have my own opinion and state it.

  • Apologies. I replied as JennyJones. I was in the wrong account. That reply is mine.

  • ok.

    and yeah u are allowed to state ur opinion.

    Like i said, i just think its rude to just go and diss everything and not find one good thing.

    its like..why did u bother wathcing it then if u dont like it?

    anywyas...w.e

  • I was watching it - as I have already stated - to see if it could be done right. Clearly not. And here, if you would like something good I found. I thought Katniss's mom could work. MAYBE. Happy now?

  • Rue and Thresh are not "black" they have tan skin

  • You are right, they are not black but they do have dark skin. My apologies for the mistake.

  • okay ...dean is from gilmore girls...its the same thing as jared..hahahaha

    and umm RUE IS BLACK!i!i!i!i!i!i!i!i!i!i!i!i!­i!i!i!

    EPIC fail

  • i have no clue what the fuck your tlking about. and i don't care if rue is black or not, i imagined her this way, so get over jackass. and epic is a horrible word. so razorblade penis you in the ass bitch HAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!! :P FUCKERS

  • UGH CAMILLLA BELLE IS YUCKY. and megan fox is too girlie. Peetas buff with blond hair so the second guy is preeety much perfect. i hate that gaspard guy, too.

    the girl who you picked for prim would be good fir rue, though !

  • i so agree with cinna rest .......

    can uu plz tell me the song

    thx

  • thnks and the song is in the info. ppl should try looking at it some time

  • You were waaay off with some of the characters like Rue, and Thresh, Peeta and Katniss, they were all too old and didn't match the descriptions in the book, but others were PERFECT! like Cinna and Prim! and DEFINATLY Haymitch! Good Job!

  • thnks....i think

  • but all the others exept katniss and peeta r good, exept the persont u thought for glimmer shood be katniss and the first person u thought for katniss shood be glimmer,

    glimmer = megan fox

    katniss = agnis bruckner,

    and dekota fanning is good but needs to die her hair brown of black,

    taylor swift is not an actress,

    but she wood fit,

    omg the person u picked for prim wood be soo good i think she cood need a bigger part, and i think that the rest to what i have said is perfect

  • tayler swift is a coming 2 b actress she was in th@ csi show remember she played the girl who was killed by her mother (adoptive mom) she played hayle (im bad w/ spelling so please dont comment on th@)

  • all too old

  • i pictured peeta with blondeish/brown hair. and KAtniss a little less preppy. and with a dark tan.. i don't know :S lol

  • this is perfect!

    but i think cato is bgger and prim has more blond hair.

  • Megan Fox is WAY too hot to be Katniss. Katniss is suposed to be tough.

    Kevin Zegers is way too old to be Peeta. And, Peeta's blond. The other one works kind of, still too old.

    Gaspard Ulleil would be PERFECT as Gale. Good choice :).

    Rue is dark skinned. Dakota Fanning isn't.

    Cato is supposed to be big and tough. Sebatian doesn't have that appearance.

    Foxface is supposed to have a foxlike face (woah big suprise). this actress doesn't have it.

    FIX THE DAMN AGES OF THEM. FAIL!

  • And Megan Fox is way too old.

  • haymitch, effie and glimmer are perfect but i don't like rue or foxface. that's my opinion though.

    LOVE THE VIDEO! :D

  • LOL like ok... Rue i think shouldnt be Dakota Fanning and the other ones i think u got 100% lol espeicially Haymitch. The thing about Katness as Megan Fox is great cuz the mom and here look related.... That was great! xD

  • great job some are totaly off but other than that perfect

  • ariel, i think, would make a good prim (: COOL VIDEO!

  • haha .... thanks for sharing (:

  • you pick bad people and ADAM LAMBERT IS A GOOD GALE

  • u r a bad picker u should not make videos  and u shuld be nicer to people and u sweared at my friend ADAM LAMBERT ALL THE WAY ANTHER GIRL SAID HED BE A GOOD GALE

  • wow thats so crazy to see how other people imagine them.. i enjoyed that even tho most of them arent what i imagined, but thats the beauty of books... thanks for sharing

  • it was clove. all in all it was great if ariel winter was a lil older lookin she would be great fer rue the only one i dont like is dakoda fanning for rue or anyone

  • lol, nice casting! i pictured rue younger though...=]

  • I though it was Clove, not Clover.

    :P

  • Ithough it wad Clove, not Clover.

    :P

  • a lot of these are good. Some i find a little too old(like Camille) and the other girl for Katniss you chose seemed too seductive haha. I think ALEX PETTYFER would make THE BEST Peeta ever! its how i imagine him at least so take a look :)

  • Wow....Most of them are perfect!

  • i thought thresh and rue were black for some reason... especially rue. i love charlie hunnam for peeta and ariel winter for prim! the song Your Guardian Angel by Red Jumpsuit Apparatus is AMAZING for this book!!

  • camilla belle i think would be better for katniss cause meghan fox seems to pretty. katniss to me while reading the book was more ... average in looks? i dunno.

    gale here is perfect!

    for haymitch, these choices are good but i think jeremy irons would be AMAZING for playing haymitch.

    i loved these choices for rue, foxface and prim and katnisss mother. they were wonderful ! :)

  • Comment removed

  • great ideas for the cast, except for Rue.

  • *sigh* that's what everyone says>_> WOULD YOU ALL STOP COMPLAINING!!!!!!!!!(not tlking directly to you)

  • woot! Jared Padalecki :D

    i guess he'll be an okay as Thresh but i love Jared from Supernatural <33

  • fuck off asshole

  • Comment removed

  • just, no. The only good match here was haymitch

  • sry, why did you bother commenting if you didn't like it?

  • cause i loved the book, and there is officially a movie coming out sometime late next year, and I wanted to see if your ideas were good, but they werent.

    I didnt know it would be good or bad till i WATCHED TEH VIDEO!

  • well sry you didn't like it, there is no guarantee you will.

  • okay, first off let me say im sorry.

    but this totally sucked.

    this like half ruined the book for mee.

    i dont think thats what they would look like at all.:p

  • how did i ruin the book for you? it's my opinion and you have yours. so i have to words for you: SUCK IT

  • i think you did a great job

    although i think some of these actors/actresses are a little too old to play the tributes

  • I imagine Saiorse Ronan playing Katniss, but after much thought, I find her too young for the role.

    But Camilla Belle and Tom Sturridge would be amazing together. LOL.

  • that looks like haymitch gale

  • I liked the Gale match up. Thats how i imagined him looking

  • thnks^_^ me too obviously lol

  • i like most of these except the first few, but honestly- i dont want anyone to make a movie..i think they'll mess it up

  • i think rue is black

  • i liked almost all of them, they looked just as i imagined them...

    except, prim is blonde... and dakota fanning is too old for rue, she is supposed to look the same age as prim,

    besides that, it was great

  • yh but i always thought that katniss and prim looked like their dad for some reason, and she is so tiny and fragile like prim is. and dakota is too old to play rue, but if she was a little younger...

  • 2:12 and 3:02 BLOOD AND CHOCOLATE!!!!!!!!!! I totally love ur picks!

  • wait...you imagined these people in your head while reading?Didn't you imagine your own people??

    Well...Atleast you had Gaspard Ulliel in there...but I can't say I agree with your choices...because I didnt imagine blonde haired actors where in the book they had brown...but..

  • DEAN CANNOT PLAY THRESH!

    NO DAKOTA FOR RUE

    HUGH JACKMAN AS HAYMITCH

    KATNISS.. MEGAN

    PEETA HAS TO BE CHARLIE

    CATO SHOULD BE BUFFER

    ....I SERIOUSLY DONT KNOW WHY YOU WOULD HAVE TAYLOR SWIFT AS HER...CAMILLE BELLE SHOULD PLAY CLOVE..

    AND COME ON ITS NOT CLOVER!!!!! clove!!!!!!!!!!!!! CLOVECLOVECLOVE!

    PRIM SHOULD BE RUE!

  • 1)there is nothing that says you will be satisfied with my choices 2)i didn't say dean as thresh, that is jared padalecki who plays SAM, get it right 3)i chose dakota for rue b/c that's what i chose.

    and if you don't like it then i rly don't care. so this is what i say to all your rude remarks FUCK OFF

  • ..somehow i get where your coming from but as for the slight spelling mistake (clove-clover) - who cares??

    if you have so many changes, you might aswell make your own vid for ppl to watch

  • i agree, they were on the old side, but i love Jack as Haymitch!!

  • they are all too old! i liked haymitch and effie

  • yes i liked haymitch and effie too. They really did look like the characters.