I think I still kind of prefer the original (probably because I'm so used to it). But this guy is amazing! I love the way he put his own spin on it, it's like a completely different song! he is truly fantastic.
My favorite Collins will always be Jesse L. Martin, but I think Michael McElroy does a fantastic job capturing Collins' laidback attitude and immense capacity for love.
i love how during Mark's part, when he calls her a Drag Queen, she looks at him like, wtf. When he calls her a she, she looks and smiles like, "Thaaats better ^^"
Makes me cry every time. This musical has touched and helped me in ways no other show (play or movie) has; and I'm only 16. Just goes to show this musical is timeless and for every generation.
i LOVE jessie martin as collins. but Michael McElroy blew me away. his ability to convey emotion in just the slightest change in tone makes the moment all the sweeter. i actually got teary eyed when i saw this performance.
You can't compare Michale and Jesse they are both amazing preformers who protray colins diffrently, but at they same time they both do it wonderfuly! I personly like jessie better but Michale is an extreemly talented preformer as well.
@broadwaybeat How can you judge him by his riffing? singing solely what's on the page is not always the best approach. It's ok to experiment with things like that.. The greatest singers do it lol.. The nerve of some of you people
@broadwaybeat once again everyone has their own take on how they would perform this song... I'm sure you would perform it one way and I would another but no version is greater than the other or less emotional
I can't stop watching it!... OMG! When Gwen comes in, it's just mind blowing!... "SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO with a thousand sweet kisses"... Give me chills man!
I hate to admit... because I love the original cast... but I think he's a bit better:) GAH! I never cry during like movies or anything... I cried like a baby at the end of this!
Michael McElroy is a great performer and master musician. No one on Broadway has done more good for more people with less publicity. A fine human being.
@Treaclewheat THIS IS THE TRUTH. He's currently one of my professors at NYU, and the people he brings into class/the connections he has are ridiculous: he knows everyone and has the respect of everyone in the industry, and yet seeks no praise or anything for it at all. What an incredible man and teacher.
yall gave me chills GREAT WORK !
KantGhet3nuff 1 day ago
I greatly appreciate the lack of clapping and cheering from the audience.
yummyelves777 1 week ago 2
this guys song was so sad. he was great
Rsheetz86 2 weeks ago
No way ... he lacked voice in the end ...
srssyn 3 weeks ago
This is the best Collins ever. Kiss his ass Jesse!
MrDisneyCats 1 month ago
I'm so sad the broadway show's over! I never got to see it! :(
Sure I've seen a couple college productions, but I always wanted to see this on Broadway
Bugsy99 1 month ago
@Bugsy99 It's back on Broadway!
musicismylife9781 1 day ago
@musicismylife9781 It's being revived off-Broadway
Bugsy99 1 day ago
I just can't handle this. Brilliant.
pathlessandwild 1 month ago
If you press the snow button it makes it even sadder
EvaFab3 1 month ago
Oh God, there isn't language barrier when the subjetct is love. Clovis ,from Brazil.
clovis744 2 months ago
The empty space left in the line for Angel...SO SAD! :'(
OneSongGlory8 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
Is this Cast still showing????
vosejpkaman07 3 months ago
@vosejpkaman07 No. This was the last show.
VideoMask93 3 months ago
@vosejpkaman07 the show isnt showing anymore. this video is closing night. almost 2 yr ago.
rosieforst 1 month ago
his vocal control is unbelievable......
tre103 3 months ago
I have no words.
WithoutAnAnchor 3 months ago
@3:46 its just AMAZING, You feel in hurt and pain and need to tell angel "i'll cover you" one more time <3
ALLIELUVS21 5 months ago
Im Performing in Rent at the moment, and i have to say that this song is the one that makes me cry:/
singerbbz 5 months ago
I think I still kind of prefer the original (probably because I'm so used to it). But this guy is amazing! I love the way he put his own spin on it, it's like a completely different song! he is truly fantastic.
broadwaydude2378 5 months ago
He performed this song better than anyone.
LegitBenDustman 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Man I So Wanna Play The Role Of Collins. Im lowkey Jealous
BHSPLAYER23 5 months ago
Man I So Wanna Play The Role Of Collins. Im lowkey Jealous
BHSPLAYER23 5 months ago
writing a death scene to a story while listening to this and just about bawled my eyes out.
Jenivi224 5 months ago
awww eden is crying at the beginning.
beingtooweird1997 5 months ago
much better than the original which says alot since i love the original
tovahtovahtovah 5 months ago
who disliked this?
calliegirl353 6 months ago 3
just listening to this makes me get all choked up... <3
FlyinKowala 6 months ago 2
Ummm... the girl who plays Mimi, on the other hand, kinda bothers me in this scene. Her voice just sounds kinda ditzy.
sansnguyen 6 months ago
My favorite Collins will always be Jesse L. Martin, but I think Michael McElroy does a fantastic job capturing Collins' laidback attitude and immense capacity for love.
sansnguyen 6 months ago 2
im a straight guy and this head voice makes me melt :P hahaha
0mannyman0 6 months ago 3
i love how during Mark's part, when he calls her a Drag Queen, she looks at him like, wtf. When he calls her a she, she looks and smiles like, "Thaaats better ^^"
potentialpenguin 6 months ago 5
This version is simply perfect! <3
LGKxBEaTzxFTW 6 months ago
he killed that last note !!!!
0mannyman0 7 months ago
Makes me cry every time. This musical has touched and helped me in ways no other show (play or movie) has; and I'm only 16. Just goes to show this musical is timeless and for every generation.
MrDraco02 7 months ago
RENT always reminds me that im an ugly cryer
harajukukevin6657 7 months ago 6
@harajukukevin6657 everyones an ugly crier.
Doomitume 6 months ago
the sadesat monment of my life
diamond19971 8 months ago
@diamond19971 I actually think the moment right before this is sadder. The way that Mike says "It's over" is just spine tingling.
elfboy676 7 months ago
Michael McElroy looks a lot like my ex boyfriend. He was too nice. Like stalkerish nice. Michael looks like a very good person though :)
SirGerard77 8 months ago
I cried. I regret nothing
SirGerard77 8 months ago
Michael McElroy is AMAZING as Collins!!!!!!
Mustlovemusic21 8 months ago 2
0:29
Angel's all "Yeah, that's right, bitch. 'She'."
chitoryu12 8 months ago 8
Jesse L. Martin kills it everytime.... but this guy really does good
x0tvigg0x 9 months ago 3
This song always makes me cry but this version here touched my soul
workittworkit 9 months ago
He sings so emotional.. and such great vocals!!
R1c00w 10 months ago
i LOVE jessie martin as collins. but Michael McElroy blew me away. his ability to convey emotion in just the slightest change in tone makes the moment all the sweeter. i actually got teary eyed when i saw this performance.
everidaygirl 10 months ago
WOW! This guy is a genius
lyrtos 1 year ago
The best version in my opinion, his voice makes me feel the moment. 10 stars
NolaKenea7 1 year ago
You can't compare Michale and Jesse they are both amazing preformers who protray colins diffrently, but at they same time they both do it wonderfuly! I personly like jessie better but Michale is an extreemly talented preformer as well.
wickedObsessed22 1 year ago
why is he riffing so much, sing whats on the page, all those vocal gymnastics take away from the simple emotion in this song.
broadwaybeat 1 year ago
@broadwaybeat How can you judge him by his riffing? singing solely what's on the page is not always the best approach. It's ok to experiment with things like that.. The greatest singers do it lol.. The nerve of some of you people
SaintzGchild 1 year ago
@SaintzGchild Im a fan of riffing, but the amount that he does it takes away so much emotion from this beautiful song.
broadwaybeat 1 year ago
@broadwaybeat once again everyone has their own take on how they would perform this song... I'm sure you would perform it one way and I would another but no version is greater than the other or less emotional
SaintzGchild 1 year ago
@SaintzGchild what are you talking about? versions are obviously better than another one and versions are more emotional than others haha
broadwaybeat 1 year ago
not better than the original more gospel than musical...but the original beats anyone whos ever had this role
lee80us 1 year ago
tied i love his version more gospel in his voice then jesse but it's a tie they're both amazing
oNegLeEk 1 year ago
This is so moving. I can't say much else more. But wow. Gives me chills, every time.
rafaCopter81 1 year ago
TOOOOO MUCH SOUL!!!!!!
SNITSINC 1 year ago
I can't stop watching it!... OMG! When Gwen comes in, it's just mind blowing!... "SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO with a thousand sweet kisses"... Give me chills man!
redhair115 1 year ago
@redhair115 I no EXACTLY what you mean ... I just love those ppl who giv you chills as soon as they start singing .. WOWZA !!!!!!
olearyciara 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Well, Jesse L. Martin is by far the best Collins ever. Michael McElroy is second best. The movie version is best version.
kayandmiguel211 1 year ago
Well, Jesse L. Martin is by far the best Collins ever. Michael McElroy is second best. The movie version is best version.
kayandmiguel211 1 year ago
I hate to admit... because I love the original cast... but I think he's a bit better:) GAH! I never cry during like movies or anything... I cried like a baby at the end of this!
broadwaystar2011 1 year ago
his vocals are mind blowing for me
RoarBangRoar22 2 years ago 51
Absolutely moving! Brings me to tears everytime I hear Michael sing it on video or in person!! Bravo!!!
carloalexi 2 years ago 4
doing this song for music gcse...ITS WELL GOOD
Stalkergirl123 2 years ago 2
Michael McElroy is a great performer and master musician. No one on Broadway has done more good for more people with less publicity. A fine human being.
Treaclewheat 2 years ago 67
@Treaclewheat THIS IS THE TRUTH. He's currently one of my professors at NYU, and the people he brings into class/the connections he has are ridiculous: he knows everyone and has the respect of everyone in the industry, and yet seeks no praise or anything for it at all. What an incredible man and teacher.
nickberke 3 months ago 4
@nickberke Hey Nick! :D
JulianComeau 2 months ago
The MOST powerful song in the show no matter who is singing it!!
daisukefan92 2 years ago 4