You want to hear a great Christmas song--- go to the link "trektotrango" at the bottom of this post and listen to "A Christmas Waltz," talk about a beautiful song, trust me just this once!
This was the same year as her win on American Idol, she has grown so much as a performer. She was great here,but you can see her growth and confidence and it has been good to see someone succeed who lives a moral life and keeps their personal life private. Kudos, what a good example.
"i;m assuming you are American and been the arrogant and insolent that you Americans are"
I don't think you should classify every American arrogant and insolent because that makes YOU ignorant. Then again, even before that comment you already sound stupid with your hate against white people. Do you know every single white person? No.
"you actually believe that God created the world on FORTH OF JULY don't you?"
Lmao. You're an idiot, and apparently us white people are the worst. Haha.
@TOLTECAAZTECA Your comments about Americans are completely inaccurate.. almost as much as your spelling and grammar. You're pathetic to be honest. Not all Americans are bad and why would you even bring a discussion like this to a clip where people come for holiday cheer. You in fact ARE the hateful one and it sickens me how the world views Americans, we don't choose war our government does and if you haven't noticed we (Americans) all HATE our government.
@TOLTECAAZTECA Okay, you are an immature moron. Before you start disrespecting our country, you might want to get your facts right. And also, there is a thing called spell check. I recommend you use it.
If you don't like this song, or white people (you racist asshole), try being civil and just say you don't like the song or hey! DON'T WATCH IT!!!!!!!!
# 2- Just because i have an opinion[some one will say a negative opinion]that does not means i HATE.
# 3- Just because you people ''celebrate'' thanksgiving today,that also does not means we the rest of the world ''celebrate it too''.
But of course i;m assuming you are American and been the arrogant and insolent that you Americans are.you actually believe that God created the world on FORTH OF JULY don't you?
WHITE PEOPLE are NOT humans......WHITE PEOPLE belong to the REPTILIANS.WHITE PEOPLE are an anomaly before the eyes of the Lord.WHITE PEOPLE or the WHITE RACE belong to the family of SNAKES.so this ugly creature[Carrie Underwood,yes she its fucking ugly] shouldn't be singing songs about God.Period!!!
@TOLTECAAZTECA You're religious? What religion taught you to hate white people? Anyway, I hope you are having a good thanksgiving :). love always, a very much human woman.
What I mean is, ironbob, your assertion makes it seem as though Judy Garland is the only superior singer ever to have lived. When you're comparing other female singers to the best, you have to exercise discretion. Others were also good, just not up to her caliber.
@lizzyvance No she isn't, they are both amazing, but Aguilera has more power and volume in her notes, therefore Aguilera can sustain hard high notes better that Underwood.
@lizzyvance Still she has better volume in her pitch, though sometimes uncontrolled, it's more vocal energy in her notes. Aguilera also has a bonus in her vocals, she can apply falsetto and her whistle register, she applied it when she performed this song at The Rosie O'Donnell Show.
I think if she would tone it down just a tad I would like it more. I was watching Nina Simone tributes. I though Christina sounded very beautiful when she was singing I Love You Porgy.
I would generally agree, but we don't need to go comparing today's singers to the best standards singer of all time. Using this as a standard of comparison, Celine Dion, Maddona, and Whitney Houston are equally horrific. Carrie is good, just not on the level of Garland. I saw "Meet me in St. Louis." Believe me, I know.
So Beautiful, such a beautiful interpretation of this song. not like christina's version, she over sings the song (wayyy too much). Great job Carrie!!
@insideurheaven i love christina's version it is soul and not country like this. this is cute, but not amazing like christina-but carrie doesn't have a voice like christina's brilliance. carrie i love you but she is not on the same level as christina and that is a given. but still beautiful versions to both. ;-) amen
@1flutedude That's your opinion and that's fine I happen to feel just the opposite -Carrie for me has as simple brilliance that shines , I don't like the vocal runs that Christina does of course it's just style but I do love Carrie's voice where with Christina, well, I never listen to her
@1flutedude You're right, she's on a much higher level than Christina. Carrie can actually reach and sustain the high notes without sounding like she's going to shit a brick. :)
@insideurheaven well christina has her own style and if she over sings the song too much in ur opinion that's because she has one of the greatest voices in the world and therfore it allows her do anything she wants. As for Carrrie, i love her style and her voice but c'mon dont tell me that she sings better than christina, that's impossible
@Maryland765 You're kidding me right? Christina goes BEYOND her natural capabilities and winds up straining the hell out of her vocal cords. That's why her voice is so scratchy and forced on the "high notes" these days. Carrie actually sings below her full capability, unlike Christina who sings way outside of her range to "impress" people, but winds up straining her voice instead. Carrie's natural ability by far exceeds Christina's. You can say you like Christina's TONE and singing style better.
@Maryland765 I'm a Christina fan too, but come the hell on. Carrie effortlessly sings and sustains the very same notes that Christina basically chokes on and needs to SCREAM in order to reach. For Xtina, the high "E" is a "high-range" note, which she always leaves for the climax of her songs and usually winds up having to scream. Carrie will sing that same note in a song's CHORUS, making it seem like no big deal. It seems higher when Christina does it because SO much more effort is involved.
If you want to Cry why not go ahead and Cry......Let it out!
pmora55 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You want to hear a great Christmas song--- go to the link "trektotrango" at the bottom of this post and listen to "A Christmas Waltz," talk about a beautiful song, trust me just this once!
TrekToTrango 1 month ago
i love her.
theMossadd 1 month ago
Damn it! Why didn't she do an album version?
badbeatbri3 1 month ago
Cool down ,guys...it's a beautiful life..
oxtemp 1 month ago
This was the same year as her win on American Idol, she has grown so much as a performer. She was great here,but you can see her growth and confidence and it has been good to see someone succeed who lives a moral life and keeps their personal life private. Kudos, what a good example.
bearball49 2 months ago 2
Great page!
rachaeltennon 2 months ago
What a pure voice !
SantiMuntaner 2 months ago 2
"i;m assuming you are American and been the arrogant and insolent that you Americans are"
I don't think you should classify every American arrogant and insolent because that makes YOU ignorant. Then again, even before that comment you already sound stupid with your hate against white people. Do you know every single white person? No.
"you actually believe that God created the world on FORTH OF JULY don't you?"
Lmao. You're an idiot, and apparently us white people are the worst. Haha.
Lovestinks7897 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@Lovestinks7897 Yes i am hateful..............I am the one whom murdered million in Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
I am the one whom burned countless of innocent in Japan with the atomic weapon.
I am the one whom murdered million in Viet Nam.
I am the one who its murdering million in IRAQ and in AFGHANISTAN, right now as we speak.
Yes ''''i am hateful''''
TOLTECAAZTECA 2 months ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA Your comments about Americans are completely inaccurate.. almost as much as your spelling and grammar. You're pathetic to be honest. Not all Americans are bad and why would you even bring a discussion like this to a clip where people come for holiday cheer. You in fact ARE the hateful one and it sickens me how the world views Americans, we don't choose war our government does and if you haven't noticed we (Americans) all HATE our government.
Spedo09 2 months ago 4
@Spedo09 Blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah So your mother its a female dog!!!!
TOLTECAAZTECA 2 months ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA Okay, you are an immature moron. Before you start disrespecting our country, you might want to get your facts right. And also, there is a thing called spell check. I recommend you use it.
If you don't like this song, or white people (you racist asshole), try being civil and just say you don't like the song or hey! DON'T WATCH IT!!!!!!!!
crashlee012 1 month ago
@crashlee012 Blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah bl;ah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah So your mother its a female dog!!!
TOLTECAAZTECA 1 month ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA Excuse me? If you have a problem, jackass, tell it to me. not my mother, asshole. And you, you racist pig, are the bitch.
crashlee012 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@crashlee012 Fair enough.........FUCK YOU.
TOLTECAAZTECA 1 month ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA no thanks
crashlee012 1 month ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA yea go on ignoring the lives lost on 9/11, pearl harbor ect. no one is innocent in war and any other time for that matter
DeathByChocolate1995 2 months ago
Good question.
# 1- NO i'm not religious.
# 2- Just because i have an opinion[some one will say a negative opinion]that does not means i HATE.
# 3- Just because you people ''celebrate'' thanksgiving today,that also does not means we the rest of the world ''celebrate it too''.
But of course i;m assuming you are American and been the arrogant and insolent that you Americans are.you actually believe that God created the world on FORTH OF JULY don't you?
TOLTECAAZTECA 2 months ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA u mad?
shadowchaos1 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WHITE PEOPLE are NOT humans......WHITE PEOPLE belong to the REPTILIANS.WHITE PEOPLE are an anomaly before the eyes of the Lord.WHITE PEOPLE or the WHITE RACE belong to the family of SNAKES.so this ugly creature[Carrie Underwood,yes she its fucking ugly] shouldn't be singing songs about God.Period!!!
TOLTECAAZTECA 2 months ago
Comment removed
heyitsgina2 2 months ago
@TOLTECAAZTECA You're religious? What religion taught you to hate white people? Anyway, I hope you are having a good thanksgiving :). love always, a very much human woman.
wheaty027 2 months ago
simply delightful XD
AaronTrutsJC 2 months ago
I can tell she is in to Christmas songs! I LOVE IT!!!
woahstar800 2 months ago
Whoever disliked shall receive coal for Christmas XD
ursocraiz 2 months ago
whoever pointed down on this should be shot at sun rise.
ROBERTALLENGRIFFETH 5 months ago
I love Carrie's simple style of singing no ridiculous acrobatic runs just pure sweet singing - thank you, Carrie
fiddleDdee 5 months ago 2
LOVE this! :)
kittenluver2006 10 months ago
damn she has an outstanding female voice, so strong, especially on the upper end of her range it gives me goosebumps!
lumberjackphil 1 year ago
SHE IS AMAZING! MY FAVORITE BY FAR!
tuffgirl777 1 year ago
My favorite Christmas song ever. I also have a video of me performing it live in my channel. Happy Holidays :)
NikolaMusic1 1 year ago
she never sounds bad its amaving i love how she sings this<33333
lovemusic1681 1 year ago
2 people are smoking crack
Marker386 1 year ago
chills at 1:56
Marker386 1 year ago
Is there any way i can get this on itunes? Carrie underwood is so talented! MErry Christmas!
fluffibunni4 1 year ago
Is there any way i can get this on itunes?
fluffibunni4 1 year ago
@fluffibunni4 you can convert it from a youtube video to a mp3 on listentoyoutube . com. Hope that helped :)
Sweetmuffins0018 1 year ago
What I mean is, ironbob, your assertion makes it seem as though Judy Garland is the only superior singer ever to have lived. When you're comparing other female singers to the best, you have to exercise discretion. Others were also good, just not up to her caliber.
greg9570 1 year ago
@greg9570 good comment exactly not up to their caliber. and they do not match up to christina's voice at all. but they are still spectacular. ;-)
1flutedude 1 year ago
@1flutedude
Carrie is better singer than Christina.
lizzyvance 8 months ago
@lizzyvance No she isn't, they are both amazing, but Aguilera has more power and volume in her notes, therefore Aguilera can sustain hard high notes better that Underwood.
kaiyno 6 months ago
@kaiyno
No Christina does minor cracks and strains when singing high notes.
lizzyvance 6 months ago
@lizzyvance Still she has better volume in her pitch, though sometimes uncontrolled, it's more vocal energy in her notes. Aguilera also has a bonus in her vocals, she can apply falsetto and her whistle register, she applied it when she performed this song at The Rosie O'Donnell Show.
kaiyno 5 months ago
@kaiyno
That’s fine but I still think Carrie is better. I don’t care if she can do it. She still sounds unpleasant as singer.
lizzyvance 2 months ago
@lizzyvance Fine, I respect that, they're both amazing.
kaiyno 2 months ago
@lizzyvance
I think if she would tone it down just a tad I would like it more. I was watching Nina Simone tributes. I though Christina sounded very beautiful when she was singing I Love You Porgy.
lizzyvance 2 months ago
its very little that u see someone who is just as beautiful live
2010flaggirl 1 year ago
Damm this song brings mad memorys..6 19 10
daballplaya32 1 year ago
love itttt
timosw91 2 years ago
Man, Judy Garland puts today's talent to shame.
Ironbob2006 2 years ago 2
@Ironbob2006 carrie is just as good.
ankatz 1 year ago
I would generally agree, but we don't need to go comparing today's singers to the best standards singer of all time. Using this as a standard of comparison, Celine Dion, Maddona, and Whitney Houston are equally horrific. Carrie is good, just not on the level of Garland. I saw "Meet me in St. Louis." Believe me, I know.
greg9570 1 year ago
Comment removed
jackson4socks 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I see nipples!
NJNetFan 2 years ago
frotffflmfafo
ElectrikkPaperClipxx 1 year ago
Carrie sounds really pretty on this. Thanks for posting.
HowIFeel07 2 years ago 3
I love her! She is an awesome singer! Go Carrie!
gj1sandiego 2 years ago 4
Wow Carrie is the first performer to rock this song as well as Judy Garland. Beautiful Carrie ^_^
foxyrocker89 2 years ago 5
i love her singing it makes me wish the world could be this pretty just like the song is
Miley4997 2 years ago 5
So Beautiful, such a beautiful interpretation of this song. not like christina's version, she over sings the song (wayyy too much). Great job Carrie!!
insideurheaven 2 years ago 55
@insideurheaven i love christina's version it is soul and not country like this. this is cute, but not amazing like christina-but carrie doesn't have a voice like christina's brilliance. carrie i love you but she is not on the same level as christina and that is a given. but still beautiful versions to both. ;-) amen
1flutedude 1 year ago
@1flutedude That's your opinion and that's fine I happen to feel just the opposite -Carrie for me has as simple brilliance that shines , I don't like the vocal runs that Christina does of course it's just style but I do love Carrie's voice where with Christina, well, I never listen to her
fiddleDdee 10 months ago
@1flutedude You're right, she's on a much higher level than Christina. Carrie can actually reach and sustain the high notes without sounding like she's going to shit a brick. :)
mellynumerounoo 10 months ago
@insideurheaven well christina has her own style and if she over sings the song too much in ur opinion that's because she has one of the greatest voices in the world and therfore it allows her do anything she wants. As for Carrrie, i love her style and her voice but c'mon dont tell me that she sings better than christina, that's impossible
Maryland765 1 year ago
@Maryland765 Carrie sings better than Christina, no doubt about it, that's my opinion
fiddleDdee 10 months ago
@fiddleDdee Basically.
mellynumerounoo 10 months ago
@Maryland765 You're kidding me right? Christina goes BEYOND her natural capabilities and winds up straining the hell out of her vocal cords. That's why her voice is so scratchy and forced on the "high notes" these days. Carrie actually sings below her full capability, unlike Christina who sings way outside of her range to "impress" people, but winds up straining her voice instead. Carrie's natural ability by far exceeds Christina's. You can say you like Christina's TONE and singing style better.
mellynumerounoo 10 months ago
@Maryland765 I'm a Christina fan too, but come the hell on. Carrie effortlessly sings and sustains the very same notes that Christina basically chokes on and needs to SCREAM in order to reach. For Xtina, the high "E" is a "high-range" note, which she always leaves for the climax of her songs and usually winds up having to scream. Carrie will sing that same note in a song's CHORUS, making it seem like no big deal. It seems higher when Christina does it because SO much more effort is involved.
mellynumerounoo 10 months ago
@insideurheaven what doesn't she over sing?? even the national anthem has been victim of it /: I like christina aguilera but she shows off tooo much.
17sexybutt 3 months ago
i want to cry its so beautiful
caitroxx123 2 years ago 10
she sings perfect
neilhunk 2 years ago 61
she all perfect
SleepingOnTheMoon 3 months ago
when was this?
trea3123 3 years ago 2
Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Lighting
November 30th, 2005
Hope this helps. ;)
KazooLuvsCarrie 3 years ago 6