Playing a piece differently, because you enjoy it that way shows originality. You played this extremely well Scott and you did it with feeling…..very important to a composer. I'm hoping you'll post more of these video performances in the near future. I think this vanpraagh person plays by the numbers and not with feeling….at least his comment shows that…..
This is one of the first pieces I learned. In this video you played it better than I ever did. FWIW sometimes I did not do the repeat either, and none of my teachers ever had a problem with that.
I've never heard this peice before n even if i had i would'nt care how u r playing notes at 1.41/43/45/47 :-) Your sound is great..smooth, clean n dynamic.
Oh .. for goodness sake play the correct notes at 1.41/43/45/47 - or have you a religious objection to playing right notes on odd numbers in this section? mm..Perhaps I ought to respect that?..ah no.. I see you fudged it at 50 and 52 - and 56 by the way should be A# not C#...and as for the repetition of the final chord - well - what did Sor know? - a man of infinite repetition in the codas (codi?!) to his big scale works - he certainly missed an opportunity to exercise his own compulsion here...
For goodness sake I can't play everything perfectly. You are correct that there are mistakes at the times mentioned in your comment. It is difficult to change to those chord shapes quickly for me, and thus errors were made.
I've not attempted to discredit Sor's genius by not playing the repeat. Get off your high horse.
Playing a piece differently, because you enjoy it that way shows originality. You played this extremely well Scott and you did it with feeling…..very important to a composer. I'm hoping you'll post more of these video performances in the near future. I think this vanpraagh person plays by the numbers and not with feeling….at least his comment shows that…..
rd2ed 1 year ago
dont ever eyeball me like that again dude........bullseye....
brengranted 1 year ago
This is one of the first pieces I learned. In this video you played it better than I ever did. FWIW sometimes I did not do the repeat either, and none of my teachers ever had a problem with that.
arizonamontana 1 year ago
beautiful
reesewerkhoven 2 years ago
I've never heard this peice before n even if i had i would'nt care how u r playing notes at 1.41/43/45/47 :-) Your sound is great..smooth, clean n dynamic.
boooksi 2 years ago
Comment removed
boooksi 2 years ago
Oh .. for goodness sake play the correct notes at 1.41/43/45/47 - or have you a religious objection to playing right notes on odd numbers in this section? mm..Perhaps I ought to respect that?..ah no.. I see you fudged it at 50 and 52 - and 56 by the way should be A# not C#...and as for the repetition of the final chord - well - what did Sor know? - a man of infinite repetition in the codas (codi?!) to his big scale works - he certainly missed an opportunity to exercise his own compulsion here...
vanpraagh 2 years ago
For goodness sake I can't play everything perfectly. You are correct that there are mistakes at the times mentioned in your comment. It is difficult to change to those chord shapes quickly for me, and thus errors were made.
I've not attempted to discredit Sor's genius by not playing the repeat. Get off your high horse.
TheSlurgi 2 years ago
You tell him!!! LOL I think it was gorgeous!
beecon1 2 years ago
@vanpraagh You're a pompous ass. The guy is not a professional classical guitarist so shut the fuck up you arrogant asshole.
greyhall1 2 years ago
no 22, not 5
Mkamalid 2 years ago
Well, it's Fernando Sor's Op 35 No 22, but it's Segovia's Study No 5. Most people know the Sor studies by their Segovia Study number, I believe...
TheSlurgi 2 years ago
Great playing, but looking at ya move around like that to a classical piece is pretty goofy.
jowildcat40 3 years ago 2
Dude you're good and stuff, but what a guitar face.. Mine is bad, but not that bad ;)
wanabeknut 3 years ago
Haha, yea. I have my moments.
TheSlurgi 3 years ago
beautiful!
Btw, it was ron down here that told me you was grate. and you are!
ceep it up.
five stars
*****
PeaceSupport 3 years ago
Most excellent. -Ron
rhopen 3 years ago