Added: 4 years ago
From: xheavenx
Views: 212,896
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (146)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 好催淚的歌

  • 唱調真的有呼吸慢慢跟不上節拍器 第一次聽真的有同身受

  • 我口白聽了都哭了

    

  • What's with you all? Why are you quarriling about this? This is just a video and has nothing to do with the politics and "china"-"taiwan"... This is not an debatte round... I am from europe and perhaps you think I am crazy... but why everyone of you don't respect the opinion of you opponent? Both side has pros and cons and if this "discussion" going on there wouldn't be any results!!!! So please, write comments about the video!!!!!!

  • 口白超感人 (淚)

  • Jolin ! TT

  • THIS VIDEO IS GREAT

    v=B0w4gDJpg1

    ok okok

  • I wish I could find english subs to this song~

    It's so pretty...

  • the song is about her trying to be some1 she isn't

    giving in for her other half, adjusting herself inorder to keep up with her other half. in the end, she loses herself and changes her personality

    sad song and my favorite out of all her songs

    yay jolin

  • Music is supposed to be a universal concept. There's no "nationality" in it--no race, no gender--it's an art, a religion for some...

    So please, let's just all respect the fact that this is a song, not a political masterpiece, and rest the argument here, because neither side is completely right or wrong, and we could go on forever arguing about China and "Taiwan". But we can't argue that this is a beautiful work that doesn't deserve a political commentary over it.

  • uhh just by putting taiwan in quotations implicates your comment of political commentary.

  • Jolin口白:

    我希望記憶不會再被刪除

    即使我會因此而痛苦一輩子

    感人T-T

  • i luv jolin her music is the best yet i dont undrestand eney of it because im english.

    p.s i beleve that taiwanese people are taiwanese not chinese or japanes. if i was taiwanese i would tell everyone that i am taiwanese.

  • Uhm Where can i see the full version of her agent j movie.\

  • you can find it here on youtube

    look up 特务J音乐电影

  • would u call american "british"?? they sure descended from britain right?

    would u call all human beings apes? because that seems to be where we descend from

    wtf. u can't decide someone's nationality by their heritage ALONE. an american chinese is different from a native chinese. a mainland chinese is different from hong kong chinese. taiwanese is different from mainland chinese. what decides a person's nationality is their choice. don't go badmouthing ppl's choice in that

  • Comment removed

  • What makes them entirely so different?

    Sure, they're nationality is different.

    I never said you could'nt call yourself Taiwanese.

    But to say that they have nothing to do with being Chinese is absurd.

  • wow to all the comments below...

    yay jolin! that's what the comments should be like ;P

  • hahah that was funny. mmm im pretty sure we have a couple of good looking people.

  • its funny 2 read ppl bashin others of their inability to speak their native language... u shudnt bash others 4 it... i noe its not a gd thing to have little knowledge of ur own country, the lanugage n its history but to bash ppl 4 it is takin it to a whole new level... if chinese born ppl cant speak chinese then it aint their fault.. its their upbringin that failed to teach them the essentials not the persons fault... so give em a break n go do somethin more useful then bad mouthin ppl on utube

  • I love this song~~It sounds really sad.....

  • y'all need to calm down

    and find a hobby

  • wow, I agree with you, it gets annoying seeing all these political comments on completely unrelated youtube videos. anyways, love Jolin's slower songs, she has such a wonderful voice

  • this video is sooooooo sad!her love died!but i love teh video and teh song!

  • she can write great songs too <3 the lyrics was written by her ^^ so nice ...

  • thank you leta0115 and LilyYuenLu

    taiwanese does NOT = chinese

    that's WRONG

    taiwan isn't part of CHINA for dang SAKE

    my GOSH taiwan is a COUNTRY we have a federal GOVERNEMENT. our own CURRENCY. can u still argue with that?!

  • Comment removed

  • Agree, the people of taiwan were originally FROM china. the only reason taiwan is known as taiwan is because of political problems, and the losing side escaped to taiwan.

  • retarded logic. everyone is from africa, then we all must be african. obviously you know nothing about history. only a small percentage of taiwanese immigrated from china in 1949.

  • Oh really? The population of Taiwan was originally from China. I do not care what you think, you cant change the truth

  • what's your point? people living in taiwan no longer identify with china and are now taiwanese. get over it.

  • Well,bad for Taiwan,then.They should actually be proud of being a part from China.

  • 雖然台灣人的確就是中國人

    但要說得更準確一點,還是台灣人

    因為要是跟別人說我們是中國人的話大多人都以為他們是從中國大陸­來的..但很多台灣人卻連中國都沒去過

    所以具體來說,台灣人大多還是會強調台灣,而不是中國

  • what's the point of leading the topic to japan for? it's funny you are trying to say something that's not even happening right now..who's ganna agreed with you this "Japan's part of China as well" logic? i mean it used to be, i agreed, but right now, no..and if you talk about the future, no one knows.

    and i was just saying most of the taiwanese would emphasize that we are from taiwan to prevent ppl from thinking that we are from china, since most of us never even been to main land china before

  • yea i agree. This logic is one of the big mistakes that chinese always make. Good thing I'm in Germany while i'm writing this, because if I was in China, people would soon come and hate me.

  • Singapore is the best chinese country in the world, and look what they going through to get here, you never been to china you are not chinese? all human come from Africa 20 million year ago, you can call us negga for all i give a shit, have you ever been to canada and usa, wherever i go i see a chinese girl with a white guy, if you dont live here you dont know that, it like Thailand hooker with white guy everywhere you go, im dating a hot white girl and white guy want to kill me for that, stress

  • lol, wtf are you talking about now?

    i already told you, let's face the truth about that we are all different countries now, you don't mix up all asians together just because they used to be from the same place, the why you put it it's just like saying all human beings are suppose to be monkies million years ago? what's the point of insisting that point of view and face what we have today?

  • 台湾永远处于中国, 以为我们永远是一家人。 所以台湾人就是中国人。

  • You don't make any sense.

    You're like "I'd rather say that I'm Japanese than saying that I'm Chinese" (wow, self hater much?)

    And then you go on and say "You are you."

    So you're basically contradicting yourself.

  • happy new year to all Chinese,

  • Love this song! so sad......

  • omg so sad T_T<3

  • Amazing, her best ballad

    Me encanta Jolin, es la mejor, sus directos son brutales, lastima que el publico no anime en los conciertos, ya que en Asia son muy educados y no gritan hasta el final de la cancion, aki en españa somos unos gritones xD Ojala viniera.

    Bye Bye

  • 蔡依林 Jolin 节拍器 MV like video wonderful...

  • T_T...wuwuwu...

  • i hate to say this but...

    many of Jolin's MV's involve a guy dying...

    the slow songs.

    just picked up this pattern

  • well, only for this album

  • that's right for this albumn x[

  • well that is because the MVs are based on the short movie clip thingy or w.e u call it

  • but this isnt really linked to the shortt movie..much

  • this MV is showing that she misses him and is just kinda like a flashback sort of thing

  • Jolin Tsai look really cute =)

    and she look like top Japanese female singer, Ayumi Hamasaki... is there any chance that Jolin Tsai will sing together with Ayumi Hamasaki?

  • =D Beautifull song!

  • so sad..........so beautiful. i cried a lot.

  • so wad if chinese can't speak chinesefluently?it doesn't give u de rights to look down on ppl?so wad if half of the society r english speaker?u r just the another half who can speak both lauguage well&so wad if we dun speak well in our mother lauguage?though u may be better than us:english speaker but there r many ppl who r better than u! here is to comment abt the video not to despise or look down on ppl!

  • totally agree with ya

  • i agree with you too..to me, what's the most important's not about the language, but it's about the person himself/herself..as long as they are honest, and don't talk dirty. who cares what language they speak? i'm originally from taiwan, and my english still sucks, still often got look down by ppl because of it, but i don't care, because i know what's more important..

    but i do agree that it would be better if everyone knows how speak their own mother language..doesn't have to be perfect though.

  • Shame on you, cant even speak chinese and youre chinese. I was born in NZ and i can speak both english and chinese fluently. English educated? More like disgrace.

  • Easy for you to say because you learnt Chinese from the beginning so of course you can speak both fluently. Think about some Chinese kids out there that are less fortunate where their parents don't even bother teaching them Chinese. So next time don't say that for all Chinese people, because you don't know everyone's situation.

  • Jolin's Songs is nice okay.

    if those people who dont like this then dont listen also nobody is forcing you all to listen -.-

    & fck those people who scolded jolin.

    & why must 中国人speaks自己的国语? -.-

    i dont understand okay.

  • ok... about the english and chinese crap, chinese people who cant speak chinese really are sad. that means they're white-washed. im chinese, i can speak english and chinese fluently

  • 说的好...

    一个中国人应该回说自己的国语....

  • 好你媽,他是台灣人

  • __台湾人也是中国人

  • 谢谢你 :)

  • So you think...

  • stop arguing and enjoy the song.

  • JOLIN ROCKS! GOGOGO! :D

  • No offense to Kelly Poon's fan but who is she? What's her chinese name?

  • this song is beautiful~~ sounds so sad

  • then why r u watching anyways?

  • that is ur own problem and what's wrong with u anyways?!this song isn't that perfect tho but it is still better than u~ and why u finding those sad and stubid songs anyways~cuz u r a stupit and don't know every thing and the last thing is go get a girlfrend so u don't need to go on youtube to find those videos to comfort urself ;P

  • sad songs r nice, ususally with good melodies~ much better than those english songs with annoying people yelling or sth~

    & btw, the song is sad or not doesnt affect the look of the singer~ they r still cute & pretty! jolin is this MV is very pretty too~

    asian artists r the best~

  • Jack off watching music video clip? You're sick!!!

  • GOOD LYRICS, JOLIN!

  • valleymagic35 you sure are showing alot of respect. and what's wrong with speaking chinese? you don't? if you don't den i really despise you. cos you're chinese but you can't speak chinese. english educated means cannot type chinese here issit? if you can't respect others den dun expect others to do the same.

  • 既然难听还要听?有自虐??

  • the song sucks den y u keep coming back to it? you like to torture yourself? or you're mentally unsound? or just to promote ur kelly poon? just some unknown singer in sg. she's not new. she's the champion of the first season's superstar contest. and the 2nd season is already finished long ago. she's only new cos nobody knows her.

  • did u noe wat the song mean?

    low class!!

  • wait what happened in the story? Like did that guy killed himself? Did she lost her memory and can't remember him? Or she's this new girl who looks exactly like his old girl friend? Sry I'm kinda lost. Someone help me by replying me plz and thank you!!!

  • well i think this video may relate to like te wu j and sun that never sets...like she meets the guy in te wu j they date in sun that never sets and in this mv the guy is killed by someone else and she is just think about all their memories and times together.

  • well,both of them are killers.The girl has to kill the guy's boss,and the guy should kill her.They were falling in love with each other.but at the end,the guy was killed by his boss.

  • thank you so much! Now this makes more sense. Great videos, i must say

  • wow that's stefen Fung! Omg he's so cute. What a great video but sad...

  • hey stupid guys, dont u ever insult jolin again! she rocks k? pretty and sexy too..look at urself before insult jolin || no matter wad, i will owes suppot JOLIN~ yeah JOLIN

  • lol..what kind of logic is that? i'm supporting her just for all the hard works she have done.

    so it means when i support her it also means i'm supporting hard working ppl..she's the best example of how much effort you've put down, it's how much you'll gain =)

  • she looked really sweet with that guy (:

  • calm down dude hehe

  • omg ur ENGLISH EDUCATED.. SUPER PATHETIC! LOL

    ur soooo out!! chinese educated should be proud~~ cant believe there r still ppl who r proud becuz they r english... lol lol lol!!!

    & btw, jolin is very pretty! sings very gd too~~

  • english educated r not proud!only ppl like u r proud of yrself

  • If you're unhappy with valleymagic, please 'shoot' properly. I'm am educated, cant tell whether it's "english" or "chinese". Why do you have to insult chinese who dont know chinese, and "english educated" people? Some call themselves chinese educated because they are weak in english, and vice-versa. Proud? I dont think any ignorance can be proud of.

  • i said these all becuz valleymagic insulted chinese educated people first!!! he/she laughed @ someone who is weak in english & insulted chinese educated people. I just didn't feel happy when I saw that comment.

  • 你有那资格吗?

  • oh wow,

    u have the courage to tell others but not do it urself.

    if u're english is so good,

    u should know what shut up and do what u say before u tell others to do it should mean

  • Please hide your nation in your profile. It's sad to see those who attack others command of English (because they do have a valid arguement) always have to come from certain countries. You are NOT English "educated". You have not learn etiquette.

  • I meant "they dont* have a valid arguement"

  • hohoho,蔡依林又要推出庆功版了!好开心喔!不到1个月就­出庆功!ur kelly poon is who?现在蔡依林算是天后级的歌手,还拿那些不出名的歌手来比­,你不知丑我都提那位感到羞耻!

  • 蔡依林 我愛你 :)

    專輯首首主打!!

  • usually ppl like to hear good comments,

    if you cant put a good comment

    keep it to urself

  • you mite not like it

    but others like it

    I bet she makes good lyrics than you ever will

    "wow cannot listen at all one this song" is not even a complete understandable sentence

    even if you are going to criticize someone

    make sure the words you use are understandable

  • wonderful singer, have never heard before, China rocks ~~~

  • u meant taiwan...learn your geography right

  • Jolin rox!

  • hey, bro i thinks you gotta show some respect to others, no need to say bed words, she tries her best, man

    take care,

    MaratLS

  • dun b sohai la...

    if u think u can sing...

    u sing the song la

    diu..

  • This is a nice video......

  • 很棒喔!蔡依林一直都是很認真的歌手....

  • say MV

  • at 1st really doesnt like it...

    but with ds video... can feel d meaning of ds song... nice

  • I think 假裝 from her last album sounded better.

  • Hmm... Not really like it.

  • what only 3.59min???

  • Thank you so much for uploading this !!!

  • You're welcome!

  • jolin worked very hard for all her albums. i really like her attitude...

  • Ya..

    Lk Jolin so muc..

    Kip on yr effort ya jolin..

  • jolin agent J album is available at yesasia..

  • 好聽~~

  • do you know where i can dl her 3 recent mvs?

  • yea it is touching

  • very touch~ i like

  • yes, I think so

  • is it the official mv?

  • Thank you~ i'm the first~

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more