蕭敬騰-安静,黑色幽默 & 不能说的秘密(周杰倫的歌)

[longbird456]

我喜歡他唱不能說的秘密的這個版本

[Rickycho6704]

3:44 ^_^

[scudder98]

其實蕭敬騰的聲音,喜好很二極,就不做討論了

我只知道像周杰倫這種風格這麼強烈的歌手

很多人唱他的歌都會或多或少有他的影子

但蕭難能可貴的是活在周最紅的時代下,唱他的歌還這麼有自己的特­色

只能說台灣出了二個天才!

[Mrprawnmee]

靠~你们怎么不能好好听音乐。吵屁啊吵。

杰伦好，敬腾好，都是很棒的歌手~

人比人比死人~

[becky5868]

拿CD和LIVE来比有什么意思。。。。

[CruzPui]

这首歌chord不好抓。。 他一直弹错， 呵呵

[jornes5364]

聽到我都不想再聽下去了...

[jpy4029]

拖拍拖的很討厭-.-''

[yiaphwee]

@jpy4029 萧每一首现场都喜欢拖拍，听听”男人不该让女人流泪“吧，听到很­想吐！！当然想吐的也很多，就算cd版的”记得“也是唱得很难听­！萧的唱功非常弱，共鸣声都集中在头部，明显重鼻音，咬字蒙，声­音散！希望唱片公司把他调教好先。。。。。

[g61002]

@yiaphwee 我本身有樂團，絕對了解所謂的咬字、共鳴，我只能說蕭敬騰是一位­天分極高的歌手，不屬於那種很芭樂矯情的主流唱腔，如果你想吐那­是你家的事，但在我眼你我看不到的評論有任何的專業性，不是把專­業詞語拿出來背誦就可以證明你多懂。節拍，其實不能用選秀節目那­套標準來看，現在很多普通人沒學過唱歌樂器，就喜歡模仿選秀節目­裡面的老師說話，自以為很專業，其實那些節目的娛樂成分很濃厚，­他們看的是明星特質和未來發展性，有時候唱功反而不是重點，但他­們就是有辦法合理化自己的評分標準，你懂嗎？

1.蕭敬騰的唱腔是所謂的壓抑式唱法，我們玩樂團的幾乎沒有人會­用，為什麼？太累、而且非常難控制，一過頭就會變成矯情，但蕭的­詮釋算是很棒了，我也有很多朋友喜歡學他的這種唱法，結果很明顯­都做得過頭。

2.咬字而言，蕭敬騰的咬字並沒有不好，字字清晰，我不知道是你­耳機喇叭壞了還是怎樣，建議檢查一下。

3.聲音散是甚麼怪形容，我可以合理質疑這是你學選秀節目的奇特­用詞，或是你自己發明的詞。

蕭敬騰的唱功非常強，出道前在天秤座民歌西餐廳就已經備受肯定，­當初的星光也沒有刻意炒作他。

想評論，先充實自己。

[gegao0225]

@g61002 你說的我也有聽過~ 好像是在胸腔共鳴的!!!!!

反正聽到都是這種唱法很難~

我覺的說唱的多難聽的人就聽聽就好~

看他現在的成績就知道不可能難聽!!!!

就算自己無法，判斷看他的活動.演唱會..等等好評不斷

也知道好聽不好聽啦!!!!

[emma82618]

他有他的味道阿

[P880739]

他前面兩首歌應該是在康熙來了唱的吧~不能說的秘密應該是在頒獎­典禮唱的~說真的~

他唱不能說的秘密~還真的是很棒~怎會有人說糟糕呢...



[easylife522]

我不專業 也懂得不多樂理

但是就我聽來

兩個人我都很喜歡

[MrJoff7]

@easylife522 兩個人經歷過的事情 成長顯現出來的感覺真的有差喔 雖然都很好聽 但是個人還是喜歡簡單一點的唱法



[jktt625]

這應該是蕭敬騰前期的演出

很習慣的拖拍

所以現在應該改善很多



[HolyKiller43]

这段短片一点意义都没有。根本就是开来让双方的歌迷吵架罢了。哈­哈 

[o0vivianluvjay0o]

兩個我最最最最最最最最最最最愛的歌手。

[0222163007]

我喜歡蕭靜藤

[antijhow]

不懂為什麼一定要批評另外一個人來錦上添花另外一個人

這兩個人已經都很完美了

周的價值在他是原創 而蕭的價值在於她的嗓音特色

難道就不能兩人都好 偏偏一定要一好一壞嗎?

當然或許也是有些人先說了 誰比較好 逼的另外一群人只好反擊另外一個人比較好

但說真的 這些都是沒有意義的...

唱歌的人並不會因為你罵他難聽或你覺得他難聽 而有所改變

讓謾罵少一點 世界或許不會變得更美好 但至少可以讓其他人安靜聽歌就好

[yiaphwee]

不能说的秘密很糟糕(每次唱歌总是缺了少许的稳定度）,前两首勉­强还可。但佩服他的勇气，向高难度挑战。看了周杰伦2007演唱­会的稳定度,就知道什么是无法被取代的天王了！

[carolmytube]

@yiaphwee 没有人说要取代谁超越谁吧？每个人都有自己的特色，相信很多人也­不愿意成为谁的替代品。另外，唱自己的歌和唱别人的歌应该是不同­的，唱了一百遍的歌和唱了几遍的歌应该是不同的。看你在别的视频­极其“专业”评论，相信“专业”的你，应该也是知道这两个基本常­识的。没有看过周董的演唱会视频，相信表现很棒。不过可否不要再­比较了？！

[Bang8Balllls]

Jam is the best! omg omg omg i lo-ve him so much

[wintersleep007]

現場唱跟進錄音室唱是不能比較的

能比較的只有比較喜歡誰的嗓音

[d26494634]

霍元甲哩



[magee029]

Jay is better : ) but ..yea...

[waihong001]

問題是連蕭敬騰的味道都沒有。。。

[leanwinleng]

jay still the best

[hide98000]

以佢既唱功,,唱呢d歌冇問題..

但冇味道~

[asd123215]

不用在討論誰比較強吧，連翻唱別人的歌都能出盡風頭了，還有人弄­不清誰強嗎。

[ruby09110812]

別有一番風味...很好聽~^^

[luvjam2012]

i luv jam a lot

but jay is so talented

those are really great songs~~

support jam and jay forever~

:)

[Wuhan]

Great composition by Jay. However, in terms of singing, Xiao Jing Teng exceeds Jay

[fannykeith]

各人的喜好不同,

但不致 糟糕吧.

看在金馬獎的現場反應就知,

我就是看金馬獎後愛上他的.

ym...相信是唯一......

[xSeven7x]

Both are really great singers! (: W/o them, music industry will be diff~

[lelouchzero520]

聽他唱周杰倫的歌， 有點想睡覺....趕快去找人寫歌啦，不要再出那種翻唱的歌，因­為不適合他。

[CubeFish1524]

Jay Chou is the best. Jam's voice might be good but he can't control. Jay Chou will always sound the best in his songs because he wrote them in his comfortable style.

[mark22013333]

嗯...還是蕭敬騰厲害 真好聽~!

[missdior888]

it doesn't matter who sings better, the bottom line is Jay Chou wrote this song, and everyone tries to sing their version of it, which means that they respect Jay and his talents.

[chocolate16strawbery]

黑色幽默还是周杰伦版本最好~

[hjkjh0797]

@chocolate16strawbery 這倒是真的(要客觀點)...我個人非常喜歡蕭勝過於周(兩者都­是最愛的男歌手)但是前兩首真的是周的版本好聽XD~~~其他歌­...蕭都唱得非常讚 例如BON JOVI的那兩首(撇開英文不談...那個聲音幾乎是一絕了)、­背叛、倒帶以及金馬不能說的秘密他就唱得很棒....

[chocolate16strawbery]

@hjkjh0797 没有啦~ 这都是个人喜欢嘛~ 哈哈~ 他唱得是真的不错~ 要是比较来比较去，话题不完咯~ 哈哈 xD

[UKCEhaha]

@chocolate16strawbery i like gary chao's

[chocolate16strawbery]

@UKCEhaha Gary not bad bha~~!! i love too xD

[ymzzart]

技巧蕭敬騰是比較好~

不過聽歌不是全部都聽技巧~

我還是比較喜歡周杰倫的版本~

有時候會覺得蕭敬騰有點"假"~

而且不能說的秘密唱的實在是有點糟糕~

[KeWacE]

應該不能說他糟糕

這是他的風格

我還是比較喜歡周董^^~

[hydrablue888]

@ymzzart jay聽起來比較舒服溫柔

[pooramy]

I wish 王力宏 could sing this song....Jay Chou is a genius at writing songs, but I think having someone else sing this song might be better....

go Jay Chou

[myacnt8999]

王力宏 and jam are excellent singers. jay is not that great yet in singing.

[4evajaychou]

he is good, but nothing compared to jay chou. jay chou has the real talent.

[jaychouisasucker]

go ask any vocal coach in where you live, jam is at least 100x better singer than jay chou.

[jaynightsong]

nooneknowwhothehellisjamlol

[jaychouisasucker]

so pathetic, jay fans are often delusional and blinded by jay's "cool" mumbling until they can't recognize and appreciate other singers.

[annajaytoma]

@jaychouisasucker I think you a the one who can't be objective. We can see that from your username.

[AAVVGG]

@jaychouisasucker

Apparently, you are a JayChou hater. However, your statement is so unreasonable b/c we appreciate his style doesn't mean that we don't recognize other good artists. "Good" doesn't only mean who sings well, but also the entire style and feeling of the songs. Yes, in our eyes we think he is cool - even the best in Asia - we don't go around to criticize other singers. Oh, at least peaceful people don't use "jaychouisasucker" as usernames.

[waichun1025]

2:23 的相片很帥!!!

[24433447]

I only love hear Jay singing those songs

of course Jam is good too ^^

[THW516]

his voice is not suitable to sing jays songs.their styles and voice are completely different...

[qlovejam]

Jam's live performance is so charming and powerful!! Unforgettable vocal and deep feeling after hearing his voice!!! He makes me listen to Chinese song again!! (I haven't listen to Chinese song for almost 10 years)

[wenyen813]

JAM is Good

[mydogvisa]

Actually his rock style is his trademark!

[myacnt8999]

yeah, that is his trademark that makes him a distinctive singer. but it doesn't suit my preference.:D i think that singing ballads with rock style is just not right. and i don't like his sliding notes too.

[hauy]

Enjoy!

[myacnt8999]

his singing is much better than jay although i never like his 'rock' singing style. but it was a bit messed up in piano.