I definitely think juicystar07 and allthatglitters make videos to get money and exposure to further their fame. i'm not trying to start a big controversy here, but something about them just doesn't seem honest or genuine. i definitely think they feel this is their shot at fame since they don't have any actual talent to make them famous
I just hate when people are paid and they go "I am affiliated with this company". Also, it's so funny that people still to this day say "hello FTC man, I bought this myself, please leave me alone" that kind of thing..
I was a little confused. If I post on facebook " Today I went shopping and i got some mac stuff..... ______ and I got some Chanel ________ Its soooo awesome! Is that okay? I mean its just my freinds. But on youtube, if im not paid do i even have to mention anything??
I think this is great, I am glad the FTC is cracking down on this. All the dishonest reviews and product pimping on utube is way out of control. Full disclosure is the way to go. You have a great channel, I am going to subscribe.
Can someone please tell me how the FTC regulations apply to people who are not in the USA? It is not an international law, is it? Does it apply to those who are using US based blog services etc...?
This is very interesting and this is the reason why i haven't completely accepted the offers these companies give me through you-tube...I rather WORK for my money lol not lie to people...i feel u girl!
another thing...i feel that people should take it for what it is, and stop making their own conclusions so they can keep themselves out of trouble and to keep them from losing unecessary monies.....period...point blank......
But no one has a right to tell us what to do to that extent. These new rules are just monopolies for the big companies to not have to compete regarding advertisements. THey have to pay millions to be on tv and that is why they are famous because of agresssive marketing...however, on the internet it is basically free and creates equal opportunities for companies who might have a great product but maybe not the marketing power of mac or maybelline. Wake up people.
EXACTLY!!!....therefore....your pockets will be hit if you violate the guidelines...true she did not actually state they would fine people for not setting disclaimers....but she didn't say they wouldn't.....there has to be something thats legally binding in the process....i feel that this goes for anyone who reviews any type of product in their videos/blogs....if there are rules/guidelines.... there are consequences for not following them....period....everyone should just be smart about it...
Thanks for the vid lovey! I saw this video and the girl had seriously freaked out but my yt family told me about and the vid and some told somethings that I could find myself so thank you love!
Well from what I'm hearing this is a good thing ... It's going to protect viewers/ consumers.... a lot of ppl are using their blogs and youtube channel for evil... I guess anyone who complains or is scared about this are the ppl who been deceitful and have no integrity or conscience .... this is only a problem to the ppl who are taking advantage of their viewers by making a profit off of us... simple as that
I am making a video about my christmas wishlist. Do I have to write that discliamer still? Only one of the product on the list was bought (by my parent).
hi erin! yeah, i watched that video last night also, and it did case a massive panic. it seems fairly simple to me, however; if you are given product gratis to review, be sure to mention that it was given to you specifically for review by "x" company. on the other hand, if you aren't sure if you have to disclose or not, just disclose the information and get on with making/posting your video. seems to me that it wouldn't be that much more than listing
whatelse is whack is they do these extravagent reviews, then turn around a month later do a contest a give that junk away. and youre right. it does show when bloggers aren't being honest.
WOW....I just heard about this and I was freaking out too...so thanks for this Erin....Youtube is tripping...or FTC....we are just having fun...leave us alone!!!
I just want to let people know that an agency can levy a fine. An agency is the arm of the government that ensures quick enforcement of their regulations. If they couldn't fine without going through the judicial process agencies like OSHA and the FDA would be moot. Would you really want to wait for a court hearing to have contaminated foods be removed or force an employer to implement safety? NO! This is the same, just consumer protection against disguised infomercials on youtube
First of all...u do look AMAZING gurl. Go head' with your glamified self. Secondly, I TOTALLY agree with the point(s) that you are making in this vid. When I saw said vid (the one the chick was freaking out) I politely did some research and found out it DID NOT and DOES NOT affect me the way she made it seem. Guess it pays to do your research. Thanks for the update sis!
love the hair and the makeup. i am glad you did you research and decided to share. i feel like if you can blog/make vids you can do your own research. no need to delete and erase because your lazy.
So if we do a review or a tutorial on items that we purchased, we DON'T have to put a disclaimer? All these comments are confusing me more than PinkCat...
I agree with you...blog or do videos because you love doing it..
you are 100% right about people giving great reviews just to make money..youtubers are very bright...they can sense an over the top.."OMG!!!YOU HAVE TO GET THIS!!!"type video
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I' glad you clear some of this up, because people really should go to the channel PrincessPinkCat, and listen to her talk, to me it seems something a little deeper, that is going on with her and the FTC. I have a spice company and really need YouTube support. So thanks for relieving our minds about this FTC thing.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
lmao i know like their names arent even elle and blair its lisa and elizabeth and if they dont want their adress given out then they shouldnt ahve a fricken website that when things are sent out it says the exact adress in kingport, tenesse haha i started hating then when u can tell things are lies cuz it just so f'' in obvious lol but yeah ftc cant fine u but they send info to court or whatnot and thats where they fine you so ooooh man i want those girls too be fined it would make my life:) lol
I thank you for clearing this up with a video. I was frustrated that the FTC guidelines were getting mixed up and that no one was understanding the meaning of the changes.
I like your hair. I really don't think an average blogger will be fined. There is just not enough money to hire enough reviewers to check everyone. However, I am sure it you are checked and found in error. You would get a cease and dis-cease order. If you don't, that is when a fine would be accessed.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
that means that allthatglitters12 and "blair" are going to have disclaimers in all thier videos because they get paid to do reviews and tutorials and it's not thier own ideas on the product
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@lightstarxx you are the one who is incorrect. the lady in the other video everyone is watching is telling everyone wrong. you ONLY have to disclose IF you got a product free/are being paid, etc. If you bought the product, you don't have to disclose anything. scandalousbeauty is correct in this. the other older woman is very wrong and freaking people out.
Ok if you want to start telling people that she is wrong you might want to come with some proof. She has so many links to CREDIBLE sources and all you have is your mouth....please go head...
Actually you are wrong. You will not get fined because the FTC doesn't fine. If it determines the person has violated it's guidelines, it will issue a complaint and notice of hearing where the person can show cause why a cease and desist order should not be entered against them. There is a civil penalty ONLY if you violate the cease and desist order but not for violating the guidelines itself. 15 U.S.C. 45 and 16 CFR Part 255. Now that's what's called citing your authority.
Secondly, it doesn't say you "have to say 'I got this free'". You simply have to disclose if you have received anything from the company, money or in-kind exchange (i.e. goodies from the company) to review its product or if you have a relationship of any type with the company.
I agree it does show when people are just in it for the money and free swag! I was sad when you locked your hair since I was on my natural journey but it suits you and I still learn other stuff!
the bill is 13 pages long and available on the FTC's website. I suggest everyone read it themselves. It even gives example scenarios to clarify certain situations. But it does state that you have to disclose how you got your products in every video, post, or tweet or you WILL be held liable. They CAN fine you. Read example 5 on page 4-5 as this directly applies to how beauty bloggers review products.
and i agree with you ...who cares about free products.
BUT one reason its a big deal is lets take juicystar and allthatglitters as examples. They have thousands of 12 year olds as fans who think they are "so kind" "omg blair you bought all those Coach bags for us?thanks your so sweet!"
these little kids have no idea they get all this for free and get 3 free Coach bags too not only that but they have been paid before for other reviews
Thanks for your comments. Actually, if you read the FTC's statements, a representative states that they do not have the authority to fine individuals, but may be able to penalize the brands themselves. Check out the ftc website and the links on the sidebar for more information.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
trust me I know all about the law my dad is a well known cival attorney in LA
im just trying to tell you so you dont get dinged or give out false info like that girl who made that bogus vid
you CAN be fined. The FTC themselves may not have authority but what they will do is investigate claims and then they will go to appropriate authorites and get the ball rolling and fine people
it will be many months before anyone actually has to oay once they have been spotted but it will happen.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
you seem like you know what you are talking about and actually im kinda pissed off at that other persons vid because she is scaring all these people. I saw so many comments "omg i just deleted all my vids after watching your vid"
her vid should be removed
anyways one last thing you CAN NOT say "sample" you will be fined. dont risk it.
Just simply say in the side I got "xxxxx" free from "xxxxxx"
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@999michl i agree--that older lady's video should be removed because she is freaking people (young girls esp.) out and making them think they have to mention every single product and also if they are wearing clothes with a brand, they have to do a disclosure on that. very false! only if they were sent the clothes, etc for free. that lady is screwing a lot of people over by giving them false info.
My issue is companies that send out mass free product and immediately after, they raise prices on buyers to subsidize the costs of the freebies that reviewers keep and give to families and friends. Sigma Makeup is a prime example and sorry, but I am not paying for select Gurus to have free gifts just because I don't make time to do youtube reviews. I think disclosure is simple, easy and should exist and for those with nothing to hide, should not be an issue. Thanks Erin for this update.
I was SO shocked when you told me this! T I know they are trying to do business and makeup money, as well as spread their brand, but it just looks bad.
Indeed. It does look bad and savvy consumers will avoid being a part of the game especially on a new and unproven line.. In other GOOD news, I had a few photos shoots and GIRL...twas HOT ! I can't wait to get the final edits and send you some. Your time was much appreciated and I look forward to scheduling something again soon! You're the best Erin and this look in the video is , wow;)
Hi! i have one quick question about the FTC and i really hope you message back!
When im doing a makeup tutorial could i mention the name of the eyeshadow and the color or what ever the product is? & if i was sent that product do i have to say in the video or just in the sidebar? thank you
I agree with the disclosure. "Free stuff" will make some bloggers post positive reviews about products even though they had a bad experience with it. It makes sense to me now, because one week I'll see a video by a certain blogger claiming that a product is their go to, must have, best brand. Then like 3 days later they post a new vid making the same claims about a diff brand. LOL. Clearly, they were just saying that to get you to buy the company's products. Sneaky. LOL.
I have been hearing about this FTC thing but I do not think it applies outside of the USA. I am sure if any UK bloggers hear of any changes in UK laws I will read about it.
Nice explanation though, I will check out the links too
Thanks for the info. I'm all for disclosure. There are a lot of YouTubers who receive free products and then do product reviews and people believe that they've purchased the whole line of products and they're trying to go broke buying the same products.
Wow! I had no idea about the FTC. The Beauty Industry is keeping the economy Afloat! The last thing they need is to scare Customers whom purchase beauty products not to buy!
Thanks for the information, bc I didn't know what was going on and I was hearing alot of different things. I did some research and found out it wasn't as bad and I was hearing about. But again thanks for doing a vid on this. God Bless YOU!
Erin thanks so much for posting this. i was getting tired of explaining to people that it's not anything to go nuts about and if you receive something for profit you need to tell people. But people are talking about they aren't going to do videos anymore and it's just getting really crazy. So thanks again i truly appreciate this.
Thank you for this video and the links because this will help me to do my own research and hopefully, I will be following the FTC guidelines (and I won't have to make too many adjustments). I'm not worried too much though because I'll just keep in mind to mention, if I received a sample while using it in a video. I think I'm fine for the most part, but still I'll check to make sure. Also I feel that this does keep vloggers and/or "YouTubers" "honest". Thanks again!
Great information. People need to stop freaking out and READ. We go on hearsay too much these days when we can google and search for the information like you did. I was not worried because I READ 1st. With all the information out there people still forget how to search and READ. Great links also and love the lip look. You know how to rock your makeup and hair Erin!!!
thank you for making this video. i was so annoyed by how ppl werefreaking out and making new account when they didnt even know what this whole ftc thing was til just afew days ago
oh my goodness, you have made this much easier to listen to. You're clear about what your trying to say. So if you get if for free, disclose. If you buy it yourself, no need to disclose. One question?? Can we still say i'm using this mac shadow called fig? and sigma brush 224. Is that okay to say? with out putting a disclouser in the side bar?
From my interpretation of the rule, if the only reason you always use MAC or Sigma brushes or any products in your videos is because you were paid by these companies to use them, then YES, you would need to disclose that. But if you use them cuz you bought them and like them... then no.. Hope that makes sense! :D
Ok, thanks for clearing this up, because I was reading the guidelines and I couldn't for the life of me figure out how this impacted me, an individual consumer...SMH. Thanks again!
Luv the make up & hairstyle dear! I'm not so concerned about this FTC thing, it's just a sentence or two, plus I get nothing free lol. Thanks for clarifying!
And one last question! When im doing hauls, tutorials or reivews on some products i got send do i have to mention it in my video or just in the sidebar? im really scared about this FTC thing but i dont wanna be. I just wanna make sure im following the rule correctly. & do i have to list everything i have like in a makeup collection if i was sent them or not? thanks!
A sentence in the sidebar will be fine! All you need to do is simply write something like "I received "product x* as a sample by the company." That's all! You'll be fine!
Awesome video. This is how my lawyer explained it to me after he went through the guidelines. He said that the guidelines are to vague and open to interpretation and given the extremely high risk of being falsely reported that he felt that it was best to disclose everything. He said that whether or not I pay for an item or receive it for free I should still disclose because I would be covering my basis. That way if I was falsely reported, the investigation would stop as quickly as it started.
WHAT DOES FTC STAND FOR?
aeaeui 1 year ago
I definitely think juicystar07 and allthatglitters make videos to get money and exposure to further their fame. i'm not trying to start a big controversy here, but something about them just doesn't seem honest or genuine. i definitely think they feel this is their shot at fame since they don't have any actual talent to make them famous
FASHIONISTADARLING 1 year ago
does it affect british citizens?
HollyMeldrum 1 year ago
I just hate when people are paid and they go "I am affiliated with this company". Also, it's so funny that people still to this day say "hello FTC man, I bought this myself, please leave me alone" that kind of thing..
AccessorizeAlways 1 year ago
I like your makeup in this vid.
DoubleEdgeSword1908 2 years ago
I love your lip gloss, is that from MAC??
katiebug300 2 years ago
Well done. Blessings.
NikiD40 2 years ago
After over 45 minutes on the phone with the FTC, there are SEVERAL things that haven't been clearly spelled out!
While not an official word, I am told that the older videos and posts that "we have control of" must include a disclaimer in some sort of manner..
I can tell you, after 45 minutes on the phone, it's not as simple as "it appears"
I'll be glad to share my info with you scandalousbeauty.
JoleneSugarbaker 2 years ago 2
I was a little confused. If I post on facebook " Today I went shopping and i got some mac stuff..... ______ and I got some Chanel ________ Its soooo awesome! Is that okay? I mean its just my freinds. But on youtube, if im not paid do i even have to mention anything??
please answer.
Thanks!! '
xoxo,
Nicole
Mimasbffl1430 2 years ago
I think this is great, I am glad the FTC is cracking down on this. All the dishonest reviews and product pimping on utube is way out of control. Full disclosure is the way to go. You have a great channel, I am going to subscribe.
MsLulu99 2 years ago 10
:) x
makeupmonster09 2 years ago
Hi Erin, the OFFICIAL Federal Trade Commission video was posted 2 months ago on this topic.
If you want the offical word on the subject, go to FTCvideo here at Youtube!!
It's clear and concise!
Thanks
Dezi1016 2 years ago 5
Thanks Dezi! I linked it.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
What I want is ... I want to be the person getting free stuff!!!!!
quitejaded 2 years ago 3
Can someone please tell me how the FTC regulations apply to people who are not in the USA? It is not an international law, is it? Does it apply to those who are using US based blog services etc...?
O663tt3 2 years ago
i just got a camera to start my beauty blog,,,but i think this is a bit much so i probably wont
MusicLover1903 2 years ago
this video was very helpful thanks for doing it.
Gomez3398 2 years ago
This is very interesting and this is the reason why i haven't completely accepted the offers these companies give me through you-tube...I rather WORK for my money lol not lie to people...i feel u girl!
thomasadrianna 2 years ago
Comment removed
SoftandBeautiful77 2 years ago
another thing...i feel that people should take it for what it is, and stop making their own conclusions so they can keep themselves out of trouble and to keep them from losing unecessary monies.....period...point blank......
SoftandBeautiful77 2 years ago
But no one has a right to tell us what to do to that extent. These new rules are just monopolies for the big companies to not have to compete regarding advertisements. THey have to pay millions to be on tv and that is why they are famous because of agresssive marketing...however, on the internet it is basically free and creates equal opportunities for companies who might have a great product but maybe not the marketing power of mac or maybelline. Wake up people.
khalilahinjapan 2 years ago
EXACTLY!!!....therefore....your pockets will be hit if you violate the guidelines...true she did not actually state they would fine people for not setting disclaimers....but she didn't say they wouldn't.....there has to be something thats legally binding in the process....i feel that this goes for anyone who reviews any type of product in their videos/blogs....if there are rules/guidelines.... there are consequences for not following them....period....everyone should just be smart about it...
SoftandBeautiful77 2 years ago
Thank you Erin... You look beautiful...
mahogany252 2 years ago
ahhhh thanks for this vid... i kept seeing this stuff and was so confused.
MakeupbyCarly24 2 years ago
you are very pretty!! :] so i dont need any disclaimers in my vids if i make hauls and stuff??
peacelovelipglos1000 2 years ago
Thanks for the vid lovey! I saw this video and the girl had seriously freaked out but my yt family told me about and the vid and some told somethings that I could find myself so thank you love!
BabyTigga23 2 years ago
Well from what I'm hearing this is a good thing ... It's going to protect viewers/ consumers.... a lot of ppl are using their blogs and youtube channel for evil... I guess anyone who complains or is scared about this are the ppl who been deceitful and have no integrity or conscience .... this is only a problem to the ppl who are taking advantage of their viewers by making a profit off of us... simple as that
SongBirdC 2 years ago
I am making a video about my christmas wishlist. Do I have to write that discliamer still? Only one of the product on the list was bought (by my parent).
qafrocks97 2 years ago
No, you don't need a disclaimer at all.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
okayy thank you soo much!
qafrocks97 2 years ago
This is really helpful, thank you so much for all the information!
biohazard2886 2 years ago
No prob!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
i heart scan. beauty!!!
wildzephre25 2 years ago
Thank you!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Wow, I had no idea this kind of stuff was going on. Your blog is great and love your vids! :)
micarae 2 years ago
Thanks!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
I usually search reviews on the products that I want to buy before i buy them. Sometimes eventhough someone says I don't like, i'll still buy.
computernb 2 years ago
so if u make a haul from lets say sephora and YOU payed 4 it u have to write NOTHING?
makeuplover303 2 years ago 2
You have to write nothing if you paid for it!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
the "products used" in the tutorial/review. oh well, that's just me i guess.
janelporter 2 years ago
hi erin! yeah, i watched that video last night also, and it did case a massive panic. it seems fairly simple to me, however; if you are given product gratis to review, be sure to mention that it was given to you specifically for review by "x" company. on the other hand, if you aren't sure if you have to disclose or not, just disclose the information and get on with making/posting your video. seems to me that it wouldn't be that much more than listing
janelporter 2 years ago
Exactly! BTW, I've been curling my hair a lot!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Thanks for sharing, great info!!
LoveThySelfandBeTrue 2 years ago 2
whatelse is whack is they do these extravagent reviews, then turn around a month later do a contest a give that junk away. and youre right. it does show when bloggers aren't being honest.
azucarmorena5000 2 years ago
Yup!!!!!!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
love this video love it!!!!!!!
Ramnari7 2 years ago 2
5 STARS*******
shaggylocs7 2 years ago 2
this really helped me... thx^^
anjaf92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HAHA
that means that "ELLE" and "BLAIR" (Lisa and Elizabeth real names)
will have to finally not pretend they "went shopping" and do this as a "fun hobby"
theyll have to disclose that they get a bunch of free crap! hahahah
I guess the jokes on them
OH and we all know that they have been paid many times by companes for reviews
and I just wanted to take this moment to say HELLO to their hollywood agent Richard Frias
hahaha they are fake ACTORS
SUCKERS to anyone who got sucled in
lightstarxx 2 years ago
thanks for the info love!!! i appreciate it. You look beautiful! God bless
naimae 2 years ago
I loveee your look here! You look absolutley gorgeous !
Livin2Worship 2 years ago
WOW....I just heard about this and I was freaking out too...so thanks for this Erin....Youtube is tripping...or FTC....we are just having fun...leave us alone!!!
Makeup is beautiful!!
Ateyaaa 2 years ago
Right?!!? Thanks lady!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
I am lovin that lip! What did you use??
4rmthamidwest 2 years ago
Violetta and Tux De Lux by MAC!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Thx.
I agree. I just wont to know if the products I'm buying is good.
LittlemissSluchice 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thanks for this video it's very helpful!! I was one of those ppl freaking out lol, I saw a video and they made it seem more chaotic and complicated.
tortolita07 2 years ago
I just want to let people know that an agency can levy a fine. An agency is the arm of the government that ensures quick enforcement of their regulations. If they couldn't fine without going through the judicial process agencies like OSHA and the FDA would be moot. Would you really want to wait for a court hearing to have contaminated foods be removed or force an employer to implement safety? NO! This is the same, just consumer protection against disguised infomercials on youtube
hypoxiccrayfish 2 years ago 11
It's so sad how tacky people have become.
calberkeley01 2 years ago 12
First of all...u do look AMAZING gurl. Go head' with your glamified self. Secondly, I TOTALLY agree with the point(s) that you are making in this vid. When I saw said vid (the one the chick was freaking out) I politely did some research and found out it DID NOT and DOES NOT affect me the way she made it seem. Guess it pays to do your research. Thanks for the update sis!
٩(̾●̮̮̃̾•̃̾)۶Kokofemme
kokofemme 2 years ago
Thanks Koko!!!!!!!! Exactly!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
love the hair and the makeup. i am glad you did you research and decided to share. i feel like if you can blog/make vids you can do your own research. no need to delete and erase because your lazy.
sultrydoll 2 years ago
Thanks so much! And I agree.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
great look! such a diva...
cclatinchic1 2 years ago
So if we do a review or a tutorial on items that we purchased, we DON'T have to put a disclaimer? All these comments are confusing me more than PinkCat...
Chrystynsview 2 years ago 11
If you purchased it, you do NOT need a disclaimer.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Very good information
TheAndreaLovesList 2 years ago
I agree with you...blog or do videos because you love doing it..
you are 100% right about people giving great reviews just to make money..youtubers are very bright...they can sense an over the top.."OMG!!!YOU HAVE TO GET THIS!!!"type video
Erin..thank you for keeping everyone informed....
lovekisses99 2 years ago
lol yep! No problem!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
thank you Erin for sharing this information.
lovekisses99 2 years ago
im deleting all recent videos. that may be considered for december 1st
macygurl556 2 years ago
Firstly; you look goregous in this video girl!
Secondly, thanks for the vidoe and info :)
addict4beauty 2 years ago 3
Thank you!!!!!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
very well done. keep us posted.
fedicia1 2 years ago
im surprised they're not making you get licensing!
loymonteiro 2 years ago
You go girl :)
*Rocksterize* makeup tutorials
rocksterize 2 years ago
ty for the info, and ur hair is hot do a tut on it please
cynmille2000 2 years ago
Thanks! I definitely will!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
You look great!!!
NaturallyDivine 2 years ago
Glad you cleared things up... BTW... I love what I can see of your hairstyle. Can you post some pics or do a tutorial?
qochemist 2 years ago
these chicas r not as smart as i thought.thank you erin.u da 1 girl!
LABELLAD83 2 years ago
Comment removed
jujajun99 2 years ago
When I saw the PrincessPinkCat video I thought that was a little overboard... Good to see that it's not that crazy.
Eponine24601 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I' glad you clear some of this up, because people really should go to the channel PrincessPinkCat, and listen to her talk, to me it seems something a little deeper, that is going on with her and the FTC. I have a spice company and really need YouTube support. So thanks for relieving our minds about this FTC thing.
carlissspcies 2 years ago
Thank you SO much for clarifing this for everyone!
I would love to know who came up with that silly $11,000 fine. Someone likes to scare innocent people.
Your videos rock, thanks again!
~Laur
P.S. Do you know if we have to put this disclaimer on videos posted before December 1st? Thanks!
MakeupByLaurenAnne 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Erin, the leader of the internet, has spoken!!!
TiMalice2009 2 years ago
thank you so much for this video !
xxGreenwithPurplexx 2 years ago
Uppppsss.... I meant fined, not find ^^
someone12310 2 years ago
So that mean that those 2 liars "Allthatglitters21" and "Juicystar07" must write annotations to their videos! HAHAHA!!! FINALLY!
Btw. Actually You CAN be find. And You will be find if you won't write "I got this for free from xxx company"
someone12310 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lmao i know like their names arent even elle and blair its lisa and elizabeth and if they dont want their adress given out then they shouldnt ahve a fricken website that when things are sent out it says the exact adress in kingport, tenesse haha i started hating then when u can tell things are lies cuz it just so f'' in obvious lol but yeah ftc cant fine u but they send info to court or whatnot and thats where they fine you so ooooh man i want those girls too be fined it would make my life:) lol
emmalou848 2 years ago
Ohh YES!!! I hope they will be fine!! They're such a sh*t liars! I used to like them... but since i know who they really are...I hell DON'T
someone12310 2 years ago
the FTC can't just fine people.. they have to follow due process just like any other entity.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago 2
I thank you for clearing this up with a video. I was frustrated that the FTC guidelines were getting mixed up and that no one was understanding the meaning of the changes.
pinkyd0124 2 years ago
I like your hair. I really don't think an average blogger will be fined. There is just not enough money to hire enough reviewers to check everyone. However, I am sure it you are checked and found in error. You would get a cease and dis-cease order. If you don't, that is when a fine would be accessed.
Mrsjackie1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
that means that allthatglitters12 and "blair" are going to have disclaimers in all thier videos because they get paid to do reviews and tutorials and it's not thier own ideas on the product
becca99004 2 years ago
this suckss! i hate this new law. but thanks for informing us(:
rachnaheartsyou 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Like ur video better than that old lady, who was freaking everyone out & making a big deal about it when it wasn't like that...
puzzake 2 years ago
im sorry but you are giving out false info
you can actually be fined. Thats the truth.
but whatevs people will watch your vid and if you believe you they can pay thousands in fines lol
and you have to specifally say the word free you cant say I "ordered" i "sampled etc so your annotaions are totally false too
If you dont want a fine DO NOT BELIEVE WHAT THIS GIRL SAYS
go read the guidelines page 5 you will be fined if you dont clearly say the word Free!
lightstarxx 2 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@lightstarxx you are the one who is incorrect. the lady in the other video everyone is watching is telling everyone wrong. you ONLY have to disclose IF you got a product free/are being paid, etc. If you bought the product, you don't have to disclose anything. scandalousbeauty is correct in this. the other older woman is very wrong and freaking people out.
thesusiegreen 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i am not incorrect and i agree the other ladys info was wrong & its pathetic that all these people believed her and deleted their vids
but this girl is also wrong...she says in her vid you cant be fined thats false
YOU CAN AND WILL BE FINED
I hope people dont believe her on that
and also she puts in annotations on this vid that you can say "i got a sample" you CAN NOT you have to say "i got this free"
if this girl wants to take her chances then fine but she shouldnt mislead people
lightstarxx 2 years ago
Ok if you want to start telling people that she is wrong you might want to come with some proof. She has so many links to CREDIBLE sources and all you have is your mouth....please go head...
Thanks for making this vid Erin!
PukhamaD 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is wrong ...but her vid is more honest then that other ladys
proof? sure look at page 4/5 of the FTC guidelines.
I just dont want her to mislead ppl into thinking they wont be fined because honey the truth is they will!
lightstarxx 2 years ago
Actually you are wrong. You will not get fined because the FTC doesn't fine. If it determines the person has violated it's guidelines, it will issue a complaint and notice of hearing where the person can show cause why a cease and desist order should not be entered against them. There is a civil penalty ONLY if you violate the cease and desist order but not for violating the guidelines itself. 15 U.S.C. 45 and 16 CFR Part 255. Now that's what's called citing your authority.
RedSatin69 2 years ago
Secondly, it doesn't say you "have to say 'I got this free'". You simply have to disclose if you have received anything from the company, money or in-kind exchange (i.e. goodies from the company) to review its product or if you have a relationship of any type with the company.
RedSatin69 2 years ago
IT is not as simple as being fined, FTC has to follow due process.
ginabinawina99 2 years ago 2
I agree it does show when people are just in it for the money and free swag! I was sad when you locked your hair since I was on my natural journey but it suits you and I still learn other stuff!
DariceHumphries 2 years ago
loooove the make up!!! thank you for the video :)
nwele 2 years ago
Thanks lady!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Cute hair.
boomboomgirl 2 years ago
you CAN be fined. You are reading wrong
6947BABY 2 years ago 13
im glade i saw this before i deleted all my vids ! thanks so much
phoniex1018 2 years ago
you CAN be fined. You are reading wrong
6947BABY 2 years ago 10
the bill is 13 pages long and available on the FTC's website. I suggest everyone read it themselves. It even gives example scenarios to clarify certain situations. But it does state that you have to disclose how you got your products in every video, post, or tweet or you WILL be held liable. They CAN fine you. Read example 5 on page 4-5 as this directly applies to how beauty bloggers review products.
Annaverseable 2 years ago 20
you CAN be fined. You are reading wrong.
and i agree with you ...who cares about free products.
BUT one reason its a big deal is lets take juicystar and allthatglitters as examples. They have thousands of 12 year olds as fans who think they are "so kind" "omg blair you bought all those Coach bags for us?thanks your so sweet!"
these little kids have no idea they get all this for free and get 3 free Coach bags too not only that but they have been paid before for other reviews
thats wack
999michl 2 years ago 14
Thanks for your comments. Actually, if you read the FTC's statements, a representative states that they do not have the authority to fine individuals, but may be able to penalize the brands themselves. Check out the ftc website and the links on the sidebar for more information.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
trust me I know all about the law my dad is a well known cival attorney in LA
im just trying to tell you so you dont get dinged or give out false info like that girl who made that bogus vid
you CAN be fined. The FTC themselves may not have authority but what they will do is investigate claims and then they will go to appropriate authorites and get the ball rolling and fine people
it will be many months before anyone actually has to oay once they have been spotted but it will happen.
999michl 2 years ago
Thanks!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you seem like you know what you are talking about and actually im kinda pissed off at that other persons vid because she is scaring all these people. I saw so many comments "omg i just deleted all my vids after watching your vid"
her vid should be removed
anyways one last thing you CAN NOT say "sample" you will be fined. dont risk it.
Just simply say in the side I got "xxxxx" free from "xxxxxx"
do not say sample they wont accept it
999michl 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@999michl i agree--that older lady's video should be removed because she is freaking people (young girls esp.) out and making them think they have to mention every single product and also if they are wearing clothes with a brand, they have to do a disclosure on that. very false! only if they were sent the clothes, etc for free. that lady is screwing a lot of people over by giving them false info.
thesusiegreen 2 years ago
you can not say "sample"you have to specifically say it was free...you need to change that
believe it or not some people do not know what "sample" means and the FTC will NOT Accept it.
you dont have to believe me but it has to SPECIFICALLY state it was FREE not "sample" etc.
but I agree that other video is very misleading
999michl 2 years ago 2
My issue is companies that send out mass free product and immediately after, they raise prices on buyers to subsidize the costs of the freebies that reviewers keep and give to families and friends. Sigma Makeup is a prime example and sorry, but I am not paying for select Gurus to have free gifts just because I don't make time to do youtube reviews. I think disclosure is simple, easy and should exist and for those with nothing to hide, should not be an issue. Thanks Erin for this update.
frenchfinish 2 years ago 3
I was SO shocked when you told me this! T I know they are trying to do business and makeup money, as well as spread their brand, but it just looks bad.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Indeed. It does look bad and savvy consumers will avoid being a part of the game especially on a new and unproven line.. In other GOOD news, I had a few photos shoots and GIRL...twas HOT ! I can't wait to get the final edits and send you some. Your time was much appreciated and I look forward to scheduling something again soon! You're the best Erin and this look in the video is , wow;)
frenchfinish 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thanks for the info. I think I know who you're talking about with the inaccurate information, but I'm glad you clarified things :)
blushingantics 2 years ago
Great explanation! Thank you so much! :)
raykhel 2 years ago
Hi! i have one quick question about the FTC and i really hope you message back!
When im doing a makeup tutorial could i mention the name of the eyeshadow and the color or what ever the product is? & if i was sent that product do i have to say in the video or just in the sidebar? thank you
BeauteByTeeBaby 2 years ago
You just have to say it in the sidebar. You can mention whatever you want!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
GREAT INFO
xstacy2 2 years ago
I totally agree with every word you said !!
carmellady46 2 years ago
your ur hair looks great!!!
your makeup is fab as always.
lena7373 2 years ago
Thank you!!!!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Great explanation!! I am all for disclosure just because not all people are completely honest on their reviews.
You look great here btw!! What is on your lips??
Taysha68 2 years ago
Thanks! Violetta and Tux-de-luxe.
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
I agree with the disclosure. "Free stuff" will make some bloggers post positive reviews about products even though they had a bad experience with it. It makes sense to me now, because one week I'll see a video by a certain blogger claiming that a product is their go to, must have, best brand. Then like 3 days later they post a new vid making the same claims about a diff brand. LOL. Clearly, they were just saying that to get you to buy the company's products. Sneaky. LOL.
msebele 2 years ago
Beauty AND brains. Thanks for this!
Kizzyonline 2 years ago
Thank you!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
"...or if you found it" haha.
CrispNoodles 2 years ago
Love the lip colour absolutely beautiful
I have been hearing about this FTC thing but I do not think it applies outside of the USA. I am sure if any UK bloggers hear of any changes in UK laws I will read about it.
Nice explanation though, I will check out the links too
Sofrolushes 2 years ago
Thanks for making a level-headed video about this
kdiddle 2 years ago
Thanks for the info and links it helped me!!!
curiousnubia 2 years ago
Thanks for the info. I'm all for disclosure. There are a lot of YouTubers who receive free products and then do product reviews and people believe that they've purchased the whole line of products and they're trying to go broke buying the same products.
Great vid.
sultry1231 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Finally someone who has gotten this whole FTC thing right. It angers me that some people got the facts wayyyyyyy wrong and upset a lot of people.
saywhatcuteface18 2 years ago
wonderful explanation!! I feel the same way =)
ginabinawina99 2 years ago
Wow! I had no idea about the FTC. The Beauty Industry is keeping the economy Afloat! The last thing they need is to scare Customers whom purchase beauty products not to buy!
ladyrose01z 2 years ago
Hey ma, you look great! Hair and make-up are hot
And thanks for the info
Simplicity75 2 years ago
Thanks for the information, bc I didn't know what was going on and I was hearing alot of different things. I did some research and found out it wasn't as bad and I was hearing about. But again thanks for doing a vid on this. God Bless YOU!
makeupdiva71 2 years ago
Erin thanks so much for posting this. i was getting tired of explaining to people that it's not anything to go nuts about and if you receive something for profit you need to tell people. But people are talking about they aren't going to do videos anymore and it's just getting really crazy. So thanks again i truly appreciate this.
AmourInfinity 2 years ago
I looooooooooove your entire look in this video! The hair, the lips, the liner = A+++
aziajs 2 years ago 3
Great vid erin, thank you for this. I saw one earlier where the girl said something about an $11k fine and it was all kinds of madness erupting, lol.
FALLENANGELBROKENHAL 2 years ago
Thank you for this video and the links because this will help me to do my own research and hopefully, I will be following the FTC guidelines (and I won't have to make too many adjustments). I'm not worried too much though because I'll just keep in mind to mention, if I received a sample while using it in a video. I think I'm fine for the most part, but still I'll check to make sure. Also I feel that this does keep vloggers and/or "YouTubers" "honest". Thanks again!
BargainClipper 2 years ago
Great information. People need to stop freaking out and READ. We go on hearsay too much these days when we can google and search for the information like you did. I was not worried because I READ 1st. With all the information out there people still forget how to search and READ. Great links also and love the lip look. You know how to rock your makeup and hair Erin!!!
TantalizingEyez3 2 years ago 3
thank you for making this video. i was so annoyed by how ppl werefreaking out and making new account when they didnt even know what this whole ftc thing was til just afew days ago
sarahlipstix 2 years ago
oh my goodness, you have made this much easier to listen to. You're clear about what your trying to say. So if you get if for free, disclose. If you buy it yourself, no need to disclose. One question?? Can we still say i'm using this mac shadow called fig? and sigma brush 224. Is that okay to say? with out putting a disclouser in the side bar?
bunny9585 2 years ago
From my interpretation of the rule, if the only reason you always use MAC or Sigma brushes or any products in your videos is because you were paid by these companies to use them, then YES, you would need to disclose that. But if you use them cuz you bought them and like them... then no.. Hope that makes sense! :D
snicoleray 2 years ago
Thanks i was one of them lol you helped a lot lol
sexiinsweet19 2 years ago
I like that lipstick too!! it looks really nice on you!!
SweetKiara008 2 years ago
WTH is FTC????
TheMsDope 2 years ago
@TheMsDope federal trade commission
mizjazzegirl 2 years ago
Thanks for the heads up and you look so darn pretty. :)
Nu20Beauty 2 years ago
such a pretty look!
DonnalaBelle 2 years ago
thank you erin! sorry i tweeted the video. i tweeted it out of panic lol.
~sPNation
ThesPNation 2 years ago
No! Not at all. I'm glad you tweeted about it so someone could provide the appropriate facts! Thanks for doing so!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ook haha. Well I commented again on that FTC vid to direct people to your page for the deal about this issue. Love your hair btw.
~sPNation
ThesPNation 2 years ago
Aww thanks man!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Good video; girl you look fierce. That lipstick is hot.
rmbb10 2 years ago 4
Thank you!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Thank you for making this video! Good stuff.
kimmaytube 2 years ago
Thanks lady!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Thanks for clarifying!!
XthickmadameX 2 years ago 2
Thank you for this video!
makeupwithlee 2 years ago
Ok, thanks for clearing this up, because I was reading the guidelines and I couldn't for the life of me figure out how this impacted me, an individual consumer...SMH. Thanks again!
Blkbderfly 2 years ago 2
Yeah that law vocabulary is not a game! lol
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
thanks for breaking it down, Erin!
kalane 2 years ago
Luv the make up & hairstyle dear! I'm not so concerned about this FTC thing, it's just a sentence or two, plus I get nothing free lol. Thanks for clarifying!
reallynow72 2 years ago 2
And one last question! When im doing hauls, tutorials or reivews on some products i got send do i have to mention it in my video or just in the sidebar? im really scared about this FTC thing but i dont wanna be. I just wanna make sure im following the rule correctly. & do i have to list everything i have like in a makeup collection if i was sent them or not? thanks!
BeauteByTeeBaby 2 years ago
A sentence in the sidebar will be fine! All you need to do is simply write something like "I received "product x* as a sample by the company." That's all! You'll be fine!
scandalousbeauty 2 years ago
Awesome video. This is how my lawyer explained it to me after he went through the guidelines. He said that the guidelines are to vague and open to interpretation and given the extremely high risk of being falsely reported that he felt that it was best to disclose everything. He said that whether or not I pay for an item or receive it for free I should still disclose because I would be covering my basis. That way if I was falsely reported, the investigation would stop as quickly as it started.
PrincessPinkcat 2 years ago 3