I have never seen so much bitching about James' performance. Shut the fuck up already. James was not able to sing well again until about 2006. After they recorded Octavarium, he really strengthened his vocals. I have been pleased ever since. I think he sounds really good now, and he rocks the older songs really hard! Go find the newest performance of Caught In a Web :) You'll hear him nailing ALL those notes just like on record.
In a garden where the seeds were spilled I favored the few that stood strong in the sun As I reached for the profit of my prize i found i have trampled the forgotten ones.
In a garden where the seeds were spilled I favored the few that stood strong in the sun As I reached for the profit of my price i found i have trampled the forgotten ones.
dream theater would be my favorite band of all time if there were no vocals. I could never get into the "opera" singers of "power metal" or "prog" or whatever you genre geeks label it lol. Great musicians, just spare me the vocals.
@paisteuser06 Check out the band "Liquid Tension Experiment". They are pretty much an instrumental version of Dream Theater (same members except for the bassist and there's no singer).
LaBrie is the weakest element in the Dream Theater Chain. He can't sing very well at Live Concerts. So I prefer the original recording. With Charly. ;-)
it was a flaw in the production that made it sound weird. the drums and bass were weird. i prefered the original vocalist myself. he didn't mess with hard rock rocals unnecessarily
@tomy000 The quality of this live version is really good though. I think it's one of their "official" boot legs and can be purchased. I have a copy myself. Sounds very good.
@tomy000 only if James sounds like he does on his solo albums or the last Dream Theater album... his live renditions tend to show a liitle too much strain (i.e. Chaos in Motion)
@tomy000 JLB can't nearly sing like CD, if you listen the other song of this live, you see he simply can't reach him. Just the fact he needs to pronounce every single vocal like an "e" to stay tuned... and the lack of expression... he's not the man for this genre, though charlie was at the time. when dream and day unite must remain as it is
@shreddingjoris I agree, although for some reason I like the really rough not so perfect sound of the original album. It marks how far they've come. GO DREAM THEATER!
Hey, does anybody know what key this is in. I have to figure it out for myself now cause all the tabs on the internet are Guitar Pro and other garbage like that.
On a second note, Damn! Dominici actually sang this one better.
mmmm yeah i think t same labrie alwwaays change the dominici songs but ionly in a fortune in lies sound better than dominici but you still rock like a god labrie¡¡¡
I dont know men, I honestly think that Dominici was the apropiated guy for WDADU, I like Jame a thousand times more, but I think that Dominici has the tone for this album
Nice to hear this song up to date. James always gets a grilling for his vocal style. Personally I think he does a great job. It cant be easy trying to sing dominici's style as alot of the material he sang was out of his vocal range.
2bad everything beyond 1999 is pure crap with DT.
Skedaren 4 days ago
I love Labrie, but this song is for Charlie.
gasol777 1 week ago
0 dislike, that's the way i like!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
AndyRhoadsVai 2 months ago
Wow this was amazing!
VinuraVinura 2 months ago
I have never seen so much bitching about James' performance. Shut the fuck up already. James was not able to sing well again until about 2006. After they recorded Octavarium, he really strengthened his vocals. I have been pleased ever since. I think he sounds really good now, and he rocks the older songs really hard! Go find the newest performance of Caught In a Web :) You'll hear him nailing ALL those notes just like on record.
Xallia621 3 months ago
Portnoy is a TRUE musician
LarsUlrichFan07 5 months ago
Standing there like cult members...show you're still breathing n mosh a little...
blaklodge 6 months ago
Labrie kills this. terrible
MUDSHARK111 7 months ago
1.17 = Can be in the collection of "Labrie´s worst moments",a huge collection...
Great song,Petrucci puts so much in it,but wake up DT,a high note does not need to be so awful,geoff tate showed us that so well
GabrielDhalaman 11 months ago
Good good... James totally ruins this song!
SpiritofSteele 1 year ago
i love dt with charlie
heavymetalleprechaun 1 year ago
Great song!
SuperXpress2 1 year ago
yeah yeah yeah!men you got it i'm fucking fan of dream theater alright mike portnoy!!!
The1905august 1 year ago
i agree, i respect charly but i prefer James on vocals.....
theextremista 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In a garden where the seeds were spilled I favored the few that stood strong in the sun As I reached for the profit of my prize i found i have trampled the forgotten ones.
wodfurg 1 year ago
In a garden where the seeds were spilled I favored the few that stood strong in the sun As I reached for the profit of my price i found i have trampled the forgotten ones.
wodfurg 1 year ago
i dont really like labrie.
heavymetalleprechaun 1 year ago
@heavymetalleprechaun listen Charlie D with DT and you'll like James a little more :P
VHDT10 1 year ago
@heavymetalleprechaun you are weird, and have no taste of music.
RadicalMetalhead 1 year ago
dream theater would be my favorite band of all time if there were no vocals. I could never get into the "opera" singers of "power metal" or "prog" or whatever you genre geeks label it lol. Great musicians, just spare me the vocals.
paisteuser06 1 year ago
@paisteuser06 Check out the band "Liquid Tension Experiment". They are pretty much an instrumental version of Dream Theater (same members except for the bassist and there's no singer).
metalrules13 1 year ago
its fynny how you can hear the count of portnoy in the pad sound so loud rigth?
dt for life
even if the play reggeaton hahaha
angelkf87 1 year ago
LaBrie is the weakest element in the Dream Theater Chain. He can't sing very well at Live Concerts. So I prefer the original recording. With Charly. ;-)
TheExplorer2000 1 year ago
I prefer Dominici's vocals for this song, but LaBrie does alright. :)
Arkatox 1 year ago
@Arkatox I bet you didnt heard him singing this song back to 92's haha
demonight2 1 year ago
WONDERFUL! And very inspiring.
sanaxe 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
John Petrucci is a fag.
Zeraninator 1 year ago
@Zeraninator you are a fagg asshole
Satch6strings 1 year ago 3
Troll'd.
Zeraninator 1 year ago
grandissima performance di labrie!!!!
Andy8329 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Very bad singing by Labrie! His high notes are out of tune!
doriamedina 2 years ago
Isn't JLB starting way to soon. Everyone looked at eachother wierd..
nightmarecinematic 2 years ago
On the original album Dominici starts in exactly the same spot, so I don't think so. Maybe Portnoy was just doing one of his faces :P
OllieLeMerc69 1 year ago
I love it ! awesome
kvedvaldas 2 years ago 7
can hardly hear rudess
pekisi 2 years ago
Are you deaf?
iluvsystemofadown 2 years ago
no, the keyboad gain must be really low... i guess
Furthermore, if i was deaf i couldn0t bea ble too hear anything =P
pekisi 2 years ago
please tawer , this song, but in spanish!
KeysNFire 2 years ago
Great song!
nightmarecinematic 2 years ago
they should rerecord the whole album with james on vocals...it would sound amazing...
tomy000 2 years ago 23
it was a flaw in the production that made it sound weird. the drums and bass were weird. i prefered the original vocalist myself. he didn't mess with hard rock rocals unnecessarily
dinkaDPB 1 year ago
@tomy000 The quality of this live version is really good though. I think it's one of their "official" boot legs and can be purchased. I have a copy myself. Sounds very good.
Herreken 1 year ago
@tomy000 only if James can sing like he does in his solo albums, or the last Dream Theater one..
godesteem 1 year ago
@tomy000 only if James sounds like he does on his solo albums or the last Dream Theater album... his live renditions tend to show a liitle too much strain (i.e. Chaos in Motion)
godesteem 1 year ago
@tomy000 they already did it, what do you think this DVD is?
solariumetallium 9 months ago
@solariumetallium I think he meant in studio, I agree with him, it would be amazing
juamposo 9 months ago
@solariumetallium lololololol
YtseJam16 8 months ago
@tomy000 JLB can't nearly sing like CD, if you listen the other song of this live, you see he simply can't reach him. Just the fact he needs to pronounce every single vocal like an "e" to stay tuned... and the lack of expression... he's not the man for this genre, though charlie was at the time. when dream and day unite must remain as it is
Goldigin 6 months ago
@Goldigin two very diferent singers, not supposed to reproduce, labrie is better anyway
boredperson81 4 months ago
They should rerecord these songs (not live) on a cd, there sound is much clearer now
shreddingjoris 2 years ago 2
@shreddingjoris I agree, although for some reason I like the really rough not so perfect sound of the original album. It marks how far they've come. GO DREAM THEATER!
lehmanpolarbear70 2 years ago
I think, this song sounds far better with Dominici. But this version is good, too. :-)
Mioline 2 years ago 2
Hey, does anybody know what key this is in. I have to figure it out for myself now cause all the tabs on the internet are Guitar Pro and other garbage like that.
On a second note, Damn! Dominici actually sang this one better.
mgunn77 2 years ago
i thought Charlie Dominici sang on this DVD? why is it called reunite if the old members weren't there for an actual reunion? lol
ironwolg 2 years ago
Charlie and Derek came in for the encore.
FlashCE 2 years ago
awesome, how did Charlie do?
and why not Kevin Moore? does he just not like DT?
ironwolg 2 years ago
I prefer the earlier more melodical dream theater shtuff to the new stuff
duggers108 2 years ago 2
the musicianship and production are so clean that it sounds as good as a studio version.
bloodbrotherz67 2 years ago 3
Dream Theater is so amazing
Leandreamo 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I love the keyboard work on this song.
ddensu 2 years ago
mmmm yeah i think t same labrie alwwaays change the dominici songs but ionly in a fortune in lies sound better than dominici but you still rock like a god labrie¡¡¡
lakabragris 2 years ago
I think Petrucci is much better looking with shorter hair :)
ShiftyBmusic 2 years ago
God damn, James sings these WDADU songs a dozen times better than that dominici-guy.
fearfate 2 years ago 3
I dont know men, I honestly think that Dominici was the apropiated guy for WDADU, I like Jame a thousand times more, but I think that Dominici has the tone for this album
ironcult666 2 years ago
Yea I think Dominici sounds better for the whole CD WDDU.. but James does a good enough job. cause i like his shit in all the other cds
thedude4044 2 years ago
This song Rocks.
alexwinged 2 years ago
I like Dominici for this song
NMartinez12 2 years ago
One of my favorites. SO underrated. Amazing quality too. Thanx
DTismajesty 2 years ago
hell you`re right, this song is sooo cool but underrated as well
sexypadri 2 years ago
perfeito o que mais posso dizer !
facsony 3 years ago
...damn even though James ruined the "I've always believed in you part" to bad stupid opera shit
carlellement 3 years ago
Nice to hear this song up to date. James always gets a grilling for his vocal style. Personally I think he does a great job. It cant be easy trying to sing dominici's style as alot of the material he sang was out of his vocal range.
danofmayz 2 years ago 3
man I love this shit soooooo much
carlellement 3 years ago
wow the sound quality is awesome
PimpMasterT 3 years ago