Bernoulli's principle is that as the velocity increases, so does the pressure. The video states exactly the opposite, so it is wrong. The simplified Bernoulli's eqtn is P=4v2, where the velocity is squared and then multiplied by a factor of 4. As you can see, pressure has a direct relationship with velocity. Please don't get misinformed by this video.
The blowing across paper thing does NOT demonstrate Bernoulli's principle. If blowing over the top lifts the paper because of the "low pressure", then blowing over the underside must pull the paper downwards. Except it doesn't. Try it -- it's clearly not true...
the explanation at 1:35 is wrong. The fluid doesn't move faster, because it "has" to go a longer distance. That sounds like two air particles which start at one end of the frisbee must get together again on the other side. Why should they? The air particle above doesn't know, how fast the air particle below moves. Of coure the air is quicker above. But the explanation is wrong.
@mikrosbobos Well I gotta say that I don't know why I wrote that :-D ("Of course the air is quicker above"), that's just wrong, sorry.
The right explanation is: The air particles are being directed downwards by the wing. So there is an impulse and therefore (many impulses per period) a force downwards (caused by the air molecules). Due to Newton's actio=reactio there's also a force upwards (representing the uplift). The Bernoulli-Effect is insignificant regarding the uplift.
Muy ingenioso me gusto el video los felicito yo soy profesor de fisica y matematica en argentina pueden entrar en you tube "profesor paez " y ver la explicacion de estatica y dinamica.
When air pressure from the top decreases due to speed, is there air pressure from the bottom which causes it (frisbee for instance) to go up and if so in what direction is the air pressure from the bottom? If anyone can shed some light, thanks.
air has equal pressure in every direction, when the air is rushing over tho top the air pressure decreases so there is greater pressure under the frisbee.
It's a widespread misconception that air which gets split by an airfoil must rejoin again at the trailing edge. In fact, air only rejoins if the airfoil is adjusted to give zero lifting force! When generating lift, the air DOESN'T rejoin. (Many beginners' books get this point wrong, and so they explain airfoils wrong.)
Don't believe me? Go search "incorrect lift theory" for the NASA page that debunks the misconception. It's called "Equal Transit Time" error.
Also search on keywords "Equal transit time fallacy
Air does travel faster over the top of an airfoil. But it travels *way* faster than the air below the airfoil. It travels so fast that the divided air can never rejoin ...and the divided air remains forever split. You can find online wind-tunnel photos which show this process, and physics papers which go into the details.
So, why the difference in speed above? Ah, THAT'S the question. Understand that, and you'll really grasp airfoils.
You say the true: Bernoulli is used to explain why something flights in beginners books. I don't think they get it wrong, it's done on purpose because it is than simple to remember that where the velocity is higher, the pressure is lower and vice versa. But you're also right when you say that it is explained wrong: at the end is never said that the explanation lacks of exactness.
I myself when I got this explanation for the first time came up with the simple question: why do the two fluid particle have to meet at the other end? The person who was teaching me actually gave me a reason for it and I believe it for years :(
Thanks for your suggestions: I'll go and read it! :D
Thank you for doing that. I was going to correct the error, but it was nice having it done already. Plus, you beat my by a year, so you probably saved a lot of people from that mistake.
this does have to do with bernoullis principle. Isnt the fact that paper lifts when you blow over it due to bernoullis principle? That demonstrates the basic concept of lift
While very cool, these are demonstrations of complex air flow, not Bernoulli's principle.
D. Bernoulli was studying the effect on liquids specifically, not fluids in general. His principle is highly idealized and strictly applies to incompressible liquids (air is not incompressible or a liquid) with laminar flow (air is usually turbulent), and no viscosity (no fluid is without viscosity).
(Check any NASA or Air Force website if you don't believe me.)
Bernoulli's principle is that as the velocity increases, so does the pressure. The video states exactly the opposite, so it is wrong. The simplified Bernoulli's eqtn is P=4v2, where the velocity is squared and then multiplied by a factor of 4. As you can see, pressure has a direct relationship with velocity. Please don't get misinformed by this video.
okiebsooner 4 months ago
Bernoulli's effect? NO.
I believe the basic premise regarding velocity and pressure is wrong in these cases. Wrong explanation to what is really occurring.
mkl3opt 6 months ago
song?
fnairportmovies 7 months ago
GENIALES TODOS LOS EXPERIMENTOS!!
DoriWP 1 year ago
The blowing across paper thing does NOT demonstrate Bernoulli's principle. If blowing over the top lifts the paper because of the "low pressure", then blowing over the underside must pull the paper downwards. Except it doesn't. Try it -- it's clearly not true...
cliveso 1 year ago
very helpful ! Thanks
HipHopUploadz 1 year ago
nice, now in case i can visit USA again i know how to spread that thing around neighbors yards and so on)))
sagabhcrew 1 year ago
Perfect for halloween papering of trees and houses with the toilet paper guns, Let the fun begin !
spiralreplicator 1 year ago
so really good.
john7epino 1 year ago
the explanation at 1:35 is wrong. The fluid doesn't move faster, because it "has" to go a longer distance. That sounds like two air particles which start at one end of the frisbee must get together again on the other side. Why should they? The air particle above doesn't know, how fast the air particle below moves. Of coure the air is quicker above. But the explanation is wrong.
AlJoKo21 1 year ago
what is the right explanation then? why it goes faster?
mikrosbobos 1 year ago
@mikrosbobos Well I gotta say that I don't know why I wrote that :-D ("Of course the air is quicker above"), that's just wrong, sorry.
The right explanation is: The air particles are being directed downwards by the wing. So there is an impulse and therefore (many impulses per period) a force downwards (caused by the air molecules). Due to Newton's actio=reactio there's also a force upwards (representing the uplift). The Bernoulli-Effect is insignificant regarding the uplift.
AlJoKo21 1 year ago
Comment removed
AlJoKo21 1 year ago
I do wish people knew the difference between Bernoulli and Coanda. Don't worry your not alone.
identernet 2 years ago
thx that helped me understand Bernoulli's principle.
MrMohamed1993 2 years ago
Muy ingenioso me gusto el video los felicito yo soy profesor de fisica y matematica en argentina pueden entrar en you tube "profesor paez " y ver la explicacion de estatica y dinamica.
Me causo gracia la ultima parte..ok
ropaez2001 2 years ago
what shame. think of all the poor students who could not wipe their ass because somone had already stolen all the toilet paper from the bathrooms :(
plord28 2 years ago 18
Comment removed
tinc57 2 years ago
This is just friction. It has nothing to do with Bernoulli. Also check out "equal transit time fallacy".
HomoBorealis 2 years ago
When air pressure from the top decreases due to speed, is there air pressure from the bottom which causes it (frisbee for instance) to go up and if so in what direction is the air pressure from the bottom? If anyone can shed some light, thanks.
number098 2 years ago
air has equal pressure in every direction, when the air is rushing over tho top the air pressure decreases so there is greater pressure under the frisbee.
1Flyboy1123 2 years ago
Jeez, is that a rocket in his pocket?
siouxieblair 2 years ago
What song is this?
bekkil5 2 years ago
The frisbee part is wrong.
It's a widespread misconception that air which gets split by an airfoil must rejoin again at the trailing edge. In fact, air only rejoins if the airfoil is adjusted to give zero lifting force! When generating lift, the air DOESN'T rejoin. (Many beginners' books get this point wrong, and so they explain airfoils wrong.)
Don't believe me? Go search "incorrect lift theory" for the NASA page that debunks the misconception. It's called "Equal Transit Time" error.
wbeaty 2 years ago 11
Also search on keywords "Equal transit time fallacy
Air does travel faster over the top of an airfoil. But it travels *way* faster than the air below the airfoil. It travels so fast that the divided air can never rejoin ...and the divided air remains forever split. You can find online wind-tunnel photos which show this process, and physics papers which go into the details.
So, why the difference in speed above? Ah, THAT'S the question. Understand that, and you'll really grasp airfoils.
wbeaty 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@wbeaty
You say the true: Bernoulli is used to explain why something flights in beginners books. I don't think they get it wrong, it's done on purpose because it is than simple to remember that where the velocity is higher, the pressure is lower and vice versa. But you're also right when you say that it is explained wrong: at the end is never said that the explanation lacks of exactness.
matt2virgilio 1 year ago
I myself when I got this explanation for the first time came up with the simple question: why do the two fluid particle have to meet at the other end? The person who was teaching me actually gave me a reason for it and I believe it for years :(
Thanks for your suggestions: I'll go and read it! :D
matt2virgilio 1 year ago
Comment removed
matt2virgilio 1 year ago
@wbeaty
Thank you for doing that. I was going to correct the error, but it was nice having it done already. Plus, you beat my by a year, so you probably saved a lot of people from that mistake.
trekgeek1 11 months ago
interesting
gtawhatwhat 3 years ago
bello..grazie
domyaska 3 years ago
Muy interesante. Creo que lo intentaré en clase.
Hammandy 3 years ago
Bernoulli is the best genie.
rherculano 3 years ago
this does have to do with bernoullis principle. Isnt the fact that paper lifts when you blow over it due to bernoullis principle? That demonstrates the basic concept of lift
pcbh84 3 years ago
this is gay and hardly anything to do with flight. wanker!
mynameiscaleb 3 years ago
Hey dumbass, It has everything to do with flight. It is the basic principal that explains how airfoils generate lift.
mpd19666 3 years ago
While very cool, these are demonstrations of complex air flow, not Bernoulli's principle.
D. Bernoulli was studying the effect on liquids specifically, not fluids in general. His principle is highly idealized and strictly applies to incompressible liquids (air is not incompressible or a liquid) with laminar flow (air is usually turbulent), and no viscosity (no fluid is without viscosity).
(Check any NASA or Air Force website if you don't believe me.)
FizxChick 3 years ago 2
Air can be treated as incompressible below about Mach .8. Also air can be treated as invicid for general calculations at sea level
mpd19666 3 years ago