Added: 4 years ago
From: kellyclarkson
Views: 6,577,502
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (6,581)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • A beautiful girl with an amazing voice! So much better than most of today's chart singers.

  • when i was seven i was SO in love with this song and every other kelly clarkson song :p

  • 458 pepole voted for Justin Guarini

  • shes not fat shes just put on weight. you know? like a normal person. because believe it or not celebrities are human.

  • i'm in love with 2:15

  • Clarkson's so natural, always just herself in her music and interviews. She's just a normal person who's famous through her music. It's great that she can seperate her working life and keep her personal life out of the media. :D

  • SHE IS TOTALLY AWESOME!!!! 

  • I always wanted that scarf when this song just came out..

    seems like such a long time ago!

  • Comment removed

  • TO PPL CALLING HER FAT - you are whats wrong with this world, making girls who arent even big want lipo etc , its sick !!

    appreciate someone whos a normal size, naturaly pretty and not faked up to the max in the showbiz world!

    i wish there were more singers around like Kelly !!!

    get a grip saddos

  • this is the awsomenest song eva shes the best singer shes so like my idle i so would stalk her if i could

  • shes not fat at all, people so stupid these days, shes really pretty. seen her live was really good! :)

  • @missloz182 i no right i went 2 her last concert shes so the best shes better than nickleback lol

  • Just because she's not a stick, doesnt mean she's fat.

  • If people call her a fat girl, i only want to date fat girls =)

  • hell she's hot who says she's fat? Idiots

  • excuse me but i would LOVE to be "fat" like Kelly Clarkson! Shes GORGEOUS.

  • shes so pretty :)

    & this song is amazing.

  • she is nowhere near fat!  she's a perfect healthy weight. people saying she is overweight seriously have something wrong with them!

  • fat or skinny, who gives a crap, she's an awsome singer and holds her own, get a life shallow people, only real people exist !!!!!

  • if those of you calling Kelly fat mean gorgeous, then she is... gorgeous! :) x

  • haha why is there a wright discussion here? take it elsewhere. enjoy the music :)

  • she is not fat, she's fine, congrats the media has brainwashed you

  • I lOvE hEr :D

  • If she's fat then I must be HUGE because there is no way she is fat in this!

  • @LostandFrozan haha u probly r huge lol

  • @madisonmalowiecki Excuse me? Being an average 15 year old girls weight isn't huge.

  • @LostandFrozan ur the one who said it :S lol + im 16 ^_^

  • Swear you actually have to starve yourself these days to not be considered 'fat' what's happend to real women?

  • fat? she's slim!

  • The title describes Kelly in one :)

  • she is not fat xoxo me

  • THE NEXT PARTY CALLS ME KELLY

  • Comment removed

  • I love kelly and she looks amazing in this video but I must admit she has gained alot of weight. She needs to get on a treadmill tbh

  • @jake27990 she may have gained some weight but at least she isnt size 0 like most people. shes normal sized

  • Brown hair suets her wel

  • it's not about being fat..... it's about how good a singer she is.....

  • people are calling her fat?

    if that so is i also want to be fat like her!

  • @hayel58 fat must be the new lingo that hippin' and hoppin' young whippersnappers use to describe HBIC's like Kelly Clarkson. I believe nowadays it's spelt with a 'ph' at the front now though to make it more edgy. Youth these days ;)

    lol jk, I'm 17. Yeah, haters are irrelevant. Kelly is flawless

  • @hayel58 shes soooo hot

  • Love this song, brings back memories! About her being fat... well, if she's fat, then I don't know a lot of people who aren't. In this vid anyway, she has a really good figure.

  • Love this song!

  • lol fat? her buid is prefect

  • She's skinny, now good.

  • 458 people are fat

  • No wonder so many females have issues with their weight when they are being called fat and they aren't

  • she is beautiful in all of her music vid

  • she aint fat!

  • How the bloody hell is she fat?? Your just jealous of her cause shes got decent curves which you could probably never get in a million years :3

  • this song has such an amazing meaning. a girl who finally let someone in.

  • @joanacrisologo Except, you know... she didn't write the song.

  • @SkullXII ye i know its the american idol song written for the winner. even if a hobo wrote it, the meaning of the song still remains the same to me

  • @joanacrisologo

    nah it was supposed to be Christina aguilera's song for stripped but she gave it to Kelly instead... :)

  • Even if she was fat (which she isn't) what does that have to do with her singing she is an awsome singer

  • fat? daim i never wanted to thrash a fatty before so much and ive had a few in my time

  • she's nog fat, she's awesome !

    Thumps up if you're agreeee ^^

  • She isnt fat :s well i dont think she is anyway x

  • Men wake up to these disulusioned self entitled princesess there all independent until the dirty hard labour hapens or untill the ship goes down and then they become dependent on the man and it ladies first again, but not next time they should be made wait in line and drown with the men.

  • WHAT HAPPENED TO MY CINNAMON BUNS!

    listen, you will hear it too :)

  • @trufflesswarley ....i heard that too after i red this phahahah made me chuckle :D x

  • @trufflesswarley I thought I was the only one who thought who heard that line. Haha. But hey, the song's great. :)

  • i've loved this song and always will

  • yeaa i bet she does look fat standing beside mary-kate && ashley "havent had a real meal since full house" olsen && paris "i get lipo 4 dessert" hilton... damn!

  • i love this song!!...i wonder why Christina Aguilera ignored this to be a part of her album stripped...hmm..

  • @jehsz23 The album is called "stripped" for a reason

  • wtf is wrong with America? Fat?... you're fuckin crazy... Chunky?... Not even... Who the fuck decides what is fat and chunky? Are they dating a stick figure? This beautiful girl is perfectly normal.... fuck you hollywood, brainwashed fucks.... i guarantee half of you who even post on here will never fuck a girl even close to her league.... Fuck the general public... she's hot.

  • 455 people are hip hop junkies

  • Kelly has always been a little chunky but never fat bc i am the size as she is in this video!! I fucking love kelly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I had no idea that this was going to originally be Christina Aguilera's song, but it makes sense. Totally her [old] style. :)

  • I Love it when she just let's it go and belts it out!!!!! DAmn!!!! Sing it....

  • Before some of you people call her fat, look at yourself in the mirror.

  • @ffxswiman33 THAT MAKES SINCE ACTUALLY

  • Kelly, you're very beautiful, very talented, and, I think, create music of genius; songs that are very brave, honest, courageous ...

    What a GREAT song this is; it ROCKS big time, and sounds brilliant 7 years on; standing the test of time really, really well ...

  • vest song ice it came out i love it best singer great performace great lyrics everything great. shes great no scratch that the actor is hot to :p""""

  • This totally rocks! :D

    

  • hahahha, if that's fat you guys are a bit sick! i also wanna be as fat as her... gr8 song and singer

  • ATTENTION: POSTED ON HER VEVO ACCOUNT WITH SINCE U BEEN GONE TOO. :D

  • who needs A man all they are good for is????

  • i luv this song because this is how i feel

  • ta chida esta rola

  • @snak13esoe

    what were you trying to say?

    "ta chida esta rola"

  • @Pestydestini its slang, por this songs awesome lol..

    chid@- cool/awesome

    rola - song (:

  • @rebblebb

    OHHHHHHH.

    I'm so whitee :D

    Thannkss!!

  • @Pestydestini wanted to say that the song is good

  • @snak13esoe

    Did you mean "este rocas'?

    Sorry im learnin spanish so im like obsessed.aahah.

  • If you guys think this video is great, check out mine! I sang this song for my high school talent show and won first place! go see, "Miss Independent by Katie."

  • sweet song! so offense, but the pic quality is crap.

  • This is the only song I like by Kelly Clarkson.. I absolutely hate all her other songs

  • @weirdscience85 If you like this song, I hope you would like it if another person sang it as well! I sang this song at my high school talent show! I won first place. I hope you come and watch it! It's in my videos called, "Miss Katie White singing Miss Independent."

  • @icecreamshakemama- Must have been good, I would have loved it

  • @weirdscience85 same

  • Kelly looks really pretty in this!

  • shit if that guy came up to me i wouldn't want to be independent anymore!!!

  • this song has become my jam! but when i first heard this song, i pictured the musci video as kelly walking around with a bunch of guys wantin her to his girlfriend, and she's like, "no. get away from me" and then one of them looks her in the eyes and she falls in love

  • @popsuperstar1000 i kno wright?

  • Nice song and video! I love Kelly!

  • YES! KELLY ISN'T TAKEN OVER BY VEVO!!!!

  • @pepsiorcoke17  WAHOOOO!!!!!!!!

  • @Bambylse I concur with u. :) 

  • Hd version on my channel for the ppI Iike me who dont take pixeI Shit in

  • LOVE THIS SONG!

  • I think shes sexy as hell! She could be 300lbs, as long as she keeps her voice, Ill always be in love with her. I get goosebumbs when she hits the high notes and I get chubb,lol

  • LOVE THIS SONG!

  • dain how'd she get her hair to look like that its so perrty :)

    my hair is super straight and never does that :(

  • @topmodelparasiempre Better, my hair is like its exploded 0.o

  • I guess in my youth I might have been a little vein what can I say I am older now but not always easy to deal with!

    I'm A HANDFUL!!! Unfortunately most women won't repost this. I'm strong willed, independent, and outspoken, I make mistakes, I am sometimes out of control and at ...times hard to handle - but if you can't handle me at my worst then you sure don't deserve me at my best. If you're a HANDFUL ...then post this on your status....I DARE You!!!

  • Christina Aguilera's job. right? Kelly I love you

  • @XxXtinaLover is there a demo of Christina singing this?

  • @mdash1348 I think it doesn't...

    You can find the original version of Fighter If you want... search 'fighter original demo' :D

  • this song is totally me!!OMG!!i love kelly clarkson,,,her songs inspire me,,,:))

  • Comment removed

  • people who call her fat are seriously crazy. really people look at yourself , you should wish you had that figure .

  • wait people are calling her fat?

    hahahahaha

    what stupid people

  • @Cazzanevo i agree, that is what's called a healthy weight x

  • @Cazzanevo I LOVE KELLY but she is little fat....but her voice is the same...awesome

  • @TheVeronicasBestFan

    But the point is she doesn't look fat to me. I am confused as to why people would think this.

  • Breakaway album was sheer genius

  • Christina Aguilara wrote this song with a bunch of other people for Kelly! Great song! Great lyrics! Great singer!

  • do people say that she's fat. well she's not. she's great.+ if she was it wouldn't matter 'cuz I would pick music because I like it. not because of the look of the singer.

    who else.

  • @robinrosie AGREED

  • Yea!!!

    this sounds so much like Xtina Aguilera, she should have kept it on her Stripped Album!!! luv u Xtina!!!

    but Kelly pulls it off amazingly!! Rock on Kelly!!!

  • i want her jacket

  • the thing I like about kelly is she dosent have to dress up like a slut to sell alburns cause she actually has talent

  • looks like one of my parties :D hahahaha

  • how is that fat!? that's a normal weight! :/ god, you people are so screwed in the head.

  • @pillowpeeknow lolz. yep they are.

  • omg she looks so young here ^_^ i l<3ve miss independent xD

  • damn!! if that's what people think is fat then i wanna be fat too

    

  • @alinaraquel2104 Me too! She looks great!

  • @smexytbone i know right

    and shes sings awesome

  • @alinaraquel2104 Hah !

    me too :DD

  • @alinaraquel2104  ha ha!

  • @alinaraquel2104 Join the club! Loll x

  • @alinaraquel2104 Kelly's gorgeous!!!

  • @alinaraquel2104 LOL no, this was 2001?!

    She went huuuge recently

  • @spiderlegs1987 She went big after she won american idol shortly before this video came out. Maybe you've been living under a rock or have secluded taste in music/only listen to the charts.

  • shes not fat!, god.. you people who say that are not true fans!

  • She was better in her CD thankful... now she's very ugly

  • @bazivi this is what's wrong with the music industry, judge by the song and not by looks because all of these "hotties" bring out songs that are either meant to brainwash you or utter crap.

  • She's an amazing singer of healthy NOT fat weight. Good for her!

  • how is a person who isnt super skinny fat!!!! grow up!! for all we know you could be fat!!

  • great! I just got this song out of my head NOW ITS BACK IN!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • love it when she´s screaming, get totally out of control!

  • Jesus will ppl stop talkin about her weight?? she's a singer not a cat walk model

  • kelly is amazing ive seen her live!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • ild like 2 put my fat c??? in her fat c???

  • is TAYLOR LAUTNER is this?? lol :)

  • @kayhla97 do u have any idea when this was made -_- taylor lautner was like under ten yrs old.

  • @kayhla97 in wath minut?? ( sorry for my bad english )

  • I prefer her with brown hair than blond.

    Mad Video

  • Love this track... Shame you can't share video.

  • Even if she was 'fat' who the fuck cares??!! She's got a kick ass voice and this song is wicked!

  • Eu amooooooooooo muito esta músicaa!!!

    A Kelly Clarkson é demais!!!!!

    tradu em inglês:

    I love this song too!

    Kelly Clarkson is awesome!

  • Comment removed

  • 1.put your hand on yo chest

    2.think of someone ya like

    3.tomorrow that person will ask u out or say i luv u

    4.put this on five videos in an hour or it wont work 3

  • If she would be fat, WHICH SHE'S NOT, then what is thin?! Come on, is it hot when you see the ribs through someone's skin?

  • how can someone call her fat???

  • Kelly is not fat. She's hot

  • Xtina Aguleira did co-write this song (with about 3 others) I guess thats where you can hear the similarity? ..although Ive nevr noticed it, at the time THIS one came out tho, I was a huge Christina fan!

  • i find kelly clarkson & christina aguilera rather similar,

    i think thats why i love both there music.

    i love this song because its exactly how we should be! - indendant.

  • @PabloSpears WTF?!

  • @PabloSpears welll, thank you! NOT! its people like yu who give celebs eating disorders. I bet your fat urself! Unless it has escaped your notice, Kelly actually has TALENT! Things that 'hot' celebs lack these days, their body is all they have! Kelly has brains and talent AND she is NORMAL sized! Not ZERO sized!!!!!!!!!

  • @adventurerocketgirlx Whatever... she's fat anyways... And I'm not fat u idiot

  • @adventurerocketgirlx Whatever! She's totally fat... 'n' I'm not fat u idiot...!