The Search For the Next Doll "I'm Going Down"

[niinarobles]

yea we alled wanted her too win but you gata understand asia needs it for the money as well its not like shes forgetting about her daughter! she did it fo her daughter :/

[LLBeana]

She only didn't win because she resembles Nicole too much. Gotta have diversity in the PCD. I'm surpirsed we haven't seen anything mainstream from Melissa. She's an extremly talened singer and danced.

[lizzndnayy]

i cant believe she didnt win... worst mistake robin antin could have ever made

[anothergirl45]

the only reason she didn't win was because she looked too much like Nicole. she was a much better singer and dancer then Asia IMO.

[JenniferSilvaOday]

She was the best there

[reginaabercrombi]

she has s beautiful voice

[kailynnmbaby]

she does and she's very pretty as well.

[SHELOVEROMEO]

She is a very good singer. I love her voice and she is cute. I love you so much Melissa :D

[RockstaronNet]

is that what she calls a skirt?

[MsCindyVo]

She didn't choose the outfit.

[illestgyal]

@RockstaronNet she's obviously clothed by the people there -_-

[iaintthelady2messwit]

Melissa should've won.

[MilaSf]

Melissa R.. <3

[dannyboy1001000]

melissa r is philipino and mexican

[muchlikefallinme09]

na AH.. shes full blooded filipina.. not even mexican or half

[sjacelar]

@dannyboy1001000 nah! melissa reyes is full blooded filipino...asia and nicole are part filipino tho...

[ladyvenice13]

nicole.vanessa hudgens and melissa r. are all filipino's. that's why they all look alike.

[personyoulike]

there all partially filipino and the same goes for asia

[MizuNotes]

Yo. That's basically saying that all Asians look the same! xD

[ladyvenice13]

@MizuNotes No, I'm saying "FILIPINO" not the whole asian race. dumb ass.

[MizuNotes]

@ladyvenice13 I responded to your original comment a year ago, what I said must have really bothered you if you decided to comment back now.

[ladyvenice13]

@MizuNotes I know :) But, you really do love to sweep statements huh? I only saw your reply on my comment two days ago, that's why. ;)

[MartinKgpcD1]

Haha is the truth! why he got two negatives?

[lululiebtsingen]

she looks like vanessa hudgens

[stephalicousbeyonce]

like crazy!i wish she won

[ilovecrayons123]

yeah she would have never won since she looks too much like nicole

[mubabala]

she should have won! Absolutley better than Asia.. Go home and take care of you child instead of trying to be a super star.. jesus..

[Caroo2]

anyone noticed that lost the melody a bit in the beginning and she was pitchy...this wasn't really a good performance technically as far as vocals

[Toutostar]

im really sorry but i loved it

[xxgirliciousrulezxx]

shuld ii listen to u? OR THE JUDGES?

[Caroo2]

it doesn't matter who you listen too cause you don't know any of us...I like this girl..she was good but if you listen carefully she falls of the melody in the beginning....you don't need to listen to either of us..just use your ear..and there was some pitch errors...there weren't big but they were there

[ilovecrayons123]

amaxing !!

[zingojill]

they fear that mellisa gonna overshadow nicole..she sounds and looks like nicole...

[princesschay16]

Same filipino race.

[mzsantonioholmes619]

i agree melissa should've won but i think they gave it to Asia because, Melissa looks and kinda sounds like Nicole

[stronzettina89]

she should be in pussycat dolls

[lucillezian]

love her,they should give her the offer.. go melissa :)

[ronnie0613]

this performance = :)

[GRLCsLover21]

That was definitely her best performance!! I love herr so much she should have won over Asia for surrree

[chiccaboom]

i dont' get why they chose asia over her.

[DancinWarrior21]

I loved this performance!!

[xiAshley]

LOVE HER !

[TalulaDonut]

this was such a good performance!

melissa is so prettyy! (:

[xoxladyjennaxox]

chelsea great voice. CANT dance

[Pixiebabylove]

i think robin antin is very hypocritcal, she said that melissa cud be in pcd and then she said in an interview she cud never see melissa fitting into pcd. bullshitter comes to mind

[lilsheley]

This is my favorite preformance by her, she is soooo talented!

[ilusidthekid]

shes gorrrg.

[bksfinestbitch]

asia is great but she aint even in the group but melissa didnt need 2 win she would do much better as a solo artist

[JacBev333]

wow she is so good

[oOoEliciaoOo]

haha your kidding right?

she can do wayyy better then you;)

[lilmaterialgirlsandy]

shes so beautiful but i prefer chelsea !

[Toutostar]

i think its hot pants

[mrtruongg]

it still kills me that she didn't win.. -.-

[inhanez]

i agreed with that..

[mrtruongg]

@mrtruongg altogether its been 4 years since this show and 2 years since this performance. and it still kills me that she didn't win . fml

[drgrinch123]

@mrtruongg The decision they made was the fact that she was an 18 year old deer in headlights, who couldn't bring anything unique to the table. With that being said, it wasn't so much because she resembled Nicole Scherzinger, but its simply because they thought she didn't bring anything unique, like they thought Asia did...*sigh*....

[Simple0Steven]

thats a hell of a skirt :)

[xmodernx]

I love Melissa R. she can sing, dance, and is pretty =)

[stronzettina89]

fantastic melissa

[nameoflove423]

i love melissa r!

she's so pretty and has a great voice!

[fireangel240]

I think it was Chelsea's perfromance where Robin said Chelsea looked good and then ron said, but this isnt about how good they look. and then i remember in this episode ron said, for melissa that she looked really good. LOL I LOVE MELISSA R. <3

[girliicous]

LOVE HER!

[answertest]

melissa should have won asia is a bad singer

[sagebates]

melissa is a lead singer i dont think she would do good in a group where nicole sings everything i think shes better being solo

[Socialbutterfly3000]

ur are yall still on this asia and melissa thing. get over it, she did not win

[ChrystinaMarshall123]

In My Opinion Asia should of never won it should if been Melissa R. or Chelsea but mostly Melissa R

[C00KiiEES]

i think this was her best performance :]

but im not saying all of her performances was bad. there all good.

[v1et4life]

Is Meilissa Asian?

[cheeniebaby]

she's Filipino

[fuckeeamee]

she's filipino

[maudy01]

you mean filipina

[fuckeeamee]

yeah, you know what i mean! lol. i'm argentinian that's why i suck at this!

[blanktalentxx]

you mean phillipina ?

[maudy01]

I Don't know xD

I'm from the Netherlands:P

I only knew that it is "-a" and not "-o"

[MSAmericanIdol21]

no it is filipino

[ShadyLady1984]

nooo its phillipino

everyone else just spells it filipino like the americans

i have no idea why though :S

[ryvin436]

lol ya im phillipino!

[CaptainHermes]

Who cares.

[flyby1t2003]

Shes really but Asias voice is strong and melissas is melow and soft...

[flames104]

personally i think she should of won but asia still good

[Asia21Baby]

one of her best perfomances?????? I dont think so

She did much better on Stickwitu

it dont matter who picked it out,.... i still dont like it

[divadive10]

EVERY ONE ! ais won so deal with it n i bet that u cant sing like aisa or melissa or chelsea so THAT THAT's

[UruguayanChiq]

what r u tlking about?

this was one of her best performances.

and i like what she has .. its not like she picked it out. ^o)

[walezkita]

melissa R. is beatifull, perfec person, has a better sound! =D

[Asia21Baby]

Melissa has a nice voice and all but i dont think this was one of her best performances.

I dont like that outfit she has on, the skirt she has on is WAY tOo short.

[princessliuz]

lol thats a skirt looks like shorts shorts

[Kittygirl890]

I thought they were :|

[iNVYU]

I love Melissa R. and I have also met her. She did a great job on this song, but I think she should've worn something different. It doesnt suit her.

[pussycatdoll12142]

Melissa r should have one i hate asia such a batch

[Simplysw33t4you]

I agree. Melissa has a better sound

[pussycatdoll12142]

Melissa r should have one i hate asia such a batch

[alikalady]

ur a batch? and a hater.

[pussycatdoll12142]

Melissa r should have one i hate asia such a batch

[alikalady]

ur a batch? and a hater.

[pussycatdoll12142]

Melissa r should have one i hate asia such a batch

[alikalady]

ur a batch? and a hater.

[meganxx23]

Melissia R should have won

[alikalady]

just in ur opinion not mine

asia won cause she da best!!!!!!!!!!!11

[Promilicious]

maythunyakij: "which means that she should've found another STABLE career so she could actually support her daughter." --> that's EXACTLY what I kept thinking EVERY time she said she needed to do this for her daughter. if she was really serious...she would be AT HOME, WITH HER DAUGHTER, trying to find a good career or put herself through school. her mother was supporting her right? she could've taken a part time job and put herself through school while her mom helped her out with her daughter.

[rewitioun]

srs?

is asia filipino

i new melissa woz but not asia

wow

[rewitioun]

srs?

is asia filipino

i new melissa woz but not asia

wow

[rewitioun]

srs?

is asia filipino

i new melissa woz but not asia

wow

[asdfguy1122]

melissa should have won asia cant sing to save her life

shes anoying

always complaining

[iwazallwoah]

it's weird how evryone is sayin that the only reason asia sucked was because she got a bad song, and melissa and chelsey didn't, but that meant she didn't have much to live up to, but for melissa and chelsey they had alot to live up to and that meant they had to do a much better job then asia, and i think they did, honestly i think that melissa shuold have won instead of asia, but thats just me.....

[Promilicious]

wow! this performance was great!

[TECHI96]

type chelsea i turn to you and pause it at 0:47 seconds. Her eye gets stuck its freakin scary.

[KaGomeRuleZ4Ever]

holy shit its is scary

[thafanstaaaa]

I agree that Melissa did well. But asia only did okay cause they gave her such a terrible song. unlike Melissa and Chelsea who had some amazing classic songs

[LinkinParkSb]

HAWT!

[snow1angel]

Melissa did AMAZING in this preformance!!

Chelsea did Amazing in hers as well!

Asia did okay...

Hahah they where my favs from the beggining and they were the final three XD

[blackboom51]

she looks like nicole & vanessa hudgeds but she is hotter than both !

[beaoc]

i agree..!!

[LinkinParkSb]

you're sooo right! she's pretty much alike to Baby V, but i think Melissa has better voice than Nicole's.

[cristybutit79]

that's bcoz all 3 have Philippine roots. =)

[rewitioun]

whos filipino in search 4 nxt doll?

just wonderin?

[jarx18]

melissa r is and asia is half filipino=)

[freeemail543]

She sounds good, and she has a nice voice - but this is NOT a hard song. I have a pretty crappy voice, but I could sing this song and make it sound decent. There's no range or hard notes at all.

Plus, her PCD picture (in the background) looks terrible. She looks scared.

[princessliuz]

i know her voice isnt strong at all she had a chance to show off her voice but she doesnt have a good voice. if only asia sang this song. would of sounded great.

[26BJUGF]

Melissa has nothing original thats why she didnt win she is just like nicole but nicole is prettier and with more a great voice.

I think Asia win because she is different but has a lot of talent and she is original and because she won the promotion tour the other day with her comercial and the photoshout and the interview and she looked great and thats and important part of been a pcd

[AsianBisquit]

She was soooo good, why did Asia win?

[ourtimeshine]

i love her ;D

[JujuTsu17]

Wow. At 0:20, they cut to two people from the audience who have an awed look on their face. Understandable, I like the song.

But those audience people are the same from two weeks ago where chelsea and mariella performed "I Turn to You." Wearing the same clothes, the same expression on all three of their faces. The duplicate is at 0:28 of Iziwe's video 'chelsea i turn to you'

Editting the songs much?

[sisi456789]

OMG she look like vanessa hudgens

[xxCrazedLifexx]

yea i agree

[janellle579]

i think vanessa hudgens looks like her. its a ge thing

[Armaniwazhere]

omg this is the only song, I like that she song, I mean cause she is so boring, this was the right song for her, she sound dead and tired, and that sound`d good to me, cause I like rare voices

[Minicz02]

i was hoping and expecting that melissa R. was gOIng to win.. :(

LOve her !

[rubz118]

Y did Asia win. Everyone seems to love melissa more then her

[nikoe14]

I know,,, and melissa r is a lot better than asia... i dunno,,, maybe bcuz asia is a mother that's why they picked her and she needs money... BUT ONE tHINGS IS FOR SURE!! THEY LOVE MELISSA R...

[cutie574]

they didin't pick her bacause they think shes like nicole or better than her(thats what i think)

[nikoe14]

Melissa R ROCKZ!!

[clariseorton]

wow gosh look at that stage! omg *In Love**

[thewalkaway80]

bellissima e bravissima

[schoolgurl95]

one of my favorite songs1