Top 5 pitchers of all time

[whothehellgivesadamn]

THIS IS REALLY FUCKING STUPID, HERE'S HOW IT GOES:

1.SANDY KOUFAX PERIOD, END OF STORY.

[Supermopho]

I disagree. I would have put: 1.) Nolan Ryan, 2.) Cy Young, 3.) Satchel Paige, 4.) Walter Johnson, and 5.) Sandy Koufax.

[jr55ful]

i guess cy young's 511 wins are just a rumor?

[357MagnumBob]

5. Cy Young

4. Satchel Paige

3. Walter Johnson

2. Nolan Ryan

1. Bob Feller

Quality vs. longevity. Koufax didn't last long. Maddux isn't close. Feller had his very best years (Age 23-28) carved out of his career when he joined the Navy during WWII. Feller, at age 17, won the 1st MLB game he pitched, the youngest ever to win an MLB game - a complete game in which he struck out 15 St. Louis Browns. Ted Williams said he would start to think about facing Feller 3 days before the contest.

[SimpleStuff31]

@357MagnumBob maddux isnt close? are you high? you just contradicted yourself, maddux is the epitome of quality and longevity, he's probably 3-4 all time. bob feller number one? no, he's probabaly 8-10.

[mrhoosier1000]

Satchel Paige

Sandy Koufax

Walter Johnson

Nolan Ryan

Greg Maddux

[lupetin100]

Cy young is always number1 but the other 4 I agree with

[JonSmoke90]

1.) Walter Johnson

2.) Lefty Grove

3.) Grover Clevland Alexander

4.) Cy Young

5.) Warren Spahn

[ThePhilliesforlife]

that list aint that bad heres the best list Walter Johnson "Lefty" Grove "Satchel" Paige Christy Mathewson "Cy" Young Randy Johnson Warren Spahn Sandy Koufax Tom Seaver Bob Feller

[chuckzone3000]

I'd put in Phil Nekro instead of Randy Johnson

[TheCuriousMoose]

@chuckzone3000 whatever its just my opinion