i think that there's nothing wrong with kelly's vocal, it's just that her voice is a little way too strong for this song. this song is suppose to be soft and gentle. btw, kelly's mandarin is not as good as sandy, so what do you guys expect?
Nothing much, I just like the original version, Sandy's vocal is more powerful and pleasing to me... I like Kelly singing Cantonese songs better, to me she is just so so in Chinese songs, maybe its the pronounciation and everything. Anyway, this is still a nice song...
Just curious, because I can't really tell the difference. If you listened to this version and then the original by Sandy without knowing who sang it, would you be able to tell which one is the original version?
Maybe, because the song is more of Sandy Lam's type of songs she sings, but this song is such a classic that a lot of singers sang it in their concerts. Sandy's original version is too down rooted into a lot of people's hearts. I mean its such a great hit when she sang the song.
you can tell by their pronounciation and their feel. sandy is very smooth and light, where as kelly has a deeper more bold sound. (while listening to this more, her pronouciation is really wonky)
Probably. Kelly's vocal is a bit sharper than Sandy especially in the chorus. And that is the way she performs her songs. I have listened to a few samples of Kelly's song. On the other hand, I don't really listen to Sandy Lam's songs, but I have heard the original of this song.
i think that there's nothing wrong with kelly's vocal, it's just that her voice is a little way too strong for this song. this song is suppose to be soft and gentle. btw, kelly's mandarin is not as good as sandy, so what do you guys expect?
christyk97 3 months ago
the best time of Kelly..
kkwok10 10 months ago
Sandy has a voice that is incomparible. Kelly is not bad... Yet, Sandy is still the DIVA.
odelaylover001 2 years ago 2
This is a very nice cover.
vin326 2 years ago
sandy is the best
egg1080 3 years ago 5
i agree with what you guys say. And her lyrics are different from the sandy lam version, the first few sentences. Maybe she sang wrongly?
kaytambre 3 years ago
both r a good singer ~no need to compare !they rock !
nicky198784 3 years ago 4
nice
yuezhu93 5 years ago
Sandy Lam's original version is still the best.
OscarJJJ 5 years ago 3
why? what is better about Sandy's version as compared to Kelly's version?
icie 4 years ago
Nothing much, I just like the original version, Sandy's vocal is more powerful and pleasing to me... I like Kelly singing Cantonese songs better, to me she is just so so in Chinese songs, maybe its the pronounciation and everything. Anyway, this is still a nice song...
OscarJJJ 4 years ago
Just curious, because I can't really tell the difference. If you listened to this version and then the original by Sandy without knowing who sang it, would you be able to tell which one is the original version?
icie 4 years ago
Maybe, because the song is more of Sandy Lam's type of songs she sings, but this song is such a classic that a lot of singers sang it in their concerts. Sandy's original version is too down rooted into a lot of people's hearts. I mean its such a great hit when she sang the song.
OscarJJJ 4 years ago 3
I agree wtih OscarJJJ. This version seems a lot weaker than Sandy's and lack that original feeling.
dreamerofeternity 4 years ago
i would.
you can tell by their pronounciation and their feel. sandy is very smooth and light, where as kelly has a deeper more bold sound. (while listening to this more, her pronouciation is really wonky)
spankpoo 3 years ago
Probably. Kelly's vocal is a bit sharper than Sandy especially in the chorus. And that is the way she performs her songs. I have listened to a few samples of Kelly's song. On the other hand, I don't really listen to Sandy Lam's songs, but I have heard the original of this song.
summertwinkle 2 years ago
I actually like super junior's remake better than sandy lam or kelly chan. Sandy lam i don't really like her version even though its the original =\
aznxphoenix 3 years ago