By far the best recording I've heard of this piece. Thanks for uploading. I'm trying to learn this piece right now and lets say I'm little over 10 years old and its pretty hard....
@spiderwomanatl The main theme of this piece is meant to be played quickly. Also, the scales are meant to be fast. Cut timed 32nd notes are pretty dang fast... Also, I thought he played the slower sections excellently.
@spiderwomanatl I think he played it very well. Not only is the first section supposed to be played quickly, it has the perfect amount of passion. I agree with @banifacio , the slower sections were great.
The technique is absolutely brilliant. However, I could make a strong case that his interpretation is rather weak, turning what Brahms wrote as an intricate intertwining of rhythmic ideas into what sound like a rustic jig - by all means, I respect Glenn Gould, but he sacrificed musicality for virtuosity here. If you think I'm being overcritical, just write me a message, and I will upload a video explaining my interpretation.
The only recording I have heard of this piece that is acceptable is Katchen's. It seems like no one can play this piece, however, Gould's is better than most of the recordings I have heard (Perahia, Lubimov, Rubinstein, Argerich, Backhaus, Grimaud, Pogerolich). This is the best out of the 7 (Pogerolich being a close 2nd).
Absolutely always the best interpretation of this rapsody. Great intensity of sound, perfect continuum, right accents, appropriate f & p variations, right tempo, no frills, the 2 scales are powerful, and of course always a talented tecnique like only very few in the history. Great Gould, even if we hear him singing!
weird rubatos. gould and brahms are not for me. listen to radu lupu for this one!
iwritemusic1 2 days ago
By far the best recording I've heard of this piece. Thanks for uploading. I'm trying to learn this piece right now and lets say I'm little over 10 years old and its pretty hard....
thisiscalvinlu 1 month ago
This is very well played but it is lacking something. Passion?
spiderwomanatl 9 months ago
@spiderwomanatl The main theme of this piece is meant to be played quickly. Also, the scales are meant to be fast. Cut timed 32nd notes are pretty dang fast... Also, I thought he played the slower sections excellently.
banifacio 7 months ago
@spiderwomanatl I think he played it very well. Not only is the first section supposed to be played quickly, it has the perfect amount of passion. I agree with @banifacio , the slower sections were great.
thisiscalvinlu 1 month ago
He takes 0:30 way too fast.
Nonetheless, I love this rhapsody.
TallMikeBismuth 10 months ago
Brahms is Santa Clause. I swear! :D
Except Santa can never make good music like this......
Prestothemusic 10 months ago
this is like rockem sokem robotts nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jorden1221 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I quoted this movie in the topic of this tune in my brog.
Thank you for Upload.
movielovercat 1 year ago
I quoted this movie in the topic of this tune in my brog.
Thank you for Upload it.
movielovercat 1 year ago
The technique is absolutely brilliant. However, I could make a strong case that his interpretation is rather weak, turning what Brahms wrote as an intricate intertwining of rhythmic ideas into what sound like a rustic jig - by all means, I respect Glenn Gould, but he sacrificed musicality for virtuosity here. If you think I'm being overcritical, just write me a message, and I will upload a video explaining my interpretation.
blendingbone 1 year ago
@blendingbone I agree with you completely. Some of the scales are ridiculously fast. I think he plays it way to dry.
Albertthefatcat5 10 months ago
mah... fredda, mica sto granché...
MatitoneMalTemperato 1 year ago
I think that Pogorelich's performance is the best. It has such a contrast between the different segments, and very huge palette of colors...
But this is great (of course it ism it's Gould!), and full of artistic liberty... For my taste, the tone is too rough.
lalasvet 2 years ago
The only recording I have heard of this piece that is acceptable is Katchen's. It seems like no one can play this piece, however, Gould's is better than most of the recordings I have heard (Perahia, Lubimov, Rubinstein, Argerich, Backhaus, Grimaud, Pogerolich). This is the best out of the 7 (Pogerolich being a close 2nd).
morvensky 2 years ago
Superb in clarity and crispness. Passionate without going overboard.
acooprus 2 years ago 9
Absolutely always the best interpretation of this rapsody. Great intensity of sound, perfect continuum, right accents, appropriate f & p variations, right tempo, no frills, the 2 scales are powerful, and of course always a talented tecnique like only very few in the history. Great Gould, even if we hear him singing!
homonovus6 2 years ago
@homonovus6 ...Yes, even if we hear him singing!
manuelkatarino 2 years ago 3
I have seen this piece played live, and it was an experiance!
Thanks for uploading this piece!
DarkRaimundo 2 years ago