Added: 3 years ago
From: arnelpineda08
Views: 438,051
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (3,993)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Steve is way better...duh!

  • both have got their plus points...to be fair no one is perfect.....it's a matter of choice....all human are born different......

  • they are both great singers, so dont compare them

  • no one can replace the original... but arnel is doing a great job too for the revive journey

  • Gregg Rolie, Neal Schon, Ross Valory, Aynsley Dunbar, George Tickner, and throw in Perry for good measure...that's the lineup I want to see!

  • SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU­UUUUPEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRR­RRRRR GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGRRR­RRRRRRRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAATTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT­TTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!

  • Arnel Pineda is the worthiest vocalist of Journey! More power to the band

  • @RuebenPaul ..,you'vE sA!d !t dUdE...,!

  • Respond to this video...  ..,GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGRRRRRRRRRRR­RRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE­EEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAATTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT­TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Steve the best!

  • i like both but prefer steve

  • It would be awesome if Arnel Pineda and Steve Perry sing together LIVE with Journey. Now that would be a concert of a lifetime

  • instead of criticizing arnel, u should think first.. dont u feel better that JOURNEY's been revived by ARNEL.. tnx to him

  • to pinoy or filipinos, don't be byast, both or them are great... RESPECT! or should i say RESPETO! more power to JOURNEY as a TEAM, as a BAND and not as ARNEL or STEVE :D peace!

  • Steve is the first and is a good singer but what can you do to someone who left the band?? Journey is a group of musicians who love their music. Too bad for Steve for leaving and Arnel is up to continue the Journey. He is not trying to replace Steve, he is just making his own name as Arnel. I love his humble beginnings and I love his voice and personality. To Steve Perry's fans, give Arnel some respect as they are respecting Steve.

  • Arnel was chosen to be the lead singer of "Journey" and that his job to sing the songs of the band. Am sure the production knew what their doing very well! Well done Arnel!

  • Arnel pineda is way better than Steve Perry & Steve Augeri..its not because im a Pilipino..Im not a professional in music. But with my own sense i can say that Arnel Pineda is the best performer among the past vocalist of Journey.

  • AP and SP are uniquely talented individuals. R-E-S-P-E-C-T.

  • I still salute steve perry, but arnel was a good example of a good vocalist, trying his best to imitate the voice of steve.. both of them are great but steve was my bet..

  • both of them are good..but is AP is my bet

  • arnel pineda is the best.. they are both good,bit i love AP most....(:

  • nice one ARNEL! guuuddd job!!!

  • Both are super singers. Hard to comment. Try singin their range. This can only be done by those who have the gift. I have the range like this but it's amazing how they can maintain this..

  • stage presence Arnel is a lot better.

  • Steve Perry all the way.

  • they sing the same way

  • i like em both

  • i love what arnel doing...i think there is nothing wrong with that...like what you've said that he is just doing his job!!to those who write negative comment to him you better shut up guys!!!

  • All ARNEL haters are stupid. you guys are just jealous.

  • nice edit, ilove it

  • look Guys, Arnel is Arnel and Steve is Steve, both are talented singers. The only reason why Arnel is singing songs that Steve originaly sang is bacause those were songs of THE Band and not of Steve alone.. and now that steve is no longer with the band, it doesn't mean that they should stop doing what they love doing.. What I'm saying is Arnel is not an impersonator, he's just doing his job as the bands new vocalist and doing a great job!

  • @Desmuzica ...yeahhh!,,,and they're both good...no use comparing!

  • @Desmuzica tnx desmuzica, i love all the song of journey ever since, so sad steve is gone, welcome arnel pineda, i'm also a pilipino, :)

  • @Desmuzica tnx desmuzica, i love all the song of journey ever since, so sad steve is gone, welcome arnel pineda, i'm also a pilipino, :)

  • @Desmuzica tnx desmuzica, i love all the song of journey ever since, so sad steve is gone, welcome arnel pineda, i'm also a pilipino, :)

  • nice arnel....i love u so much

  • arnel maybe good but if you are thinking of comparing him to steve, please, wake up!

  • arnel penda is the best singer here in philipines!!

  • steve sings this song better than anyone but arnel sings the rest better than steve this song was made 4 steve dont sound same when hes not singing

  • yup.. I agree... You are an IDIOT!

  • ARNEL PINEDA IS THE BEST.

  • Arnel = impersonator

  • @ArnelPinedaSucks FUCK YOU NoSteveNoJourney

  • @NoJboysAPN0Journey ... TO THE STATUS OF JOURNEY NOW...YOU SHOULD BLAME YOUR STEVE NOT ARNEL...ARNEL DOESNT EVEN PUSHED HIMSELF TO BE A JOURNEY BAND MEMBER...HE WAS CHOSEN BY THEM,,,

  • Arnel's performance of this song in Vegas was much better, "Touch of modernity" folks. ;)

  • the thing is arnel "learned" to sing like steve when he was in the cover band "zoo". he also imitated axl rose, sting and so on...

    eventhough arnel is a great singer it looks and sounds much more natural when steve sings.

  • @amyouma I would agree with you, I like both singers, but you watch, Arnel is almost forcing it out while Steve is so natural...he knows it is his song, every note from Steve is from the heart.

  • why does everyone have to compare two distinct people? each of them have the charisma and power to rock.. so just stop comparing and just listen.. you idiots..

  • Arnel aint got shit on Steve

  • yeah but definitely he got sh it on you.. literally.. he'd poop in your face and you'd be gald to gobble it all up.. don't be hatin mother fuck3r!!!

  • steve Perry is the onley one .Journey never be the same without him.And anel never will sing like Steve .Steve Is the greatest

  • ill go for arnel.. may because of his powerful voice and soul, you will really feel the song.. perry is great too.

  • arne pineda

  • no hay Duda,que steve perry siempre sera uno de los mejores vocalistas,pero compararlo con arnel seria una falta de respeto para el,dejense de hacer eso....♥♥CrissPooL♥♥

  • No doubt, that Steve Perry will always be one of the best vocalists, but compared with arnel serious disrespect for, dejense to do that .... ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ CrissPooL

  • Steve Perry!! MOST GREAR VOICE

  • Oh, to the guy who put this together. You should of matched the volumes. Perry is much louder. Still great idea and concept.

  • yeah

  • Appreciate both of them for what they are. Great Singers.

  • Best Journey song ever, why have we got a Karaoke singer from the Philipines on here, go to Thailand and sing in the bars, Jessus neva FOOK with a classic!

  • @woodyfurball what classic! Gay sound classic? ja ja ja Steve Perry was actually said " He loves Arnel Pineda's voice than his voice" ja ja ja

  • Steve, no doubt about it. The presence in stage is another big difference. Steve filled the stage with energy, emotion. Arnel not really. Journey without Steve isn't the same. The best song of the 80's!

  • STEVE PERRY!

  • Both great singers . Journey have found someone to compliment their sound perfectly . Just be grateful a top notch singer on board to fill Steve,s shoes . No sense in comparing or looking back . Hope they tour UK sometime soon .

  • They both are so amazing! It's a very difficult song to sing..Com'on guys..don't compare them. Of course, Steve is original but Arnel did great. Don't u think?

  • now who says JOURNEY has lowered the keys for arnel to make it? IT IS TOTALLY INSANE, COS ITS THE SAME...

    ARNEL WITH JOURNEY=LEVEL UP!

  • Arnel has a stronger voice at the present time than Steve Perry , as Steve Perry needs to transpose the songs down(make them lower to sing), if he performs live nowadays. However, I think that Steve Perry in his prime sounds better than Arnel.

  • Whilst i cant deny arnel's genius... he has not a patch on perry..

  • Arnel has not a patch on gay perry sound for sure. Never, Steve Perry can fill in the shoes of an amazing strong vocal pipes of Arnel Pineda.

    Hence, Steve Perry has edge when it comes to CROONING like a woman voice during his prime time.

  • Don't compare them.. are they competing? no...

    give respect to them guys.. Their both good and knows how to sing.. lets keep it that way..

  • arnel anyday of the week and twice on sunday!wooohoo!!!

  • yeah arnel is much better than the original.

  • JOURNEY, STYX and KANSAS will be doing a tour for 4 weeks later this year 2010.

  • is it just me or do they both sound identicle ?

  • have problems with your hearing? are you sure you hear it? do not understand why you say that Arnel sings better than Steve. Whenever Arnel gives a high note eardrums feel that sticking to my brain. Seriously, go to your ear revisarte.

  • @mrichig ja ja ja

    Steve sings like haggay FAGGY. Arnel rocks. ja ja ja

  • Seriously, check your ears.

  • @mrichig

    your ears are old and fag.

  • Incredible, congratulations Arnel.

  • Arnel is better than original.

  • both singers could take over the world with their voice :p you can't compare them

    to the maker, nice editing, you really make them fit into eachother!

  • no way is arnel 42!!!

  • steve is great bt i preffer arnels voice and style, seves ourney comes to an end and its arnel now. eventhouh he cant replace steve with what he accomplished with ourney, arnel is a great singer thouhg and his version of dnt stop believing rocks!

  • i love the old singer! but Arnel is also amazing!!

    It's really hard to sing at that lvl!!

    And it seems that Arnel can pull it off^^

  • perry all the way

  • @short2222 you wish...the fag quitted ja ja

  • No matter how good this guy might be ,they got somebody to do an impression of Steve Perry ,lets face it,and to me thats dihonest and total bullshit.

  • @winterlandboy

    be honest steve perry s no longer in the band now, journey hired him because he can carry the tune of steve perry. augeri was praised and why they could not do that with arnel. ja ja ja in fact augeri did perry's impression with a firm. if you don't know why then because he is a Filipino. SP fans are supremists faggot. cry cry all the time. ja ja ja insecure from us.

  • I'm Pinoy and I support Arnel. But in my honest opinion Arnel can never be better than the original Steve Perry in terms of what Journey accomplished with him. But Arnel is great in his own right and in continuing Journey's legacy. PEACE!

  • no son comparables, ya que steve es superior en todo aspecto. ademas pusieron la mejor presentacion de arnel, si quieren comparar no pongan la version de japon de steve, en houston steve destruye a toda competencia

  • @iviseco but Steve Perry sucks

  • yes, Arnel is Journey. Journey Resurrection!!!

  • journey was born with steve, we are used to listen steve´s voice. Arnel is not a bad singer, but he will never replace steve. JOURNEY IS STEVE

    ARNEL IS JOURNEY

    sorry for my english (ARGENTINA)

  • No Arnel No Journey! He is terrific and versatile singer. Journey's rocker and crooner.

  • No mames Steve Perry mucho mejor 10000000 respetos

    Arnel pineda si la arma pero esta mucho steve

  • Thanks jacksparrow628..

    SP had the luxury of not following anyone & who could top his voice w/ 20-Journey-yrs?.. Then came SA & JS.. poor AP, he had to follow THE Journey voices before him.. can't imagine how he was able to face the challenges when he took the first step on Chile stage.. obviously he's also a tough act & his unbreakable spirit made him shine! AP's success w/ Journey spoke for himself.. he may not even reach 20yrs w/ Journey but quality spent with the band matters..

    Peace4Journey

  • jingjav27 i agree wid uh

  • This video is really a very good example of the Perry's voice quality and how far is Arnel's one

  • no-one can deny that arnel is amazing (i still rate him as the greatest tribute act ever) but steve is so comfortable with those notes, arnel looks like hes about to collapse!

  • Comment removed

  • I remember watchin the movie ROCKSTAR... once frontman leaves another one goes in

  • i hope i cud be the next journey front man haha!

  • Any product from China or where ever as long as the manufacturer authorized it, passed their global standards & the consumers (majority of them at least) are loving the equal quality w/ added features to keep up w/ the times because the older model can't bring good revenue anymore, then there's nothing wrong w/ a "copy" especially when it has proven its worth already.

    The world is flat now. It doesn't matter where you are from.

    Journey will never be the same w/o SP BUT it could be better w/ AP!

  • Comment removed

  • @andrewsroastbeef

    "Arnel is just a chinese copy of an Iphone"

    Yeah right and just like Iphones(and their copies)you can find singingvoices like Arnel and Perry on every streetcorner..go back to your jab and stab drawing board and come back with something intelligent!

  • It beats me why some people keep on dropping the "Not Original" accusation at Pineda`s doorstep?

    Address that to Journey and do not blame Pineda.

  • It`s simple as tick tack toe.

    Journey needed a singer who could give them a voice which is capable to do justice to their songs with Perry and Augeri(no I won`t forget him !)

    And VOILÁ there was Arnel...and did JOURNEY want a singer who did his own freestyle versions of the classics ! NO !!

    And BTW if Journey had songs with Soto(no I won`t forget him either) Arnel would do them to.

    And last but not least ARNEL PINEDA HAS HIS OWN SONGS !!

  • You're one of the few with a sensible comment on a what has become a ridiculous and downright racist argument. Of course Journey will never be the same without the amazing SP, but that being said, Arnel is a terrific singer. Good for him that his dream has come true and he's doing well!

  • @Suzeism

    Thank you!

    I am a musician and I know how much you have to sacrifice to get to a certain level.

    But some people have a God given talent... they are a natural !...Steve Perry had it and I believe Arnel is a naturel also!

  • I'm Filipino and a Journey-SP fan before Revelation. But Journey is rocking again. Thanks to AP!

    @hardcore SP fans: Be fair. Did you watch AP live or listened to Revelation before lambasting the person? can't deny the talent!

    @over zealous Pinoy AP fans: Be fair. If you never heard or owned a Journey album before AP & if you have nothing to say but being "proud to be Pinoy" & nothing to do with AP's talent, don't bother to post at all because it's not helping AP's credibility!

    Peace4Journey

  • There is no debate who is the "Legacy Voice" but it can't be denied what the new "Golden Voice" has done for Journey today!.. SP left & what happened between SP & the band is beyond us. As Journey fans, let's support the band's direction now. A 2x platinum is not bad for a newbie in the int'l scene & AP is continuously improving since Chile (AP was not a no name performer before Journey but how it is in the Philippines' entertainment industry is a different story) SP is SP! & AP is AP! period

  • Steve Perry was one of the greatest voices ever but the blunt truth is he has lost that golden voice..so does that mean the music of Journey has to stop..NO !

    The music goes on and on and on.. long after Perry,Augeri,Soto and Pineda ,it will outlast us all..... because it`s timeless !

  • its steve perrys song and always will be. arnels a good singer but cant hit the high notes.

  • Steve CAN''T ROCK and he can't hit his own fag notes now coz he's old and sux.

  • I know who steve perry is but who's the copy-cat dude sucking on the microphone like a chicken leg in adobo?

  • DrFlip mama makes a very tasty chicken and pork adobo ja ja ja

    the faggot sound Steve Perry is not welcomed outside US ja ja ja Xfactor UK pulled out don't stop beleivin as the winning song. Miley Cyrus kicks his old fag ass. ja ja

  • maganda nga. pero karaoke ang dating ni arnel.

  • TT mo baklitang inngitera,ulol.

  • Stop flaming on Steve Perry!

    He wasn't called "The Voice" for nothing!

    His voice is brilliant, even better than Arnel's!

  • Who is Steve Perry? ja ja ja the faggot voice

  • Perry is a shit gay... Arnel FTW hes the best......ppl just say he sux cuz there jealous cuz filipinos are talented...

  • arnel is good singer but never will be like steve perry....there's only one steve perry for journey...if there's no reunion ,will never be other journey

  • Go Go Arnel! You rocked Japan and UK. You are the Best.

  • Niech Pineda się schowa!

    Steve Perry rządzi!

  • ja ja ja NoSteveNoQUEER shit

    !!!

  • Perry sing the song can't make goosebumps and not soulful. Perry GAY voice is feminine pipes.

  • PerryGAY voice is already JUNKED...

  • Perry has pure GAY voice,

    Arnel voice and masculine pipes.

  • Arnel is better to see live

    steve perry is boring :p

  • I can't believe the Journey fans picking the shit out Arnel? You'd think they'd be grateful the band found someone who delivers the songs with a similar style.

    This is more petty than the brian Johnson - Bon Scott crap.

    Grow up...

  • Perry obviously sing better... arnel sux hard

  • arnel sucks like hell.... steve perry for ever....

  • PerrryisGAY voice can't make goosebumps .

  • ,!,

  • I think I prefer Steve Perry's voice...but he likes himself too much. The whole band looks rejuvenated with Ariel so..be it!

  • It makes no difference about race here folks. No matter how much you may love Steve Perry and hate Arnel Pineda or vice-versa you have to admit one thing, they are both very, very talented voices in the rock world. I would give a million bucks and more to have a voice similar to either one of these two. God bless you Arnel and continue to live your dream out you are very, very talented and very down to earth. Long live Journey !!

  • fool of themselves!!! No Steve Perry rocks on NOW! He is RETIRED senior citizen in his adopted US country. ja ja ja

  • Of course, I do. I'm just pointing out the fact that he/she is making an even bigger fool out of themself.

  • Wow! 4600 comments between two dudes ripping on one another about who's the better singer. I think that's obvious, but you two can carry on now.

  • MY IDOL STEVE SUCKS

  • NoSteveNoJourney=SUPER MONGOLOID

  • RACIST ASSHOLES DOWN THERE!!!

  • Sorry but No One can replace Steve Perry, They will never be the same.....

  • @vilechemical123 another SUPER PUPPET ACCNT OF NoSteveNoJourney

  • Both are really good.

    Arnel is just as good as Perry.

  • On what basis? Not musically or his place in history. Did Arnel write any of Journey's songs? His voice cracks and he loses pitch - go watch some more of his videos on YouTube. He's copied Perry's style down to the letter - no originality. Arnel is decent I'll grant you but he's no Steve Perry.

  • STEVE PERRY ALL THE WAY!!! CLASSIC JOURNEY IS THE WAY I LIKE IT... now dont get me wrong... Arnel is a great singer but i just like the classic Journey with Steve Perry.... Stop fighting guys... everything is just opinion... enjoy the music... STEVE ALL THE WAY

  • obviously a better faggot singer and Arnel doesn't need to be one. yes, Arnel is better sound.

  • Steve Perry is obviously a better singer, but in these days, can you find any better singer than Arnel? I dont think so.

  • Comment removed

  • Sorry but Perry OWNS this contest - more power, more style, more stage presence...

    Arnel's voice is very good but predictable just not as professional as "the voice".

  • who write message above me is MONGLOID....

  • NoSteveNoJourney=SUPER MONGOLOID!!!

  • why you always here nostevenojounney you dont have job? mama says your disable me special ok

  • you lose to me NoSteveNoJounney ok

  • NoStevenOjounney you jerk with perrys pictures? I do

  • haggay gay donkey lady, sufferings helpless ,hopeless ,envious ,jealous ,deluded ,unsure ,insecure ,bitterness ,hatred ,loneliness ,sadness ,woow .what a pity haggay. he's such a LOSER 100%,muahhhh !!!!