Sag Mir Wo Die Blumen Sind - Juliane Werding , Marlene Dietrich

[meegomae]

vanaisa ulatab sul käe, näe kevadlill tal käes! on künkaid palju meie maal, ja vähe mehi alles jäänd. siis kuulad laulu sinutorust ja saad aru et saab sest lorust ,üks vabariim

[Ermal8711]

An ode to a generation that was thrown into the meat grinder... an ode to the millions of lives that could have accomplished far greater things, could have grown old and enjoyed their lives... instead they litter the Ukrainian, Russian and Polish countryside...

Fuck fascist, warmongering tyrants and dictators who throw the lifeblood of their nation into the garbage to feed their own egoism... Let them fight the wars themselves... and fuck those who stand by them!

[TauntsMaunts]

Makes me think about my grandfather and hes brother who fought in German army....grandpa's brother never returned ! Beautiful song !!!

[straco64]

Fajna piosenka i urocza kobieta, ale wykonanie Marleny będzie na zawsze the best. Chyba dzięki tej piosence zacząłem uczyć się niemieckiego.

[Stedke]

@ppaall66 Gorzej Ci?

[martinbeco]

Beautiful song! Easy to understand. I hate wars too. 

[otherworldtrader1]

Had Germany not elected an idiot(adolf hitler to lead them it's likely that this country would be a world leader reather than The USA or Russia or china. Hitler only had himself to blame when he attacked Russia(something his commanders said was suicide. Germany could have cakewalked into the middle east and africa without the russian front and in effect forced a treaty giving them much or most of europe.

[2011Cambridge]

they were just kids playing with guns.... they didn´teven know what they were doing let alone why they had to hate jews...

[otherworldtrader1]

@2011Cambridge ; not true. yuo can murder 6 million people without knowing something. yuo can build crematoriams without knowing what they are for. especially when you could smell the peoples cooking day and night. when your relatives saw kids starving todeath in trains and trucks heading into but not coming out of death camps they knew what was going on.

[deseret1000]

@otherworldtrader1

it is sooo easy and cool, isn´t it?!? as easy as your mind. make a try and think. visualize.

[exefall]

цыточки

[bobatosenior]

Well done, great movie, great song!

[shelkie742]

La guerre est la même dans chaque pays..........Cela fait remonter des mauvais souvenirs

[sandhogy]

american s and their politicians elected are evil aspects of current society ! JEWS WILL CONTROL WORLD COMMERCE, this will come to pass ! because of benile effort to being steadfast to original concepts of constitution !!!!!!!!

[otherworldtrader1]

@sandhogy ; Jews now control the world commerce because many thousands of years ago they were enslaved and their properties removed from them, left to wander, and therefore created the actual art of commerce as an effort to survive. don't belittle them , just learn rorm them. everyone on earth owes the jews much more than they will knowingly admitt. they are the ones who introduced us to commercial as a survival tool.

[amirflorida]

Пусть немцы слушают подобные песни-и больше не начнут ни одну мировую войну.

[MrHimmel89]

@amirflorida

это касается не только немцев. Песню должны послушать все. С переводом, чтобы понимали, о чем.

[oOAndrewsOo]

"Where have all the soldiers gone?"imagine six years of war fighting for their country ... and back home.. all his friends died ... and his country is destroyed ... and you go home without glory ... no banners ... or guard of honor to welcome you ... and is still judged by the world as a criminal ... damm ... these brave soldiers should have had more respect ... they fought bravely as any soldier in war ... and they were young ... they fought for what they believed as well as any other ...

[ericyanikov]

@oOAndrewsOo And now try to imagine 1500 fired out Russian towns, 600000 died in Leningrad by hunger blocade, each 4th killed in Byelorussia, 200000 Poles killed in Western Ukraine, ruined Stalingrad with its childrens, fired alive and hanged Russian children... And relax, buddy! Sleep well...

[oOAndrewsOo]

@ericyanikov there is no right or wrong in war ... Russians were no saints ... there are indications that the Communists killed more in the world than the Nazis ... but obviously the crimes of one does not justify the crimes of another one.. both sides were wrong ... and both paid the price for their mistakes ... that's all I have to say ... and I'll sleep well because now there is peace ... although problems still exist in the world ...

[oOAndrewsOo]

@ericyanikov and btw! Russian Communists and Nazis were allies at the beginning of World War II ... you can see that in the film "The Soviet Story" ... at least the Russians continued to exist and were greeted as victors in their cities ... the Germans on the other hand had a divided and destroyed nation and were hated by the world ... there is no end worse than this...

[otherworldtrader1]

@oOAndrewsOo ; the russians were greated as heros everwhere but in places in the soviet union where they killed more of their own citizens than did the germans. Over 50,000 american troops were in eastern europe as prisoners of war and turned over to the russians after occupation of europe. they were never heard from. Not one american president has taken the russians to task for that.; about 12 known survivors are known to have married russians or lived there. rest were murdered

[otherworldtrader1]

@ericyanikov ; History acknowledges that apparently 10 million germans, 10 million brits, and 20 million Germans alone died as the result of the war. I think unless the muslim /china situation is decided upon and democracy enforced there the future war with them will be in the billions dead. Just as with hitler yuo cannot treaty with dictatorships and fools

[CaptainMiller1]

@oOAndrewsOo i respect soldiers of wehrmacht not waffen ss they did so many horrible crimes

[horsebackarchers]

@oOAndrewsOo

"...without glory..." Absolutely wrong! So many years after and they all are alive in our mind! From Nordkap till Kreta!

EWIGE RUHE DEN HELDEN!

[oOAndrewsOo]

@horsebackarchers Sorry you misinterpreted. When I meant no glory i mean No win, no parades to receive them, no medals, no ceremony of welcome, without recognition, they returned to a country completely destroyed, of course they have within them the spiritual glory of having fought. but is not the same thing. But indeed! They will always be marching with their flags in the history and in the hearts of the people that they defended. Indeed there is no greater glory to have fought until the end!

[horsebackarchers]

@oOAndrewsOo Thank you dear!

Of course I understand your meaning. I'm refering to those ignorants of History, surely not to you.Warmest greatings from Athens-Hellas!

[Swilow]

German army wasn't just "nazis"... They was also soldiers and humans!! God bless their sacrifice.............

[MrTadek1970]

Tu ktoś napisał głupi niemcy ... Pewnie ma 20 yary i jest z NRD !

[MrTadek1970]

moj onkel po Racibożym cwaj T34 z pancerfausta strrelił! oberschlesen a po wojnie wstydził się !

[alexdesalm]

beautiful song and no mix your hatred here

[MultiZamek]

mam rad tuhle písničku a obrazky

[figliodellidee]

sag mir wo Deutschland ist. Wo ist es geblieben ? was ist geschehen ?

[xynt84]

lol and showing fucking nazis on pictures hahaha seriously, there is a lot to be proud of, stupid germans

[viaiphone]

@xynt84 the song is actually about war and soldiers... I'm not german, but I understand the meaning and for me It's not surprising to see german WW2 units in the vid. You should to think about yourself before judging the others.

[xynt84]

@viaiphone u should suck german cock, you like that czechs dont ya?

[kedarbarak]

@xynt84 I cannot get it - what is your opinion exactly? I hope that you are not a native speaker of English. Your ortography would be a disgrace then. Anyway, there is no major nation that have not experienced an era of defeats and humiliation. Czech kings ruled in Hungary and Austria for some time in the Middleages. Czech nation has never abandoned its own language as the Irish had to because of English exploitation. We can be proud of our past struggle against germanization in the past.

[NevenDimitrov]

@xynt84  Haha "stupid germans" and this told by a Polish?!!? This is really ridiculous! Thousands of Polish looking for job in Germany ... Hundreds of years of retard in the polish development...

[MyThewho]

love this women

[karczewski35]

Mówcie o wojnie. Każda jest do d... A chłopacy muszą iść i strzelać.

[zindr2b]

česky je to mnohem lepší...

[chojak222]

Jedynie, aby Was pogodzić to dać Wam po kałachu i zamknąć w kanałach miejskich, jeżeli przeżyjecie to wyjdziecie, a jak nie to wypłyniecie jak ... rurą.

[olek94]

Co za wspaniałe foty. Wszyscy na froncie byli albo fryzjerami albo słuzyli w orkiestrach. Od biedy mogli być kucharzami. No przecież żaden sobie rąk krwią nie pobrudził.

[zaratustrianin]

Chyba niebardzo zrozumiałes przesłanie pioseniki, przecież o to właśnie chodzi, by pokazać, że zwykli ludzie potrafią być mordercami i co czyni armia z ludźmi każąc przywdziewać mundur.  Piosenka zaśpiewana przez Marlenę jako manifest antywojenny i dla uczczenia straconego niemieckiego pokolenia na zawsze naznaczonego piętnem Holocaustu

[olek94]

Chyba nie zrozumiałem.Stracone niemieckie pokolenie, na zawsze naznaczone piętnem holocaustu. Ja bardzo przepraszam. Ktoś chyba ten narodowy socjalizm stworzył, ktoś go poparł. Prawda? Chyba, że większość niemieckiego społeczeństwa urodziła się z prawą ręką wyprostowaną i żaden chirurg nic nie mógł na to poradzić. Inaczej nie potrafię wytłumaczyć tłumów z okrzykiem heil...heil... Może Ty mnie oświecisz skąd się to wzięło?

[Siergey]

To się wzięło z tego że po skończeniu I wojny światowej powstało niezadowolenie po porażce, do tego doszedł wielki kryzys. Ludzie chcieli zmian. Nie chcieli starych władz. Zaufali charyzmatycznemu Hitlerowi - ten w pierwszych latach zaczął odnosić sukcesy - rozwój państwa, wyjście z kryzysu, rozwój armii, zdobycze terytorialne, pokochali go. Potem wszystko zaczęło się sypać....

[olek94]

I wg Ciebie to tłumaczy zezwierzęcenie Niemców? Weź to powiedz mojemu ojcu, który jako 5 letnie dziecko patrzył na śmierć swojego ojca. Powiedz to tym którzy stracili swoich najbliższych. Sorry. Nie przekonujesz mnie.

[Siergey]

Nie to nie tłumaczy zezwierzęcenia Niemców ale to była odpowiedź na to jak napisałeś "ktoś ten NS poparł"

Wojna ma swoje prawa - w każdym narodzie były takie rodzynki, Niemcy były agresorem to u nich tego było więcej.

Dodatkowo główne zwierzęce cechy były w SS nie w Wehrmachcie który robił to co im kazano

[Siergey]

W tym momencie pisząc "I wg Ciebie to tłumaczy zezwierzęcenie Niemców?" albo nie zrozumiałeś mojego przesłania, odpowiedź na to co pisałeś albo zastosowałeś sprytną ekwilibrystykę zmieniając temat. Zmieniając znaczenie moich słów.

[Siergey]

Dla jasności. Ja straciłem w czasie wojny pradziadka. kresowiaka , żołnierza Armii Czerwonej ( z przymusu ) zamordowanego gdzieś w okolicach Stalingradu przez NKWD na mocy rozkazu 227. I jakoś nie żywię przez to nienawiści do WSZYSTKICH rosjan, nie opiewam mianem zezwierzęconych morderców WSZYSTKICH żołnierzy radzieckich. Staram się zrozumieć te czasy. Ten system. Byli źli, byli dobrzy. Nienawidzę NKVD, zwykli sołdaci mieli swoje grzechy, ale nie wszyscy - ja nie generalizuję

[olek94]

Czy ja napisałem gdziekolwiek, że żywię nienawiść do Wszystkich Niemców czy Rosjan? Po prostu nie rozumiem. Narody które stworzyły tak potężną i piękną kulturę nie znalazły wśród siebie "dziesięciu sprawiedliwych" którzy powstrzymaliby szaleńców. I proszę nie pisz, że istniał w wojsku niemieckim wewnętrzny opór. To jest bzdura. W 1944 kierunek był już znany. Totalna klęska. Im zależało by wyjść z tej wojny z jak największymi zdobyczami. Sorry Chyba nie na temat

[szukajek]

tak ci wspaniali ssmani i ich metody pracy :[

[maaaaaaazx]

2:04

[RazonHistorica]

@maaaaaaazx und was is das Problem mit 2:04?

[Atyde91]

this is such a beautiful song. it's easy to play, easy to remember, easy to sing. at the same time it makes me think about the war and all the young people that died...

german version is definitely the best.

[xynt84]

@Atyde91 polska wersja jest Lepsza.

[YepImT]

@Atyde91 German version is good indeed, but its hard for me to agree, because I'm not german. I like to listen to the German version, but listen to Estonian version "kuhu küll kõik lilled jäid"

[Atyde91]

@YepImT

I'm not German either ;)

I had no idea there is an Estonian version! I'm so going to listen to it. I'm keen on Estonian!

[YepImT]

@Atyde91 oh cool, where are you from? :D

[Atyde91]

@YepImT Poland ;) you ?

[YepImT]

@Atyde91 Estonia :D

[TheProfessors]

... but [part two] ... @Video-editor. There are many freeware video editting program's on which you can mix pictures. This, you show us now, is just a photoalbum and not a video. Also ... you can edit pictures with a program as simple as paint. Just spray black over some. Use a freeware-morph-program and 'it will become a clean pic' [or sprayed, depending on the route].

[TheProfessors]

RandallJonesey's - MARLENE DIETRICH - SAG MIR WO DIE BLUMEN SIND - Live 1963 [Baden-Baden]

===

When you see and hear the original, you don't need pictures of graves. The expression of Ms.Dietrich say's enough. And her voice ... is demanding one time, begging the other. Juliane Werding has a nice voice, but will never reach the class of Marlene Dietrich.

@Video-editor. I see flowers, men and graves. It's not a bad video as such, because you did seek the right pictures onto the lyrics.

[KainOriginal]

Völlig bewegend, sie hat so eine schöne Stimme. Vielen dank! Die Fotos passt gut dazu.

[Nachtjaeger2]

Die Bilder passen so gut zu dem Text. Vielleicht solltest du nicht ganz so viele Bilder nehmen und nicht so kurze Schnitte machen, manches würde man sich gerne ein bisschen länger ansehen und es auf sich wirken lassen. Die Fotos sind wirklich bewegend.

[MultiOtty]

super video

[MrPatriot97]

Nicht mehr KRIEG ! ! ! LIEBEN und FREUNDSCHAFT

[Bavaria1976]

J'ai grandi en France et en Allemagne. Puisque mon père était officier de la Bundeswehr, j'ai visité un grand nombre de cimetières de guerre lorsque j'étais enfant. Je suis très heureux que nous vivons dans une époque pleine de paix et d'amitié entre les peuples.

Vive la France, vive l'Europe!

[01932b]

Bavaria1976

Vielen, herzlichen Dank für diese zarte Stimme der Vernunft und der Freundschaft, so selten gehört auf YouTube. Nach all diesen hasserfüllten Kommentaren auf anderen Videos stimmt Ihr Beitrag umso zuversichtlicher!

Merci beaucoup pour votre commentaire!

[azigga]

es wird immer krieg geben die ressourcen der erde gehn zu ende bald wird es richtig krieg geben

[RoterBaron666]

manche verstehen einfach nur die sprache des krieges und die sprache der vernunft oder der diplomatie

[xXMiniMonsterXx]

Also nicht das mit den Soldaten, das ist traurig! Ich hab das abgeschickt als nur die Blumen kamen! ;)

[azigga]

wie unheimlich net von dir

[xXMiniMonsterXx]

Voll schön!

[rummpitz]

Gut gemachtes Video - da passt alles.

[DanutaDeludia]

Świetne to jest!

[gfkd11]

Thx very much for sending me, too thx at the uploader!!

Its a fantastix version of the german singer Juliane Werding, which had always such a lovely and powerful voice..

[Vernitz]

Ciekawy filmik i do tego fajna piosenka ;)