Added: 2 years ago
From: BoreMeScience
Views: 112,459
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (383)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • How come these people arent presidents?

  • @olabandolaification because in case you hadn't noticed, being president is the pits.

  • it's actually a lot wilder than that Neil. we are spiritually connected with a 'physics' you would never have imagined.

  • Did it ever occur to any atheist, that someone can be religious, as in follow the principles of the religion and take morals into consideration from the stories, rather then blindly believe every piece of mythology is true? Cuz if they can, then they find me. A Hindu, loves the mythology because it teaches us morals, ones thatt i'd say if i abide by, i'd make a pretty decent dude.

  • @MrVJyoshi I'm an atheist. I dont need religion to tell me how to be a good person. The morals in religious books are already internal and instinctual. I don't act like a good person, I am a good person. I do good things for other people because it makes me feel good and they need help. I don't act like a good person to impress some invisible father in the sky.

  • @andlyndav You showed how intelligent you are by completley missing the whole purpose of my point. As a child i didn`t konw what was right or wrong, NOT EVERYTHING can be learned by experience. I didn`t konw why things like lying or not respecting elders was wrong. After i read a few religious stories i was able to relate to the characters and learn from them. I learnt to do good things because they were good, not due to reward. Thats the premise of Hinduism, and well i`m a good preson so far.

  • @MrVJyoshi I think you're a dick for insulting my intelligence.

  • @andlyndav well i KNOW you are a douchebag AND a dick for assuming blindly that someone can't be intelligent and religious at the same time.

    Just as some fools blindly follow religion, you blindly think that everyone who obtains his morals from a book is dumb, hence you are exactly what you argue against.

  • @MrVJyoshi I never said anyone was dumb for doing so. You have read 2 things from me and yet you've completely figured me out as a human, right? You wouldn't know that i've read the Bhagavad Gita 5 times cover to cover. It's basically the same as reading the bible.

  • @andlyndav Are you an idiot? The Gita is a story of a war that occurred in ancient india. Based off the actions of each character, a moral can be learned. The Ramayan is also another story upon which various stories can teach us a moral or two. The Vedas are different they refer specifically to creationism, but majority of Hindu's dont follow them because they are impractical. The Bible is different in the sense it has a cree or set or rules.

  • @andlyndav i have figured you out as a human being because i posted something simple. I haven't stated that atheist are stupid, i just stated that there are people who are religious yet good people. You've felt the need to say that you don't act good to please an invisible father in the sky. Had you truly read the Gita you'd realize that the permise of it is to do the right thing in the face of adversity.

  • @andlyndav Heck i had a blind religous phase, atheist phase in highschool, now i`m as open minded as it gets. I feel someone can`t be atheist or a devout religious person until thye have read ALL religious creeds and judged them. Until then remain agnostic. I am at peace with my religion because i think its principles make sense. Everyone`s morals come from somewhere, can be religion, adult figures, heck it could be from TV. It doesn`t matter where it comes from, what matters are the morals.

  • The subtle chord right before Neil says, "That's kinda cool," gets me every time.

    :')

  • Wow, maybe this guy is worthy of Cosmos after all.

  • check out the video "the most astounding fact(neil degrasse tyson)" its what he says here but better.

  • By the video title: "Neil deGrasse Tyson shares a cool thought", this video could be literally any video starring NDT

  • You know that feeling when you're learning a subject in school, and you get to the point where you totally understand it? Like your mind just becomes at ease? I got that feeling, multiplied by ten, just by watching this clip.

    Why can't people like Neil run our countries?...we would've been on Mars 20yrs ago if he was in office, instead of arguing about who's possibly Muslim or not...Man, politicians suck.

  • Does anyone know the name of the TV show this is taken from?

  • It cannot be said any better than that.

  • Every time I watch this I sing it! Symphony of Science FTW!!

  • Within, without you.

  • that was beautiful

  • If only objective Atheists could learn to speak about science in spiritual terms as The Right Honorable Dyson does. Then more people would "convert" to reason. But you've got to speak in THEIR language, the language of spirituality. There is nothing wrong with preaching about the true wonder, marvel, and humility that nature and the universe provides for us - actually it's EXACTLY what we need. In Dyson We Trust.

  • @DanMcCaffrey Well said sir.

  • I am related to E.T.

  • Possibly the most beautiful thing ever said.

  • up next, swamp people!

  • THE AIR THAT I BREATH WAS ONCE JULIUS CESAR'S FART

  • If we saw ourselves as a products of this universe instead of beings planted here by a supernatural being to "be fruitful and multiply" or "to be good stewards", maybe we would thank the universe by preserving & respecting life instead of exploiting & destroying it, or by taking responsibility of childbearing by having 1 only when we have the desire & means to raise 1, so that each precious life is well educated & loved, not lacking in the attention and guidance that each human being deserves.

  • @basimpson2161 chinese?

  • @basimpson2161 Yeah. Religious faith is irresponsible. Faith in ourselves, that it's all in us, that's it's all UP to us, to make this world a better place? That's the difficult and righteous path and there's far too much at stake now to keep quiet about it. ( And that means speaking out in public, with people, not just partaking in internet circle jerks. Like I'm doing right now...)

  • Comment removed

  • Love this. So beautiful. What's even more amazing is that you don't need blind faith or lies to find beauty in the universe. You find so much more beauty in the truth.

  • "We are stardust; we are golden; we are billion year old carbon."

  • Neil always states it very well! Neil, thank you sir!

  • is this in text form anywhere??

  • Aaaand, religion teaches that we are masters of everything, second olny to god, that we should kill and mame in his name, and fuck everything else.

  • who are the sick scum that disliked this?

  • How does Neil manage to always be so goddamned cool?

  • I do this every night with your son.

  • @MortonSeinfeld You do what every night with your son, you perv?

  • we're all part of a nuclear fart. hooray - i feel connected.

  • @hoddy2001 Don't try to degrade the notion outlined in this video to justify your own "faith" position. Just think openly for at least five minutes, that's all I ask. Five minutes of clear thought about this video and the statement therein. You may well see the beauty, majesty and wonder that is our natural universe.

  • incredibly beautiful

  • i dont know about this: my body and the atoms it's made of don't come from a star, i was made from an egg (mother) and a sperm (father) and grew inside a womb. Then i was born and no stars of any kind had s/thing to do with it.. I think :/

  • @davydekemp Every element... carbon, iron, magnesium, water etc that your body is composed of comes from a star. Stars are the birthplace of the elements. It is during the hydrogen fusion process that the heavier elements are born.

  • @DC8Super72 Yes, i know, but let's say, when i'm born i'm like 30 cm (1 ft) tall, and 10 years later i'm 1,5 meter. So my body contains MORE 'elements'.. But those elements didn't come from a star and made my body 'bigger', my body grew, because i fed it with nutrition and so my body is able to develop... It's not that a distant star 'throws' carbon and water at you, you absorb it and you grow and/or age.. Or am i missing the point?? thx for reply.. (Sorry for the bad grammar ;))

  • @davydekemp The point is those heavy atoms originated from far older, and long dead stars before the Sun of the Solar system even fell together, much less the planets of the Solar system. So while your original DNA and cells were assembled in your mother's womb, your mother got the resources to build them from food she ate, which in turn grew out of the Earth, which fell together from material which came from dead stars. It all traces back to the birth of the universe.

  • @aidanjt So, it comes down to: We contain or are made of the SAME KIND of elements that created the sun, our solar system and even our whole universe so long ago...?

  • @davydekemp You are a child of the stars my friend, they provided the very material you are made out of.

  • @davydekemp All matter and energy hold equivalence (hence Einstein's E=mc^2). Atoms are made up of energy particles and adding more particles to an atom gives you a heavier element. In all stars hydrogen fuses to become helium, helium squeezed together to form carbon, oxygen, iron, and then stop burning, and in extremely hot stars, their death throes create the heavy metals like uranium and most of the other stuff on the periodic table.

    So, we're all made of star stuff, everything is.

  • @davydekemp Not quite. The sun is composed of hydrogen the elemental building block of all elements. We are made of elements created in stars. You have it backwards. Everyday, stars are being born from vast clouds clouds of hydrogen condensing under their own gravity. At one point gravity creates enough heat to create hydrogen fusion where the hydrogen atoms join to create helium atoms.When the hydrogen is depleted the star begins helium fusion. Massive stars go on to produce heavier elements.

  • @DC8Super72 Thx for taking the time to reply. I think i understand what Neil is saying now.. The building-blocks everything is made of, are/were created in space in some kind of chemical reaction. And since we (humans) consist of these buildingblocks, we are made by stars.. Right or wrong??

  • @davydekemp Big thumbs up! Only one change... these were nuclear reactions in stars. In a chemical reactions all the elements still remain in their basic elemental form even after the chemical reaction has taken place. In nuclear fusion or fission the actual element is changing by the splitting or joining of atoms.

  • @DC8Super72 I'm getting smarter by the minute here! lol This was fun.. Thx man!!

  • @davydekemp Not the same kind. The very same particles. There's only one way to produce a carbon atom, and that is in the center of a star under high pressure. Whenever your body gains weight, it's not like your body is building any atoms. It is rearranging atoms. The atoms themselves comes from the food. The food comes from the earth. The earth comes from a gigantic dust/gas cloud, from before the solar system formed. And that dust/gas cloud came from exploding stars.

  • @HKragh Hmm.. That's some crazy shit!! I'm going to get some books about this, thanks for taking the time to reply..

  • If only humanity acted like that...

  • Tyson 2016

  • We are of the universe but better arranged.

  • @ztwntyn8 Oh, I don't know about that. When I look at the representation of a galaxy, super-cluster, or the visible universe, it seems to be pretty nicely arranged to me. Less goopy when you look inside it as well! :D

  • @ScienceofWinning Ok, I guess that we are better arranged for our purposes. I don't want to be arranged in the order of a star or blackhole. Yes, less goopy... good one.

  • @ScienceofWinning Oh, and as a youngster, I did something that enabled me to totaly feel and understand what he is talking about and understands in his normal mindset. The feeling is beautiful. I can't get there again or totaly recall the feeling. That is what I experienced was a feeling that can't be put into words.... unless you are an astophysist. lol

  • @ztwntyn8 well, I AM a physics major, & am still debating whether I should specialize in particle or astrophysics lol

  • @ScienceofWinning That's great! I wish you luck at such a dream job but.... I bet not many people have understood the concept to the degree that I did. It made so much sense. I was in gifted classes as a kid and that abstract way of thinking never left. My analogy would be that explaining something like this with mathematics would be like texting versus talking to someone in person.

  • Abiogensis - My take, We were all primordial soup, When Affairs where completely acceptable.

  • Science saved my soul

  • Neil Tyson is the shit

  • This has been proudly quoted in my facebook for a few years now ever since I paused my Tivo and went "Wait... what the fuck did he just say."

  • 8 aliens, from different universe, dont like this video !

  • watched this high, bought tears to my eyes. so beautiful

  • This man should wear a cape and his undies on the out side.

    Thank you Neil.

  • Watch out guys, we're dealing with a badass over here.

  • It IS kind of cool Neil! It's mind blasting, inspiring, and empowering....:) I love scientific poets like Neil and Mr Sagan....

  • I come back to this on my down days...thank you.

  • This was when the history channel was still about history huh...

  • @Th3Sh1n1gam1 i know right?! wtf is all that shit on pawn stars and fucking ancient aliens. i mean i liked the ancient aliens originally but now its gone wayyy to far. its just as credible as the 3 Holy Books

  • @Th3Sh1n1gam1 Yepp. I like American pickers and all but come on...

  • @Th3Sh1n1gam1 Well there's the science channel and history2 which show what the history channel used to show... but they aren't on cable and you have to pay a few dollars more

  • Shut up!

  • yeah... that's pretty cool...

  • Thank you, brother Neil......

  • Far more poetic and beautiful than any Religion.

  • @shawnanthony1992 well said

  • @twst1 Thanks a lot buddy.

  • @shawnanthony1992

    That is because nature is not wise itself but is acting wisely...

  • @shawnanthony1992 Meh the vedas says the same.

    We are the universe and the universe is us.

    "Humans may be the dreams of a God or perhaps God is the dream of humans"

  • @Andysingtoyou

    I didn't ask to be created, I was created against my will. So therefore, I am not thankful

  • @AwesomlyTacticalTom but if you had not been created yet... you would not exist, and therefore would not have any "will" to speak of. The theory of creation is just silly.

  • I feel like crying now :')

  • 8 creationists disliked this.

  • Makes me more than smile. Absolutely exhilarating.

  • We do not need the crutch of imagined revelation, we need only our eyes and our minds to perceive and understand the most moving, most wonderful, greatest and simplest of truths.

  • This one fact alone should push people away from Gods and religion. But it wont, because they beleive what they want to beleive because they want to beleive it. NDT is so well spoken yet he explains things so that even a creationist can understand it.

  • Very close to Buddhist philosophy.

  • Beautiful, man, just... beautiful.

  • @Andysingtoyou Yeah, the Universe did, and I am thankful.

  • "The cosmos is also within us, we're made of star stuff. We are a way for the cosmos to know itself."

  • is he a scientist or a poet?

  • @duhhxxxiloveyou

    Can't he be both?

  • And some people say it's more amazing to say 'God did it'. Fuck off!!

  • so beautiful, thank you for uploading this

  • We are atoms that know about itself.

  • @ccraven95

    we are like annonymous.

    many many atoms, individual parts that has become aware of it's own collective.

  • this is one of the most beautiful things i've ever heard

  • There once was a headline in a National Inquirer type newspaper that sentationally stated "Elvis Presley's brain is from the stars". A paraphrased quote from an astrophysics conference. Perfectly true.

  • Now that is beauty in words.

  • So everything is basicly "togheter"? or made by each other

  • @Zisaar

    a bit of both :)

  • YOU'R MY HEROOOOO!!!! 

  • I'm actually feeling quite large at the end of this video.

  • could we say he's successor to Sagan in a sense? He seems to have a simliarly awe inspired understanding of things. knows that that is what brings people to science and talking about it in that way will bring more.

  • 7 people are incapable of thinking a cool thought.

  • It's interesting that I repeatedly seem to bump into materials used in the Symphony of Science music (which you should check out if you haven't already). The maker seems to have the ability to continously find the best of the best source material.

    This monologue is just overflowing with serene beauty. I'm with dr. Tyson in this one, this really makes one feel big.

  • its like were docking with the universe...

  • Cool thought, bro.

  • Comment removed

  • Wow whats not to like about that? I love the truth because everything else is just plan whu we...

  • HOW ON EARTH can any sane human being dislike this?! Seriously! How can someone like the idea of not being a part of the greatest thing the human race have ever seen, the universe itself or that people on earth have not the same origin thus they can claim that peace among those is impossible?

    I know its only 6 to >1000 but the same ratio keeps back science and the maturity of society!

  • @narutokage777 One word, Jesus. This man made story has held us back for two millennium. According to some of the faithful, science is the devils spawn. Man being created by mud....now that's reasonable. Lol.

  • @MarcusTheReverent That remains to be known, as it stands, the burden of proof is on Theists, after all. Every theory must be tried and tested before it's proven fact -- so far, no God has been seen.

  • and yet there are men who say theres no god

  • @MarcusTheReverent Yep, there is no god and no reason to believe in one. Tough shit.

  • Damn.. he had to be high when he thought this up. And it's so spot on.

  • They said I could be anything I wanted, so I became a star.

  • Watch out we've got a badass over here

  • I'm feeling quite large after watching this video.

  • this is better than any nonsense of the 3 holy books. Spoken by man, embraced by all!

  • @halflifeproductionz Oh hoho, how cute.

  • Neil has the most interesting insights I've heard outside of Carl Sagan.

  • "That makes me smile."

    *sigh*....my nigga, that makes me smile too :)

  • 0:52 nbd

  • @basmithtx We are all connected. What a great message. I am super excited about the new Cosmos. I remember how excited I was as a young man in 1980 to see the Cosmos series.

  • This is something Carl Sagan meant when he said we we all "starstuff."

  • @jeffreydebra1 Tyson is actually doing an updated remake of Sagan's Cosmos. It's possible that may be why there are clips of him discussing the universe in a manner akin to Sagan; though I think it's also how he normally is. He's mentioned that while he will "be himself", he also wants to honor Sagan's original work. I'm excited. :-)

  • Anyone find it amazing that the universe became self-aware and named itself, but somehow still has an almost primitive understanding of itself? (I mean us for anyone who doesn't get it.)

  • @YoonaNeomuYeppeoSeo The universe is a person. And it is trapped within another person. OMG!

  • and there you have it, Neil deGrasse Tyson is a Jedi. And that is awesome

  • that was told by Sagan... beautiful

  • Tears.

  • I always thought 240p&dinosaurs died together...silly me

  • I have spent my life curious about the sciences of our universe, and recently, over perhaps the last few months, I have lived my life thinking about the same things he just said. Let me tell you what, it's like I have discovered a religious enlightenment, because it feels so good. This is why my life matters. Because I am a part of all of this, and even better, I am a part of it.

    This gives me inner peace. Our universe is beautiful.

  • I used to be very religious...mainly out of ignorance and just to follow what my family was following....but now as I'm growing up 21 years young going into 22 I seem to be leaning more towards science. Everything about it intrigues me, makes more sense to me than what religion has to offer and what religion offers is separation of the human race. Science tells me that no matter what color or creed we're all the same just like Mr.deGrasse stated.

  • @mrlif305 Religion makes you feel small...this makes me feel equal to the universe and everything around me.

  • This guy is my hero.

  • Wow. I love that perspective. You almost have to feel sorry for creationists, theists, and advocates of intelligent design. They're missing out on a truly beautiful reality. It's long since past time for man to disabuse himself from ancient views and primative beliefs of what life is about ..... more importantly, what it ISN'T about.

  • Sagan said it best:

    We are all starstuff ... a way for the universe to know itself."

  • This is why I play Super Mario Galaxy -- big nerds like me already knew this.

  • This isn't new ish. We have been stars since stars.

  • The number of dislikes is equal to the IQ of the average creationist.

  • @zaktan415 Very nice, thank you for linking me to your comment :D

  • @ThePeacefulPacifist You're very welcome! Neil speaks the truth and this video makes me smile and feel better than any religious fairy tales would make me feel :D

  • @zaktan415

    Genetically engineered gay babies?

    For it or against it?

  • I left my house for a bit and the computer on, and when I got back this was on my screen... Wtf?

  • What if the universe is God?

  • @zoidberg96913 well then that would be the vaguest, most arbitrary definition of god there is.

  • @zoidberg96913 Then it changes the fundamentals of a lot of Earthly religions.

  • Very poetic. Amazing.

  • Absolutely beautiful. Maybe one day the rest of society will be smart enough to fully grasp the weight of that statement.

  • What about the bible and jesus and allah and muhammad and LRon Hubbard..where do they come in to this. Tyson missed that part.

  • "Enriched guts" is his favorite term XD