Has history been tampered with? Pharao,Moses,David,Solomon,Jesus relate to Middle Ages

[BggProductions]

That book might be great but this six minute advert could be a hell of a lot better.

[wanshei]

Interestingly enough the letter "J" was not in the english language until the year 1049 AD. This itself poses a problem with those who buy into christianity as there is no letter J in the hebrew language. Then i hear that the new testament was written in greek. So...? Is there a Jesus in the Greek language? No. And the New Testament was not written entirely in Greek. Paul was a Roman citizen who did speak other languages but he didnt write the entire new testament.

[ELVISCHALLENGE]

The very opening is bogus. How can Jerusalem be of a Roman empire or Contantinople when the dead sea scrolls pre-date Rome in this region? The Hebrew bible is the most evidenced writing humanity possesses. The Tel Dan find proves King David 3,200 years ago and an Egyptian stelle mentions a war with Israel 3,500 years ago. Which other scripture can equal that?

[shaybird76]

All I have to say is White people are always trying to take credit for everything. lol

[feeefyefofuuum]

I am not a creationist, I am all about truth and facts! Read about Fomenko and how the scientific community has declared his theories "pseudoscience", he is a statastician and mathmatecian who fit his math to fit his theories ...his own people awarded him the Russian "shit" award for worst book ever! This is bullshit. Educated yourselves friends.

[greg12145]

@feeefyefofuuum So do you believe the OFFICIAL 9/11 REPORT? That will be a main part of history taught in the future - do you understand! Fomenko might not be off - it's all a SCAM! The hardest part is accepting that you've been lied to (like a cheating spouse... you might live in denial at first, but later accept the reality that you were lied to/dishonoured). I bet you're young, and I bet all the people here saying it's BS are young - I bet you'll get a different answer from the aged-IM 43

[hybridamerica]

the facts don't matter...

People believe what they want to believe.

People are stupid that way.

Fuck it.

[numberonesurvivor75]

The classical age sucked for most people, but it still existed.

[numberonesurvivor75]

So all the Christian texts dated before 1053 A.D. are forgeries? No.

[Chairmaneoin]

How does this book explain pompeii?

Did the church coax the volcano into erupting then made some roman looking houses and shoved some people in togas down there?

[formless777]

It is ridiculous to suppose that the ruins of antiquity were all produced in the Renaissance. Similarly the atmospheric traces of these civilizations in the ice sheets and age old archaeological evidence like dendrochronology or the eruption of Vesuvius, burying an entire contemporary ancient city in its entirely make this book ludicrous. Forget the bogus Bible nonsense, no truth to be found in religion in any case. This book is an obvious set of lies.

[LFdefiance]

Besides the fact that the allegations are absolutely ridiculous and the "brainwash" style of the video is annoying, the writer might have an excuse for believing this load of crap. Has anyone here actually read that book? Is he actually believing this shit or he is just being provocative in order to sell a few copies?

[AlRaZi559]

wtf??? jesus born in 1053 AD??? Crucified 1086AD???? Totally bogus facts written in this book!!!

This clip just give me THE REASON not to buy/read it and demoralise me to all i've learnt since childhood. The facts would be all wrong and against wiv all the dates/history/facts i've learnt & everything happened in south east asia. God....where did he dreamed making these false statements/facts....ini adalah satu Penipuan!!!

[RSpisket]

I'm convinced!

Not

[sweetsabrina23]

Never heard of that mathematician, thought it would have been a historian or something that would have dealt with matters like this.

[greg12145]

@sweetsabrina23 Well, maybe historians are all playing the game... like a group of Poker people/buds - wink, wink! I doubt a historian would want to step on the toes of his colleagues selling and teaching historical material. There probably have, and have been silenced or work terminated. What exactly would a Historian be skilled at in that profession (not much other than being a Historian).

[sweetsabrina23]

I started to lose my focus once you started talking about Jerusalem being located in this area and not that area. And where did you get these facts from? Im very confused now. Your source of facts are reliable?

[sweetsabrina23]

Yes Maybe all we know is untrue, but we would have to know the Bible first for that to become a reality. Not knowing about the Bible's contents kinda blows that theory out the door.

[derposi]

who cares :D come back to now. dont think about shit like that ^^

[Bavarian88]

These books are almost a psuedo-religous "mein kampf" type booklet for modern russian nationalists. It places moscow at the centre of world history for centuries, claiming every major economic and scientific invention was russian, whereas all other nations were subsurvient to it. A very dangerous message for russians and the world alike. Books like these come and go but logical, rational thought and experimentation always prevail.

[DonMeaker]

Since an old copy of the bible dates to 800 AD, pushing Jesus forward to 1053 is ludicrous...

[CombustableHuxtable]

I take it this goes for Muhammad too? So the quran is also a middle-ages fabrication? Please tell me, I want to know because I don't want to go to hell! hahahaha allah says "Of a surety they will not believe, no matter how much you warn them!"

[mithec]

8. That the history of religions runs as follows: the pre-Christian period (before the XI century and JC), Bacchic Christianity (XI-XII century, before and after JC), JC Christianity (XII-XVI century) and its subsequent mutations into Orthodox Christianity, Catholicism, and Islam;

[MannaBoBannaPeople]

6 Million jews were not killed.

[candymanio]

Yourright, only 5,999,999...one resurrected after 3 days, and he is kicking asses and taking names! WHO CARES, one person killed is too much: "Ce que tu fais au plus petit des miens c'est a moi que tu le fais". Sorry this is just for showing off really, and for the fun of you going through an online dictionnary trying to figure out what it means. HINT: It's in the bible¬!

[MannaBoBannaPeople]

He was NOT a JEW as these filthy imposters he was an ISRAELITE Seed of DAVID whom God blesses, and works through him and his people. Killing is OK and GODly you just hate the truth because satan lives in your heart. EAT Holy Meals instead of shit.

[Estaah77]

my great great great great grandmother's diary is only 20 years old! How did you know she was in on the conspiracy? Oh crap she didn't exist...dang you caught me trying to rewrite history too. I guess the earth was formed about 1050 years ago. You been listening to your rice krispies too much. Ohh I am not really 30 Im only 10.

[candymanio]

hu hu, earth doesn't exist we are only living somebody else's nightmare...

[elephant1111]

women have trouble finding a man blabla because there is 95 women for 100 men blabla.. OK, in the ACTIVE population, it's the other way around, there are just more older (70+) women, just verify on the cia site. + men are more active! They just say that to portrait things in a way that will encourage what they sell and what they want you to do, it's stupid, everything an english-speaking person tells you, you should discard

[elephant1111]

There is no history in books, only the present. What it teaches us is in the choices we make when deciding what to read; tells about our current state of mind.

Everyone knows History is bullshit, everyone tries to use it for their agenda. Take statistics for example, just the other day on the radio it says:

[candymanio]

In years of reading comments on youtube, this is most definitely the best one! Kant would not disagree with you. Allow me to expand: Bible Quoran, Torah, and so forth are only worth what their result is. Judaism is lost in technicalities, Islam in solipsim and Christianity in time. GOD is one and TELLS us in any possible language to STOP KILLING eachother. That would be his job when your are ready. The rest is just acting like (for) the devil trying to be like the allmighty. It's just all wrong!

[luisalmeida01]

This is what secularism does to society, with the exception that now, it reaches worldwide scales. Have any of you read the works of Tacitus and Josephus? Which WERE historians in early AD? Christ was born 2 BC, FYI.

[fuckhappy]

If you had read them with any context you would know that Josephus has been proven to be a fiction and Tacitus refers only to the Christ, a title, not a person. Both mysteriously appeared recently in world history, and at a time when great sums of money were paid for such manuscripts. There is no copy in existence older than a few hundred years.

[Chairmaneoin]

This isn't the result of secularism, this is the result of bullshitters believing everything they read.

Trust me, I'm an Atheist but even I accept that Jesus existed, the only thing for me is i don't believe he was the son of god.

[mithec]

power,greed,fear:to google or to amazon>to `more`> to `book search`>type keyword `fomenko`, read TOC or the whole book free of charge.

[KalleRedson]

absolutely ridiculous and just impossible, even if they wanted too they couldnt have done it.

[KalleRedson]

ok then, lets call the muslims the 'infidels' then as they used too call them. So, all writers in the world collaborated too deceive us.. ALL of them.. they all tell us a matching story.. statues of roman emperors were forged, COINS were forged.. right, gold costs, some expensive hoax with which goal? tombs however are carbon dated. And so are documents. Can you even explain what you just said?

[mithec]

Occam razor: Humanoids>5 mln years. Sapiens sapiens <=150.000 years old, civilization (state+army+ideology+writing) goes only as far back as AD 800, scarce information from 8-10 cy AD events, historical events took place in 10-15th cy AD. Jesus 1153-1186 AD. Old Testament compiled in 12-16 cy AD, AFTER New One, it renders events of that period. All methods of dating of artefacts, including c14 are non-exact and contradictory, there are no written ORIGINALS datable earlier than the XI century..

[KalleRedson]

bullshit.

You are saying that people wrote all those texts, translted them into roman, BUILT CITIES in a few hundred years which we believe to be built in very different periods. Wheeeere do you suppose they got the manpower?

the money?

the REASON?

it just isn't possible. give me proof of what you say, give me a reason.

[mithec]

Dr Fomenko:..No, we do not cancel events, artefacts, Pyramids, Great Walls, etc..etc, but suggest to find their true position on the time axis.

[greg12145]

@KalleRedson It's very plausible. You just have to look at the OFFICIAL 9/11 REPORT. If you've done your homework it's obvious it's a book with some truth and MANY, MANY, MANY DISTORTIONS of what really happened. So it's being done today - FABRICATING REALITY in books like the above, I guess it couldn't happen in the past.

[greg12145]

@KalleRedson It's very plausible!

[KalleRedson]

riduclous.

First,carbon14 dating prooves the age of al these documents. As if people in the 16th century had the SLIGHTEST knowledge of radioactivuty and forged it..right!

yea everyone can show us nice graphs, i want proof.

I guess the pope must have had the muslims in on the hoax as well, making them build roman temples and churches in the middle east which was in muslim hands by the 11th century.

RIDICULOUS.. aka america

[mithec]

documents are not dated with c14, it means burning a chunk of it. c14 labs do nothing but confirm suggested age; the fail dismally ALL black box tests. c14 method is calibrated on dendrochronology which is based on age of logs suggested by historians is not statistically viable. word muslim unknown till xvith cy.

[mithec]

Fomenko also alleges undue cooperation between physicists and archaeologists in obtaining the dates, since most radiocarbon dating labs only accept samples with an age estimate suggested by historians or archaeologists. Fomenko also claims that carbon dating over the range of 0 to 2000 AD is inaccurate because it has too many sources of error that are either guessed at or completely ignored, and that calibration is done with a statistically meaningless number of samples.

[greg12145]

@KalleRedson You just have to look/read at the OFFICIAL 9/11 REPORT and know how history can be DISTORTED right in front of you. If they're doing it today... guess they'd never do anything so deceptive back in the day for economic, financial, political, psychological and etc. gain -- YEAH RIGHT!

[mithec]

right..a simple application of computational astronomy to the rules of calculation of the Easter according to the Easter Book introduced by the Nicean council of alleged 325 AD shows that it definitely could not have taken place before 784 AD. Some related questions may arise: when and where was Jesus Christ born, when was He crucified? Was The Old Testament compiled before or after the New One, etc..?

[chefratzinger]

An mathematician talking about history. That makes it a lot more creditable. So the Concilie of Nicea of 325, where the basics of christianity was founded took place before the birth of the most imported man of that religion? Weird...

[silverbackman]

So how does this all relate to the history of China, India, Persia, and other eastern civilizations? Are the historical documents in the East false or inaccurate too?

[greg12145]

@silverbackman If the Elites/Ancient Educated/Royals are all connected and have been, why would it be hard... our top leaders all get together today... they didn't back then through proxy (messengers) means?

[mithec]

check this heresy just in case: go to google>to `more`> to `book search`>type keyword `fomenko`, read TOC or the whole book for this matter and free of charge

[Timinator15]

Are you kidding with this? This is really stupid sorry.

[cutshaw]

Why does the voice sometimes sound like Stephen Hawking?

[BryanAJParry]

Sounds VERY interesting. I'ld love to read it.... I dout it is actually true, but it would be interesting to read.

[mithec]

this theory pulls the rug from under consensual history and da vinci code, which is nothing but appetizer for religion..

[vega32]

This theory would make a great 'da vinci code' type movie.

[mithec]

check this heresy just in case: go to google>to `more`> to `book search`>type keyword `fomenko`, read TOC or the whole book for this matter and free of charge

[faridjabba]

Hi, intereesting, but Im not convinced, Im a HIstorian, to trade`ideas and material on Enigmas of History, my msn `is farid_jabba

[nixter888]

nobody can surpass the giant hellenism!!!

[Chairmaneoin]

how about a hellenistic revival but this time with computers and spaceships!

[Cuscusgrass]

Interesting....I must check out the book.