Added: 4 years ago
From: InFINITI28
Views: 487,925
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (487)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • horrible? yeah right. this was heartwarming, raw and beautiful.

  • U call this havin hard time to breathe regine dont even half a beauty of mariahs voice!

  • 2:52 onwards was perfect.

  • You have no idea how awful is having vocal nodules and not being able to sing as you used to or even speak somedays. Stop criticizing Mariah because she damaged her voice for us (fans) going on tour and singing live enevnwhen she lnew that was not the best in her case. And btw Regine's voice has nothing special, she sings great but I don't feel a thing she bores me with her karaoke style....

  • this was gorgeous she sounds amazing

  • @Mrchrismaniego excuse me regine who? You talk about regine but all she is is a fake a person who gets up on stage and mimicks songs made by others! Thats all she can do! Please mariah can do much more with her voice than regine can, and mariah has a 5-7 octave voice something that hardly anybody in the world has! The proof is in the pudding call me when regine sells over 200 million albums!

  • I love Mariah i am a huge fan but this is horrible!

  • I love this entire cd... :)

  • Shoot!!! I REALLY wanted her to do that VERY low note at 3:34.

  • She's the best.

  • her nose was stuffy cuz she had a cold... it HAPPENS and she still sounds amazing love it

  • ok that last phrase she sang... CHILLSSS!!! wowwww. So much resonance in those low notes.

  • O, this song... *menangis tersedu-sedu* *terbawa perasaan ceritanya*

  • People need to STFU talking shyt.. Y'all just jealous of her... Ask ur fucking self.. If u can be like her? The STFU... Isn't easy to be like her... So chill Leona is a singer also.. But they're different time. Both Have different kind of song... We can't compare 90's and 2000's together.. Like wtf... Chill out.. And listen.. Just simple.. She had so many song on top hit.. That's proved everything.. Period

  • does she have a solo performance of this song??

  • no matter what others say, i still love Mariah Carey! blehhhh

    please Mariah, come back, we need you and your music.

  • AND AND AND... NOBODY WOULD DARE TO REVIVE ONE OF HER SONGS OR MAKE THEIR OWN VERSION.. EXCEPT DAVID COOK'S ALWAYS BE MY BABY.

    HER SONGS ARE REALLY TOUGH.

  • Uh why is Rosie singing in the background?

  • @LisaSpringfield it's not rosie xD

  • Whoever thinks this was bad and does not get the musical skills she used to work this song and the silky and soothing melody in that last vocal arrangement, should just Zip it.

  • she sends shivers up and down my spine! shes terrific. he who criticizes her in a bad way, needs actually to zip it up. her high notes are great and if you think your better, you would not write a comment right here but you would be in the top ten. since your not famous and nobody knows you, and till you prove that ur better please stay silent. thanks in advance :))

  • @vacmich21 well said!!!!

  • To have Mariah and Whitney in the 90s. The 2000s have missed a vocalist of their caliber.

  • the best song from the best singer forever...

  • @TheAswad87 Soooooo true!

  • do you wanna know why mariah stayed for so long in the business not like the other singers or divas,, because she writes her own song she doesnt need a writer and wait for another years to come up with a new album.. so dont dare comepare to anyone else shes incomparable.. not any singer in the earth GOt it!!! use you neurons people!!!

  • What a great singer she is! Love this song!

  • I think this is her toughest song ever. most of the time she sing this song she would struggle to hit the high notes more then her other songs. too bad it wasnt such a big hit

  • @susceotible i think whenever you call is more tougher to sing

  • @ponkho22 through the rain is the hardest ,even harder than emotions. this is not about high notes, but about the flow of the song.

  • @jennyfamilybaby the fluidity in wnever you call is also hard.. but i agree that T.T.R is really hard to sing ...

  • @jennyfamilybaby and by the way . all mariah's song is really hard to sing =)

  • @ponkho22 I agree with you, but this one of the hardest songs of hers to sing.

  • @ponkho22 it´s not hard to sing, it´s har to have a beautiful voice like her. it´s high notes!

  • uma cansao bem romantica

  • uma musica muinto otima e muinto  romantica eu amei

  • the beginning was weak as hell but she pulled herself together at the 2nd verse

  • Her voice is very loud but she sings so far away from the mic, she can blow anyone off the stage! LOVE HER!!

  • why can't she hit the higher notes in falsetto?

  • @Jim1971a her headvoice was really weird in this time and breathy.

  • @296218047 called falsetto, and she had this going on way better in SNL performance

  • Perfect

  • her nose looks so funny :)

  • Press 6 to see Mariah's impression of a horse on crack...lol

  • she breathe loud but beautiful haha

  • Pfft..... Miley Cyrus is better LOL :P

  • @harmyk1 HAHA :D in your dreams !!! your miley cyrus does not sing, she is screaming like a chipmunk :P

  • @NiRie017 Erm... I was joking XD

  • @harmyk1 haha :D but even a joke .. i can't imagine miley cyrus is better xD she's nothing compare to mariah carey :)

  • this is so amazing and moving.. gets me everytime. Great performance!!!

  • I think lyrically this is her most poetic song. It's also a vocal tour de force.

  • @jrr1234567890 It definitely is poetic! Vividly emblazoned in my mind... how I love that line. :)

  • yassssssssssss mimi breath life into me.....yasssssssssssssssssssss­sssssssss can't get that kind of life these days...youtube is my respirator...

  • what a very good performance... we love you mariah carey here in philippines...

    :-)

  • do not doubt Mariah Carey voice is amazing, in Malaysia there is the same artist is Celine Dion Mariah Carey Siti Nurhaliza and Jaclyn Victor is ...... you listen to the voices of these awards ....

  • @ejam83macho Jaclyn yes, Siti sucks

  • @theoneandonly2503 I think we need to see the difference between the two singers, if you can not be said Siti Nurhaliza Siti Nurhaliza to sing Why is recognized as a legend in Malaysia?

  • @ejam83macho I don't know but her voice is so damn average. Jaclyn is a powerhouse

  • OMG everytime i hear this song,tears start comining out of my eyes

  • beautiful

  • @hasting29 leave bitch

  • @DanielAvilaAGT

    Tell ya dead idol to leave the music industry and join the FUCKIN CIRCUS !!!

  • @hasting29 *yawns* *shakes head* *exhales deeply* *rolls eyes* *laughs*

  • You stupid young ungrateful mo fuckers don't respect any part of what true artist entails and as I read the blogs in your responses, you never experienced the true side of it nor the real artist who performs with stage poised, clarity and hardly no backup singers, Adlibs that are natural and improtu style as good as we breath the crispy thin air! Riffs and Runs !!! operatic vocal gynastics with gut and soul !!! The one & ONLY WHITNEY HOUSTON left her fucking seal that can't ever be broken !!!

  • @hasting29 Do you not realize that you're the one coming on mariah videos and making comments! The only hater is you...... You are soo retarded.

  • @witch26071

    well I am out numbered by many of mariah fans who always post neg shit on whitney's posts !!! You're prolly one of em !!!  Hater fucking murderer !!!

  • Comment removed

  • @hasting29 Okay so now I'm a murderer? Okay Whatever idiot.

  • @hasting29 Bitch your fucking crazy stop sending me personal messages and then blocking me? You are complete looney tunes!! "the gift" lol get over yourself idiot!

  • Again MaTryah Un saved Fucking Unicorns Not Lambs !!! Go back to hell and look up to the giants until she comes down to join ya'll !!! True Fucking Haters from your guts !!!

  • Yes I can sing and I can recognize great singers but this Bitch needs to take a recourse on her illuminati singing vocals !!! By the way Bitch, You can like my dead grandma's pearl tongue !!!

  • Take away those background singers and she sounds most Aweful !!! This shit sounds pitiful !!! Run this Bitch off the planet !!!

  • @hasting29 hater......

  • @hasting29 bitch please i bet u cant sing at all!!

  • jajaja Rossie O´donnel Is a fucking Fat, Mariah is a godsness

  • Don't confuse LOUDNESS with power. two different things

  • @KristenJn I agree, Xtina is no where near them. She's not even one of the best vocalists of today.

  • @repenttyourself oh SHUT UP !! christina is better than anyone else. CELINE, WHITNEY and YOUR MARIAH CANT SING LIKE CHRISTINA !!

  • @waynestripped Floptina can't even belt over a D5 without SCREAMING and straining her voice to the point that it sounds like she's dying. Her voice is GONE for good. She ruined it, just like she ruined her career with that shitty mess Bionic. Xtina will NEVER be on the level of the LEGENDS of vocals, such as Aretha, Patti, Whitney, Celine, and Mariah. Her voice has never even been near their level. Sorry you stan for a flop, screeching mess. Try harder next time.

  • @repenttyourself FYI !!! X-TINA isn't screaming !! she just does that to at least put a little texture in her singing !! to give different flavour to her singing . CHRISTINA ALWAYS SING LIVE !!!! unlike your so called "LEGENDS" who's 70% of their performances were lip synced. they don't change there style coz that's the only thing they know !!

    HANDS DOWN FOR LEGENTINA !!! YOU'RE THE BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @waynestripped Whitney always sings live!!!!!! Mariah started the lipsync thing after her drastic voice change around 1998. Celine lipsync also, but still can belt live when she wants to. But Aguilera is also amazing!

  • @theoneandonly2503 yeah. Aguilera always sings live too !! :)) but wait, what was the cause of mariah's drastic voice change ??

  • @waynestripped Daydream live performances>>>>Butterfly live performances>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>­>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Rainbow live performances :)

  • @theoneandonly2503 Some said that "she gave everything during the Daydream tour" but that's bull*****,I think the reality is much darker than that, the only thing that can affect the voice so quickly is cocaine or overdrinking.Add to that the fact that maybe she didn't do the same vocal routine she used to do when she was with Tommy and I think you have the answer. But of course stupid lambs will never see that, for them, the reason is that she overused her voice,but they know nothing at singing

  • @theoneandonly2503 huh ? i didn't get that :)

  • @waynestripped too bad ur fav voice is declining, too lmao dismissed

  • marih carey love you

    

  • what mistakes? she sing's with her soul clearly here..

  • Mariah my love,of colombia from amor

  • it sounds like she was having trouble? 

  • @MercedesKlai she got like cough or some kind of throat problems here..idk exactly, though

  • she's giving some part to her background singers..WTF!!!!

  • HER BACKGROUND SINGERS MAKE ME LAFF ALL THE TIME! lol hahahahah

  • she is beatiful,singer excelent, and very wemen, congratulations mariah from mexico, city.rafael

  • Mariah is the defintion of true talent

  • She wasnt happy when she did this performance

  • WONDERFULL!!! PERFECT!!!! AMIZING!!!!!

  • WOW!.. nice performance!

    just imagine a due [Mariah Carey and Christina Aguilera]!!!

  • What is the year of this music and album ? I like,I love this music is so romantic !

  • @kitaresodoerenemi around 1997, from her BUTTERFLY album

  • theres no one that can cover this song but Mariah Carrey!!!

  • i hate it when people criticize mariah's singing so much like der are hundreds of other singers that surpass her or something, her voice & singing style are unique, for example search utube for people trying to sing dis song, der IS no one else, try singing on pitch at least 10 seconds of this song-most likely u will fail. So ppl please dn't talk about the few mistakes she makes. MJ, Whitney, Mariah, Celine, its been more than 2 decades since they came out & nobody has even come close since.

  • @mmete147 no you're wrong!!! cause there is a filifino singer that can do that!!!!!! not exactly the voice!!! but at the tone!!!! she can hit that tone!!! and she is regine velasquez!!!! if you want an evidence!! watch this

    "Regine Velasquez - Mariah Carey Medley SOP Live "

  • @alwinmj02 I saw that video and Regine is a good singer and she can do that high pitch tone but she is missing something that Mariah has, and that's passion and soul you can hear it when she's sings. She makes you feel what the song is saying. If you don't hear that then ok. I'm not trying to start shit or anything, I'm just telling you.

  • @Mew4U you are right!!! but i want to clear that im saying that regine is better !! i just said that she can hit not pitch that mariah can do!!! but mariah is still the best for me!!! i just cleared that statement that no one can ever hit that note!!!

  • @Mew4U yes im a big fan of mariah!!!!

    but in singing!! not always copying is to be done!!!

    regine is making her name in her way!!!!

    but mariah is so far from regine!!! and all of us know that!!!!

  • @mmete147 I totally agree. This isn't Mariah's best singing, for sure. But nobody is arguing that it isn't live! Yay! hahaha I'm going to sing this song on my channell, and it is a really hard sing, and i don't consider myself to be a "bad singer". It's not an easy song. Thumbs up for your comment!

  • this was before she got her nose done..

  • @STOPHAYTIN1 she looked so much better with this one!

  • fatal

  • whtiney was the best voice

  • @manuel2508 ppsssss mariah songs and 5 octave voice owns whitney since 1990... sorry when mariah sings whitney is a noob, especially today even though i like whitney.. she was never good like mariah, just loud and not everbody wants to hear 24 hours gospel sound, but mariah voice has so much facettes not like whitney

  • @manuel2508 this is mariah performance why you say this thing? i agree with youthat whitney has stronger voice but we watching mariah performance and we must comment this one ;)

  • @nippi89 Yeah, we heard Whitney on GMA 2009, her voice was that strong that they even had to dub it.

  • 1 word

    AMAZING

  • This is before she got her tits done.

  • love ths woman!

  • This is the only song i've ever cried to while listening to it (not just now, a few years ago). Mariah is an amazing singer AND WRITER! And people stop with all the Whitney comparisons, they're different types of singers.

  • you don't her actual "live" voice very much...it's very nice :)

  • Mariah, you don't how this song is important to me. When I heard this I feel like crying my eyes out. You are sure extraordinary singer. Your One Of A Kind!!

  • mariah you really are excellent. passion, amazing voice...just one of a kind (a legend)

  • And what you 4get!!! Is that the quality of this video is crappy and old from when?!!! Before she did her boobies and! Had we watched this when Rosie was on TV, we would have indeed seen the entire spectrum of these 4 magical minutes. It was a great performance. Right next to Butterfly. I love MC!!

  • mariah perde colpi

  • Holy crap <3

  • GOOSE BUMPZ....no words!

  • I think she's overworked... but still a great and wondrous performance....

    Good job utilizing the back up singers....

    ^^

  • this is one of the moments when u can clearly see that she already lost it.

  • @estoryahehe She said it was too early for her in the interview and I'm sorry to break it down to you but she sounded AMAZING. Her voice is so unique. She never lost it, she never will. How can you say that someone who makes an imperfect vocal moment sound so beautiful has lost it?

  • @estoryahehe lost it ?

  • @estoryahehe many should lose there voice like this!!....such a great voice....wasn't perfect performance but still great very hard difficult song because its so low and emotional and every riff has to be filled with emotion in order to carry thru.....and breathing is always an issue from studio to live...even luther vandross said that....because you can sing two lines at a time instead of the whole song at once...but check out her peformance with pavorotti

  • Superb performance!

  • I love this, minus the horrific breathing, Hahaha, But that's ok. The voice. :)

  • Puts few fat ladys that can't sing in a row and owns em....how retarted.Ahes a real whore.

  • galing,,,

  • the vocals were sultry...breathy and classy^^

  • yes i think is very versatile in everything .. even her performance in her concerts she changes the version , some adlibs from the song and everything.... she never disappoints her fans allover the world

  • her voice wasnt good that day but she gave an inspired performance!

    very special, as usual <3

  • AMAZING IS ALL I CAN SAY.. SHE KILLED THIS SONG

  • my favourite!!!

  • she is just the best....

  • I love Ioana! :)

  • Its performances like this that prove why you are one of the greatest singers and will always be in my top 3

  • ...very mesmerizing!! ;) d(^_^)b

  • This is waht i call singing!

  • i love u mariah carey...

  • daaaaaaamn damn damn

    amazing

  • bravo... 

  • Whenever she sings these days she seems as she always lacks sleep.. Thats one problem that she might have had because she said that she always sleep so late till daylight like until 3am to 4am..

  • this is her vocal break from a very Amazing belt to Angelic Low notes

  • she is so sweet...

  • Awesome !! But one time she went out from the rhythm in this song.any way SouLful !!

  • ♫ ♫ Beautiful song for a perfect voice ♫♫

  • da hora.

  • She is great, awesome. I love her!

  • hey i see rosie!

    far right choir singer

  • Celine nor Cristina nor Whitney could never sing a song that way mariah sings her own song. They would come close, Whitney tho, celine and Cristina don't know tho...

  • @DanielAvilaAGT nor beyonce

  • Im a HUGE fan of Whitney and also Mariah, and Whitney can't sing Mariah Songs, and Likewise, Mariah Can't sing Whitney songs............So I am not understanding your point here? Mariah and Whitney are completely different... both amazing but different. Just the same as Christina and Celine.... all DIVAS!!

  • @ticklemecrazy well said