I ususally don't like slow songs... I always liked the band version of this song... But last night I was like hmmm I haven't heard this version... Now I'm in love... Lol I got it on my iPod and I have been listening to it non-stop. BTW awesome lyrics! :]
Oh how I'd love to walk away and pull myself out of the rain, but i can't leave without you. How I'd love to live without the constant fear and endless doubt, but I can't live without you... those lyrics ring in my head. WHY'D THEY TAKE THEM OUT?!?!? they were so good. So deep. So, easy to relate to.
I. Love. This. Version. :D "I would give every breath from my chest to give you all the things my mind couldn't bear" Omg, I love that, and they should've kept that
Nope. It was never on an album. There is a version of it on Origin which is just piano, vocal and David Hodges doing background vocals, and that version is the same version on Fallen (just without the strings) but this version was never released on an album.
No origin version has hodges backing lyrics and no strings but otherwise same as Fallen. This was a really old demo that was cut from the Evanescence EP
At the time of recording I'd assume it was an acoustic. A very bright grand? Not sure. They were very small at the time of the recording, I don't think they had access to a keyboard.
I love the lyrics and her voice in this song a lot more, but I think that the piano in the official version is better. So if this version of the song had the piano in the new version, then it would be almost perfect :}
omg i have never heard this demo version...wow....its so....like unprofessionally edited but its good! just different from im used to much more real. luv it
Her voice has greatly improved since this time. She went flat a few times and the piano wasn't great either... it's amazing listening to old stuff from artists to see how they've grown as performers.
I love this version of the song and the official version.... I like listening to this one better though because I listen to the original version to much... Lol
Pros: her voice the first minute the lyrics the ending the 3-4 minute part(those were my favorite lyrics in there) her voice again(sounds more real and has more feeling and sounds more fresh. Cons: the piano( it was too loud and seemed to take away from her voice) a tad to slow the piano sounded off key WHY ISNT THIS ON ITUNES????!!!!
I like this version better. Maybe because it seems a bit more raw, you know? I like some songs to sound a little raw, because it sounds like the voice wasn't worked on by computers or anything like that. I don't know, maybe it's just me. ;)
It's okay. I have this song on my mp3 and I was just thinking about what I've been through, and I was thinking about how I died when I was first born.
My favourite is this one, and I found it on a website that allows you to download all of the Evanescence Demos for free, because Evanescence are no longer making money from it, so Amy has said something about encouraging us to download it. I could send it to you, if you wish.
if you reverse this song (it's satanic ) !!!!
mohcinebouhya 4 weeks ago in playlist eva,escence all songs
I ususally don't like slow songs... I always liked the band version of this song... But last night I was like hmmm I haven't heard this version... Now I'm in love... Lol I got it on my iPod and I have been listening to it non-stop. BTW awesome lyrics! :]
ImFuckingInsane 1 month ago
Oh how I'd love to walk away and pull myself out of the rain, but i can't leave without you. How I'd love to live without the constant fear and endless doubt, but I can't live without you... those lyrics ring in my head. WHY'D THEY TAKE THEM OUT?!?!? they were so good. So deep. So, easy to relate to.
Kittenlover313 2 months ago
Comment removed
Kittenlover313 2 months ago
This is the demo that they presented to Dust For Life.
JimmyPage968 3 months ago
This is better than the other version :)
toclafanemastersuper 3 months ago
I Wish I could Catch those 4 ppl who Dislike this Perfect Song .. Are you Agree With me ?
Nesta20678 4 months ago
amazing :)
xKathrynPeircex 5 months ago
T^T So beautiful.
mizushadow 5 months ago
Wasn't she only, like, 17 or 18 when she sang this version?
JacobInvading 6 months ago
@JacobInvading Yeah, I think this version was recorded in 1998 or 1999, so Amy was around 18 years old then!
heliaz11 3 months ago
i love this song!!!
Pinutbutterfly 10 months ago
I only just found out about this! After my friend Izzy showed me it :D
He's A great Friend :3
I wouldnt trade him for the woooorld <3
BambiMaggot666 1 year ago
Interesting but the album version is faaar better :)
HelenaPaparizou4ever 1 year ago
Amy Lees voice is perfect for this kind of deep songs. Epic.
Isalinn 1 year ago
i actually dont like this version. she sounds high
Thehighschool8888 1 year ago
This is such an amazing song... why wouldn't they release this, rather than the official version?!
Jamessc13 1 year ago
Makes me think of my younger twin sister. RIP, you'll always have 'all of me.'
Such a beauitful version. They should've kept the bridge! <3
LilBlackEmoCat 1 year ago
***haha have funny***
0JapanGirl0 1 year ago
i love this ive never listen to this before thank u very much ^-^
snowwhitequeenlover 1 year ago
I love this version <33
Jenz767 1 year ago
I LOVE this song,.. it dont care if i listen to the full band version, the album- or the demoversion- this song makes me cry ;(
she has the most beautiful voice ever!!
Deni93ful 1 year ago
I. Love. This. Version. :D "I would give every breath from my chest to give you all the things my mind couldn't bear" Omg, I love that, and they should've kept that
kitkatkarley 2 years ago 20
I love this version, but i do love the lyrics
'i've tried so hard to tell myself that you're gone, & though you're still with me, i've been alone all along' that're in the released version....
kiitty99 2 years ago 4
so cool
whenrique1993 2 years ago
god i wanna download this song so bad
jeffhardy4057 2 years ago
i love this one its so much longer then the other one either way they are both good because its Amy ^.^
sangojr 2 years ago
I like this version so much more than the studio version :)
EvenxInxDeath8 2 years ago
this song makes me cry everytime I watch this video
breannanavarre2 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like this song but not when you sing it no effence
americanbulldog120 2 years ago
..I didn't sing this song.
This is Amy Lee singing.. just an older version.
O__o
xDeadxVampirex 2 years ago 15
ohhh it sounds like someone else is singing
americanbulldog120 2 years ago
this is definately amy lee
durin d gud ol days
thx for uploadin! n_n
pataya69 2 years ago
@americanbulldog120 roflmao he didnt sing this Amy did
d0ri12 1 year ago
@americanbulldog120 This is Amy Lee. It's just a demo version.
VKFan42 8 months ago
A bit scary compared to the original. o.o
But good no matter what~ ^^
Conkerfan364 2 years ago
Was this from Evanescence EP?
GenieBella 2 years ago
No, this was just a demo version of My Immortal.
idkwat2say3 2 years ago
No it was from a very old album many say its from origin
villeluv1 2 years ago
Nope. It was never on an album. There is a version of it on Origin which is just piano, vocal and David Hodges doing background vocals, and that version is the same version on Fallen (just without the strings) but this version was never released on an album.
benmoody0220 2 years ago
No origin version has hodges backing lyrics and no strings but otherwise same as Fallen. This was a really old demo that was cut from the Evanescence EP
jordanrudessrulesok 2 years ago
I like this better than the "official" or radio version!
cleanhomer 2 years ago 4
the bridge of this song is absoulutely beautiful!
edward4ever192 2 years ago 3
That's so pretty, are those fender Rhodes? Or those deep keyboard thingies?
WOLFFDEPPSPONGEBOB 2 years ago
At the time of recording I'd assume it was an acoustic. A very bright grand? Not sure. They were very small at the time of the recording, I don't think they had access to a keyboard.
HollyTheFireNinja 2 years ago
I think that the three versions are equal (though the piano and combination between it and the voice on the one from Origin is better)
But you have got to admit her voice gets a little weak at moments in this song.
SUPER DUPER GREAT anyway xD
gummiplutt 2 years ago 2
very different, but a really good version
algaholic1 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Different but nice
DaniiGirl103 2 years ago 6
this song is realy special to me an this is evan better thn the one on fallen an origin thnx for posting it
gokhanx99 2 years ago 8
I love the lyrics and her voice in this song a lot more, but I think that the piano in the official version is better. So if this version of the song had the piano in the new version, then it would be almost perfect :}
Ihavevids 2 years ago 5
such a sad and beautiful song :)
AHHHHCALL911 3 years ago 3
Omg
Luffles this songplz
I like it better than teh other versionnnnnnnn
O:
CattyHeavens888 3 years ago 2
The piano is awfully done compared with the origin and fallen version, but the lyrics I think are better
jordanrudessrulesok 3 years ago 5
Actually this is the hardest version to play in fact the album versions were edited to play easier
villeluv1 2 years ago
Try playing them lol - this is all chords
jordanrudessrulesok 2 years ago
yeah they're really straight chords...
cavalier777 2 years ago
Nice Song I Like It Better
TheHumanRuffian 3 years ago 3
YES!!! I have been looking for the lyrics for this on the internet,not even THINKING abotu checkign Youtube! So,thank you!!!
SnowWhiteQueen29 3 years ago 7
You are most welcome. ^____^
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
It's wonderful! Her voice is great here, but the piano a bit too loud... but I love it <3
and great video :)
July18071 3 years ago 3
my opinion: she sings beautifully here, but the piano is not as beautiful as in the fallen or the origin version
Evanescencexmyxlife 3 years ago 2
omg i have never heard this demo version...wow....its so....like unprofessionally edited but its good! just different from im used to much more real. luv it
Cheyannewhore 3 years ago
she sounds so vulnerable...its so beautiful
999fallenangel999 3 years ago 4
Dudee this is just heaven! makes me cry every time i listen to it. its a great song and uve done a great job vampire once again (: x
IntwinedAssasin 3 years ago 2
Thank youu! :)
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
I think both are equally beautiful. You can't choose.
BADforYOU89 3 years ago 3
She has such an incredibly beautiful voice.
This is such a powerful song.
Thank you xDeadxVampirex.
BoldRevelationsMight 3 years ago 5
You're welcome, and thank you. :)
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
Her voice has greatly improved since this time. She went flat a few times and the piano wasn't great either... it's amazing listening to old stuff from artists to see how they've grown as performers.
LittleCloserBoi 3 years ago
I love this version of the song and the official version.... I like listening to this one better though because I listen to the original version to much... Lol
TheRune5capeShow 3 years ago 2
Pretty cool demo, but the official one is better. EVANESCENCE FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!
DevilsStudent 3 years ago 2
I can see why the producers wanted to change the song. This bridge section does not flow as well as the one on the album. Not as good in my opinion.
anfran05 3 years ago
ThisHeartBeats4You 3 years ago
i luv evvy they're the best i finally learned how to play this song on the piano. i luv it its so beautiful.
TheFrayRocks267 3 years ago
I like this version better. Maybe because it seems a bit more raw, you know? I like some songs to sound a little raw, because it sounds like the voice wasn't worked on by computers or anything like that. I don't know, maybe it's just me. ;)
JuStMeAnDmYd0g 3 years ago 4
Yes, I agree. Their newer stuff (is hella amazing, don't get me wrong), but this does sound fresh and pure.
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
Well, both voices are hers.
She doesn't get her voice edited by much..
Just to get the screachy-unnatural tone out of it.
Both versions are beautiful, but this one truly shows how she was feeling when she wrote the song.
BloodieRoses 3 years ago 2
She did not write the song, Ben did.
benmoody0220 2 years ago
that´s so nice...
it´lovely *.*
someone wipe my tears ...
:)
Katzensarg 3 years ago
Hi (^oo^)
TheRune5capeShow 3 years ago
Its Light not lie BTW
nightwishfan60 3 years ago
Thanks, I was just following a lyric site though. :)
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
i like the lyrics on this one better, i wonder y this isnt the final cut? i love the lyrics, a lot of emotion
Tayuya129 3 years ago 2
sounds like Amy was sleeping as she record... xD
but I like this version^^
EvanescenceFreaky 3 years ago 6
it doesn't even sound like it it's like in a different key and the piano is different and some of the lyrics r different
shikashadowpower 3 years ago
That's because it's a different version - it's not meant to sound the same.
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
it the demo version dumb ppl
angelofdarkness6548 3 years ago
You have to find the album this song is in. Then, once you've found the album, find the song. Once you've found the song, right click and save link.
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
I heard she sang this when she was sixteen. :x
jsaactoabn 3 years ago
she doesnt even sound the same here
KirstySpencer1991 3 years ago
This sounds much better, it has more passion and emotion, but I like the lyrics from the Fallen version better.
rainbowskinnyjeans 3 years ago 5
i wonder if i can find this version on limewire...not likely but not impossible.
powerplayer84 3 years ago 3
You can download it freely, along with loads of other Evanescence demos, from evanescencereference dot info/music
xDeadxVampirex 3 years ago
once on the site how do you downlioasd the music??
sry im really bad with computers.
x
GraceHowes 3 years ago
She sings this version with more emotion.
It's very good. I loved it.
she sings very well.
She's my eternal love.
johnLecompt 3 years ago 5
She sings this version with more emotion.
It's very good. I loved it.
she sings very well.
She's my eternal love.
johnLecompt 3 years ago 4
i love this'n..
i like it better than the other..
but the other is still amazing.
myimmortalfool09 3 years ago 3
Like the original, this version makes me cry too.
mistrbig671 4 years ago 2
i like this version even better... more passion
xxxMegGgiExxx 4 years ago 5
I'm about to cry over this song right now.
cilla310 4 years ago 2
Aww. I'm sorry..
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
It's okay. I have this song on my mp3 and I was just thinking about what I've been through, and I was thinking about how I died when I was first born.
cilla310 4 years ago 2
Oh. Well, not to sound nosy, but how could you die if you're alive now? Meh, me and my nosy self O_x
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
When I was a baby I had problems breathing and I kept dying everyday.
cilla310 4 years ago
I'm very sorry to hear that.
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
It's okay. But it reminds me of heartbreak and my death as a baby too. And it's okay I learned to deal with it.
cilla310 4 years ago 2
Yeah, I imagine it does. I'm glad that you've learned to deal with it, though.
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
Well, thanks to Amy Lee and Evanescence. I have finally decided to just deal with it, so that's how I get through it all by myself.
cilla310 4 years ago 2
Aww, I thank them too in that case. =]
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
Yeah, well it's true.
cilla310 4 years ago 3
Aww awesome
And yesh pweez :D
Also eehh? What? :S Dead? Lol
<33
ZombifiedBarbie 4 years ago 2
The website is evanescencereference dot info/music
And dead? Huh? :S Lol
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
Wow o_0
This is really different from the final version
<3
ZombifiedBarbie 4 years ago 2
Yes, 'tis. (:
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
Hehe XD
Which is your favourite?
And how did you find this version :S? Lol
<3
ZombifiedBarbie 4 years ago 3
My favourite is this one, and I found it on a website that allows you to download all of the Evanescence Demos for free, because Evanescence are no longer making money from it, so Amy has said something about encouraging us to download it. I could send it to you, if you wish.
xDeadxVampirex 4 years ago
This is my favorite version of the song. :D
EvanescenceRules12 4 years ago 3