I'm playing as Carlotta this year in our production of POTO, and I just got to say: It's tougher than it looks. (there is no easy when you are PRIMA DONNA)
i like rebecca most. she hit the notes better and didn't try to rush out of it. kim was ok how ever i didn't get a great view of her in this i suppose it's better live. the rest...eh
Kim Stengel is the best Carlotta ever, and incredibly nice and funny in person as well. I've seen the US Tour four times in the last two years, managed to not get an understudy any of them, and she's blown me away every time. Incredible.
Kim Stengel. NO comparison. I saw her in Baltimore during the US tour, and I was blown away by not only her voice, but the acting as well. She has an excellent interpretation of the character - perfection!
Wendy!!
ShellTard 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I absolutely LOVE Wendy Ferguson!! Go Wendy you diva you! =]
mulattob 2 months ago
Comment removed
mulattob 2 months ago
Some of these women couldnt hit the notes , and they tried to hide by going faster then the music was written .
##Tragic !
tHEXxMiStAbROWNxX 2 months ago
Evelyn and Rebecca are my favourites! ;)
spoonetti 2 months ago
Barbara Gray sounded more like a couple of cats I heard fighting in my garden last night.
mushypeas10 5 months ago 3
Rebecca wins.
BombalurinaOfRedwall 8 months ago
Rebecca XD
classicalgalNYC 10 months ago
I'm playing as Carlotta this year in our production of POTO, and I just got to say: It's tougher than it looks. (there is no easy when you are PRIMA DONNA)
nighttheif417 11 months ago
Eichenberger and Stengel were my FAVORITES!!! They will be my inspirations.
AstridElphieLovegood 1 year ago
For me Wendy is th best, but I understand that you have your own thoughts.
two1065 1 year ago
i like rebecca most. she hit the notes better and didn't try to rush out of it. kim was ok how ever i didn't get a great view of her in this i suppose it's better live. the rest...eh
patmrhottiepantz 1 year ago
Kim Stengel is the best Carlotta ever, and incredibly nice and funny in person as well. I've seen the US Tour four times in the last two years, managed to not get an understudy any of them, and she's blown me away every time. Incredible.
iankunx 1 year ago
Kim Stengel. NO comparison. I saw her in Baltimore during the US tour, and I was blown away by not only her voice, but the acting as well. She has an excellent interpretation of the character - perfection!
itsbigvic21 1 year ago
Rebecca Eichenberger...without a doubt!
bwayliz1 1 year ago
Is the show with Wendy Ferguson up for trade? I'm really interested in it.
PhanPhanPhanPhanPhan 1 year ago
@PhanPhanPhanPhanPhan sure is.
vmkwinner 1 year ago
@vmkwinner When is it from? I'd like to trade it.
Monkeyballmania 8 months ago
kim is by far better...her acting compliments her voice nicely! :)
sallad741 1 year ago
Kim Stengel is so funny :) I like her acting in this role
namphong0612 1 year ago
Someday, I hope you include Mirta Arrua LIchi's cadenza (Argentina).
Anyway, this is a great video!
LakerGirl2489 2 years ago
She's blocked visually but Barbara Gray Nystrom's voice is definitely the best.
MissRosie89 2 years ago
why u haven't got it from Poland?
UpiorOpery 2 years ago
Because I have no clips of Poland Carlottas. Do you have any? o_o
vmkwinner 2 years ago
Of the ones in the video, Evelyn Werner was the only I genuinely loved. But I liked Laureen Vigil and Kim Stengel too.
Not very fond of Wendy Ferguson and Monika Safar, while I'm neutral to the other ones.
operafantomet 2 years ago