New Moon Book Recap: Chapter 11 "Cult"

[SarahMMartini]

I think she wants Jacob to be Edward

[emilicious23]

Bella is starting to love Jacob?

[Chaybay22]

shes still hurt from edward but taking it out on jacob

[oreo51397]

she gad the dream because first edward hurt her then jacob hurt her and she thought tht jacob was different

[BiggestTwilightFan23]

When I saw Twilight and read the saga, I was on Team Edward..... But after I saw New Moon, I decided to be on Team Jacob. But now I like both, so I guess I'm on Team Switzerland. :)

[OoTaNgeRinEzoO]

I think it means that jacob and edward both love her and she's starting to feel the same way but jacob turned because he's leaving her too.

[TheShannyBobs]

The meaning of Bella's dream was probably because Jacob started acting like Edward. Edward always acted quite cold and had a deep voice. No sence of warmness unless he was with Bella. Bella is probably dreaming about this because Jacob is turning into a new version of Edward very very slowly

[GoldieGurl08]

I think it means she's starting to fell the way about jacob that she did for edward

[TVrockschick]

It's like the Edward incident all over again. He is "leaving" her and breaking her heart.

[PKVideozz]

he is doing the exact same thing as edward - breaking her heart

[Bestbebest12]

I think it is because Jake is really turning into Edward. he is doing the same things Edward did to her

[moxie4ever]

it means tht shes gone completely pysco

[crazyliapia]

It's simple and no one has got it yet! All the things Edward did to her is similar to what Jacob is doing to her now. For example: Edward loves her and cares for her and will do anything for Bella, and so will Jacob. Like Edward, Jacob has now left her alone after she thought she could trust him and he would never leave her. Also Edward had a MASSIVE secret which he couldn't tell Bella same with Jacob, so its like Jacob is turning into Edward with all the lies.

[brilisyoung]

Idk the answer to the pop quiz lol

[Melcamwiggle]

It means she loves Jacob but she can never love him the way she has always loved Edward, even six months after he left her

[TinyTiff12]

Its easy. She still has feelings for Edward but at the same time she also has for Jacob. SHE NEEDS TO WAKE UP AND SMELL THE CUTE WEREWOLF FUR!!!!!!

[oOoIceytundraoOo]

It means that she's falling in love with Jacob, but she also loves Edward.

[86542v]

shes falling in LOVE with Jacob!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[twilightfreakt21]

personally i think that she has this dream because she fears

jacob will leave her just like edward

[xstrawberry86x]

i think that edward was coming back to see her

[deryan15]

she was using jacob to fill the hole edward left so hence she wasnt seeing jacob as jacob but rather jacob as edward's "replacement"

[nanny496]

she is torn bewteen the two and does not know what to do at this point in time.

[NaturePrincesses]

it means that she is torn between the 2 of them

[cuteemma1997]

i think that means that they both hurt her the same way

[cuteemma1997]

i like the idea of team seth he's really funny anyway love the shirtttttttttttttt i'm on team hottttt jacob.thts my favourite chapter besides the italy one and the one after it.:D that lady tells the chapter in agreat way :D

[jenarei]

omg love the shirt! (:

[fullmidnightmoon]

is means that Jacob is leaving her just like edward did

[JBNessie]

hey =P.i thot u were on team Edward

[Fantasylover7]

Jake heart her like Edward... i guess that's the reason for the dream....

[TheTwilightfan411]

she misses edward and so she had a dearm

[teamjacobforever101]

he hurt her like jacob just did and her hart just got ripped up again after jacob was mending it he ripped it up again

[sweetluv322]

yay the other lady is back!!

she recaps the story in a way that its more interesting than the other lady.

[TeamSeth12]

Yay! Blondies back!

[seeyavannah]

yay! I like this lady better!

[myImmortalluv4u]

Jacob hurt her just like Edward did... Poor Bella... T~T. I'm here for you...

[PauPau1396]

ok she's just hurt and if you read into the stroy it the same dream she had the night she found out edward was a vampire. but edward hurt her and now Jacob hurt her even more

[xxXsoniseXshadiaXxx]

shes confused who to choose, bcuz she wants them both in her life, but jacob's making her choose.

[miniview]

he hurt her as much as jacob i think...

[dancepants009]

I think it means that jacob hurt bella just like edward did.

[CuteGirl632]

Because Jake hurt her as much as Edward did.

[xtwilightgirlx1]

because jacob is hurting her like edward did soo jacob is turning into edward (btw LOVE THE SHIRT!! GO TEAM JACOB!)

[jump5freak90]

first off LOVE your shirt (i'm Team Jacob). And second, i think that probably like everyone else is saying that...Jacob hurt Bella the exact same way (I thought it was worse though) as Edward has.

[kodochaiscool1]

it means that they both left her and shes very sad

[coolanaluz13]

OMG! the dream has nothing to do with chooseing one or the the other! it that edward left her and now jacob too! she's sad cuz as soon as she gets someone she cares about they lev. i mean wouldn't u cry that not one but TWO people abanden u?!

i no i would.

(btw. GO TEAM JACOB!!!!)

[123lilliangarcia]

Probably that sooner or later she'll have to choose one/the other.

[twilightnight16]

Bella has a place in her heart for both Jacob and Edward but the dream is telling her that she is going to have to choose betweem the two. Jacob will be with her to heal but someday Edward will be back and he will want her to stay with him.

[roloqween]

bella can't forget edward, but jacob is replacing him

[marioxxx25]

she miss edward

[xMusicluverx17]

Her dream basically means that now that Edward is gone it's like Jacob is replacing him. But not completely because Bella sill can't forget Edward. (Btw: I love Dannas enthusiamsm)

[russel814]

she is falling for Jacob

[2blak1guy0]

???......................uh huh........so u wudnt consider someone a jerk if they hurt someone else because there trying to make themself happy?......i'm prety sure there are worse words to say for someone like that but i dont use them and no I wouldnt do that unlike bella i put my friends before myself......poor jacob....i'm prety sure the only reason ur a bella fan is because your in general a team edward person but watevs that nt here nor there.bella f'd up thats all there is to it. X)

[LadyParis123]

please add 12

[mcdonoughrams]

shes starting to like jacob like she likes edward

[nadzsunshine]

they both left her

[2blak1guy0]

hey its my opinion and i'm intitled to it,My oppinion is that shes a jerk for wat she does proceeding the dream.....I wont say what bcuz i might ruin the books for the feux fans who havnt read yet and are reading now because of the movie

[miickiie97]

she has that dream because edwards the love of her life but shes thinkin mayb jacob could so he turns in to edward because edward was the love of her life but now jacob might b !!!

[newecplisebreaktwi]

she is confused about who she misses the most.

ps: your tee is soooo cute:!!!

[iwish2004]

i think it shows that the way edward broke up with her, it's the same way that jacob did. they both hurt her. i think its just a resemblince.

[simoneaw]

I think it was the similar feeling of being abandoned by the two people who made promises they didn't keep. And she used to think of Jacob as someone who helped distract her from the pain of losing Edward, but now Jacob's gone and the void in her from losing Edward surfaces again.

[kaylap1410]

I wouldn't mind opening it for taylor either

[soccercrazy999]

it means that jacob did exactly what edward did, left her. and now she's lonely again

[TerrificTwiTina]

@soccercrazy999 whoa man, that's deep.

[soccercrazy999]

um thanks..? lol...idk if it's a compliment or not but w.e.

[TerrificTwiTina]

It's a compliment, haha.

[Twilightfan437]

she feels the same way about jacob that she does about edward. she loves edward and she loves jacob the same way. she could not live without them

[Tiffpare]

it means basically that since jacob well kinda broke up with her thats what edward also did saying this will be the last time you ever see me then jacob says i can't see you anymore Bella

[myspace029]

that she feels the same about jacob as she felt for edward

[CammonTwiGirl]

It is there to show her that there is something mysertrious about both of them 1) Vampire - Edward (known)

2) Wolf- Jacob (unknown)

Mythical creatures.

[Virgostar285]

Maybe it is because there is a connection with the two and how they both arent completely human.

[DVDANCER123]

Bella is comparing the way Edward left her to the way Jacob just left her. Both we ubrupt and painful for Bella. She dreamt about it and she felt that both had left her in a similar way putting another whole in her heart.

[amynoel123]

the pain of the cuts they both left on her heart. they both cut her heart deep

[twilightvampires11]

first, i love your shirt!

i think she feels the same way as when edward was leaving her

[purple1329]

she is think of the way edward left her and it reminds her of the way she felt and she is comparing it to when jacob told her to do and its the same way edward did to her.

[confusedgrl2006]

Just to let you know. I don't think your gonna finish before the movie comes out

[coolk624]

she's feeling almost like she felt when edward left her

[OeCdGuRl]

She"s comparing the way that they both left her..

[durmiendonminubeazul]

i think she wasn´t expecting for jacob to hurt her but when he did she unconsciously compared them and the damage they had done to her and she realized that jacob left her alone "without" thinkin´ about her, just like edward did

//wich is funny cuz they whare both thinkin that it would be "better" 4 her... boyz!...x3//

[kelly1005911]

She misses Jacob but misses Edward too.Jacob hurt her and left her and she loved him just like Edward.

[deque92]

both love her both hurt her and protect her and she love both hurt both and help/save/protect both

[deque92]

jay you are back dana

[junglebookgirl101]

that jake leaves like edward did...or thats what she thinks!!

[TheMadgin]

that means that jacob leaves her same as edward did!!!

Love U clevver tv!'

Xoxoxox......gin

[dancechick1008]

In ways they are a lot a like. They have both hurt her. They both protect her. They both usually disagree with her, but Edward more.

[KristenRoberthugefan]

jacob pretty much did what edward did to her, so he became like edward.

[Saylin1226]

i think that bella had that dream because she was so depressed when edward left and now jacob is leaving her in his own way to so that's what shes thinking.

[jonasbroluver1996]

im soo sad for bella i would be heartbroken as well

[sporty685]

I think it because it's the edward break-up all over again. In friend way for Jacob. It's weird isn't it.

[puccaXrocks]

Its cuz Jacob hurt her just like Edward did & just like Edward it was for a reason

[DancingAddiction]

Jacob almost 'broke up' with her like Edward in the forest.

Jacob doesn't reply, refuses to try and talk it out.

Similar to Edward.

Just leaves, and doesn't come back.

**This is when i started to not like Jacob, i thought he hurt her more.**

[kkannie99]

DUHH!!! SHE LOVES JACOP...

[elenathomas030]

I think its because

1. in this chapter he "breaks up with her" like edward did in the forest and jacob is hurting bella too.

2. Not in this chapter, but later on, jacob starts to become like what edward used to be, which was who bella loved.

[juliagirl4]

1:25 that pic of taylor is too cute!!! : DDDDD

[emiily97]

I think because Bella thaught Edward was going to stay with her forever, but he leaves her, now she is seeing the same thing happening again but with Jacob, just not the staying with her forever part.

[ParamoreFan208]

It's because Jacob and Edward had both hurt her in a way and had both left her for a while.

[vonnyyay]

jacob is hurting her as edward had hurt her. pushing her away....sucks....

[baabyfac3]

edward being a vampire, jacob as a werewolf, ties in with the whole 'legend thing' in twilight, and theyre both dangerous in their own way :)

[2blak1guy0]

it means that bella is a flip floping jerk....

[yofriend291]

i think that it means that shes starting to love him adn as shes noticing things abt him her thoughts go to edward b.c hes her true love and and as jacob becomes more friends with her she starts falling for himm to , but in a diffrent way,

[iluvtaylorlautner987]

i think it means that she is beginning to have feelings for him. not like her and edward, but that shes starting to love him in a defferent way,(:

i wish i was herrr!!!!!!!!!!

[jonasbrother25]

maybe it means that Jacob is becoming like Edward in a way meaning so much to her that she cant stand to be with out him

[XxTwiPiresxX]

i dont no. it could mean: at least it wouldn't hurt as much as that because jacob didn't love bella like edward did and bella didn't love jacob the way she loved edward? or maybe that jacob acted like he loved her but he didn't at all like she thought edward didn't? idk

[mileyfannah9770]

it means that jacob is hurting bella like dward did

[IrishChickGoneBad]

It means Jacob hurt Bella as much as Edward did. Just left her like he did.

TEAM EDWARD

[alltimesickestkids]

Bella didnt go into a deep deep depression because Jacob left And Jacob came back to her before anything got serious with Bellas condition.

[wHoPaHz]

AND WHAT IS HER CONDITION?

[alltimesickestkids]

poorly developed

haha!! xD

ba-dum-tsss

[wHoPaHz]

HUH? WTF IS BA-DUM-TSSS

[xladyjajax]

bella's dream means that jacob has as much impact on her as edward had,, they ave both hurt her at this point and bellas dream made her realise that she needs jacob as she feels almost as much pain as she did after edward leaves her,,also althoug bella is still unaware of it, she does begin to fall in love with him and this is her subconsiousness telling her this,,

[bballamanda2436]

Because Jacob became the main person in her life like edward was then Jacob leaves just like Edward left her :(

Edward come back!

[ilovcandy091]

hey guys, if u want my honest opinion, no more twilight book recaps in the future. i miss the celeb match ups. just my opinion.

[dragonflyi3]

jacob is replacing edward in her life and that he is helping her with the pain edward caused

[HeartChibi]

I think Jacob turns into Edward because He promised he would never do wht Edward did but... he went and done it.

[totalstupidness9]

lmao

[freepaperbags]

Jakes hurting Bella.. but he promised he wouldnt!

[snookie75]

UGH!! Jacob said he wouldnt leave bella, that he wouldnt hurt her like edward had, but he lied and bella is hurt again!

[kkkaylaxox]

jacob is hurting her like edward hurt bella :( poor bella :(

[kooka123456]

because jacob is leaving her just like edward did

[lifnfstfwd]

Bella dreams of Jacob turning in to Edward for a few reasons 1) Bella's subconcious realizes that Jacob has a secrete just like Edward, 2) Bella realizes that Jacob leaving her hurts almost as bad as Edward Leaving did and 3) Bella is falling for Jacob and in someways he is replacing edwars in her heart and mind

[gottalovethem1]

i think she had the dream.....because she is realizing jacob and edward have more than one thing in common...especially keeping secrets

[karen5puppy]

I think she had the dream, bcuz Jacob left her, like Edward did. & it hurts her so bad to know that 2 people is leaving her.

[CullenLovato81396]

she probably had the dream cause jake left her but jake almost did more damge than edward cuase he was just yelling at her and wouldnit tell her anything

[ThattttGirlll1994]

Jacob is gorgeous, I'm team wolf but I hate Sam and Jared

[XxSweetLady]

jacob is hurting her like edward did when she left

[XxSweetLady]

I mean HE left xD

[brittanylesnick]

because htey both hurt her.

[kezandjase]

i think that the dream means that jacob is turning in to edward because of the pain that has been caused but on the other hand it could also mean that she has the same feeling for both of them and does not know how to keep her feeling apart even tho both of them have hurt them

[nikki3374]

naq im with Kez on this one i think she got it spot on so i do ......

[nikki3374]

lol na* i mean lmao

[verYCreepyDoll]

it means that she has been hurt not only from edward but also from jacob...both have let her fall like a hot potatoe

[maine030596]

it means that jacob is turning into edward coz he hurt her as much as edward did.

[lovingrussian]

It remind her that Edward left and hurt her like Jacob just did and maybe something to do with her trying to figure out that he's a monster too..? That's what the dream trying to tell her.

[XjemiXStoryX]

Because Jacub is hurting her like Edward did she thinks that Jacob is turning into Edward because Jacob doesn't want anything to do with her antmore like Edward.

She sees Jacob and Edward as the same thing now.

[roses00000]

she still misses edward...and jacob is getting different....i guess....

[kreeti21lol]

Jacob did what Edward did to Bella and she might be falling for Jacob like she did for Edward

[mffn1989]

because jacob really hurt her like edward did.

[TwiShaSha]

both edward and jacob left her and she cant live without the both of them

[VampGirljMtv]

jake did what edward did to her - he left her and the way they both look and act are alike - cold - and i like that this draam would be so cool if it was in the moive

[cutesymeg]

it means that she was hurt by Edward when he left her and that now she feels that Jacob is doing the same. Edward had promised her that he would be with her as long as it was what was best for her and left her behind when she still needed him.

now Jacob, who had told her that he would always he there for her, is now distant and she feels that he is leaving her.

she is connecting the 2 by the pain that they have caused her, weither it was intentionally or not.

<3

[tigerwoman444]

Jake would leave her soon to protect her from himself

[LH1711892]

i think it could go two ways. Either she wishs that jacob was edward or she is thinking that Jacob hurt her like Edward did.

[MusicandTwilight94]

it means that jacob is becoming the thing she cannot live without

[cutesymeg]

i never thought of it that way i just always thought it was because Edward had hurt her and now that Jacob was causing her pain, she was connecting the 2 of them.

i never thought of it being the fact that she cant live without them.

good thinking lol

<3

[CurvesRsexy08]

jacob hurt her just like edward did, even when he promises he would be their for her when he hasnt been

[haveFaithxabbie]

i think this dream means that as she was falling for jake like she fell for edward, he suddenly is becoming like edward who leaves her unexpectedly and breaks her heart leaving her depressed.

[ballerinarachet11]

She's having dejavu. Edward left her and now jacob is doing the same without a reason (for now) And thats the meaning of the dream.

[dcbabe13]

she is thinkin of how edward left her and now the one person that she thought would save her from the depression that edward put her in is actually making her goin into a new depression that he caused from become wat she doesnt know but fears that he would become

[alannajeanC]

it means that she's falling in love with Jacob and he's taking Edward's place in her life.

[Solchicks]

I think her dream symbolizes that Jacob is becoming like Edward and leaving her with a gaping hole in her chest. All it did was make her more depressed, feeling unwanted by the two best guys in her life.

[xXxSkullLoverxXx]

if means jacob hurt her just like edward did

[mcutie123456789]

you need to keep up there is only 15 more days until new moon and you need a lot more chapters. hurry up time is a wasting.♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

[boang]

it means she got hurt and she is going to think hat she is slowly losing jacob like she lost edward..but later on she also realizes that they both have secrets that she will become a part of..

[samisakevinjonasfan]

b+e=LOVE

[kimmycub758]

jacob was just the same as edward [dajavu] and that terrify her cause she wasnt healin at all

[bellasmama03]

Bella is liking Jacob but loved Edward, and thats why in her dream there the confusion of the 2.

[TwilightxxxxFanpire]

bella likes ejacob but she knos that she loves only edward she sees him everwhere

wow new moon comes out like in 3 weeks and you still need like 15 chapters

[jaybabe1471]

I think its because he hurt her like edward did and then said he couldnt be with her anymore

[jaybabe1471]

JACOB HAS THE HOTTEST BODY IN THE PACKK

[LostImmortal42]

The meaning is he hurt her like edward so he turned into edward also there both imaginary creatures so thats all i got ... lol

[chrissy6790]

jacob is soo like edward just for leaving her but, in his own way still that doesn't help her heal at all.......... ='[

[moviemaker456987]

lmao i got so sas when the months pass in the books and my friend just blurts out is because she didnt know what to write LMAO~!

[kridancer513]

think it means that she likes jacob and edward but she cant decide.

[2727BreakingDawn]

bella loves him

[BellaLatina1717]

i think it means that bella internally is either scared that jacob will leave her again or its the first sign of bellas feelings for jacob.

[RandomDancingActress]

I think its probably both

[CrimsonTearsFilmms]

that's the dinosapien guy!!!!

[judylovesbaby]

yep KKDwebshowz is right

[KKDwebshowz]

I think its kinda like a Deja vu kind of thing. They were such similar break up scenes that it maybe subconsciously reminded Bella of that dark day in the forest with Edward. Its also that she had been rejected more by the ones she cares about and it also probably subconsciously reminded her of the memories so that's probably where the dream came from

[Maija4music]

Yeah this was a very sad chapter :( I felt soo bad for Jacob.

[yYTwilightGirlYy]

my friend cried at the part where Jacob and Bella started fighting. lol i feel asleep at that part, hee hee!

Team Edward!

[Teamsquirtle]

lmao

[college87]

i think the dream might mean that bella sees jacob as edward meaning she is so close to jacob and missees him so much that it's the feeling of missing edward

[angelim007]

<3 ur shirt XD

[zmartinez95]

I think the dream means that Jacob is becoming just like Edward in leaving her