One direction - The X Factor 2010 - Live Show 8 (full) You are so beautiful

[sharnet008]

Louis and Niall don't have strong enough voices to have a solo in this song, particularly but they have amazing voices, in 'One Thing' they both have solos, and on their album they have a solo in almost all the songs.

[urmystar11]

1:46 - 1:50 DANG THOSE EYES!!!

[sussimammi]

SERIOUSLY? louis and niall didn't sing anything? that's just asdfghjhgfd, unbelieveable -.- -.-

[NeLLeKe95]

unbelievable, Niall and Louis don't sing something. How stupid is that? It's always Liam than Harry and then Zayn.

[munyofu10]

THANK YOU^^^^^ i completely agree. i love all of the boys to death but Louis and Niall just don't have strong enough voices to carry a proper solo. not maybe if they got more opportunities to sing they might improve but this song didn't have room for them to join in anyway.

[MsDirectioner1]

so.. niall and louis are just standing there.. and do nothing?

[jerseygirls3]

Everyone shut the fuck up about who's solo is who and who doesn't get one. Everyone loves them and Niall and Louis have beautiful voices, we all can say that, but not everyone in every single boy band gets a solo. They get solos in their new album. So...just stop

[lindalovesthesummer]

i really love one direction. i really do.

but it's not fair that liam harry and zayn got solo's in every song and Louis and Niall don't! just saying..

[karateclaire]

they all have amazing voices, and i think they're equally amazing. Louis and Niall don't have many solo's, but see them live, and they have about the same as the others, and in 'One Thing' they both have a solo, as they deserve, because they're all so talented!

love you 1D xoxo

[SkylerDonn]

Louis and Niall need more solos =/ Amazing song, though :D They were awesome!!!!! I <3 u, 1D <33333333333

[ymz25]

'It proofs that everyone in this band can sing'

excuse but if I'm not mistaken only 3 people sang not everyone. I love this boys, I really do, but Niall and Louis need to actually have a chance at singing.

[ymz25]

I want Niall and Louis to have more solos and I also want them to sing this you me :)

[iLiveForArianaGrande]

When Harry sang at 2:20 I smiled at the computer like an idiot

[MegaSmileywiley]

ZAYNZAYNZAYNZAYN IS SEXY. HIS VOICE IS AMAZING. LOVE YOU ZAYN

[singingforev]

wtf! what happened to showing that "the boys really can sing" all simon did was show that harry, liam, and zayn can sing. what about Niall and Louis?

[ElaineVuNgocMai]

harry's voice PHENOMENAL!

[Jjanelleparrishh]

As much as I love One Direction, I will never hear this song and NOT think of The Little Rascals

[MrKatie99]

ZAYN AT THE END. HOLY SHIT HES TOO FUCKING CUTE.

[ThePepperka]

While performing this song Louis and Niall were just standing there. WTF?

[aniszyn18]

oh Zayn . ♥ I'm proud of him too . ♥

[jennifercwebster]

poor niall and louis did NOTHING in this!!!



[HeyItsSyfqh]

0 dislikes!! Love them xx

[MrRocks333]

louis with the clothes of the second 30 does not seem gay

[ellie101xx]

Why does louis and niall never sing ?!

[xcmecz]

Liam is the best of all. ;)

[arletteylett]

@xcmecz agreed !!!

[Lovexvampirexdiaries]

My heart just melted <3 :O

[KnopaKnopovna]

harry's voice is PERFECT

[ElaineVuNgocMai]

HARRY HAS THE SEXIEST VOICE ON EARTH!! SHITT!!

[sweatfreaky]

this is their BEST PERFORMANCE, i full-screened it so it seems like they are serenading me.

YES, YOU ARE SOOOOOOOOO BEAUTIFUL to me....

[vknguyen93]

I hate that Louis and Niall don't sing at all in this song. .____. "It proves that everybody in this group can sing." What !?

[TheMstweet]

everybody can sing? I KNOW EVERYONE IN THERE CAN SING! but wht dont they allow Niall and Louis to ever sing!!?

i swear, this band isnt gonna last unless they share equal participation and say in the band. I love the band, i really do, but mind you, the routine is highly annoying.

Liam opens up

Harry sings next

the whole group sings

Zayn does echo

harry sings again and ends it

[ILoveYouuBabeeey123]

@TheMstweet louis and niall have a lot more solos in their up coming album :D they even sed :P

[cheryblossom105]

@TheMstweet well on the x factor yes they do that but on their origanal song they have equal parts

[Marleenetballer]

forever pressing 5 to hear an angels voice <3 harry!

[JordannLouise123]

forever fangirling at 2.18 - 2.25 :3 Harry is so gorgeous :3 Louis<3

[vildefrahemsedal]

harry, stop being so fucking georges

[msmakemeholo]

so, again no solo for louis. -.-

[gilesiloveyou]

When Harry sings need at 2.20 .. WOW :O

[TwilightnGA]

WOW! Zayn's vocal in this was note perfrect!! They all were! Even though I think Niall and Louis should have sung aswell. But for those people who said they're useless, they did the backing harmonies and they were perfect, without the harmonies the song wouldn't have sounded as awesome!

[rupelove39]

Harry's voice <3 oh gawdd hes soo hott

[LaleyiJean]

Zayn should sing he has a great voice

uugh i hate Dannii(Kylie) Minogue shes such a bit'' and always says what simon says shes so arrogant and thinks shes the best

[annielaraxox]

they did this on my birthday last year, and i love them and this song so so so much!<3

[niallhalltheway]

niall shud have sung !!! :(

[OrganizedChaaos]

Zayn is just so damn fine!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

[hackertdog1]

Do you think that girl loves Harry? She did yell it like 14million times! Love this performance! They are so beautiful to me! :)x

[JessTerrii]

si what was te point in louis and niall being in that!

[BibbyLisa1]

I LOVE NIALL

[XCeerysChiickX]

why didnt niall and louis sing?:| <3

[xmissrose]

how come louis never sings?!

[toluoneofakind]

@xmissrose he never sings but he can sing he sings on his youtube account

[danika5067]

Zayne <3

[LeahS1996]

harry is beautiful.. em did louis seriously say at the start "i think this is the perfect rock song" then at the end say "i dont really think this is a rock song"

[DeliJumbie]

I FREAKIN LOVE YOU ZAYN <3 YOU'RE BEAUTIFUL BABBBAAAYYY!

[dizzeh101]

zayn zayn zayn zayn zayn <3 xxxx

[MMAOUTLOUD]

louieee is a joke

[jonasfanphilippa]

louis needs to leave the x factor hes messing it up

[pinksparkles456]

LOUIS. iloveyou?.<3

[Peylinlovesmusic]

''I JUST LOVE HARRYYYY!!''

[itsNiCAx3]

WE WANNA HEAR LOUIS SING!!

[icecoldsazerac08]

i've never really heard louis sing :P

[mizzi42]

@icecoldsazerac08 he has a youtube channel where its just him singing. type in louistomlinson 07 i think it is - he has an amazing voice :) xxxx

[Catanator]

come on, let's face it, I love them all but Louis and Niall don't have strong enough voices to have a proper solo in this song and there isn't really a proper chorus for them to chime in

on another note Louis (the judge) is an idiot in the VT he says "it's a brilliant rock song, I hope they get it right" and then after he says it's not a rock song... I think he just wants to pick a fight with Simon, he's like the little brother trying to get the attention of his older brother

[Juliz]

@Catanator - I completely agree with you. Louis and Niall aren't the strongest singers (plus Niall actually messes quite a bit). Personally they could probably do a 3 person kind of band, but that would probably upset some people. lol

Oh and Louis was so Jealous of Simon winning an Emmy, it was like STFU about it. Plus Louis made it sound like he's with his acts all the time. But they all have vocal coaches, its not like the mentors even hear them until the Friday before the show.

[jassia18]

Naill and Louis were doing the ooooh and aaah we just don't see a close up shot of it:)

[lauren4jls]

Zain Harry and Niall they are gorgeouss<3

[therese457]

i love u xx

[therese457]

lads if u lovee one directiom vote now theres still in the bottom 3....now seriously wud u want wagner rather than 1 direction................u wud have to be mad!! vote xx who agreees

[bieberluva12]

HARRY STYLES YOU ARE SO BEAUTIFUL!!! <3

[VickiAliceXxx]

Harry Styles your so beautiful, funny and sweet 100% babe!! xxxxxxx

[Onedirectionfan1]

Louis And Niall amazing singin oh wait did yu even sing

[Onedirectionfan1]

Louis And Niall amazing singin oh wait did yu even sing ?

[kikichoo123]

so goood! poor niall and louis thoughh? didnt sing at all ...

[roooo42]

amazing! loved it boys!!!

[eilishbbz1]

I love One Direction, but I was so pissed off when Niall and Louis didnt get to sing. I still havnt heard Louis sing a solo piece which I think is very unfair on him!

[Pumpkintheginger]

btw... Louis Walsh says at the beginning "It's a brilliant rock song..." . Controversial... I bet he only said it wasn't a rock song at the end to take the piss out of Simon. HAHA', love him. He's such a sunshine!

[The2HappyHippies]

@Pumpkintheginger And Joe Cocker IS VERY MUCH A ROCK SINGER!!! I love JOE COCKER! He is my ABSOLUTE FAV! AND One Direction did a great Job Singing one of his songs :)

[Pumpkintheginger]

@The2HappyHippies exactly. Louis basically contradicts everything he says on live shows. Even tho he knew it is a rock song -and made it clear on VT- he completely contradicts himself live just to get to Simon!! what's his problem?! haha', wouldn't even leave alone the fact that Simon went to america that week! annoying funny creature... One Direction did a fantastic job, I was just too excited about summer of 69, so hearing a slower song later didn't really go with my emotions

[Pumpkintheginger]

well... not ALL of them sang. at least Niall got to sing "turn around" in that halloween week. poor louis, still haven't heard from him. I enjoyed summer of 69 better. this should be their first performance... great job, tho

[BubbleGum6537]

Louis and Niall were stood there like lemons. 

[olearyciara]

Harry's eyes are gorgeous <3

[Dreamzzgirl]

Damn whyy did zayn plug his eyebrows:S the things which made him special were his eyes lashes eyes etc ..and the fact that he didnt pluged his eyebrows.. well he surely did plug his eyebrows now :S anyways hes still nice

[recyc07]

This is good but they need to improve in order to beat Matt & Rebecca. They should also sing more ballads. Harry's voice could be better esp. in the falsetto part.

[xgabybabesx]

zayn♥♥♥

but i swear louis and nial just stood there..

[ManCityFan1988]

stil want to hear Louis sing - but it was a great song choice !

[ilovetodreamatno3]

aww, thats s sweet

[LifeOfaRocknRolla]

ZAYN YOU ARE TOO FUCKING BEAUTIFUL :')

simon's comment actually made me cry! i was so happy for you!

GAH I LOVE YOU! and its so true, your voice is the best <3

oh and you and liam are the BEST FRIENDS EVER :) xxxx

[BrucasLoveX]

harry you are too beautiful <3

this is one of my fave performances by them <3

[ElBesoDeMuerte]

It's some kind of joke?!

Why in the band which has 5 people sing only 3 ?!?!

However... I still love you! <3

[jumping4joy1]

@ElBesoDeMuerte they need harmonies, and 4 sing, louis doesnt get many solos thats all

[rocky4595123]

@ElBesoDeMuerte i noe right!!! -.-

[EdwardvsJacobFan]

@ElBesoDeMuerte It's not that only 3 of them sing. It's that only THREE of them got SOLOS. The other two, Louis and Niall were singing the background.

[ElBesoDeMuerte]

@EdwardvsJacobFan Yeah.. that's true, but come one - I want to hear Louis solo!

[atmenner76]

@ElBesoDeMuerte those 3 are their best singers and they have to keep going with them for solos because they have to bring the best to win. I'm sure after the competition they will definitely let the other 2 sing a lot more

[ElBesoDeMuerte]

@atmenner76

I hope ^^