Added: 3 years ago
From: sgstyle
Views: 285,394
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (322)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • awww i love dis song lol

  • GUYS UNDERSTAND THIS!

    Women and men are equal

    and besides men cheat on women and women cheat on men

    not one sex is better then the other

    and I think they both sing great but the message is really clear like Twilight and paul said it's a message saying "if you want true love stay loyal and stop messing around because girls are fragile at times yes,but guys can also be fragile and we should see it that way we are equal not greater then the other. enough said and check please on that thought.

  • its 2012 and i jus found this,,,,GREAT JOB

  • Kell's version is the best..

  • The problem is that boys aren't girls, and girls aren't boys. Moreover though, with the feminism of the current and subsequent generations of guys it's more likely that the girl is the one that acts in these inappropriate ways. Beyonce is bi-polar with the message she sends with her music as well, going from the likes of 'If I were a boy' and 'Irreplaceable' to the likes of 'Love on Top'. It's all sexist bullshit that has to stop.

  • what the bloody..r.kelly ftw. nice-ish but painful on the ears.

  • I really like this version. Just love it <3

  • I THINK THEY SOUND GREAT TOGETHER ON THIS SONG!!!!

  • I like this one better than the the first version!!!! Love It!!!! <3

  • I believe there are just as many sleazy women out there, that there are men. People need to realize, it's just a song.

  • @elisewhite9990 there is.

    i agree. but this song has some truth

    despite how good people can be

    there are always misunderstandings and complications.

  • j'adore le ft avec lee carr ,tres belle voice ,lol

  • THIS IS BOOMMMBBBB :)) KUDOS

  • WHY ISNT BEE AND HIM DOING A DUET! D;>

  • ''id listen to him.. cause i don't know everything'' hahaha

  • love ur voice Lee

  • this song was really good i like the fact you took it from both prospectives of female & male sides of relashions.This is partly true on a lot of things keep rocking your music your really great. :)

  • This version is so homophobic.

  • Dude Lee Carr hit this on the button!!!

  • GAY!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @eastlondz stfu kid ! Your gay for thinking that way -.-

  • @youbekillenthem yeah yeah lol

  • @eastlondz just like u(:

  • @atxjonathan just like me?? u don't even know me you dougnut/smart ass!! a bunch of lost youts getting emotional over my comment looool get a life mate!

  • @eastlondz why are you getting so defensive if your not? i'll get a life just as soon as you do, your the one with nothing better to do with there life so they make fun of people who actually did something with theres

  • @atxjonathan defensive?? if you read back through the comments you find that you are the one who got personal lool I made a comment which i am with in my rights to make! the lyrics in MY opinion are gay! u got emotional/defensive/offended and got personal by saying I am gay which i'm not as I am a woman! if you said lesbian that would make more sense but then i'd still call you a smart ass/doughnut cause I'm far from THAT! its nastiness regardless of how societies forcing it down our throats!

  • @eastlondz yeah i gave me opinion just like you did so your just being a hypocrite, so bye

  • @atxjonathan lool !!!!

  • @eastlondz are u f**king kidding me?? everything you write screams out that you're a guy!! A scared little one, who would'nt dare to say something like that to someones face IRL! Come out of the closet, you idiot!

  • @Nicific WOW!!! *surprised face* didn't realise until today how far from God our world has gone!!!! The things we should be getting defensive about we ignore??!! The subject has obviously rattled your cage, I wonder why?? *confused face* ......Look! I don't know who & what you represent, to be honest you are none of my business! I'm sorry if its a sensitive subject for you but it is what it is!!! I don't like the subliminal message behind the song! that's my opinion & i'm entitled to express it.

  • R.Kelly's version was better, Also R.Kelly's voice is better

    Lee is hot tho [:

  • Where can I get the lyrics to this?

  • This was the best remix to this song he sang his ass off and he had something to say that provoked her lyrics in the beginning. I love R. Kelly but he can sit down with his remix Lee do yo thing

  • Lee Carr speaks the truth hahaha i alwaes plae this to my girl and sing it .. "If i were aaaaa girl i dont think id understand how it feels to love a boy i swear i be a better woman"

  • perfect!!!

  • I like Lee Carr version better.

  • i think kells is better its more from the male pt of view

  • this is sooo true.

  • ye his version better than R. Kellys .

  • i like lee's version better

  • lee carr so cool

  • Love this version!!

  • damn. i think i kinda understand guys a little more.lol

  • LMFAOO..ooohh..he kinda got her there..he was a bit of an asshole tho lool.

  • This is sooo Amazing !

  • wow maybe if beyonce made a song like dat it would be good and ppl would like it!

  • @tumolo95 if i were a boy is a number 1 hit all over the world.. so people already like it.. boys, girls, males, females.. we all like the song!!

  • I'm a girl, and while I love Bee and her music, I like this version more because of its two-sided element.

    Personally, I think the original song was aimed at a particular jerk of a guy, but it can come across as unfairly categorising all guys as unfaithful callous people and all girls as innocent helpless victims, faithful to their men. If both sexes could see both sides (as this version suggests) there would be more 'better men/women' in the world.

  • @TwilightMemoirs Girl like u make the world a little bit better, u r so right and i wish more girls thought like u.

  • @TwilightMemoirs could not agree more - beyonces version practically breeds misogyny

  • @queenmcsleaze you meant misandry

  • @methushael yes and no - i mean that beyonces version will turn boys against women, even mildly - misogyny

  • perfekt

  • im lovin it :)

  • 19 idiots missing the luke button

  • Both of these POV's are stereotypes in the beginning.

  • i dont care what all of you say, this is a badass song!

  • their be good ass women out their who dont cheat try to make everything good , cook him his 3 meals keep the house clean take care of his kids but he be dumb and treat her wrong. guys know how they treat their girls but still treat the same way every day than they be mad at themselves when she leaves ha that shit is messed up. has happened to many times

  • this a great version. u havent done what others have thought, just remove the woman parts. its both. i dont think Beyonce meant the song as generalization, just a story to the song. but i prefer this version. both sides. both cheating on each other xDD jkz no very well done Lee :D

  • men and women are complicated, and of course, use, "women" can be wrong too.

  • guys and girls cheat it dont matter what sex you are its because you dont care or you dont think about what your doing!

  • You can never try and change someone unless they want to be changed..You just have to try and work with them and mabe do things differently for a different reaction from them..If that still doesnt help then you make the choice if their really worth it !!

  • love dis version <3

  • Hey,we can't help it if we take a long time to get ready. If you think about it, theres so much to do! (hair, make-up, handbag-to-outfit coordination to name a few)

  • @cuteminti3 You need some perspective as to what's important in life.

  • this song is very hot!!!!!!!! it seems almost as if both of them are pleading there cases trying to get a better understanding of the flaws they have and how there spouse precieves them

  • @SuperFantasy18 that's how i took it too

  • 5/5* Cool. (fist pound) Ring that bell...

  • yo this is true talent, i love it! wow speechless, thank u 4 blessin me with ur talent

  • I love this remake :)

  • ,.,this is very beutiful song,..,,.,.,.

  • I'm Diverse , I save the World second I Get High First

    Yo Queen B got Nice Tits Damn

  • I loved this song this is the shyt

  • awsome

  • i liked it and good job

  • FUKIINN HAWTTTTT VOICCE!

  • lol HE MADE THE REMIX AND TALKIKN ABOTU THE GIRL

    way to go boy!

    since the girls always put down the guys lol

  • not bad...but the songs is only called IF I WERE..

  • lol

  • type it in your web browser LOL

  • i like it!

  • gay guys get it though :)

  • love it!!!

  • but your not a boy so cant understand! :-)

  • love it much!

  • DAAAAAYUMMMMMMMMM this version is dopeee man! Love it, and your hella fit yeah ;) aha x

  • i absolutely love thiss!!

  • 1:28 is where he starts singing. I thought it was just gonna be Beyonce lol. I love this!

  • @britneeirenebenson see where it says:ft. Lee Carr ? that means he is featured on the track.

  • this is such a good song. lol:)

  • Somebody send this to my ex lol

  • i love u dude, thats hot

  • me encanta¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

  • its me a second time. I jus finished lookin @all of da comments ppl lef nd i saw how sum of the grlz was talkin about how Lee Carr is prejudice...how exactly?...nd sum of u otha gurlz r tlkin about how u hate him from makin dis version bcuz sum gurlz r not like dat but sum of em r and if u say dis song is not refferin to u, y r u commentin about how ur not like dat...nd dont go and start commentin on vidz if u dont like it, he made it so ppl culd appreciate his work not disrespect it.

  • dang lee carr u cute, u could sing, and u make original songs sound better...WAT CAN U NOT BE lol...great song though ;D

  • This is better than the original, it puts it in a different perspective and stops the song from looking down on guys. =)

  • nice song

  • lol....da lyrics r so real jedz......awesome doe

  • beautiful song!

  • damn um feeling dis song

  • Comment removed

  • dude u hott!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • thang sexy boy

  • damn...wow.. best remake

  • its good but not not better then shawn stockman if u were a boy. but its second best its really good tho

  • Love when he says "and your just a girl"

    Amazing.

    x

  • smhernandez88:

    "they killed it" is just short for " its awesome" shane sparks and lil mama and others say they killed it alot

  • i like the part when lee says if i were a girl.

  • I love this song

    I f i were a girl :-) lee carr are amazing nad Beyonce too

  • love this song.. love you beyonce your my idol.. i love RNB mix or not.. love yah lee carr.. i admire your voice both..

  • Whoa. mix with r.kelly & lee carr? arr celee. ahaha. anyone else see it? But definitely prefer this version. Love it.

  • They harmonize great together.

  • Lee is a hottie

  • love is a commitment from both sides like this song explains

  • Beyonce is hottie

  • Here's the problem. Ready?

    the sexes aren't annoying

    We're just different

    It GETS annoying when they constantly tell you OVER and Over again about changing.

    Both men and women are different

    But heres where it turns into a tradgeity

    they try to UNDERSTAND each other. I'm not saying trying to understand is bad but you need to realize that men are men and will handle things differently and women are women and will also handle things differently/ Good song btw. i love this version. they killed it.

  • you exactly right.. it's so sad to see so many good relationships hit the rocks over shit like that..

  • i completly understand your oppinion of the situation... men are men and women are women and we will always think different and we will always say them different too... why at the end you say "they killed it"? if you have a great point to the song???

  • @TamziRose123 thats real

  • @TamziRose123 on the money, mean description. Thanks heaps, straight up.

  • @TamziRose123 i love you...

  • ppl talk bout how fake othaz are but do the people who talk do the relize that they are quick to judge everyone but there selfs

  • mane he sounded freakin good r.kelly messed it up n made it sound like shit but lee carr he was gettin it n he sounded betta den beyonce she shouldve let lee jus do it by himself he couldve made dis joint a hit unlike beyonce i hate her screamin voice

  • love this version

  • Damn, this is cutee (((:

  • yeah for some reason i didnt like r. kellys version that much... it seemed like he was tryin to cram to many words in, but lee did an awesome job

  • that boy is cute

  • I'm Sayin. lol

  • good job son, you did way better than R.Kelly. R Kelly messed the song up but you did good and didn't make it sound girly.

  • AWESOME. I love this version.

  • Tht was rly good!!!

  • love lee carr hes so sexc

  • Hell yeah!

    When I heard Beyonce's song (which isn't even her song) I thought it was fuckin' ridiculous. Lee Carr was right on the money.

    Women think they're always right, and that they never have to change, yeah right! - its typical snobby behavior and they're so easily convinced by their mates!

    Psh! - they just don't understand. That guys have feelings too.

    Girls are so annoying sometimes.

  • You are so right!

    You just wrote down all of my thoughts^^

  • We're both annoyingXD

  • AMEN!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @Jasexxxxx I think it goes both ways... I think there just isn't enough trust between the two, a lack of communication...

  • @Jasexxxxx but at the same time, you dont know what it feels like to be a girl.

  • @Jasexxxxx Lol You know what? Life is too short to be worrying soo much about girls and boys, Live life as much as you can as your young and when your older and ready to settle then commit. Just live a life of bliss!!! :DDDD

  • @Jasexxxxx You speak THEE truth.

  • @Jasexxxxx ur gay XD

  • Wow... there is so much ridiculous arguing in here. Lee Carr's lyrics are purposely stereotypical to point out the hypocrisy in Beyonce's version.

  • Real talk right here if i were a girl

  • This Song Is What Went Wrong In My Life Tbhh :).. Best Ever:)

  • Perfeitaa... e perfeito0ooo

  • tru say sunrise

  • i like it i got tired of if i was a boy so its nice to hear a response video!

  • i think beyonce is totally right with this song...but the problem is girls aren't perfect they make the same mistakes so both sides are right ^^

  • because it's bullshit what beyonce says.

    I know enough girls who are cheating on their boyfriends and treating them bad.

  • yeah your right but you have to admit that it's more common with men soz but true. love ya voice but the point of the song is that she made all the sacrifices whereas he made none plenty of songs where a man sings about the same thing in reverse at least in this song we're girls not whoes. x

  • her boobs are lopsided too

  • haha omg joker ☺

  • my nigga Lee Carr go hard..lol

  • lee carr and beyonce rock together. he's so handsome too!

  • this better than r. kelly whack self!!!!!

  • love itt

  • r.kelly is better

  • fuck r kelly hes a pedo...!!

    Lee Carr is much better

  • wow...aMaZiNG....O.O

  • keep goind gir i love it

  • i kind of like dis song but i like caira version better!!!...

  • good.

  • wow I have read stupid stuff before, but you just beat a record,. Please follow your own advice, one less you would be better for our world!

  • Racist twat

  • i dont quite understand why he is a nigger wannabe .. coz from where im standin he is black (im not being racist) i love lee Carr he is so talented & he has an amazing voice .. get a life!!

  • Any chances of seeing the male version lyrics ?

  • OMG I just loved it. I think it was the best one so far...

    DO you have any other songs ?