Avril Versus Hayley Live Voice Battle Part 2

[sillypup12]

BOTH

[girlabc4]

avril lavigne

[llButterCup]

Avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril Avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril Avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril Avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avrilAvril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril avril

[DmSceneKid1]

Maker, Hayley Williams puts meanings into her songs. Not like Avril I do Like Avril BUT HAYLEY IS MY IDOL FOREVER!.

[cryssye]

avril avril avril avril <3

[MiniMichaelaMischeif]

Seriously WTF is wrong w/ u y do u keep on putting good audio of avril but not hayley

[DmSceneKid1]

Hayley.

I LOVE RIOT. ALLWEKNOWISFALLING. ( Emergency )

OH MY DAYS.

HAYLEY ALL THE WAY.

[weirdox123]

I swear you put the songs that Avril sang on better than the one's that weren't Hayley's best but either way Hayley.

[1just6me]

como que Avril desafina a veces :O

[Izaebele]

if we're talking live, i think avril is pretty good, but i'm biased so i think hayley is FABULOUS. if we're talking pure talent, HAYLEY HAYLEYYYY ;A ; her lyrics aren't meaningless like some of the stuff avril sings.

[underclassdamnriot]

@Izaebele meaningless???? haha it's that supposed to be a joke, Go buy her GOODBYE LULLABY album, so AMAZING!!!! meaningful songs that Avril wrote.

[sierrakusterback]

@underclassdamnriot But did even happen to hear her previous album? It absolutely sucked. Maybe 2 good songs on the whole thing. And Goodbye lullaby wasn't that great. It's not even close to how good her first 2 albums were. Avril has changed for the worse. Hayley has only grown stronger, unlike Avril who changes all the time to fit her surroundings.

[underclassdamnriot]

@sierrakusterback wrong. Avril is already writing her 5th album right now, did you know that? she has 3 instrumental songs here. Go search the songs GONE, CANDY and COMPLETE ME. Whearas paramore became wearker since the farro brothers left the band. I already heard the song monster, a good song but nowhere near as good as their 3 album songs

[sierrakusterback]

@underclassdamnriot Paramore did not get 'weaker'. They have grown even stronger. Have you heard 'In the Mourning'? It was a little song Hayley and Jeremy wrote to help deal with the loss of their bandmates. It is one of the most beautiful songs I've heard from them. And maybe you think that 'Monster' isn't as good as their other stuff but that is probably because you don't understand the meaning of the song. Also, do you know what Paramore as a band has gone through?

[sierrakusterback]

@sierrakusterback At first it was The Farros, Jason Bynum, and Taylor York. then came Hayley and Jeremy. When the band was signed they lost Bynum and York. a year later they lost Jeremy and Jason came back. After a year Jeremy comes back and Hunter Lamb replaces Jason. two years pass and Hunter leaves. Then came Taylor. He is barely in the band for two years when The Farros sadly leave. Taylors brother Justin is likely to join the band. You show me a band as strong as Paramore!

[underclassdamnriot]

@sierrakusterback many bands since i'm 25 years old. BLINK 182, they have been around since 1993, although they have a hiatus from 2005-2009, they're having a new album NEIGHBORHOODS. Sum 41 who is around since 1997, Greenday since 1989, many bands. You should know that Avril just recently performed at SESSIONS @ AOL 5 days ago. Amazing

[sierrakusterback]

@underclassdamnriot i know all of this. and I'm only 17. But I don't think any of them could handle what paramore has gone through.

[underclassdamnriot]

@sierrakusterback search other bands, there are tons of them who can stay longer than paramore

[underclassdamnriot]

@sierrakusterback oh i forgot to mention RED HOT CHILI PEPPERS, they have been around since 1984, haha same with Metallica, acdc, iron maiden, bon jovi, etc...

[RoseDance16]

both are amazing. Avril's voice ia stronger. But Hayley doesnt cuss and she is a good role model.

[MrFelipesaavedra]

HAYLEY ......

[Vacammcc]

They bouth aren't brilliant singers,but actualy Avril has better voice and that's what this video's about. Hayley sings well,but I prefer her voice on record and I like Avril more live,I don't like her high scream on record.

[minnow26]

i love how she laughes during here we go again :)

[xcaitlynannex3]

you put in clips of Hayley singing with crowd interactment, WHICH IS HOW A ROCK BAND CROWD SHOULD BE! hayley williams is also muuuch prettier than avril. (= and her voice is just; FLAWLESS! i love Hayley Williams.

[pssitsGiu]

@xcaitlynannex3 I'm agree with you.. HAYLEY WILLIAMS FTW

[xcaitlynannex3]

@trappboiy uhm, WTF?! hayley and paramore actually CARE about their fans, and they dont change their style every 2 years. they arent POSERS, like avril. they put their heart and soul into their music and love their fans, because they are amazing.

[TheFabikaulitz]

The only Hayley is better than Avril's voice, because the numbers in the instruments and Avril is way better than her. That is, Avril has more merit, it >>>>> Hayley

[pinkflowerme]

HAYLEY FTW!!!!!!



[lizzielollipop816]

AVRIL LAVIGNE IS SO MUCH FUCKING BETTER

[musiknotes4u]

HAYLEY FTW!!!!!!!!

[francolestrange]

avril lavigne sings better than hayley ...

hayley sings well ... but sometimes you will hear his voice and very bad ...

eh seen that has a voice say hayley mezzoprano ... where they got that? niciquiera amy lee's voice reaches mezzoprano ...

avril sings and plays better!

[francolestrange]

avril lavigne canta mejor que hayley...

hayley canta bien... pero aveces se le va la voz y se oye muy mal...

eh visto que dicen que hayley tiene voz mezzoprano... de donde sacaron eso?  nicikiera amy lee alcanza la voz mezzoprano...

avril canta y toca mejor!!!

[XxTooHyperxX]

I'm a Paramore fan but I was an Avril fan WAY before I even knew who Paramore was. I only knew of them because of Twilight. Also, Avril is pretty much better. I love them both but Avril wins in my heart. :)

[sofreshh123]

Hayley :)

[nuramber]

its kind of like comparing twilight 2 harry potter (?)

[xXemozrusXx]

Does it really matter who is better. I mean,anybody can have talent like that, i do and i have a record deal in new jersey to record, but really it's what you do with that talent that makes you something, so in this case they've both achieved the same goals as one another, but if we're talking bout looks.........AVRIL!!!!!!

[amanduhedmo]

hayley all the way!

[ivanhec]

AND I REPEAT IT!

both of them are awesome ! really awesome but in my opinion those paaramore fans who offense avril just can't take tha fact that sometimes avril is better than hayley

[miseryriot777]

You were saying paramore's fans are annoying? Oww...that's 2 bad.But I think you're avril's annoying fan..You're obviously trying to defanding Avril..If you don't like Hayley than don't make this video.Just make Avril video k..this is really offensive video you know...camparing sucks cz they r nothing alike..You love avril , we love hayley..and tats all it matters k.please just STOP IT !

[underclassdamnriot]

@miseryriot777 i'm saying SOME paramore fans are annoying, i didn't say ALL ok? I like hayley, i've never ever said that i hated or dislike her, i just can't stand some paramore fans ok??? it's all about the matters of opinion DUH!!! can't you just get that???

[retardo4music333]

lol i know all we know is falling is just as good and that was hayleys voiceb4 brett

[retardo4music333]

@underclassdamnriot i know ur sooo right i hate how just cuz they think robert pattinson is hot they like paramore cuz they made a song that has something 2 do with them ...btw i commented on ur homepage its pretty nice :D

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 thanks for commenting anyway. Anyway i called them paraMORONS!!!! they don't care about first album ALL WE KNOW IS FALLING, they only know 2 albums RIOT and BRAND NEW EYES

[bonnie978645312]

@underclassdamnriot that's not true AT ALL all we know is falling has even turn gold that proves you pleinty of fans love all we know is falling. their most demanded song is MY HEART josh told this a few weeks ago okay let the paramore fans alone if you don't like paramore

[pssitsGiu]

@underclassdamnriot HAHHAHA, who said we don't care about All We Know Is Falling, I love that album so shut the fuck up, and I can clearly see that you don't have any music knowledge, cause Hayley williams have a very prepared voice, and it's because you wanted to protect Avril lavigne o this video you choosed the paramore's songs with the worst audio EVER... you need to shut up, and everyone here who doesn't like this girl the best thing you can do is get the hell out of here.

[xTheBackwardsRace]

@underclassdamnriot I.FUCKING.LOVE.ALLWEKNOWISFALL­ING.

DONT YOU EVAR SAY WE DONT CARE ABOUT IT.

[retardo4music333]

@underclassdamn riot i think we should stop all this texting cuz i donno if ppl r getting annoyed lol haha but i saw in 1 of ur comments here thst u like hayley THANK U <3 ;D

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 of course i like hayley!!! the only ones i don't like are some childish and immature paramore fans coz they are annoying, i say some not all. They only like paramore because of twilight, hayley, farro brothers are hot instead of their music, That's the reason i create videos like these. Hayley deserves to be compared to Avril's greatness period!!!

[retardo4music333]

@underclass damn riot she was really good there cuz she was better in her younger dayz wen she wasnt trying 2 act all rock i REALLY liked her b4 but i dont really lsn 2 her anymore hehe XD

[retardo4music333]

oh nad @underclassdamnriot i hate demi 2 she is such a POSER!!!

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 actually, demi is a good singer, watch her FOOTBALL NATIONAL ANTHEM video for proof, she's flawless there haha

[retardo4music333]

@underclassdamnriot im not sayin this just coz i like hayley but she does NOT lypsinch she changes the song in the tone of her voice live and loldo u really think hayley would get awards on her vocals live if she lypsincs cuz the back round vocals on record arent there live u can check eveything out urself and she took lessons with bret on their 2nd album (riot) and u can check out her "NATURAL" brett manning-free voice there i dont wanna make fun of avril cuz i kno ur a fan i kinda like her ;)

[retardo4music333]

@panicatthediscofever thank u ....every1 who thinks avril is better just read her comment first

[retardo4music333]

@underclassdamnriot if avril actually had verbrato maby she would go 2 brett manning but ya i guess her voice is more natural but NOT better than hyleys in my opinion okay??? i said i like avril beacause i think she is nice not cuz her music :]

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 ok fine at least you respect avril in some ways, same to me in hayley, she's a good singer in my opinion. Avril doesn't need to have a voice training to brett manning coz she has her own technique, in live performances it is meant to be that she sound different live than in recording and that proves that she's not lip synching, singers nowadays lip synch live which is sad and i'm glad that avril is totally against that,hayley and demi lovato are also against lip synching

[retardo4music333]

@underclassdamnriot i know i wrote alot but just 1 more thing.....hayley only went 2 brett manning cuz she couldnt control her verbrato NOT her voice she said so herself ...and at least she had verbrato 2 begin with right ......sry again lol ^_^ i still like avril

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 you said that avril sucks but you actually like her, congrats, you jsut contradict herself,okay let me get to the point, avril is a NATURAL SINGER, hayley only relies to the technique that brett manning taught her okay???

[retardo4music333]

lsn i really dont hate avril i actually kinda like her .... i just yhink that hayley is better and if u dont think her voice is thta natural just watch her acoustically or the final riot and ull fall in love with her trust me + hayley is active and fun 2 watch live btw hayley can play the piano guitar and the drums were the first insrument she played actually ....and again I DONT HATE AVRIL just my opinion =D sorry

[retardo4music333]

@ underclassdamnriot ur one of the only ones who seem 2 think so avril doesnt even have vibrato and she cant hit high notes and she sucks live.while hayley got an award 4 being 1 of the only female vocalists to hit every single note including the whistle. and she also had an interview with SINGING SUCCESS about how her voice is so strong live and she maches it up on record. but at least she tries 2 change things up a bit AND SHE IS NOT A POSER! 2 avril dressing in black dosnt make u rock!!!!

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 like i sad, hayley only became good because of brett maning vocie lesson, am i right, on the other hand, avirl is a natural singer, more natural than hay, hahaha besides AVRIL PLAYS A GUITAR, DRUMS and PIANO while singing simultaneously, while HAYLEY only SINGS hahaha

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 dude, i want you to comment on my video PROVING THAT AVRIL IS BETTER THAN HAYLEY

[retardo4music333]

hayley rocks avril sucks

[underclassdamnriot]

@retardo4music333 oh really??? i don't think so

[angelicamossmann]

o áudio tá meio ruim mas nota-se que a Hayley é a melhor *-*

Hayley Nichole Williams minha divaa 4ever ♥.♥

[TheOneAndOnlyTiaLace]

Get we are broken from Hayley, live and you will be stunned. Your pathetic! Hayley is much more amazing and talented and you and just favoring avril.

[underclassdamnriot]

@TheOneAndOnlyTiaLace

i'm not pathetic you moron!!! I'm just being HONEST and FAIR!!!

[redkirby01]

@TheOneAndOnlyTiaLace Dude! i was just about to write that!

"we are broken" on the final riot was a GREAT example of how much emotion hayley williams sings in her songs!

[karinyoliveira2000]

I love both , but I prefer Hayley .

[jowjeew]

i have one question, why do you only pick the bad parts for hayley and the better parts for avril? its obvious that u are a avril lavigne fan

[underclassdamnriot]

duh they are not bad parts!!! all of them are random raw sound, i ripped their live videos here on youtube and convert them to mp3 format and put them on my videos.

[jowjeew]

@underclassdamnriot u only picked the bad parts from the live performances from hayley, i've seen some good parts on youtube so dont blame it on that.

[underclassdamnriot]

no i don't!!! like i said they are random

[jowjeew]

@underclassdamnriot and u want me to believe that?....

[underclassdamnriot]

go see the videos yourself and i'm always honest when i say things.

[LegendaryBoyA]

I doubt that Avril knows that there are these videos about her and Hayley on the internet. I bet she only uses her PC to use Skype.

[underclassdamnriot]

in avril's spare time, she of course uses internet, she already had connected wit hus fans at the website avrilbandaids[dot]com and it's really her because the site administrator already met her personally.

[renaylovesanime]

to be honest, i really don't care who sings better, all i know is hayley is by far the best role model i've seen. so hayley for the win!!!

[Lashisaty]

@renaylovesanime Dam straight She in no #1

yehh me 2 Fuck she is so HOT.

[7MeowMix]

Avril use to sing good but her third album she sounded really weird..

[fartloOrd]

EDDpsp TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOUU HAYLEYY IS REAALLY A GOOD SINGEER!! BUT THIS TIMEE AVRILL KICK HER OUT!

[lovedxox]

have you even heard Hayley's latest live performances? I'm pretty sure paramore can out-sing avril any day

[underclassdamnriot]

yeah i heard her, even though demi lovato can sing like hayley

[mllover13]

yeah fucking right, are you deaf? they sound nothing alike!

[underclassdamnriot]

check out demi's american national anthem at football, so amazing!!!

[mllover13]

no, she practically shouted it and she way oversang everything.

[Crazy4Avril]

aVRIL!!!!! WINZ!! itz my opinion dont hate!!

[Elfjaah]

I think Hayley is better. I'm sorry. i like avril 2. But do you like hayley or don't you ?

[underclassdamnriot]

yes i like hayley

[panicatthediscofever]

Hayley's vocal range has been praised by many people.

obviously

the video you watched (hayley vocal range)

isnt all

she can go higher. SHE SAID IT HERSELF SHE DOESNT SHOW EVERYTHING TO THEIR SONGS.

so yeah. i suggest you stop under estimating HAYLEY's vocal talent coz u havent seen anything yet :)

[underclassdamnriot]

really??? avril can also do higher range aside from recorded

[panicatthediscofever]

hahahaha..

oh yeah

can i ask u

how many octaves avril has? ..

avril can go high

but hayleys upper range is higher than her

[underclassdamnriot]

avril can do 3.5 octaves i guess, to be honest she's not as diva as mariah carey, kelly clarkson, celine dion, beyonce because their singing is on the higher level, those divas can do more than 4 octaves as for hayley please give me a video where she reach her maximum high note. For me, hayley and demi lovato have close singing styles, watch demi lovato's american national anthem, she hit those high notes

[panicatthediscofever]

hayley has 4.5, she said it herself.:).

HAYLEY hasnt shown her full range

but it doesnt mean it wasnt there.

DEMI and hayley ? NO

i like demi but

her national anthem? she was shouty her vibrato there was awful specially the FREE note. she was oversinging which isnt good.

though demi was an amazing singer her national anthem isnt good. she really didnt hit every high note. she goes out of key abit

[underclassdamnriot]

once more if you say that avril's voice is forced, then you're wrong!!!! she sings natural too like your hayley do. She's canadian, remember, her accent affects it.

[panicatthediscofever]

So? i never said shes forced i said the way she put emotions in it . avril may sing natural but. HAYLEY 's voice ? its just there.

you can tell shes having fun. and performing is her life. HER ACCENT? wtf is the conncetion of it in her voice?

HAYLEY Has a tennesee accent too

ACCENT IS NOT AN EXCUSE TOO LAME

[EDDsp2009]

Avril's range is bigger than Hayley's range. Avril can sing in more than 3 octaves, but she show only 3. And Hayley show 2.5 octaves but she says that can hit 4.5 octaves. The highest note of Avril in studio is an A5 without falsetto, in background of "I Will Be" and she hit a G5 in "Hot" too. The Highest note of Hayley is a G5 in Conspiracy. The lowest notes of Avril is a B#2 in Fall To Pieces and a C3 in Forgotten, and Hayley can sing an E3, but I think she can go lowest. To me, Avril win

.

[panicatthediscofever]

oh hey.. the video you saw about hayleys range

is pointless. JUST BECAUSE HAYLEY DOESNT SHOW IT ON THE RECORD

DOESNT MEAN IT WASNT THERE

IF I WERE YOU BEFORE YOU POST AND CONTRADICT YOURSELF TO UR POST. know ur facts first.

[antihenawhata34]

I agree with panic, since she's the only one who makes sence (:

[underclassdamnriot]

"I agree with panic, since she's the only one who makes sence (: "

it's SENSE not SENCE, learn how to spell please!!!!

[antihenawhata34]

My typing gets lazy when I talk over the internet (:. Besides...

This is youtube, it doesn't matter. Btw....

Come up with better arguments please!!!! n.n