Just a beautiful melody and Neil's voice is so underrated. Nobody writes a song like Neil. Even when he goes awry with a somewhat silly "churches .. preaches sex is wrong Jesus where is nature gone?" he recovers with WHAT AM I DOING HERE? He had a knack for concerts that could closely represent or improve studio versions. I say "had" as he may have lost it but still time to recover...
Sorry, but as an "old," Neil Young fan, this song is on the "Live at Massey Hall," Remastered, and it sounds the same to me.
I don't own the BBC Sessions, because it is much of the same music, except the clapping at the end of this song can be heard on the BBC Sessions.
Still, in fairness to previous comments, I'm not saying you need to change anything and I certainly don't want to get into a fight, because as Neil says about all things in arguement:"That's just a negative vibe."
Just a beautiful melody and Neil's voice is so underrated. Nobody writes a song like Neil. Even when he goes awry with a somewhat silly "churches .. preaches sex is wrong Jesus where is nature gone?" he recovers with WHAT AM I DOING HERE? He had a knack for concerts that could closely represent or improve studio versions. I say "had" as he may have lost it but still time to recover...
11xzxzxz 1 year ago
Self indulgent nonsense from the man who knows it all
g5uk 1 year ago
Great song I would love to see him in concert!!!!
blawrence32 1 year ago
i like the Time Fades Away version better. It seems more haunting
septip123 2 years ago
who has another canada shoe in toronto
just day before the realsed Version of Live at Massey Hall
thanks!
limunan 3 years ago
why Live at Massey Hall not released before?
till right now?
limunan 3 years ago
neil didnt want it released.
goastbrane 3 years ago
C major in middle keys to F major ...elegant, simple, this guy is a child!
phddddd 3 years ago 2
Well, he certainly has lasted a while.
BrokenChair88 2 years ago
This wasnt from Live at Fillmore East this is the same one from BBC Sessions.
Beefgog 4 years ago
It is from Massey Hall 1971, isnt it?
cajander 4 years ago
I have a BBC Sessions with Neil Young on it and it is the same as this.
Beefgog 4 years ago
Ok I will include it in the description
Thank you very much
cajander 4 years ago
tht is not the BBC version.
irtimed 3 years ago 2
Sorry, but as an "old," Neil Young fan, this song is on the "Live at Massey Hall," Remastered, and it sounds the same to me.
I don't own the BBC Sessions, because it is much of the same music, except the clapping at the end of this song can be heard on the BBC Sessions.
Still, in fairness to previous comments, I'm not saying you need to change anything and I certainly don't want to get into a fight, because as Neil says about all things in arguement:"That's just a negative vibe."
Peace.
Rock
Rockitinmypocket 3 years ago
The Massey Hall version is slightley different.
BrokenChair88 1 year ago
One of my favorite.
Beefgog 4 years ago 4
He played this for the first time on his new tour last friday...
smoke117 4 years ago 6
you mean this is the first time he played this song on this particular tour? I heard this at Odeon Hammersmith what thrity years ago!
phddddd 3 years ago
Yeah that's what I meant. He hadn't played the song in 30 odd years as you say you heard it.
smoke117 3 years ago
cool song
BRICOlagessss 4 years ago 3