Added: 3 months ago
From: LouReedMetallicaTV
Views: 135,083
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (911)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Lou Reed ain't my favourite person in the world - but he's a 'vocalist', not a singer. It's about emotion and reality, not pleasing everyone and thinking about those pop charts.

    Can you imagine what the world would be like if everyone sounded like fckn M.Carey or dumb equivalents?

  • hahahah lulu voice - HAHAHHAAAH it's funny

  • you so real metallica you nice guys je vous ADORE MES AMIS COOL q;D

  • This album was created in a matter of weeks, and at the end of the project, Metallica I give A- (as in amazing), while Lou Reed gets an F (as in fuck off).

  • The instrumental part could have made an awesome song if only this skeleton would just shut up and another singer had made up something compleatly different for the vocals and sang it

  • The instrumental part is kind of beautiful...but I can't understand a fucking word from lou reed's mouth ._.

  • Keep the music and replace Lou with Tom Waits.

  • deep, deep lyrics, but can totally understand why many Metallica fans don't connect with it

  • Even tho its a pretty crappy album and i only like Iced Honey, James is making the best guitar in the whole album which is in my opinion the only reason why i listen to it..

  • This is very cool but don't be disappointed youngsters this is a new body of work and you have to take the elements that they brought to the table and Lou's raw aged voice against Metallica's sound very warm sound is a great mix this is not Lou or Tallica it is a triumph of music enjoy it. Besides they don't care what you think.

  • you guys are all fags, you forget that Metallica and Lou Reed have been around since the 70s... this OBVIOUSLY isn't going to be their golden years anymore and honestly i don't give a shit, i respect them both for they are both doing what like

  • They need to turn off lou reeds mic and let james sing

  • @metallicafanclub15 They just need to Shut Lou Reed up and let the music play because the music sounds AWESOME!!!!!

  • "the greatest disappointmentttttttt"-Lou Reed on his collaboration with Metallica.

  • this is way to chill..... "turning on my stereo" "insert Kill 'Em All" HEADBANGING TO DEATH!!!

  • Sounds like metallica prog (Which is awesome), it sounds like a dying old man is ranting over the music though :S. Really not a good idea. Mostly annoyed at the fact I have to wait even longer for a proper metallica album

  • Thanks Mr. Reed and 'Tallica Guys, this is real music, you'd open new paths in my life

  • WOW This music have the Unnamed Feeling, don't know if it's good, don't know if it's bad, but damn this feels AWESOME

  • puedo agradecer que lo vi por youtube, y no pague un boleto como todos los que estan ahi

  • @okzigeno ya quisieras estar ahi maldito miserable

  • @helldemonpig xD

    no te proyectes, y la verdad que si, metallica es mi banda favorita, es solo una manera de expresar que ese album no me agrado ni un poco, saludos

  • @okzigeno pero no es un album de metallica amigo, es de lou reed con metallica como colaboradores, disculpa por mi comentario anterior

  • @helldemonpig ntp, no hay problema, que estes bien! saludos =)

  • its bad enough with no singing but then lou reed has to make old man noises throughout the song

  • I like it

  • Haha Dude had a Master of Puppets shirt. Musta been disappointed.

    Definitely an interesting take. Blows St. Anger outta the water

  • Metallica have the fu***** right to do this. I think it's poor music but they deserve to do things without asking any of their fans!!!

  • they actually played that shit live?????oh dear mother of metal....i have lost all respect for metallica as a band...

  • @sweeney665 Why? Because they're doing something different? Because they're doing what they want to do?

  • @DamnedGamers no man, don't get me wrong. I like their move as a big middle finger to whomever, but man Lou is just horrid to listen to. I'd rather he just read his lyrics in a preaching/talking kind of way. Not listen to him trying to barely hit a correct note...I mean...c'mmon..

  • @sweeney665 Personally, I like Lou Reed. He doesn't try to sing like a good bit of singers. He just kinda speaks it. It's more about personal preference. I think this song is fine and I respect the direction that Metallica is going.

  • im open minded when it comes to metal...i am...but this...this is...utter shit

  • I actually like it. It has its own appeal. It would make a badass instrumental without the vocals as well. Lou sings like he is wasted, and that his voice hurts...but that roughness is kinda interesting. If Lou or Lars saw this, he would say to all the haters....GO FUCK YOURSELVES...all the way to the bank.

  • this only proves that you can't mix however you like.

  • Fucking masterpiece Avant-garde metal

    Long live Lou Reed and James Hetfield

  • @libano90 amen.

  • Well... it's.... different.... certainly not metallica... yes they have a softer side but this is not the right sound for such legends.... now i LOVE metallica but... bad move guys sorry =(

  • This is conceptual rock, the 60-70´s era, not just a headbang, this is music for ideas, getting stoned; just to think a bit; thatn was the idea that Lou got With the Velvet Undergroung, & with Andy

  • Reed bashed Metallica fans saying that the people that don't appreciate Lulu aren't intelligent enough to grasp the poetry and artistic depth of the Record as a whole. I'm a poet and I am also studying poetry... this sounds like Helen Keller rambling into a microphone to a Daughtry riff...

  • i hope they release an instrumental version of lulu

  • just listen and feel.. if you cant hear.. keep close in your room with your teenager dreams

  • what the fuck is this shit!! metallica used to be beast! the guy dosent even sing he talks!

  • What the fuck is going on with their faces? I mean they aren't playing something beatiful just ok. They're like "ooooooh such beauty I will close my eyes to feel the power of the music and because I can play with my eyes closed" except for kirk, because he sucks :P not bashing him he used to be good but now I only listen to wah wah wah in his solos

  • They play such a heavy song and crowd don't headbang

  • obviously lou read ;d

  • he can't even say a song, got to read -.-

  • come on guys, don't hate, just take a look at james' face, he's soul is in this song... i love it

  • Hilarious. My top comment got deleted. Censoring the truth will never bring you back you fucking retards. What the fuck were you thinking!? 

  • This song is bullshit. Lou Reed should have died when he was still relevant. Metallica is still the best metal band of all time. they can do what they want. you mad bro

  • Y'know what? I don't care how good or bad the rest of the album is, because at the very least it produced this beautiful, wonderful gem of a song

  • LOL 5:13 at left... the Metallica fan was expecting to see MASTER! MASTER! ahahh

  • I read thy Lyrics to the songs on the Album. This guy needs a holiday or a root. He is a depression addict lol.

  • Lu Reed cant sing for shit! Worst CD I have ever bought.

  • Comment removed

  • where's the mosh?

  • I'd rather listen to Bjork.

  • The only reason I can say I like this song is because I can relate to the lyrics with issues I have with my father, and it's probably the most tolerable track on this entire record.

  • Kinda Johnny Cash-ish, very raw, wish Kirk would have put a nice jam into this, I guess he did on the album version. All in all I liked it.

  • they must have lost a bet!!!!

  • ohhhh my god metallica become bore!!

  • Beavis and Butthead need to review this.

  • Did I just ear an old guy say I will teach you the penis?

  • Metallica's fan base is one of the worst ever. Never satisfied.

  • demo

  • Why the FUCK am I listening to this shit??!!!!!

  • @TheMarkMarxon Because in that music, there is Metallica \m/

  • @TheMarkMarxon yeah WHY are you listening? you obviously dont like it. get the fuck out you fucking troll.

  • @TheMarkMarxon its kind of calming.

  • @cars812 exactly.

  • @TheMarkMarxon Why the FUCK are you commenting??!!!!!

  • @TheMarkMarxon Because Metallica are playing .

  • who the fuck is Lou Reed and how in the world did he convince Metallica to poop this crap out??

  • @Bultish are you fucking serious? Lou Reed is only one of the most creative, intelligent people of all time! Yes this album is pretty terrible but that never gives you the right to diss Lou Reed. Velvet Underground(Lou's old band) and Metallica are great, just not together. Look things up before spewing shit

  • @jetmusic879 Are you retarded? How can you say for a fact that he is one of the most creative persons in the world? Thats just your subjective opinion and when I "hear" you write that I come to the conclusion you must be retarded. Fourteen year old girls think Lady Gaga is the most creative person in the world and they are known for a FACT to be retarded. And btw, i live in a free soceity so I can "diss" Lou Reed on whatever fucking basis I want...

  • @Bultish hey, you know this is my fault. I normally don't get involved in internet arguments. I should just let ou have an opinion. It just extremeley irritates me when someone insults an artist without knowing who they are. I should have just let it be, but I didn't. So you're right, its a free a country

  • waste of beautifull guitar tunes

  • шо за бред??? этот старый пердун все испортил..Хей Металлика, вы сами монстры!

  • okay metallica, you've really put us through some shit. st.anger, load and reload, even death magnetic was kinda meh, but this, this is like a bad high school band. seriously get your shit together

  • I perfer the album version, it disguesses lou reeds voice better... but love the song, best on an ok album if ur in the right mood

  • Perhaps being "old" and knowing the foibles and surviving makes me love this song.

  • Ok so I can understand most of these songs, but Lou Reed just ruins the hole damn thing!! And honestly I feel bad for the audience at this event.

  • The entire LULU album is great but you have to be literate to get the most out of it.

  • the music isnt too bad, but the vocals ruin all these songs!

  • I wish Johnny Cash was still alive.

  • Jesus H Christ are they serious???

  • Ouch!!!!! I'd rather listen to Chili's music than this crap

  • this is the worst song i have ever heard

  • never thought i'd hear metallica do post-rock

  • I like it! too sophisticated for most Americans. 

  • @robradharc wtf about this trash is sophisticated??? The fact that you have some old geezer who cant sing for the life of him? Or is it the fact that for 10 minutes straight its the same exact guitar and drums shinanigans repeatings over and over again?? Mabye that this is about some play that was made in the early 1900's about some little girl who is having troubles??Or is it that its some 70+ year old man "singing" as if he was a little girl having troubles??

  • @alinebabypuncher before bashing thrash learn to write it well, is not "trash" unless you mean it like that. tHrash :)

  • @robradharc I'm American & I love this album. Instead of targeting us, you should be targeting the majority of Metallica's fanbase.

  • I love this song :]

  • robert was sleeping :D

  • hey james your voice is realy great man i understand now :D

  • the live version sucks, it's pretty good on the album...

  • would be better if lou just kept singing "baaaa-ba-ba-booooeeeeeeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeeeeey...."

  • If this is James "sober", then he really needs to start drinking again! I'm really one of the biggest Metallica fans ever, I dont dislike any of their other songs but, Holy shit! This is the worst song Ive ever heard! And on top of that... Who the fuck is Lou Reed? And why the fuck does Metallica think that their fans should give a fuck who he is? Good job on "officially" fucking your fans Metallica. This is the only album where they must have sat down and said.."screw the fans we're Metallica"

  • @helliphinonate Just because it isn't the same music Metallica has done in the past doesn't make it bad or a slap in the face of the fans. And btw Lou Reed was only a part of one of the most greatest and most influencial bands ever moron

  • @helliphinonate In a way you're right. They're at a point in their career where they have become 100% uncompromising, to the point where they don't care if they alienate people, no matter how closed-minded their fanbase is. Also, who is Lou Reed? Are you kidding me? Have you ever heard of a little band called The Velvet Underground? He also made great solo albums over the past few decades including Transformer & Growing Up in Public. He is revered as a legendary songwriter.

  • i fuckin really like this

  • love it

    go Howard

  • i may have just lost all faith in music. thanks metallica, thanks lou. im going to go burn my black album guita songbook now. bye

  • now,this is heavy metal band Metallica

  • This song is awesome. Thanks Howard for the suggestion!

  • "i ate my brother"

  • Wow I don't know wtf that was

  • It's the same riff over and over.

  • Wow.. It sounds like Elmer Fudd backed by Metallica. Not deep, not moving and simply not good.

  • But music in Lulu is really good

  • The only reason I am hearing this lame song was because of Howard Stern Baba Booey to you all!!!

  • Haters!...... AWESOME

  • i think it's a cool experiment. the music is moving, vocals not so great. could use more melodic singing. having said that....you're going to hollywood!!!!!!!!!

  • i can sing as good as this dude. He might have been a good singer at some point in his life but now it just sounds like a rambling old man. He's talking more than singing. The music is cool and all and would be great if a singer was singing instead of this crap.

  • @emspirit its lou reed retard.... not 'this dude' or some 'old man" if you dont know anything about the band do give a point of view. Lou Reed was a legend

  • @alexkpapascs dont*

  • @alexkpapascs "was" a legend is correct. He is a terrible singer. Give me one good song that he has strong lyrics in. He may be a great musician but I can sing better than him. That doesn't make me a retard to observe the obvious.

  • @alexkpapascs "was a legend" the key word here is WAS. This doesn't mean that anything he does now is worth a turd in a toilet. Bush league dribble coming from this "effort".

  • deep stuff, still love this band

  • Wow this sucks harder then anything I have sat through, I prefer Benjis song!

  • Howard is WAY wrong on this one...turd city!!!

  • F Jackie!

  • like it or not THE BAND ENJOYED IT ! just deal ....

  • Haters gonna hate. I love this song. People just can't get over the fact that Metallica chose to collaborate with Lou Reed. If you don't view this as a Metallica song, it's simply beautiful.

  • @Charization - However, I must say that I don't really care for the live version. The studio one is much better.

  • @Charization A-frickin-men. However, I think they could've cut the studio version down in length by about 9 minutes.

  • terrible

  • Howard Stern is the man...

    

  • how can this man be a singer.shitty voice, is like my grandfather singing.this is a big shit and a big mistake for metallica

  • @touareg91m Metallica is no better, They haven't made a good album in 25 years.

  • I like this song because Howard Stern likes it.

    Idiots.

  • Comment removed

  • Good marketing strategy... after this even St.Anger would be amazing

  • I think this is the definitive proof that KC Armstrong actually is crazy..

  • I WILL TEACH YOU THE PENIS!

  • This sounds like someone hit the demo button on the world's shittest keyboard and some grumpy old cunt is moaning over it. Horrific.

  • Dont get why people dogged this and loved that Johnny Cash Hurt shit.. its pretty damn similar.. both old guys walking to their graves

  • @Elslav Reason behind that, Cash was good.. Lou just blows chunks, his ratty voice hurts my ears!

  • @Elslav Johnny Cash was falling apart with multiple diseases and had lost his wife yet he still sang as best as he could, and the song made sense and his dying voice fit. Lou Reed is cramming in croaky nonsense where a singer may have made a song out of this.

  • Lou Reed is a bonafide rock n roll legend, but this is akin to watching Muhammad Ali, today, take on Junior Dos Santos.

  • I tried oooh God i tried 10 times sorry Howard it is pure MUCK

  • @bobbytaxi1 Right.. Lou's voice is just awful

  • Somewhere out there KC Armstrong is crying and angrily masturbating to this in a hotel room.

  • eric the flying midget fly me with ballons is way better

  • I love Howard, but this is the dumbest fucking song I have EVER heard. I've been a huge Metallica fan for years, but this is easily the worst song they've ever recorded.

    As far as Lou Reed, h's insanely overrated. A fourth-grader could have written these lyrics.

  • No one would be listening to this shit if it wasnt for Stern......BABA BOOEY TO YOU ALL!!!

  • The lyrics are kinda full of it but the music is okay.

  • Sex and drugs and rock n roll

    I like it.

  • i hope lou reed and metallica stay together forever and ever

  • Howard is a genius

  • Thumbs up if you are listening to this crappy song thanks to Howard Stern

  • @quicken02 classic you cant beat this..rock on howard!

  • @quicken02 Yes I am but the song is really good.

  • is lou reed supposed to be a good singer or something...?

  • my god, that crowd looks so intense!

    -__-

  • KC sucks and thinks Lamb of God is the greatest band ever. This doesn't work, Lou is disjointed and can't make it work. Iggy Pop would do better with this. Howard should go back to Barbara Streisand and Miley Cyrus.

  • Baba booeeeeeyy power chords!

  • So basically some spoken word over some droning music. Howard Stern is full of crap.

  • At times it looks like Lars Ulrich is getting ready to fuck his drum set.

  • Rob's face in the default frame describes everything...

    

  • I can fart a better tune. This song sucks ginormous, Rosie O'donnell type sweaty, zit covered, un wiped, cottage cheese ASS!!!

  • Lou Reed is a legend... but sorry.. he's sounds like shit here.

  • this is the first time i like to hear metallica and i think something went wrong with metallica fans musical education.

    ridiculous discussions and reactions, do you want them to play their greatest hits forever & ever?

    fuck you all

  • this is a fucking sick song after the 2nd 3rd listen like howard said. just hell groovy

  • @BROADSofficial agreed.  its relaxing.

  • @BROADSofficial No.  No, it is not. This is fucking beyond horrible.

  • he looks like a stoned monkey thats come out of a spin dryer

  • The music is pretty, but Lou Reed is pulling our leg, right?

  • Howard shows his musical tastes sucks. He authenticates the authenticity. Proves to be brain-defective, brain-deficient, and brain-DEAD. RIGHT?

  • But is this song better than "pussy good, pussy sweet, pussy good enough to eat"?

    - "I swear to god he said bloomies, I wanted to throw him out of the car"

    Artie Lange

  • SHIT... thats all... worst 5 seconds of my life...

    

  • it take guts to make this.....they give a real reason to think they're musicians before being a band called metallica......they search for music, not only metal.

  • FUCKIN A!!!